Consumer acceptability
To ensure the validity and consistency of sensory evaluation, a hedonic test was conducted following established procedures reported in the literature. According to
Sharif et al., (2017), hedonic testing is an effective method for identifying key sensory attributes that reflect consumer acceptance of new products. Accordingly, the acceptance of 12 formulations of kecombrang flower probiotic drinks was evaluated using a 7-point hedonic scale for color, aroma, taste, texture and overall liking. These attributes were selected as they represent the primary sensory factors influencing consumer perception and purchase intention. Color provides the initial visual impression, aroma shapes flavor expectations, taste determines palatability and texture affects mouthfeel and comfort. Evaluating these attributes enables the identification of sensory aspects requiring improvement to enhance overall product acceptance.
Color
Table 3 and Table 4 show that the most preferred color attribute is the treatment with 1% BAL addition and 24 hours of fermentation, with a value of 6.00 (like) and a color of “red-very red.” Meanwhile, the least preferred color was the treatment with 5% BAL addition and 48 hours of fermentation, which had a score of 3.71 or “somewhat dislike” with the color “orange to pink”. Basically, the color of kecombrang probiotic drinks is influenced by kecombrang ingredients and sugar addition. The pink to red color is caused by the original color of kecombrang flowers, which is red. This color originates from the anthocyanin content in kecombrang
(Naufalin et al., 2021). Furthermore, in (
Xue Mei et al., 2020), it is mentioned that anthocyanin is a water-soluble flavonoid pigment. This pigment is responsible for the red, purple and blue colors seen in plants.
Aroma
The results of the analysis in Table 3 and Table 4 show that the most preferred aroma attribute with the addition of 3% BAL and a fermentation time of 24 hours has a value of 4.88 (somewhat liked) with a “distinctive kecombrang” aroma. However, the addition of 1% BAL and a fermentation time of 24 hours, with a value of 5.03 (somewhat characteristic of kecombrang), had a higher aroma value despite a lower preference value (4.21). This is supported by research
(Maharani et al., 2025), which found that yogurt products containing kecombrang extract showed a slightly stronger kecombrang aroma, increasing the overall preference rating and tending to be preferred by panelists. According to , the longer the fermentation process, the stronger the combination of taste and aroma of fermentation, as evidenced by a decrease in pH as the fermentation time increases.
Taste
The taste parameter results (Table 3 and Table 4) show that the most preferred treatment was the addition of 1% BAL and a fermentation time of 36 hours, with a value of 5.34 (somewhat liked) with a “neutral” taste, although in terms of sourness assessment, the addition of 3% BAL and a fermentation time of 36 hours had a higher value of 4.56 (somewhat not sour) with a lower liking value of 5.23 (somewhat liked). This is supported by research
(Nahdiyah et al., 2022) discussing young coconut water probiotic beverage products, where the taste parameter disliked by panelists was the product’s tendency toward sourness.
Texture
The texture attribute analysis (Table 3 and 4) showed that the most preferred texture was observed in the treatment with 3% BAL addition and 24 h fermentation, which obtained a liking score of 5.55 (slightly liked) and was described as slightly liquid. The highest texture intensity score was recorded for the treatment with 1% BAL addition and 24 h fermentation (5.75; liquid), although its liking score was slightly lower (5.51; somewhat liked). No significant differences were observed among treatments, as nearly all samples had Acceptance Factor (AF) values above 80%, indicating that BAL concentration and fermentation time did not significantly affect texture acceptance. This result is consistent with
Rozali et al., (2025), who reported that samples with shorter fermentation times and more liquid textures were preferred in roselle kefir popsicles.
Best treatment
The determination of the best treatment for kecombrang probiotic drinks was carried out using the Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS) based on hedonic and hedonic quality evaluations. The analysis integrated multiple sensory attributes, including color, aroma, taste, texture and overall liking, to rank all treatment alternatives. The preference values and final rankings of the 12 treatment alternatives obtained from the TOPSIS analysis are presented in Table 5.
Based on the TOPSIS preference values and final ranking results table 5, the formulation with 1% BAL addition and a fermentation time of 24 h was identified as the best treatment among all formulations. This result indicates that panelists preferred products with an attractive color, acceptable aroma and balanced taste that were not overly influenced by the fermentation process. Similar findings were reported by
Nahdiyah et al., (2022), who demonstrated that lower BAL concentrations combined with moderate fermentation times resulted in higher organoleptic acceptance.
Consistent trends were also observed in previous studies.
Aydın et al., (2025) reported that yogurt fortified with kecombrang flower extract at higher concentrations achieved superior sensory scores for taste, aroma and overall attributes. In addition,
Novitasari et al., (2025) showed that fermentation time significantly affected color, aroma and taste attributes of kecombrang flower-based beverages, although overall acceptance was not significantly altered.
Descriptive analysis
The quantitative descriptive analysis (QDA) involved trained panelists who evaluated kecombrang probiotic drinks based on taste, aroma, flavor and texture using an unstructured 15 cm line scale, where 0 represented the lowest intensity and 15 the highest. Each selected sample from the hedonic and hedonic quality tests was evaluated twice to ensure data consistency. The mean intensity values of all attributes are presented in a spiderweb diagram (Fig 1) and summarized in Table 6. The results showed that kecombrang probiotic drinks with 1% BAL addition and 24 h fermentation exhibited the highest intensity for sweetness and floral aroma. In contrast, the highest sourness intensity was observed in samples with 3% BAL addition and 36 h fermentation, indicating that both BAL concentration and fermentation duration significantly influenced sensory characteristics. Sugars such as glucose and fructose serve as substrates for lactic acid bacteria and contribute to acid production during fermentation, which affects taste perception
(Fuso et al., 2023; Irmayanti et al., 2020). The floral flavor attribute showed fluctuations during fermentation, consistent with findings by
Ban et al., (2025), who reported flavor weakening at early fermentation stages followed by reformation at extended fermentation due to increased alcohol content. The highest texture intensity was observed in samples with 1% BAL addition and 36 h fermentation.
To further interpret the sensory data, principal component analysis (PCA) was applied and visualized using a biplot (Fig 2). Samples located close to each other on the biplot exhibited similar sensory characteristics, whereas samples positioned opposite each other showed contrasting sensory profiles. The PCA results indicated that kecombrang probiotic drinks with 1% BAL addition and 24 h fermentation were characterized by high sweetness, floral aroma and floral flavor, along with low acidity and a light texture. According to
Amador-Sacoto et al. (2025), acute angles between vectors indicate positive correlations among attributes, while longer vectors represent higher variability. Correlation analysis revealed that sweetness and floral aroma were strongly positively correlated (0.793), while floral aroma and texture showed a strong negative correlation (-0.716). A moderate positive correlation was observed between sour taste and floral flavor (0.572), whereas sweetness and texture exhibited a moderate negative correlation (0.440). In contrast, sour taste and floral aroma showed no correlation (-0.84), indicating independent behavior between these attributes. Similar interpretations of PCA biplots and vector relationships have been reported by
Jagriti et al., (2024).