Zootechnical performance and mortality ratio
The results regarding the effects of incorporating Milk thistle seeds into broiler feed and drinking water on zootechnical Performance are summarized, in Table 2.
The highest ²FI² was noted for the “control” group with a value of 4300.32 g and the lowest was noted for experimental group ²2² (3674.12 g), while values of 4241.21 g and 3818.68 g were noted for experimental groups ²3² and²1², respectively. Although Milk thistle seeds incorporated into the feed and drinking water increased feed intake compared with other ²experimental groups² it remained lower than that of the ²control² group.
In contrast,
Zaker-Esteghamati et al., (2020) reported that consumption of 0.8% heat-treated Milk thistle seeds increased ²FI² in broilers of the Cobb 500 strain. Similarly,
Fani et al., (2013) showed that Milk thistle
’s active ingredient, silymarin, had a positive effect on feed intake.
The group with the highest live weight at slaughter was recorded as group ²4², with an average of 2803.50 g. The lowest live weight, at 2493.20 g, was recorded for group ²3², while group ²C² and ²2² recorded values of 2578.90 g and 2708.60 g, respectively. The ANOVA test (P<0.05) showed that the incorporation of Milk thistle seeds in the feed (1.5%) and drinking water (1.5%) had an effect on live weight at slaughter (2803.50 g) compared to groups ²C, 2 and 3². A significant difference was observed between group “3” and group ²4², according to the Tukey post-hoc test.
Our results are in agreement with
Janocha et al., (2021), who demonstrated that incorporating ground Milk thistle seeds (2/3%) into the diets of Ross 308 broilers throughout the rearing period (42 d) significantly increased live weight at slaughter. Similarly,
Gawel et al., (2003) reported an increase in live weight at slaughter of broilers when they received silymarin. However, according to
Sťastník et al., (2016), the addition of Milk thistle seed cake to the feed of Ross 308 broilers at 5% and 15% did not affect the average body weight. In their study, the control group had a weight of 2320.31 g, while the experimental groups at 5% and 15% had weights of 2166.69 g and 1988.78 g, respectively.
Regarding the ²CI², group 3 had the lowest ²CI² (1.40), while group C had the highest ²CI² (1.66). Groups ²3² and ²4² had CIs of 1.47 and 1.51, respectively. The inclusion of ground Milk thistle seeds in the broiler feed (3%) significantly reduced the Consumption Index (CI) (P<0.05) compared to the other groups. A significant difference was observed between group “C” and group ²2², as determined by the Tukey test.
Kralik et al., (2015), demonstrated that adding 3% Milk thistle oil to the diet of Cobb 500 broilers increased the”CI”. Similarly, the introduction of 0.5% Milk thistle in the diet of broilers decreased feed conversion compared to other chickens fed a feed without additives; Milk thistle, state
Kalantar et al., (2014). Our results are not in agreement with those of
Zaker-Esteghamati et al., (2020), who obtained a slightly higher feed conversion ratio in the 0.4% heat-treated raw Milk thistle seed diet (1.37) than in the 0.8% heat-treated Milk thistle seed diet (1.36).
The recorded ²AWG” for group ²C² was 58.87 g, while group ²2² had a value of 61.91 g. Group ²4² had the highest ²AWG² (64.11 g), while group ²3² showed a significant drop in ²AWG² (56.91 g).
The inclusion of 1,5% Milk thistle seeds in both feed and drinking water significantly increased average gain (P<0.05) compared to the other groups. The Tukey test revealed a significant difference between groups ²3² and ²4².
Our findings differ from those of
Suchý et al., (2008), who reported that incorporating 0.2% and 1% Milk thistle Seed Cake in Ross 308 broiler feed resulted in a decrease in average gain. In contrast,
Ahmad et al., (2019) obtained similar results to ours, finding significantly higher mean weight gain (P<0.05) for the groups fed a ration containing 10 g/kg and 15 g/kg of Milk thistle seed powder. During the 2
nd, 3
rd, 4
th and 5
th weeks, the addition of 15 g/kg of Milk thistle seed powder to the broiler feed significantly increased the average weight gain, followed by the group fed 10 g/kg of Milk thistle seed powder.
