Physicochemical characteristics
Table 1 presents the physicochemical characteristics of ice cream fortified with shiitake mushroom water extract (SMWE). The results showed that SMWE fortification did not cause significant differences in pH values among treatments (P>0.05). In contrast, viscosity, melting resistance and overrun were significantly affected by SMWE fortification (P<0.05).
Fortifying 1% SMWE significantly increased viscosity and melting resistance compared to the control, but the overrun decreased. As the concentration increased, both melting resistance and viscosity gradually increased and reached their highest values at 3% SMWE. These changes suggest that SMWE affected the structural characteristics of the ice cream system.
The overrun response to SMWE fortification was not linear. The lower overrun values at 1-2% SMWE may be attributed to the higher viscosity of the mix, which limited the incorporation of air during freezing. However, at 3% SMWE, the overrun increased and showed the highest value among all treatments. This suggests that SMWE components may contribute to improved air cell stability at higher concentrations despite increasing the viscosity of the mix.
The variations in viscosity, melting resistance and overrun that were observed are likely associated with the presence of water-soluble polysaccharides in shiitake mushroom extract, particularly β-glucans
(Murphy et al., 2020). Masterson et al., (2020) and
Vezaro et al., (2022) reported that shiitake mushrooms contain considerable amounts of β-glucan, which may function as a natural stabilizer in food systems (
Ahmad and Kaleem, 2018).
Muse and Hartel (2004) and
Bahram-Parvar and Tehrani (2011) also reported that stabilizers can increase mix viscosity, modify melting characteristics and influence the overrun of ice cream.
At low to moderate SMWE concentrations (1-2%), the increased viscosity likely limited air incorporation, resulting in reduced overrun and enhanced melting resistance. This observation is consistent with studies using conventional stabilizers such as guar gum and carboxymethyl cellulose, which reported increased viscosity accompanied by reduced overrun
(Marshall et al., 2003; Kurultay et al., 2010; Bolliger et al., 2000). Soukoulis et al., (2009) and
Muse and Hartel (2004) also indicated that higher viscosity reduces melting by restricting air cell movement and ice crystal growth during storage. Similarly,
Tsai et al., (2020) observed that polysaccharide extracts from
Tremella fuciformis used in ice cream formulations increased viscosity and improved melting resistance.
The increase in overrun at 3% SMWE may indicate a shift in the functional role of â-glucan from primarily thickening the mix to stabilizing air cells within the ice cream structure. At sufficiently high concentrations, these polysaccharides may strengthen the continuous phase and help prevent the collapse of air bubbles during churning.
Aljewicz et al., (2020) reported similar effects in ice cream containing purified β-glucan, which improved melting resistance and increased overrun.
Stone (2009) also noted that variations in β-glucan content, molecular weight and structural properties can influence air cell stability and overrun behavior.
These findings indicate that both viscosity and air-cell stability play important roles in determining overrun. At relatively low concentrations (1-2%), SMWE behaved similarly to conventional stabilizers by increasing viscosity and melting resistance while reducing overrun. At higher concentrations, however, SMWE demonstrated the ability to stabilize air cells, suggesting its potential application in ice cream formulations to improve both viscosity and foam stability.
The SMWE fortification did not significantly affect the pH of ice cream, which remained within a narrow range close to neutral. This finding is consistent with previous studies indicating that shiitake mushroom extracts generally exhibit pH values around neutrality, although variations may occur depending on drying conditions
(Yang et al., 2019). Similarly,
Hereu et al., (2012) and
Dermiki et al., (2013) reported that mushroom extracts did not significantly alter the pH of meat products or other food systems.
Nutritional characteristics
Table 2 shows the nutritional composition of SMWE-fortified ice cream. The addition of SMWE did not significantly affect crude protein, crude fat, or ash content. However, increasing SMWE concentration significantly increased total solids and carbohydrate content while decreasing water content (P<0.05).
As SMWE concentration increased, water content decreased while total solids and carbohydrate levels increased. Ice cream fortified with 3% SMWE had the lowest water content (60.83±4.39%), the highest total solids (39.83±2.56%) and the highest carbohydrate content (28.54±2.83%) among all treatments. These changes are likely associated with the water-binding capacity of β-glucan and other polysaccharides present in SMWE.
Mohammed et al., (2022) reported that â-D-glucan exhibits strong water-binding properties, while
Lestari et al., (2019) demonstrated that stabilizers can influence water retention, texture and viscosity in food systems.
Shiitake mushrooms contain high levels of polysacc-harides, particularly β-glucan, which contributes significantly to their carbohydrate content.
Rahman et al., (2023) and
Miroňuk-Chodakowska and Witkowska (2020) reported that â-glucan accounts for approximately 33.9-37.4% of the total carbohydrates in shiitake mushrooms. The polysaccharide fraction mainly consists of glucose, with smaller amounts of mannose, arabinose, galactose and xylose
(Choi et al., 2016).
Although low levels of SMWE did not significantly affect protein or ash content, slightly higher values were observed at higher concentrations. This trend is supported by studies indicating that shiitake mushrooms naturally contain relatively high protein and ash levels (
Cağlarirmak, 2007;
Zivanovic et al., 2003; Tabata et al., 2006). The fat content slightly decreased as the concentration of SMWE increased, which may be attributed to the aqueous nature of the extract and the relatively low lipid content of shiitake mushrooms
(Rahman et al., 2023).
Sensory characteristics
The sensory test results are shown in Table 3. Panelist responses varied depending on the SMWE concentration, indicating that fortification influenced several sensory attributes. Although all formulations received favorable responses, increasing SMWE concentration gradually reduced scores for overall acceptability, color and flavor. The most preferred formulation was ice cream containing 1% SMWE, which showed comparable scores for color, flavor and overall acceptability to the control sample.
The results obtained in this study are consistent with previous studies reporting that the incorporation of functional or plant-based ingredients in ice cream formulations can influence physicochemical characteristics and sensory acceptability of the final product (
Vanathi and Palani Dorai, 2020;
Kumar et al., 2025). Similar observations were reported in functional ice cream enriched with plant-based ingredients, where improvements in nutritional quality and consumer preference were achieved without adversely affecting product quality
(Varathanathan et al., 2025; Pawar et al., 2011).
As the SMWE concentration increased, texture preference improved, likely due to the ability of SMWE polysaccharides to enhance structural stability. The highest texture score was observed at 3% SMWE. However, at higher SMWE levels, overall acceptability decreased by approximately 2-4%. The lower acceptance at higher SMWE levels was mainly attributed to changes in color and the umami flavor characteristic of shiitake mushrooms.
Argyropoulos et al., (2008), Kurata et al., (2020) and
Chaipoot et al., (2023) reported that processing and drying conditions of mushrooms can result in color changes that influence consumer perception.
Chaipoot et al., (2023) also suggested that the presence of amino acids such as glutamic and aspartic acids contributes to the characteristic savory taste of mushrooms.
These findings indicate that higher concentrations of SMWE (>1%) improved texture but reduced overall sensory acceptability. Therefore, moderate levels of SMWE are preferable to maintain a balance between improved texture and overall sensory quality in ice cream.