Effect on Physic-chemical Quality of Soymilk Blended Channa based Sweetmeat by using Natural Coagulant

A.S. Honkar1,*, A.S. Hembade1
1Department of Dairy Science, Yeshwant Mahavidyalaya, Nanded-431 602, Maharashtra, India.
Background: Animal origin protein prices are beyond the purchasing capacity of average population. So for those who cannot afford costly protein available in market, plant origin protein source is very good choice e.g. Soybean. Many food scientists are working on to enhance the nutritive value of milk products. In this investigation an attempt has been carried out to enhance nutritive value of sweetmeat with low cost of production by using natural coagulant.

Methods: In this investigation soymilk used for partial replacement of cow milk in order to reduce cost of production of Channa Murki. Passion fruit juice (PFJ) having good nutritional properties successfully used for coagulation. 

Result: From this investigation it has been concluded that passion fruit juice can be successfully used instead of traditional coagulants in making of coagulated dairy products with high nutritive value.
Milk is widely used in the preparation of sweetmeats. The sweetmeats made from milk are delicious, highly nutritious and very popular items. On occasions like birthday, marriages, funerals, religious festivals everywhere sweetmeats are unavoidable. Channa Murki has a longer shelf life owing to its preparation by heat desiccation of Channa in sugar syrup in an open pan, reducing its water activity and thus spoilage (Gurditta et al., 2020).

Soyabean regarded as an ideal food because it contains high quantity and quality protein. So to fulfil our body protein requirement soyabean is a very cheap and nutritious source. Soymilk is good alternative for people who cannot consume dairy products due to their lactose intolerance, milk protein allergy or galactosemia (Xu and Chang, 2009). Soymilk is a water solution of soybean constituents, such as high quality proteins, essential fatty acids, carbohydrates, vitamins and minerals; however it does not contain cholesterol, gluten and lactose (Roque et al., 2013). Due to use of soymilk replace some quantity of cow milk so reduces the cost of product and also increases the protein content of it.

Passion fruit (Passiflora edulis) is native to Southern Brazil. It is commercially cultivated in tropical and subtropical areas for its sweet, seedy fruit. The fruit is both eaten and juiced, the juice often added to other fruit juices to enhance aroma. Raw Passion fruit contain 73% water, 22% carbohydrates. In a 50 gram amount (roughly size of one fruit) fresh passion fruit contains 18% of the Daily value (DV) of vitamin C. Santo et al., (2013) they  prepared probiotic yoghurts enriched with passion fruit fibre. Vieira et al., (2015) spotted that yogurt added with passion fruit peel flour. Malaka et al., (2017) they were use passion fruit juice as a coagulant in preparation of Dangke fresh cheese. Dhanya et al., (2019) manufactured channa podo by incorporation of passion fruit pulp.

By considering nutritive value of passion fruit as well as soymilk Channa Murki was prepared with following objective i.e. 1) To prepare the channa by incorporating of soymilk in different proportions. 2) To study the quality and yield of such channa using different natural coagulant. 3) To evaluate the acceptability of the products and study its physicochemical properties.
The materials were used in laboratory for analytical purpose during the entire research work was milk, soyabean, passion fruit, sugar and citric acid brought from local market.

The analysis of raw milk was conducted for sensory evaluation of  colour and appearance, flavour, mouth feel as well as chemical analysis for fat, protein, total solids, acidity, pH and ash.

Preparation of Soymilk by method suggested by Kapoor and subsequently modified by Grover (1983).
Standardization of Cow milk as well as soymilk at 4% fat and 8.5% SNF was done.
 
Preparation of passion fruit coagulant
 
Fresh ripe passion fruits were used for extraction of juice. Cut the fruit and take out all pulp and seeds of passion fruit with the help of spoon. Before extraction lightly crush seeds of fruits for this use pestle mortar or use a mixer for very short time. After that all pulp and crushed seeds of fruit squeezed and strained through muslin cloth to remove impurities if any. Due to squeezing of pulp, juice was separated and that juice used as coagulant in making of Channa Murki (Ingale et al., 2020).
 
Preparation of Channa Murki
 
Researcher finalizes 70:30 ratio (S3) of cow milk and soymilk blend at primary level by six trained judges with 3 replications for further study (Table 1).

Table 1: Per cent soymilk added.



Good quality of milk purchased from local market. Standardize it at prescribed rate of fat and SNF. Blended it with fresh prepared soymilk [70:30 ratio (S3) cow milk and soymilk] and strained with the help of muslin cloth. Then milk was transferred to stainless steel vessel and boils it up to 90°C temperature. After that vessel removed from fire and brought temperature of milk down to 75°C to 80°C. At this temperature the coagulant Passion fruit juice added slowly in to the milk in different proportions like in T0 treatment citric acid used as control sample, in T1 passion fruit juice 2.9%, in T2 it was 3.5% and in T3 it was 4.1% then stirred it to mix properly (Table 2).

Table 2: Per cent passion fruit coagulant added.



After some time coagulation of milk takes place, then the coagulated milk strained through muslin cloth in another vessel to drain the whey. After draining of whey, remaining solid mass i.e. channa which was the base of Channa Murki. Channa was then cut it into blocks or dicing into one cm cubes. Then take 50% of sugar by weight of channa in a karahi and make sugar syrup. These cubes cooked in to boiling sugar syrup for 5-10 minutes in a karahi. Take out karahi from fire stirring for another 10 to 15 minutes till coating of sugar on cubes takes place. Allowing it to cool and there was ready of Channa Murki to serve (Arora et al., 2019).
The data obtained were subjected to statistical analysis following completely randomized design recommended by Snedecor and Cochran, (1994).

