Moisture content and sorption isotherm behaviour
The initial moisture content (Mo) of kecombrang tisane yogurt powder was 6.42±0.0023%, while the critical moisture content (Mc) was 8.13±0.0043%. The critical moisture content represents the moisture level at which noticeable physical deterioration, particularly powder clumping, begins to occur. During storage, moisture can migrate from the surrounding environment into the powder, resulting in increased moisture content and loss of powder flowability. The equilibrium moisture content (Me) obtained from the sorption isotherm analysis was 8.18±0.0060%. These values indicate that the initial moisture content was below the critical moisture content, providing a moisture safety margin before visible deterioration occurred.
The moisture sorption behaviour was described by the linear regression equation y = 0.362x -0.244, with an R2 of 0.923. Moisture sorption isotherms are important for understanding the relationship between water activity and moisture content in hygroscopic food and agricultural materials
(Zeymer et al., 2023).
The relatively high coefficient of determination indicates a strong relationship between water activity and equilibrium moisture content within the experimental range. The slope (b) of 0.362 was subsequently used in the Labuza critical moisture content model for shelf-life estimation. However, the regression should be interpreted as an empirical approximation within the tested water activity range rather than as a universal representation of moisture sorption behaviour. The relatively high R² supports its use for the present shelf-life calculation but does not by itself establish the predictive accuracy of the model outside the experimental range.
The relatively low Mo and Mc values are characteristic of a low-moisture powder system in which relatively small increases in moisture can cause physical changes such as caking and reduced flowability. Compared with conventional dairy powders, the moisture stability of yogurt powder may be influenced by its protein, carbohydrate and acid components as well as by the drying process. The incorporation of kecombrang tisane may further influence moisture sorption because its phenolic compounds and other soluble components can alter the hydrophilic characteristics of the powder matrix. Therefore, moisture sorption is an important deterioration pathway for this fermented dairy-based powder. Similar relationships between moisture-related properties and storage stability have also been investigated in powdered milk products
(Fathimaa et al., 2026).
Shelf-life estimation and effect of packaging
Shelf life differed substantially among the packaging materials, demonstrating that packaging barrier properties strongly influenced the stability of kecombrang tisane yogurt powder. Shelf-life estimation was performed using the Labuza critical moisture content model under storage conditions of 38°C and approximately 90% RH. The model incorporated Mo, Mc, Me, the sorption-isotherm slope, package surface area, water-vapor permeability, product weight and water-vapor pressure. The values of these variables used in the shelf-life estimation under 90% RH conditions are summarized in Table 2.
Among the packaging treatments, aluminum foil provided the longest estimated shelf life, reaching 442.64±26.13 days (approximately 14.54 months), whereas PE provided the shortest shelf life of approximately 58.16±1.25 days. The estimated shelf life of kecombrang tisane yogurt powder for each packaging treatment is presented in Table 3.
The large difference among packaging treatments indicates that water-vapor barrier properties were a major determinant of predicted shelf life. Aluminum foil has a substantially higher barrier against water vapor, oxygen and light than conventional polyethylene- and polypropylene-based packaging. The importance of packaging materials in maintaining food quality during storage has also been demonstrated in other food products, including fresh mushrooms
(Attri et al., 2025). Similar findings have been reported for other food products, in which aluminum foil packaging was associated with improved shelf-life stability during storage
(Liviawaty et al., 2021). Consequently, its use can reduce moisture ingress and delay the attainment of the critical moisture content.
The results also indicate that packaging performance should not be interpreted solely from the polymer type. Differences in thickness, permeability, package configuration, sealing quality and surface-area-to-product ratio can influence the effective moisture transfer rate. Therefore, the predicted shelf-life values represent the performance of the specific packaging systems evaluated in this study rather than an intrinsic shelf life of the material itself. This distinction is important when extrapolating the results to commercial packaging systems.
pH changes during storage
The pH of kecombrang tisane yogurt powder decreased during storage. The decrease was observed in all evaluated packaging systems, with aluminum foil and HDPE showing relatively large changes, from approximately 4.46 to 4.23 and 4.18, respectively. The initial and final pH values for each packaging treatment are presented in Table 4. The final pH values remained below 4.6, which is consistent with the reported quality criterion for fermented milk.
The reduction in pH can be associated with continued metabolic activity of surviving lactic acid bacteria and the formation of organic acids during storage. However, pH reduction should not be attributed solely to oxygen permeability. Moisture ingress may also increase the mobility of residual microbial cells and dissolved substrates, potentially facilitating post-processing acidification. Therefore, the lower permeability of aluminum foil may reduce moisture and oxygen transfer and consequently slow quality changes, but the present study did not directly measure oxygen transmission rate or lactic acid bacterial counts. Thus, the proposed mechanism should be considered a plausible explanation rather than a directly demonstrated kinetic relationship.