During the entire test period, groups ²C² and ²3² did not experience any mortalities. However, groups ²2² and ²4² had a ²MR²of 4%. The observed health issues included aerosacculitis, fibrinous pneumonia, perihepatitis and pericarditis. Additionally, a sporadic case of colibacillosis was suspected. No treatment was administered to living subjects, as they did not exhibit any symptoms.
Production performance
The results regarding the effects of incorporating Milk thistle seeds into feed and drinking water on broiler production performance are summarized, in Table 3.
The impact of Milk thistle seeds on carcass weight and liveris significant (P<0.05). Group ²4² recorded the highest average weights for full carcass (2327 g), empty carcass (1968.30 g) and liver (54.70 g), compared with those of group ²3², which represented the lowest values (2050 g, 1728.90 g, 43 g), respectively.
Group ²2² had weights of 2239 g for full carcass, 1889 g for empty carcass and 51.90 g for liver, followed lastly by group ²C² at 2221.10 g, 1881.60 g and 49.70 g, respectively. The incorporation of Milk thistle seeds in feed and water (1.5%) “group 3² significantly increased liver weight (p<0.05). The Tukey test revealed a significant difference between group ²3² and ²2².
Our results are similar to those of
Tavakolinasab et al., (2020), who concluded that Milk thistle extract added at 250 mg/kg to broiler feed resulted in an increase in liver weight. However, introducing 15% Milk thistle seed cake into the broiler diet increased liver weight compared to control groups and chickens fed a diet containing 5% Milk thistle, but the effect was not statistically significant (P>0.05).
The addition of Milk thistle seeds to the feed and drinking water did not significantly affect ²CY², abdominal fat weight (P>0.05). In our experiment, the highest “CY” was found in group ²C² (73.11%) compered to group ²3² (69.39%). No significant difference was found between the different groups (P>0.05) according to Welch’s test.
Our results are similar to those of
Schiavone et al., (2007), who found that the addition of 40 and 80 ppm silymarin to the feed of Ross 308 strain broilers decreased ²CY², however the control group recorded the highest yield (75.04%). Similarly,
Sťastník et al., (2016), found in their experiment that the use of 5% and 15% Milk thistle seeds did not have a positive impact on ²CY², with the control group still recording the highest yield.
Group ²2² recorded the highest average abdominal fat weight of 37.40 g, compared to 34.40 g for the control group, whose subjects had the least amount of fat. The inclusion of Milk thistle seeds in the ration and/or drinking water did not have a positive impact on abdominal fat. A research study carried out by
Rashidi et al., (2015), shows that the incorporation rates 0.5%, 1%, 1.5%, 2% of Milk thistle seeds in broiler feed do not have a significant effect on abdominal fat weight. Similarly, a significant reduction in abdominal fat was recorded in broilers fed a diet containing 250 mg/kg Milk thistle extract,
Tavakolinasab et al., (2020).
Biochemical parameters
The results regarding the effects of incorporating Milk thistle seeds into broiler feed and drinking water on certain biochemical parameters are summarized in, Table 4.
Incorporation of Milk thistle seeds into the feed and/or drinking water had no significant effect (P>0.05) on AST, ALT and glucose. Regarding AST, group ²2² had the highest average (390 IU/L) compared with (366.80 IU/L) for the Control group but this increase was not significant.
For ALT, the highest value was recorded in group ²4², where animals received Milk thistle in their feed ration and drinking water,
i.e. 4.10 IU/L, while group ²C² recorded the lowest value, 3 IU/L.
The results show that the highest blood glucose level was obtained in the control group (2.05 g/l), while the lowest glucose level was reported in group ²3² (1.93 g/l).
The results obtained by
Tavakolinasab et al., (2020), show that adding Milk thistle extract at 250 mg/kg to broiler feed significantly reduced (P<0.05) glucose (164.40 mg/dl), AST (4.53 IU/L) and ALT (212.67 IU/L) levels, respectively, compared to the control group, which recorded 191.23 mg/ml glucose, 300.33 IU/L ALT and 8 IU/L AST.