MacConkey’s broth, Nutrient broth and Violet Red bile broths are most commonly used for the growth of coliforms in the analysis of dairy and food products. With an aim to develop competitive broth, lactose was kept as main essential ingredient. On the basis of preliminary trials Bile salts, Sodium chloride, Di-sodium phosphate, Mono sodium phosphate, Yeast extract powder lactose monohydrate and Tergitol were considered for base broth formulation.
Design Expert 10.0.1 used responses of the preliminary trials for formulation of broth with some range of parameters. These factors were Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (in the range 0.1-0.4 g/100 ml), Gentamicin sulphate + Amoxycillin (1 mg/ml of each in 1:1 proportion per 100 ml) ranged from 5 µl -15 µl/100 ml and Cefsulodin (10 mg/10ml) ranged from 125-500 µl/100 ml). The software suggested 20 runs which are given in Table 2.
Influence of varying levels of ingredients on the growth of coliforms and targeted organisms
Sodium lauryl sulphate salt usually added as an inhibitors of gram positive organisms. Gentamycin has a wide spectrum activity due aminoglycoside group against
Pseudomonas aeruginosa,
E. coli,
Proteus spp.,
Klebsiella spp.,
Enterobacter spp.,
Serratia spp.,
Providencia spp.,
Acinetobacter spp.,
Citrobacter spp.,
Morganella spp.,
S. aureus, Staphylococcus spp.,
Viridansstertococci, Enterococcus spp. and Mycobacterium
spp. (www.antimicrobe.org). Gentamicin sulphate is effective against gram positive bacteria and gram negative bacteria hence added with Amoxycillin and allowed the design expert to decide at what rate it would be effective against targeted organism
Ilomuanya et al., (2018). Amoxycillin is effective against many different bacteria including
H. influenzae,
N. gonorrhoea,
E. coli,
Pneumococci,
Streptococci and certain strains of
Staphylococci (www.medicinenet.com). Cefsulodin is useful selective agent against
Aeromonas spp. and suggested to promote coliforms
(Alonso et al., 1996). Slack et al., (1979) put forward combinations of Cefsulodin and Gentamicin to have additive or synergistic activity against a strains of
Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Supporting to this finding,
Price and Wildeboer (2016) suggested that false positive coliform results were due to the presence of
Aeromonas spp. which could be eliminated by using Cefsulodin in the media formulation.
LMX broth first described by
Manafi and Kneifel (1989) was modified later by
Ossmer (1993) to improve substrate utilization, sensitivity and reduction of incubation time up to 24 h. In this broth added Sodium lauryl sulphate @ 0.1 g/liter was good in inhibition of gram positive microflora. MI agar method recommended by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency for determination of total coliforms and
Escherichia coli uses Cefsulodin, an antibiotic, to inhibit non-targeted growth which likely to cause false positive reactions (oh.water.usgs.gov).
Brenner et al. (1993) on the same line of work developed a new membrane filter agar medium consisting cefsulodin in levels of 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 10, 15 and 25 µg/ml. In that study, they found that addition of cefsulodin @ 5 ml of a freshly prepared 1 mg/ml filter sterilized solution greatly reduced the background counts of
Flavobactenium and
Aeromonas species.
Geissler et al. (2000) compared the performance of Lauryl sulfate MUG X-gal (LMX) broth, Chromocult Coliform agar (CC) and Chromocult Coliform agar plus cefsulodin (10 mg/ml) (CC-CFS), with standard multiple tube fermentation (MTF), for the enumeration of total coliforms and
Escherichia coli from marine recreational waters. Overall CC-CFS showed that total coliforms recovered as 2.63, 1.95 and 1.90 times in LMX, CC and MTF respectively indicting potential use of cefsulodin.
The quadratic model for evaluating a formulated broth; parameters under investigations like changes in the population of coliforms, inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028,
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212 and
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 were obtained through successive regression analysis. The Model F, the coefficient of determination (R2) and the adequate precision value (APV) for changes in coliforms, inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028,
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212 and
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 suggested a better fit of the quadratic model highlighting the suitability of it to navigate the design. Anova for regression analysis of these changes in given in Table 3.
