The addition of kecombrang (
Etlingera elatior) flower powder and isolated soy protein (ISP) affected several physicochemical properties of vegan ready-to-eat products, including moisture content, ash content, pH, water activity and color parameters. However, the magnitude of these effects varied depending on the product type and formulation. Therefore, each physicochemical parameter is discussed based on the observed experimental results and its relationship to the characteristics of the product matrix. Such interactions are particularly beneficial in high-moisture systems like vegan RTE products, where excessive water release can negatively affect texture and consumer perception.
The addition of kecombrang flower powder and isolated soy protein produced different physicochemical responses depending on the product type. In general, significant effects were observed on pH and certain color parameters, whereas moisture content and water activity tended to remain relatively stable across formulations. These findings indicate that the incorporation of kecombrang powder primarily affected the chemical characteristics of the products rather than their water retention properties.
Moreover, the antioxidant activity of kecombrang may contribute to the preservation of color and flavor during processing and storage. Oxidative reactions are a major cause of quality loss in plant-based meat analogues, leading to discoloration and the development of off-flavors. The incorporation of antioxidant-rich plant powders has been reported to slow lipid and pigment oxidation, thereby improving visual appeal and sensory stability over time
(Naufalin et al., 2021). Although oxidative stability was not directly measured in this study, the observed color stability across formulations suggests that kecombrang powder may play a protective role against thermal and oxidative degradation.
Kecombrang flower powder contributed not only bioactive compounds but also plant fibers and phenolic components, which may affect water binding capacity, acidity and color intensity of the products. Meanwhile, the incorporation of ISP played a crucial role in improving protein network formation, thereby influencing textural properties such as firmness and cohesiveness. The interaction between kecombrang powder and ISP resulted in different responses depending on the processing method and structural characteristics of each product type. These findings indicate that the physicochemical impact of kecombrang flower powder and ISP is formulation-dependent and highlights the importance of optimizing their concentrations to achieve desirable quality attributes in vegan RTE products. In addition to these formulation-dependent effects, the functional role of kecombrang flower powder in vegan RTE products extends beyond basic physicochemical modification. Kecombrang is known to contain phenolic compounds, flavonoids and essential oil fractions that exhibit antimicrobial and antioxidant activities
(Naufalin et al., 2021). These bioactive compounds are particularly relevant in high-moisture plant-based products, where microbial growth and oxidative reactions are major limiting factors for shelf stability. The presence of such compounds may contribute to product preservation by creating less favorable conditions for spoilage microorganisms and reducing oxidative degradation of the food matrix, thereby supporting both safety and quality maintenance during storage
(Silva et al., 2024; Baune et al., 2022).
In this study, vegan sausage, vegan patty and vegan meatball are defined as plant-based ready-to-eat products formulated to mimic the structure, texture and sensory characteristics of their conventional meat-based counterparts, without the use of any animal-derived ingredients. A vegan sausage is defined as a cylindrical plant-based product produced from a homogeneous mixture of plant proteins, fibers and functional ingredients, which is subsequently stuffed into edible casings or formed using shaping equipment and subjected to thermal processing to achieve a compact and elastic texture. Vegan sausages are designed to resemble conventional meat sausages in terms of appearance, bite and mouthfeel. A vegan patty is defined as a flat, disc-shaped plant-based product formulated from plant-derived proteins and binders, which is molded to a uniform thickness and cooked to obtain a firm structure and cohesive texture. Vegan patties are commonly developed as alternatives to beef patties and are characterized by their ability to retain shape during cooking while providing acceptable juiciness and flavor. A vegan meatball is defined as a spherical plant-based product produced from a finely mixed plant-based matrix containing proteins, carbohydrates and binding agents. The product is shaped into small balls and thermally processed to form a cohesive internal structure. Vegan meatballs are intended to mimic traditional meatballs in terms of bite resistance, springiness and overall palatability
Vegan sausage
Moisture content of vegan sausages ranged from 59.57-60.03% and did not differ significantly among formulations, indicating that variations in kecombrang powder and ISP levels were insufficient to markedly alter water retention (
Khoiri and Nurwati, 2024). The role of isolated soy protein in sausage formulations is also supported by
Moirangthem et al., (2022), who reported that the incorporation of soy protein isolate influenced the physicochemical and organoleptic characteristics of low-fat duck sausages. These findings highlight the importance of plant protein functionality in maintaining the structural and quality attributes of sausage products. The appearance of the vegan sausage products is shown in Fig 1.
However, a slight increase in moisture content was observed with decreasing ISP concentration, confirming the well-known role of ISP as an effective water- and fat-binding agent
(Nurmiati et al., 2020). Ash content showed an increasing numerical trend with higher kecombrang levels, reflecting the mineral-rich composition of kecombrang flowers, although differences were not statistically significant (
Santika and Batubara, 2024). The physicochemical characteristics of vegan sausages are summarized in Table 1.
