Quality Assessment and Evaluation of Amino Acid Profile of Black Wheat Supplemented Noodles

Anuprita Joshi1,*, R.B. Kshirsagar1, C.K. Bhokre1, H.W. Deshpande1, A.R. Sawate1
1College of Food Technology, Vasantrao Naik Marathwada Krishi Vidyapeeth, Parbhani-431 401, Maharashtra, India.

Background: Functional foods are a topic of ongoing industrial use and research. Currently, coloured grain is being prioritized more in research since it is a source of neutraceutical chemicals. Black colored wheat is known for its anthocyanin content. Black wheat therefore has the potential to offer extra health advantages over those that standard wheat cultivars typically offer. Noodles are most popular products widely consumed throughout the world and represents second in global consumption to bread. The present study was undertaken to evaluate effect of processing on loss of amino acids content in black wheat supplemented noodles and control white noodles.

Methods: In the present study, High performance liquid chromatography was used for the quantification of amino acids in Black and Netravati white colored wheat flour and prepared black wheat supplemented noodles and control white noodles samples prepared by extrusion.

Result: Black wheat flour and Black wheat supplemented noodles samples had higher total amino acid content, Essential amino acid content and per cent essential amino acid score in comparison Netravati white flour and control noodles samples prepared from whole Netravati white wheat flour, while content of lysine was more in Netravati white wheat flour and control noodles samples. The noodles samples prepared exhibited average percent reduction in amino acid content in black and Netravati white wheat were 1.06 and 2.63%, respectively. Black wheat flour and black wheat supplemented noodles were rich in anthocyanins also rich in amino acids in comparison to Netravati white wheat flour. Minimum losses in amino acid content were observed in Black wheat supplemented noodles, while maximum losses were observed in Netravati white wheat control noodles samples.

A healthy population is one of the country’s most valuable resources since it may benefit both society and the economy. Colored grain is currently receiving increased attention in study since it is a source of neutraceutical compounds and higher amount of essential amino acids in them. The essential amino acids (EAA); must be taken from food since can’t be produced by the human body (Panthee et al., 2006), are necessary for human nutrition and have a substantial impact on a number of biological processes in addition to serving as antioxidants (Zafar et al., 2014). A single essential amino acid deficiency could prevent the production of additional amino acids and the production of other proteins and biological molecules (Jiang et al., 2008).

Wheat (Triticum aestivum) makes a sizable contribution to the daily caloric requirements of the wheat-eating population. The nutritional value of wheat grains is determined by the protein content and amino acid composition (Joye, 2019). Wheat’s amino acid profile is unbalanced and does not include enough EAA, such as Lys, Thr and Met (Jiang et al., 2008). The nutritional background of coloured wheat grains, in particular their amino acid content, is currently poorly understood (Tian et al., 2018).

Therefore, in order to evaluate the amino acid profile of black wheat flour and noodles derived from, the current study was designed. This would be the first study to document how processing affects losses of amino acids developed noodles high in anthocyanins. Such information could be useful to meet nutritional requirements of people, particularly of countries with wheat as staple diet.
Black wheat grains were obtained from local area of Punjab state and traditional wheat variety Netravati as a control sample procured from Seed Research Centre, VNMKV, Parbhani.
 
Standardization of recipe for black wheat supplemented noodles
 
For noodles incorporated with Black wheat flour, slight modifications were made to the method provided by Fu (2008) and Inglett et al., (2003) with replacement of whole wheat flour with black wheat flour (10 to 100 per cent) were tried to obtain the best acceptable formulation. Noodles made with 100 percent Netravati wheat variety flour was considered as a control. After mixing of all ingredients in the extruder, extrusion was occurred and strands of 2.0 mm thickness of noodles were obtained and subjected for steaming over boiling water for 2 minutes. Further the steamed noodles were dried in a cabinet tray drier at 55- 60°C for 3 hours.
 
Determination of protein
 
Protein content was determined by Micro-kjeldhalmethod (AOAC, 2000).
 
Amino acid profile
 
High Performance Liquid Chromatography profiles used to understand the amino acid profiling in black wheat and noodles prepared (Fabiani, 2002).
 
Quality parameters of amino acids
 
The amino acid score (AAS) of each flour sample and black wheat supplemented noodles was calculated using the reference protein values, as provided by the FAO (2013).
Essential amino acids score
 
The essential amino acids score (EAAE) was calculated with reference to the standard recommended by the FAO/WHO (FAO, 1985) and results were expressed with the methodology of Pires et al., (2006).
Amino acid profile of black wheat flour
 
The results in Table 1 revealed that the black wheat flour reported 17 amino acids which are in good agreement with the results of N. Sharma et al., (2022). Out of the 17 amino acids observed both essential (9) and non-essential amino acids (8) contents followed the order: black wheat flour> Netravati wheat flour.

