The present study was undertaken to determine the efficiency of
Lactobacillus plantarum as a biocontrol agent against some foodborne pathogens
viz.
Staphylococcus aureus,
Escherichia coli and
Bacillus cereus. The extent of antibacterial activity of
L. plantarum against these pathogens was also studied.
Occurrence of S. aureus, E. coli and B. cereus in foods and clinical sample
Out of 20 samples comprising of raw milk (5), mastitic milk (5), raw chicken meat (5) and sheep faecal samples (5) that were screened for the presence of
S. aureus, 9 turned out to be positive for
Staphylococcus spp. and of theses 9 isolates, 6 were identified as
S. aureus (Table 3) based on morphological and biochemical characteristics. One isolate each was recovered from raw chicken and sheep faecal samples and two isolates each were recovered from raw milk and mastitis milk samples, respectively. The isolates of
S. aureus on Baird-Parker Agar (BPA) showed typical jet black colored colonies surrounded by white halo zone (Lecithinase activity). On Gram staining, the gram-positive cocci arranged in bunches were seen under a microscope. The
Staphylococcus isolates characterized biochemically gave a positive reaction for catalase, methyl red test and Voges-Proskauer while as negative reaction was observed for oxidase activity and indole reaction. On the basis of these tests, out of 20 samples, 9 isolates of
Staphylococcus spp. were identified. These 9 isolates were subjected to coagulase test and 6 coagulase positive isolates were recognized, thereby confirmed as
S. aureus.
Similarly, for isolation of
E. coli, raw milk (5), mastitic milk (5), raw chicken meat (5) and sheep faecal samples (5) were screened and 7 isolates were recovered (Table 3). The isolates of
E. coli were recovered from raw milk (2), meat (2) and faecal samples (3) and from the mastitis milk none of the isolates of
E. coli could be recovered. Of the 7 isolates recovered 4 isolates were selected for experimental testing of which one each were from raw milk and chicken and two isolates included those recovered from sheep faecal samples. All the isolates that produced a characteristic greenish metallic sheen on Eosine Methylene Blue (EMB) were presumptively considered as
E. coli and were small rod shaped when seen under a microscope
. The
E. coli isolates characterized biochemically revealed positive reactions for catalase, indole and methyl red. While as isolates were negative for oxidase, voges- proskauer, citrate and urease utilization and triple sugar iron fermentation activity.
For isolation of
B. cereus, 5 samples each of raw milk, mastitic milk, raw chicken meat and sheep faecal samples were screened and in total 5 isolates were recovered. The isolates were recovered from raw milk (2), raw chicken (2) and faecal samples (1). Of the 5 isolates, 4 were tested in the experiment of which, 2 were recovered from raw milk and 1 isolate each was taken from raw chicken and faecal samples. All presumptive isolates of
B. cereus showed typical fimbriate or crenate peacock blue colored colonies with egg yolk reaction (Lecithinase activity) on PEMBA medium. On morphological characterization all the isolates were found to be Gram positive, rod shaped, spore formers and were devoid of toxin crystals. All the isolates were motile and strongly hemolytic (β-hemolytic) on 5 per cent sheep blood agar. The presumptive isolates of
B. cereus were further characterized using biochemical tests. The isolates reduced nitrate, were also positive for VP and citrate utilization tests. All the isolates fermented glucose both aerobically and anaerobically and none of the isolates fermented mannitol.
The inhibitory effect of
L. plantarum was observed on
in vitro growth of selected pathogens (
S. aureus,
B. cereus and
E. coli). The enumeration of these pathogens was carried out after different incubation periods (24 hrs, 36 hrs and 48 hrs). The standard concentration of pathogens (10
8/ml) was grown along with varying concentration of
L. plantarum (10
4 to 10
8/ml). The mean colony forming counts of
S. aureus in the controls after 24 hrs of incubation were found to be 622.66 x 10
8 CFU/ml and in treatment groups the counts were 2.56 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.78 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.90 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 3.03 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 39.19 x 10
8 CFU/ml treated with 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml of
L. plantarum, respectively. The mean counts of
S. aureus in control groups were statistically higher compared to treatment groups. After 36 hrs of incubation the mean counts of
S. aureus in different treatment groups with concentrations of
L. plantarum as 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml the counts were 2.04 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.44 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.39 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.97 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 74.60 x 10
8 CFU/ml, respectively. In the control group, the counts after 36 hrs of incubation were 7466.66 ´ 108 CFU/ml. Therefore, the difference in the mean counts of control group and all the treatment groups was statistically significant. The mean counts of
S. aureus in the control group after 48 hrs of incubation were 902.66 x 10
8 CFU/ml. The mean counts of
S. aureus after 48 hrs in different treatment groups with concentration of
L. plantarum as 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml were 0.11 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.14 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.17 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.23 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 3.87 x 10
8 CFU/ml, respectively. Again the difference in the counts of
S. aureus between all the treatment groups and the control group were statistically significant.
For
E. coli the mean colony forming units in the control group after 24 hours of incubation were 446.66 x 10
8 CFU/ml and were 0.81 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.09 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.36 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.85 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 24.62 x 10
8 CFU/ml, when grown with 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml, of
L. plantarum, respectively. The counts in the control group were significantly higher compared to all the treatment groups. After 36 hrs of incubation mean colony forming units of the control group was 5720.00 x 10
8 CFU/ml. The treatment groups with concentration of
L. plantarum as 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml, was 1.13 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.64 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.20 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 2.54 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 24.84 x 10
8 CFU/ml, respectively. A significant difference was there in the mean counts of
E. coli between the control and treatment groups at 36 hrs of incubation. The mean colony forming counts of
E. coli in control group after 48 hrs of incubation was 624.66 ´ 108 CFU/ml. The counts of
E. coli in the treatment groups after 48 hrs of incubation were 0.10 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.12 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.14 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.18 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 2.26 x 10