Color analysis revealed that lightness (L*) remained unaffected, while redness (a*) and yellowness (b*) decreased with increasing kecombrang addition. This change may be attributed to thermal browning reactions during processing and the presence of anthocyanin-related pigments from kecombrang
(Naufalin et al., 2021). Increasing kecombrang concentration significantly reduced pH, likely due to organic acids present in the flower
(Naufalin et al., 2007), whereas water activity (aw) remained relatively stable, indicating that the formulation range did not substantially alter free water availability
(Permatasari et al., 2024). The stability of water activity observed in vegan sausages is technologically important, as Aw values below 0.80 are generally associated with reduced microbial proliferation in ready-to-eat foods. When combined with the slight decrease in pH induced by kecombrang powder, this condition may enhance microbiological stability without the need for synthetic preservatives. Similar preservation mechanisms have been reported in meat and fish products enriched with kecombrang-based ingredients, where organic acids and phenolic compounds contributed to antimicrobial effects
(Naufalin et al., 2007; Santika and Batubara, 2024). This finding supports the potential of kecombrang powder as a clean-label preservative in vegan sausage formulations.
Vegan patty
In vegan patties, moisture content was also not significantly affected by formulation differences, suggesting stable water retention across treatments (
Khoiri and Nurwati, 2024). The physical appearance of the vegan patty products is presented in Fig 2. In contrast, ash content differed significantly, indicating that mineral contribution from kecombrang and ISP played a more pronounced role in this product matrix (
Santika and Batubara, 2024). The physicochemical characteristics of vegan patties are presented in Table 2.
Color parameters showed that formulation significantly influenced yellowness (b*), while lightness and redness were unaffected, highlighting selective pigment interactions in the patty system
(Naufalin et al., 2021). pH values were significantly influenced by formulation, confirming that kecombrang powder contributed to increased acidity
(Naufalin et al., 2007). However, similar to sausages, aw values were not significantly different among treatments, indicating consistent water availability despite formulation changes
(Permatasari et al., 2024).
Vegan meatball
Vegan meatballs exhibited moisture contents ranging from 54.57-57.08%, with no significant differences among replications. The appearance of the vegan meatball products is shown in Fig 3. The relatively high moisture content was primarily associated with the intrinsic high water content of oyster mushrooms, which also contributed to the soft and elastic texture of the product (
Wardani and Widjanarko, 2013;
Permatasari et al., 2024). Mushrooms are highly perishable commodities and their physicochemical and textural characteristics may change during storage.
Srivastava et al., (2020) demonstrated that modified atmospheric packaging and storage conditions influenced the biochemical and textural properties of button mushrooms. These findings emphasize the importance of maintaining product quality and stability in mushroom-based food applications. Ash content remained low (0.01-0.64%), reflecting the moderate mineral content of oyster mushrooms and indicating formulation consistency. The physicochemical characteristics of vegan meatballs are summarized in Table 3.
Color differences among replications were minimal and mainly influenced by raw material characteristics and non-enzymatic browning during thermal processing (
Adhiguna, 2024). The pH values (6.4-6.7) were within the neutral range, consistent with oyster mushroom properties and stabilized by the use of phosphate additives, supporting adequate water-binding capacity and product stability
(Nurmiati et al., 2020).
Overall implications
Overall, kecombrang flower powder demonstrated potential as a natural functional ingredient capable of modifying mineral content, color attributes and pH in vegan RTE products without adversely affecting moisture content or water activity
(Naufalin et al., 2007; Santika and Batubara, 2024). These results support the application of kecombrang as a local, plant-based functional additive for improving the quality and potential shelf stability of vegan meat analogues
(Baune et al., 2022; Silva et al., 2024). Furthermore, the utilization of kecombrang flower powder in vegan RTE products offers strategic advantages from a sustainability and local resource perspective. As an indigenous Indonesian plant, kecombrang is readily available and culturally familiar, making it a valuable ingredient for developing region-specific functional foods. The development of plant-based functional foods also requires consideration of nutritional quality and consumer acceptance.
Hasan et al., (2023) demonstrated that soybean variety and fermentation conditions influenced the nutritional and sensory quality of fermented soymilk, highlighting the importance of ingredient selection in developing acceptable plant-based food products.
Its successful incorporation into multiple vegan product formats in this study demonstrates formulation flexibility and potential scalability for industrial application. The integration of kecombrang with commonly used plant proteins such as isolated soy protein aligns with current global trends in plant-based food innovation, which emphasize clean-label formulations, functional performance and the use of natural bioactive ingredients
(Silva et al., 2024).