Several preliminary trails were conducted to standardize the processing technology of pomegranate peel powder based cow milk
shrikhand on the basis of literature and preliminary trials.
Sensory evaluation of Shrikhand fortified with pomegranate peel powder
Sensory evaluation is critical in determining consumer acceptability of functional dairy products. The sensory attributes of
shrikhand samples enriched with varying levels of pomegranate peel powder (PPP) from 0 part (T
1) to 4 part (T
5), were assessed using a 9-point hedonic scale. Attributes included flavour, mouthfeel, colour and appearance, body and texture and overall acceptability. The sensory evaluation trends observed across treatments are presented in Fig 1.
Flavour and mouthfeel
As shown in Table 1, flavour scores for T
1 and T
2 were the highest (9.00±0.004), with no significant difference (p>0.05), indicating optimal flavour retention upto 1 part PPP inclusion. A significant decrease in flavour score was observed from T
3 (8.00±0.004) to T
5 (6.00±0.004), likely due to the astringent, bitter taste of tannins and polyphenols present in PPP. A similar pattern was noted for mouthfeel, which declined from 9.00±0.003 in T
1 and T
2 to 6.00±0.003 in T
5. The fibrous texture at higher PPP levels possibly contributed to reduced creaminess and smoothness. These findings align with
Suvera (2017) and
Ahmed et al. (2022), who reported flavour deterioration in yogurt with increasing plant fiber additions and apple pomace and pomegranate peel powders addition. Also
El-Said et al. (2014), who revealed that increasing the percentage of the added pomegranate peel extracts resulted in decrease in the sensory score of the stirred yoghurt, there by affected the sweetness.
Colour and appearance
The colour and appearance score of
shrikhand followed a downward trend with increasing PPP. T
1 received the highest score (9.00±0.005), followed by T
2 (8.50±0.005), while T5 scored the lowest (5.50±0.005). The dark reddish-brown hue of PPP, attributable to anthocyanins and condensed tannins, altered the visual appeal of
shrikhand. These findings are supported by
Pugazhenthi et al., (2020), who observed similar declines in visual scores for citrus peel-fortified dairy products and
Ahmed et al., (2022), who reported colour and appearance deterioration in yogurt with increasing apple pomace and pomegranate peel powders addition.
Body and texture
Body and texture score of
shrikhand remained superior in T
1 and T
2 (9.00±0.005), followed by a significant decline in T
3 (8.50±0.005) and T
5 (6.50±0.005). The fibrous particles of PPP likely disrupted the protein matrix, resulting in lower cohesiveness. This observation supports the conclusions of
Ahmed et al., (2022), who reported that body and texture score of yoghurt tended to decrease with the increase in apple pomace and pomegranate peel powders concentrations also
Singh and Immanuel (2014) who reported that paneer prepared by the addition of natural antioxidant extracts of pomegranate, orange and lemon peels were acceptable at 2% level of inclusion. The results were also in close resemblance with the findings of
El-Said et al. (2014), who revealed that increasing the percentage of the added pomegranate peel extracts resulted in decrease in the sensory score of the stirred yoghurt.
Overall acceptability
Overall acceptability of
shrikhand was highest in T
1 (9.00±0.0047) and T
2 (8.87±0.0047), indicating that PPP can be included without compromising palatability. The lowest score (5.87±0.0047) was recorded for T
5. This observation supports the conclusions of
Thorat (2018) and
Abirami (2023), who found that higher levels of fiber-rich plant additives negatively impacted textural and sensory properties of
shrikhand and related dairy products.
Ahmed et al., (2022) found that Overall acceptability scores of functional yoghurt prepared by using freeze-drying on apple pomace and pomegranate peel powders were found to be significantly higher than other analyzed treatments.
El-Shafei et al. (2017) evaluated the possibility of utilization of pomegranate peel extract as natural preservative in goat’s cream cheese, Organoleptic results of these study showed that concentration of Pomegranate peels extract up to 0.5% and 1.0% respectively recorded high scores.