Table 1: Amino acid profile of black wheat flour.



The overall essential amino acid contents in Black wheat flour were at highest concentration than Netravati wheat flour except Lysine which was high in later (2.27 g/100 g of flour). The greatest value was recorded for leucine (22.23 g/100 g of crude protein), followed by lysine (18.90 g/100 g of crude protein). Most of the values obtained for concentrations of all essential amino acids were somewhat higher than those reported previously. According to Wang et al., (2019), environmental factors such as humidity, CO2 concentration, temperature, various biotic and abiotic stresses during crop growth, soil water content, wheat hardness type (hard, soft, or medium), protein content in grains, genetic makeup of wheat varieties and fertilizer use can all affect the amino acid contents of different wheat flours (Zhang et al., 2016).

Among the non-essential amino acids, the Black wheat flour exhibited high concentrations of all eight non-essential amino acid than Netravati wheat flour. Glutamic acid (4.92 g/100 g) was the most abundant non-essential amino acid in Black wheat flour. Next to Glutamic acid, highest concentration of aspartic acid was observed in Black wheat and Netravati wheat flour samples respectively. All other NEAA were at more concentration in Black wheat flour samples as compared to Netravati wheat flour sample. Most of the values obtained for concentrations of all non-essential amino acids were somewhat higher than those reported previously (Sharma et al., 2022).

The black wheat flour had significant concentration of the total amino acid (28.32 g/100 g) and total essential amino acids (12.94 g/100 g) content than Netravati wheat flour (Table 1) and were higher compared to total amino acids reported by Sharma et al., (2022) (13.17 g/100 g). The non-essential amino acids (NEAA) as 15.38 g/100 g for black wheat flour and 12.85 g/100 g for Netravati wheat flour. Tian et al., (2018) concluded that the black, blue and green coloured wheat flours were more nutrient-dense than white wheat flour owing to higher levels of amino acids.

The values for per cent essential amino acids (%EAA) in Black wheat flour were 46.48 per cent and these were higher as compared to reported values of per cent essential amino acids (%EAA) (30.05%) by Sharma et al., (2022). Similar trend was reported for per cent non-essential amino acids (%NEAA) also as reported by Sharma et al., (2022). The higher values of protein content in the black wheat flour might be the reason behind higher values of all amino acids contents. The results are in close agreement the values reported by Siddiqi et al., (2020); Pepo and Gyori (2007) and Sibian et al., (2016) for essential and non-essential amino acids in wheat.
 
Quality parameters of amino acids
 
The completeness of a specific protein is predicted using the amino acid score (AAS). Additionally, a score of 100% or above indicates that a protein is complete with respect to that EAA which is equal to or greater than the standard reference pattern recommended by the FAO/WHO. Less than 100 AAS represents incompleteness of protein with respect to a particular EAA. The AAS for all EAAs were >100 in both Black and Netravati wheat flour samples, indicating the completeness of their proteins with respect to these amino acids (Table 2). Different wheat varieties have various AAS, which can be related to the reference protein utilized, species, geographical origin, harvesting season, environmental circumstances and the physiology and genetics of each species, as well as the method used to measure them (Jiang et al., 2008).

Table 2: Quality parameters of amino acids: Per cent essential amino acid score.



Effect of black wheat flour incorporation on amino acid profile of noodles
 
There was steady increase in the concentration of all the essential and non-essential amino acids with increasing Black wheat flour incorporation except for Lysine as it was decreased because of higher concentration in Netravati wheat flour (Table 3). The sample BN6 as selected on the basis of sensory evaluation having 60 per cent incorporated Black wheat flour contained highest concentration of Leucine (3.01 g/100 g) followed by Lysine (2.21 g/100 g) and Isoleucine (1.59 g/100 g) of noodles respectively. The other essential amino acids such as Threonine (1.52 g/100 g) and Valine (1.46 g/100 g) were also in notable concentration.

Table 3: Effect of Black wheat flour incorporation on essential and non-essential amino acid profile of noodles.



The sample BN6 contained highest concentration of glutamic acid (4.564 g/100 g) followed by aspartic acid (2.802 g/100 g) and proline (2.168 g/100 g) of noodles respectively. The other non-essential amino acids were also in notable concentration. The similar results were obtained by Sharma et al., (2022) as concluded in their study as black wheat flour had more contents of all essential and non-essential amino acids except Tyrosine.

The noodles sample BN6 containing has found to be statistically significant over control noodles sample in all the amino acids concentrations except for Histidine and Methionine, it was at par with control sample.
 