Rehydration behaviour
Rehydration time increased during storage for all packaging treatments. The greatest increase was observed in HDPE, from 42.66 to 46.94 s. The initial and final rehydration times for each packaging treatment are summarized in Table 5. The increase in rehydration time is consistent with moisture uptake during storage, which can promote particle aggregation and caking. Such structural changes reduce the ability of powder particles to disperse and dissolve rapidly when water is added. The relationship between moisture uptake and rehydration is particularly important for hygroscopic dairy powders. As moisture enters the package, the powder may undergo surface plasticization, particle adhesion and formation of larger agglomerates. These changes increase the resistance of water to penetrate individual particles during reconstitution. The relatively small increase in rehydration time observed in aluminum foil is therefore consistent with its superior moisture-barrier properties. Nevertheless, because particle morphology and water activity were not directly measured during storage, the structural mechanism is inferred from the moisture and rehydration behaviour rather than directly demonstrated.
Total titratable acidity
Total titratable acidity (TTA) increased during storage, indicating an increase in the total concentration of titratable acidic compounds. TTA showed a greater increase in the less protective packaging treatments, whereas the change in aluminum foil was comparatively smaller. The initial and final TTA values for each packaging treatment are presented in Table 6. The inverse relationship between pH and TTA observed in the present study is consistent with continued acid development in the yogurt matrix. The initial TTA values were higher than those reported for soy milk yogurt powder by
Hayati et al., (2024). This difference may partly be associated with the acidic characteristics of kecombrang tisane, which has been reported to have a relatively low pH. The increase in TTA during storage may also be facilitated by moisture uptake, because increased water availability can increase the mobility of residual microorganisms and substrates. Therefore, packaging with a lower moisture-vapor permeability can slow the changes in acidity. Although HDPE showed a relatively large increase in TTA, the moderate deterioration observed in PP suggests that permeability alone may not fully explain the magnitude of acidity changes. Differences in package thickness, sealing, headspace and actual moisture transmission under the experimental conditions may also contribute. Thus, the effect of packaging should be interpreted based on the overall barrier performance of the tested packaging system rather than polymer classification alone.
Protein content
Protein content decreased during storage in all packaging treatments. For example, the protein content of the aluminum-foil treatment decreased from 11.32% to 9.54%, while the HDPE treatment decreased from 11.54% to 8.67%. The initial and final protein contents of the powder under different packaging conditions are presented in Table 7. The protein values remained considerably higher than the minimum protein requirement reported for yogurt. The observed decrease should be interpreted cautiously because protein concentration can be affected by changes in product moisture. An increase in moisture content can dilute the protein concentration when expressed on a wet-weight basis, producing an apparent decrease without necessarily indicating equivalent protein degradation. In addition, prolonged storage may promote protein hydrolysis or oxidative modification, particularly under conditions that allow greater moisture and oxygen transfer. However, because protein degradation products and moisture-normalized protein content were not determined in this study, the data cannot distinguish quantitatively between true biochemical degradation and concentration effects caused by changes in moisture. Therefore, the decrease in measured protein content should be described as a reduction in apparent protein concentration rather than definitive evidence of protein degradation. Further analysis using a dry-basis calculation, protein hydrolysis indicators, or electrophoretic profiling would be required to confirm the biochemical mechanism.
Antioxidant activity
Antioxidant activity decreased during storage, although the magnitude of the decrease varied among packaging treatments. In aluminum foil, antioxidant activity decreased from 58.48% to 57.53%, whereas the decrease in HDPE was greater, from 58.09% to 54.76%. The initial and final antioxidant activity values for each packaging treatment are presented in Table 8. Aluminum foil and PP did not show a statistically significant difference in antioxidant activity, indicating that the numerical difference between treatments should be interpreted together with statistical significance and effect magnitude. The reduction in antioxidant activity may be related to the degradation or oxidation of phenolic compounds contributed by kecombrang tisane. Phenolic compounds can undergo oxidation during storage, particularly when exposed to oxygen, moisture and light. Similar considerations have been reported in fruit juice powders, where drying techniques influenced the retention of phytochemicals and antioxidant properties
(Prathengjit et al., 2025). Packaging conditions may influence antioxidant retention in food products by affecting their exposure to environmental factors during storage
(Lubis et al., 2022). Aluminum foil provides an effective barrier against light and oxygen and therefore can reduce environmental exposure that may accelerate oxidation. Previous research on beras kencur beverages has also demonstrated the importance of packaging and storage conditions in maintaining antioxidant activity and physicochemical quality
(Suwarno et al., 2022).
However, the decline in antioxidant activity cannot be attributed exclusively to phenolic oxidation based on the present measurements. Other mechanisms, including interactions between phenolic compounds and the dairy matrix and non-enzymatic reactions such as the Maillard reaction, may also contribute to changes in antioxidant capacity during storage. Therefore, the observed decrease represents a reduction in measured antioxidant activity rather than direct evidence of a specific degradation pathway. The relatively small decrease in aluminum foil is consistent with its superior barrier against environmental factors, whereas the statistical results should be considered when determining whether the differences among packaging treatments are practically and statistically meaningful.
Overall, the results demonstrate that packaging barrier properties are closely associated with the physical and chemical stability of kecombrang tisane yogurt powder. Aluminum foil consistently provided the greatest protection against moisture-related deterioration and resulted in the longest predicted shelf life. However, the mechanisms underlying changes in pH, acidity, protein concentration and antioxidant activity involve multiple interacting factors and some mechanisms proposed in this study should be confirmed through direct measurements in future research.