Suryawanshi et al., (2022) reported that incorporation of prebiotics and papaya pulp in synbiotic shrikhand significantly influenced sensory and physicochemical properties of the final product. Likewise, studies on fruit peel incorporated shrikhand demonstrated enhanced antioxidant potential along with acceptable organoleptic quality at optimized levels of incorporation.
Colour attributes
The colour characteristics of
shrikhand samples supplemented with varying concentrations of pomegranate peel powder (PPP) were evaluated using Hunter Lab colour coordinates: L* (Lightness), a* (Red-green axis) and b* (Yellow-blue axis). The results revealed significant alterations in all three colour parameters with increasing levels of PPP, as presented in Table 2.
Lightness (L*)
The reduction in L* values with increasing PPP incorporation is illustrated in Fig 2A significant decline (p<0.05) in the L* values was observed with increasing PPP concentration in
shrikhand formulations. The L* value dropped from 84.93 in T
1 (control) to 62.96 in T
5 (4 part of PPP), indicating a gradual darkening of the product. This reduction in lightness can be attributed to the presence of high levels of Polyphenolic compounds in pomegranate peel, such as tannins and flavonoids, which are known to impart darker hues when incorporated into food matrices. Polyphenols, especially in dried peel form, often leading to the formation of brown pigments, during processing and storage, thereby lowering the lightness index. These findings align with those reported by
Thorat (2018), who observed a similar decrease in lightness in dairy products fortified with polyphenol-rich plant extracts. Additionally,
Kupnik et al., (2021) demonstrated that the addition of phenolic-rich powders, including pomegranate peel, resulted in significantly darker shades in yogurt, cheese and other fermented milk products.
Red-green coordinate (a*)
The increase in redness (a* values) with increasing PPP level is presented in Fig 3. The a* value, which quantifies the red-green colour dimension, increased markedly from -1.29 in T
1 to 6.38 in T
5, suggesting a pronounced shift toward redness with higher PPP inclusion. This positive shift in a* values can be primarily attributed to the presence of anthocyanins, natural water-soluble pigments abundant in pomegranate peel. Anthocyanins are known for their pH-sensitive colour transformations and are responsible for red to purple hues in food systems. The intensification of redness was consistent with findings by
Al-Zoreky (2009), who reported that dairy products enriched with pomegranate derivatives exhibited increased a* values due to the anthocyanin content. The cumulative effect of these pigments, along with potential interactions between milk proteins and phenolic compounds, might have further enhanced the reddish tone in the treated
shrikhand samples.
Yellow-blue coordinate (b*)
The increase in b* values indicating yellow-brown coloration is shown in Fig 4. The b* value, indicative of the yellow-blue chromatic spectrum, increased significantly (p<0.05) from 14.93 in T
1 to 31.42 in T
5, demonstrating a strong trend toward yellowness or yellow-brown coloration. This change was primarily attributed to the accumulation of tannins and other polyphenolic constituents in the PPP, which, upon interaction with milk components, contribute to non-enzymatic pigment development. Furthermore, the natural pigments inherent in PPP, along with its oxidative stability, enhance colour development during storage.
Daoutidou et al., (2021) reported comparable findings in meat and dairy matrices fortified with PPP, noting that the powder not only intensified the yellow-brown hues but also imparted an appealing natural tint to the products.
Overall colour trend
The overall shift in L*, a* and b* values indicates a progressive darkening and enrichment in red-yellow tones with increased PPP addition. These visual modifications are considered favorable from a functional food perspective, as consumers often associate darker colours with higher antioxidant content and natural ingredients. However, the extent of colour change must be balanced to ensure it does not adversely impact sensory acceptability. The trend similarly found in findings of
Altunkaya et al., (2013) that did spectrophotometric measurement of bread enriched with pomegranate peel showed, with increasing levels of PP addition, L*values decreased, while a* and b* values increased, showing that PP affected bread color. These observations were indicative of a loss in brightness of the bread caused by PP.