Effect of varying levels of ingredients on the growth of coliforms
The values presented in Table 3 revealed that addition of Sodium lauryl sulphate salt had significant (P<0.05) positive effect on the growth of coliforms at linear level while interaction of sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (AB), sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Cefsulodin (AC) and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin and Cefsulodin (BC) had a non-significant effect on the inhibition of coliforms. At quadratic level all the ingredients showed highly significant (P<0.01) negative effects on the growth of coliforms.
The response surface plot generated multiple regression equation for Coliforms
, Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028,
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212,
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 and corresponding graphs for these equations are shown in Fig 1 to 4.
Effect of varying levels of ingredients on the growth of Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028
It was observed that addition of Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (A) had highly significant (P<0.01) effect on the inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028 at linear level and significant effect (P<0.05) at quadratic level (Table 3). The interactive effect of ingredients Sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (AB) and Sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Cefsulodin (AC) had a highly significant (P<0.01) effect while interaction of Gentamicin sulphate+ Amoxycillin and Cefsulodin (BC) had a significant (P<0.05) effect on the inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028. The square of factors indicated that all the ingredients decreased growth of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028. Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (A) had a significant effect (P<0.05) and Cefsulodin (C) had a highly significant effect (P<0.01) on the inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028.
Effect of varying levels of ingredients on the growth of Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212
The values presented in Table 3 revealed that addition of ingredient Cefsulodin (C) had significant effect (P<0.01) on the inhibition of
Enterococcus faecalis at linear level while other ingredients Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (A) and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (B) had a non- significant effect. Interaction of Sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Cefsulodin (AC) had a highly significant (P<0.01) effect on the inhibition of
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212. The square of factor (quadratic) indicated the Cefsulodin (C) had highly significant effect (P<0.01).
Effect of varying levels of ingredients on the growth of Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923
The addition of Cefsulodin (C) had a highly significant (P<0.01) effect on the inhibition of
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923 at linear level; however Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (A) and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (B) had a non-significant effect. Again as shown in Table 3, the interactive effect of Sodium lauryl sulphate salt and Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (AB) had a highly significant positive effect at P<0.01 while interactive effect of Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin and Cefsulodin (BC) had a significant positive effect (P<0.05) on the inhibition of
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923. The square of factor (quadratic) model indicated the Sodium lauryl sulphate salt (A) had highly significant effect (P<0.01) while Cefsulodin (C) had a significant effect (P<0.05) on the inhibition of
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923.
Optimization of selected ingredients in the developed selective broth
RSM suggested that Sodium lauryl sulphate salt @ 0.2226 µl/100 ml, Gentamicin sulphate+Amoxycillin (1:1 ratio) @ 10.1344 µl/ 100 ml and Cefsulodin @ 301.951 µl/100 ml as the most suitable solution with desirability of 0.92%. However, during actual trials, it was observed that Sodium lauryl sulphate salt @ 0.2, Gentamicin sulphate + Amoxycillin (1:1 ratio) @ 10 µl and Cefsulodin @ 312.5 µl per 100 ml were found best for the maximum coliforms growth response and best in the inhibition of
Salmonella typhi ATCC 14028,
Enterococcus faecalis ATCC 29212 and
Staphylococcus aureus ATCC 25923. The process was replicated seven times. The selected factors and the average values of the results were derived. The values of the selected constraints shown in Table 4 were compared statistically using paired t-test with that of the predicted values. Level of importance 3 for all three constraints indicated that addition of each ingredient is moderately important in broth formulation. The calculated values of all these selected constraints suggest that the calculated values of ‘t’ for all the constraints were less than the table values, thus it was inferred that there was no significant (P>0.05) difference between the predicted and actual values of responses.
It was therefore confirmed that the selected combination of the factors was the best in terms of the responses delineated at the study. Final optimized formulation of the coliforms broth is provided in Table 5 and photograph of the formulated broth is shown in Fig 5.