Essential amino acid profile of selected black wheat supplemented noodles (BN6)
 
The results in Table 4 revealed that the sample BN6 had significant amino score for each amino acid except for aromatic amino acids (Phenyl Alanine and Tyrosine) which had amino acid score <100 (88.05%) and for Methionine (77.89%) and it might be due to absence of cysteine in black wheat flour and possible lower values of amino acids scores in Black wheat flour itself.

Table 4: Evaluation of essential amino acid profile of black wheat supplemented Noodles (BN6) for children and adults in comparison with FAO/WHO (1985).



The values for amino acids scores in literature reported previously were >100 for Met + Cys and Phe + Tyr in Black wheat flour and chapatti from it (Sharma et al., 2022). Also the values of all the essential amino acids in selected Black wheat supplemented noodles were reported significant higher values than the Recommended Daily Allowances values suggested by FAO/WHO. The excellent amino acid profile of prepared Black wheat supplemented noodles is an indication of good quality protein.

The black wheat supplemented noodles (BN6) were fulfilling more than 100 per cent requirement of recommended daily allowances as suggested by FAO/WHO (1985) for all age groups mentioned. Moreover BN6 sample had all the amino acids to a greater extent exhibiting score >1.00 for children 2-12 years old and for adults too. The EAAE scores above 1.0 are considered to indicate the protein contains essential amino acids in excess of the human requirements WHO/FAO (1985) could be because black wheat has a higher protein content. The amount of essential amino acids requirement decreased as the age group increased, e.g., for adults.
 
Adult daily recommended allowances (DRA) of indispensable amino acids (IAA) and their composition (mg/g of protein) in proteins from black wheat supplemented noodles (BN6)
 
Table 5 provides a comparative overview of the amounts of indispensable amino acids in the selected Black wheat supplemented noodles with the WHO/ FAO/UNO adult indispensable amino acid requirements pattern (WHO/FAO/UNU, 2007). It is revealed that Black wheat supplemented noodles were found to have IAA levels higher than the levels suggested by WHO/FAO/UNO pattern for adult human’s requirement.

Table 5: Adult daily recommended allowances (DRA) of indispensable amino acids (IAA) and their composition (mg/g of protein) in proteins from black wheat supplemented noodles (BN6).



The noodles had lysine content of 185.7 mg/g protein and it contained sulphur amino acids at a level of 44.4 mg/g protein; these were above the suggested levels by WHO/FAO/UNO. However, total IAAs contents (1033.99 mg IAA/g protein) of Black wheat supplemented noodles exceeded the recommended daily allowance (277 mg IAA/g protein) might be due high content of protein in Black wheat flour. The results obtained in present investigation were higher as compared to reported values in previous literature may be due to varietal difference.
 
Losses in amino acid contents during noodles making
 
Losses in Tryptophan was more (5.13 per cent) in control sample and that of Phenyl alanine (2.23 per cent) in black wheat supplemented noodles as reported in Table 6. Ile was the most resistant to reduction in concentration in control sample and Leucine in black wheat supplemented noodles. Based upon amino acid losses during noodles preparation, black wheat supplemented noodles samples were found to be better than control samples. Noodles were prepared by cold extrusion process and the contents of amino acid were determined for dry samples therefore the losses in amino acid composition were very little as compared to high temperature cooking like steaming or boiling in which amino acids get degraded and oxidized (Adebooyeand Singh, 2007) as reported in previous studies. The amino acid losses ranged between (0.07-2.23%) for black wheat supplemented noodles and (0.72-5.13%) for control samples from Netravati wheat flour. Previous studies such as Filip and Vidrih (2015) reported 50.41% reduction in EAA content upon cooking in wheat pasta.

Table 6: Losses in amino acid contents during noodles making.

Black wheat flour and black wheat supplemented noodles showed greater levels of all essential and non-essential amino acids as well as amino acid scores with percent essential amino acid scores. The Black wheat enriched noodles showed the least amount of amino acid content losses, which may have been caused by their higher anthocyanin content than the Netravati white wheat control noodle samples. It has been revealed that anthocyanins have the ability to conceal and protect amino acids and proteins from oxidative alterations and heat. Thus, anthocyanin-rich Black wheat showed improved amino acid stability and might significantly improve the nutritional quality of human meals if employed as food ingredients or as a component of flours. Hence, anthocyanin rich Black wheat could contribute greatly in increasing the nutritional quality of food if included in flours or used as food ingredients.
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.

  1. AOAC, (Association of Official Analytical Chemists), (2000). Official Method of Analysis (13th ed.). Washington, DC, USA: AOAC.