8 CFU/ml when grown with 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 104/ml of
L. plantarum, respectively. The difference in the counts of treatment and control was statistically significant.
After 24 hrs of incubation the mean colony forming counts of
B. cereus in the control group was 83.60 x 10
8 CFU/ml and in the treatment groups the counts of
B. cereus were 0.31 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.43 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.60 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 0.69 x 10
8/ CFU/ml and 7.12 x 10
8 CFU/ml, when grown with
L. plantarum with concentration of 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml, respectively. Statistically, it was seen that the mean colony forming units of control group of
B. cereus varied significantly with
B. cereus treated with different concentrations of
L. plantarum. Similarly, the counts of
B. cereus were highest in the control group (1330 x 10
8 CFU/ml) compared to all the treatment groups. The counts of treatment groups with the concentration of
L. plantarum as 10
8, 10
7, 10
6, 10
5 and 10
4/ml were 1.22 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.31 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.60 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.73 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 6.86 x 10
8 CFU/ml, respectively. All the counts of treatment groups were statistically lower compared to control groups. The counts of
B. cereus in the control group after 48 hours of incubation were 1434.66 x 10
8 CFU/ml. In the treatment groups with different concentration of
L. plantarum viz. 108, 107, 106, 105 and 104/ml the counts of
B. cereus were 1.30 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.31 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.46 x 10
8 CFU/ml, 1.57 x 10
8 CFU/ml and 7.56 x 10
8 CFU/ml, respectively. The difference in the counts of
B. cereus in the control group and all the treatment groups was statistically significant.
Food-borne diseases are of global concern and the World Health Organization estimated that diarrheal diseases are responsible for around 1.9 million child deaths every year (
WHO, 2008). Despite improved hygiene and sanitation, there is an increased incidence of food-borne diseases around the globe and more so in developing countries. Many technologies have been employed to combat the food-borne pathogens involving physical and chemical methods, but they are with many disadvantages. These conventional preservative methods may be at the cost of food quality, for example, heat treatments are associated with deterioration of organoleptic properties, extensive use of antimicrobials have led to the development of resistant bacteria and chemical preservatives have a negative effect not only on sensory parameters but also on health as many of them are carcinogenic. Therefore, the consumers prefer organic food which is free from all sorts of chemicals and the addition of chemical preservatives prevents consumers to buy these products. Hence, there is a need for new strategies that fulfill consumer demand and ensure food safety. One such promising approach is the use of a natural antagonist towards pathogenic bacteria to control food-borne diseases as well as bacterial contamination in foods by a process called as biocontrol. The biocontrol methods may tackle the drawbacks of current processing and preservation technologies and is likely to be acceptable to consumers. One such method involves the use of beneficial bacteria to control harmful bacteria, the classical example being Lactic Acid Bacilli (LAB).
The main properties of beneficial/probiotic microorganisms involve equilibrating the endogenous microflora, in protecting the gut from pathogen invasion by competitive exclusion and production of antimicrobial molecules and in stimulating mucosal immunity. Of the various species of LAB,
Lactobacillus plantarum is one of the most versatile species with valuable use in milk industry and recognized probiotic features (
Da Silva Sabo, 2014;
Guidone et al., 2014). Concurrently, because of the increasing attention of consumers for healthy and natural food the food industry is prompted towards scientific research to investigate the application of natural compounds for the processing of food products, in order to eliminate or reduce chemical additives used as antimicrobial agents. Thus, in recent decades, several lines of research have tried to find the natural solution to the chemical problem. Among these, the selection of microbial molecules or bacterial strains able to produce such compounds to be used as antimicrobials and preservatives, proved that Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB) could be suitable candidates for biocontrol (
Da Silva Sabo, 2014;
Suskovi et al., 2010).
The present study was carried out to study
In-vitro antagonistic effect of
Lactobacillus plantarum on the growth of some important food-borne pathogens
viz. Staphylococcus aureus, Escherichia coli and
Bacillus cereus recovered from foods of animal origin and clinical sources. The isolation and identification of these pathogens were carried out by standard microbiological protocols. The pathogenic isolates recovered from various foods of animal origins were also characterized for virulence properties involving molecular methods. The experiment was also carried out on these pathogens, in order to assess the extent of antibacterial effect of
L. plantarum on the pathogenic isolates involving disc diffusion assay.
Staphylococcus aureus is widely distributed across the globe and is linked to an array of infections in humans and animals. The organism is profoundly known for its pathogenicity and ability to diminish the impact of antimicrobials. The organism causes infections, ranging from mild superficial skin to severe and fatal diseases. In the present study, of the 20 samples comprising of raw milk (5), mastitis milk (5), raw chicken (5) and sheep faecal samples (5) screened for isolation of
S. aureus, 6 turned out positive making an overall occurrence of 30%. The results concur with the observations of
Philip et al., (2006) reporting an occurrence of 31.6% from foods of animal origin. Among all the categories of the samples processed, the highest occurrence (40%) of
S. aureus was found in mastitis milk samples. Similar results from mastitic milk were reported by
Sharma et al., (2015) and
Awad et al., (2017), with 33.7% and 42% occurrence of
S. aureus, respectively. The highest recovery of
S. aureus from mastitis milk samples indicates that the pathogen is one of the prime causes of mastitis in bovines in this part of the world. The reports of
S. aureus being one of the leading causes of mastitis in cattle has been reported by other authors as well
(Reshi et al., 2015, Wells et al., 1998). Of the raw milk samples, 2 (40%) were positive for
S. aureus. The results are in agreement with the findings of
Suelam et al., (2012), reporting 30% occurrence of
S. aureus in raw milk samples.