  2. Adebooye, O.C. and Singh, V. (2007). Effect of cooking on the profile of phenolics, tannins, phytate, amino acid, fatty acid and mineral nutrients of whole-grain and decorticated vegetable cowpea [Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp]. Journal of Food Quality. 30(6): 1101-1120.

  3. Fabiani, A., Versari, A., Parpinello, G.P., Castellari, M. and Galassi, S. (2002). High-performance liquid chromatographic analysis of free amino acids in fruit juices using derivatization with 9-fluorenylmethyl-chloroformate. Journal of Chromatographic Science. 40(1): 14-18.  

  4. FAO, (2013). Dietary Protein Quality Evaluation in Human Nutrition: Report of an FAO Expert Consultation. Rome.

  5. Filip, S. and Vidrih, R. (2015). Amino acid composition of protein- enriched dried pasta: Is it suitable for a low-carbohydrate diet? Food Technology and Biotechnology. 53(3): 298-306.

  6. Fu, B.X. (2008). Asian noodles: History, classification, raw materials and processing. Food Research International. 41: 888-890.

  7. Inglett, G.E., Peterson, S.C., Carriere, C.J., Maneepun, S. (2003). Rheological, textural and sensory properties of Asian noodles containing an oat cereal hydrocolloid. Food Chemistry. 90: 1-8.

  8. Jiang, X.L., Tian, J.C., Zhi, H.A.O. and Zhang, W.D. (2008). Protein content and amino acid composition in grains of wheat- related species. Agricultural Sciences in China. 7(3): 272-279.

  9. Joye, I. (2019). Protein digestibility of cereal products. Foods. 8(6): 199. doi: 10.3390/foods8060199.

  10. Panthee, D.R., Pantalone, V.R., Saxton, A.M., West, D.R. and Sams, C.E. (2006). Genomic regions associated with amino acid composition in soybean. Molecular Breeding. 17(1): 79-89. 

  11. Pepo, P. and Gyori, Z. (2007). Amino acid compositions in wheat species with different genomes. Cereal Research Communications. 35(4): 1685-1699.

  12. Pires, C., Vieira, M.G., Jose, C.R. and Neuza, M.B.C. (2006). Nutritional quality and chemical score of amino acids from different protein sources. Food Science and Technology. 26: 179-187.

  13. Sharma, N., Kumari, A., Chunduri, V., Kaur, S., Banda, J., Goyal, A. and Garg, M. (2022). Anthocyanin biofortified black, blue and purple wheat exhibited lower amino acid cooking losses than white wheat. LWT - Food Science and Technology. 154: 1-9.

  14. Sibian, M.S., Saxena, D.C. and Riar, C.S. (2016). Nutritional and functional quality analysis and amino acid score evaluation of germinated wheat (Triticum aestivum) grain. International Journal of Food Sciences and Nutrition. 1(4): 16-22.

  15. Siddiqi, R.A., Singh, T.P., Rani, M., Sogi, D.S. and Bhat, M.A. (2020). Diversity in grain, flour, amino acid composition, protein profiling and proportion of total flour proteins of different wheat cultivars of North India. Frontiers in Nutrition. 7: 141. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2020.00141.

  16. Tian, S.Q., Chen, Z.C. and Wei, Y.C. (2018). Measurement of colour- grained wheat nutrient compounds and the application of combination technology in dough. Journal of Cereal Science. 83: 63-67.

  17. Wang, J., Hasegawa, T., Li, L., Lam, S.K., Zhang, X., Liu, X. et al. (2019). Changes in grain protein and amino acids composition of wheat and rice under short-term increased [CO2] and temperature of canopy air in a paddy from East China. New Phytol. 222: 726-734.

  18. WHO, (1985). Energy and Protein Requirements: Report of a Joint FAO/WHO/UNU Expert Consultation. WHO Technical Report Series No. 724. Geneva: WHO.

  19. WHO/FAO/UNU, (2007). Protein and Amino Acid Requirements in Human Nutrition; Report of a joint WHO/FAO/UNU Expert Consultation, WHO Tech Rep Ser no. 935. Geneva: WHO.

  20. Zafar, S.N., Nazir, N., Abbas, S., Khan, M., Abdul, (2014). Analysis of selected amino acids in different varieties of wheat available in Punjab, Pakistan. Chromatography Research International.

  21. Zhang, M., Ma, D., Wang, C., Zhao, H., Zhu, Y. and Guo, T. (2016). Responses of amino acid composition to nitrogen application in high- and low-protein wheat cultivars at two planting environments. Crop Science. 56: 1277-87. 

Editorial Board

View all (0)