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of ascorbic acid for Passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between 43.89 to 46.57. The lowest score was observed in T1 (44.28) where as highest score observed in T3 (46.57). Score for Ascorbic acid increased as the rate of coagulant increased it might be due to high vitamin C content in kiwi fruit and due to Vit. C there is separation of fatty acids from other ingredients.

Table 3: Effect of different level of Passion fruit juice as coagulant on physic-chemical quality of Channa Murki.



The results in this study also collaborates with Pallavi, et al., (2020) they discovered that in preparation of nutrient rich lassi by using different fruit pulp, kiwi fruit pulp added lassi have 45.76 per cent of ascorbic acid in it.

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of moisture for Passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between16.72 to 23.06. The lowest score was observed in T1 (16.72) where as highest score observed in T3 (23.06). Score for moisture increased as the rate of coagulant increased. In the study Rana et al., (2017a) unearthed that cottage cheese prepared from buffalo milk with different levels of papaya latex moisture content of cottage cheese was lying from 42.10 per cent to 42.57 per cent as compared to cheese prepared by rennet it was 42.00 per cent. The results in relation to moisture contents was in agreement with Karki and Ojha (2018) testify that there was moisture content 50.46 per cent by using kiwi juice in coagulated mozzarella cheese as compared to animal rennet it was 54.12 per cent.

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of total mineral for Passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between 01.02 to 01.24. The lowest score was observed in T3 (01.02) where as highest score observed in T1 (01.24). Score for total mineral decreased as the rate of coagulant increased. This may be probably due to very low ash content of passion fruit juice. Our results also coincide with Toledo et al., (2018) use passion fruit by-products in drinkable yogurt ash content decrease very low as passion fruit flour increase. In control 1.2% ash and in treatment it was decreased from 1.2 to 1.4%. Dhanya et al., (2019) observed that ash of channa podo manufactured by incorporation of passion fruit pulp was 1.36 per cent compared to control 1.65 per cent. The results for ash content depicted that addition of passion fruit pulp resulted in decrease in the ash content of channa podo.

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of protein for Passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between 15.79 to 23.01. The lowest score was observed in T1 (16.55) where as highest score observed in T3 (23.01). Score for protein increased as the rate of coagulant increased. Our results coincide with Celia et al., (2015) observed that in fermented milk enriched with passion fruit peel flour, protein content increase with addition of passion fruit peel flour. In control protein 2.19% as compared to in treatment 1, 2 and 3 it was 2.44%, 2.59% and 3.24% respectively. Jesmin et al., (2021) used papaya plant latex for making cottage cheese from cow milk content protein per cent from 26.20 to 30.97.

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of fat for Passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between 19.45 to 30.41. The lowest score was observed in T1 (21.11) where as highest score observed in T3 (30.41). Score for fat increased as the rate of coagulant increased. The reported value was in consistent with the value revealed by Olorunnisomo and Adewumi (2016) they native that fat content in soft cheese made from fresh and reconstituted milk by using Lime and Mango juice as a coagulant was in between 17.90 to 22.40 per cent. Dhanya et al., (2019) observed that fat of channa podo manufactured by incorporation of passion fruit pulp, the variation in the fat content of channa podo due to the incorporation of passion fruit pulp was found to be significant. Ingale et al., (2019) detected that fat level increased as there was increase in quantity of kiwi juice.

From the Table 3, it is observed that mean score of carbohydrate for passion fruit Channa Murki ranged between 34.50 to 35.93. The lowest score was observed in T1 (34.94) where as highest score observed in T3 (35.93). Score for carbohydrate increased as the rate of coagulant increased. This result was in agreement with Sharma et al., (2018) concluded that total carbohydrates content of cottage cheese produced with Kiwi fruit enzyme was high (9.18) as compared to animal rennet (7.27). In another study Ibrahim et al., (2019) located that carbohydrate content in range between 12.72 to 17.10 per cent in cheese produced from soymilk by using some selected coagulants of natural origin.
From the present investigation it is cleared that all the samples were satisfactory in terms of physic-chemical properties like ascorbic acid, moisture, total mineral, protein, fat and carbohydrate content. By this study it may be concluded that due to use of soymilk cost of product decreased and nutritional value in terms of protein increased.  Passion fruit juice can be successfully used as a natural coagulant in preparation of channa based sweetmeats.
None

  1. Arora S., Ashok, A. Patel, Gurditta, H., Yadav, U. and Mahajan, S. (2019). Estimation of production cost for Hard-variant of Channa-Murki (Indian cottage cheese based dessert). Haryana Veterinary. 58(2): 174-180.

  2. Celia, J.A., da Silva, M.A.P., de Oliveira, K.B., Freitas e Souza, J.L., Souza, D.G., de Moura, L.C., da Silva, R.M., Cagnin, C., de Freitas, B.S.M., Placido, G.R.A. and Caliari, M.  (2015). Fermented milk enriched with passion fruit peel flour (Passiflora edulis): Physicochemical and sensory aspects and lactic acid bacteria viability. African Journal of Microbiology Research. 9(35): 1964-1973.

  3. Dhanya, S., Rajakumar, S.N. and Joseph, K. (2019). Manufacture of Channa Podo by incorporation of passion fruit (Passiflora sims fo. edulis) pulp. Indian Journal of Dairy Science. 72(5): 473-479.

  4. Grover, U., Singh, S. and Mittal, B.K. (1983). Studies on extending the shelf life of soybean curd. Journal of Food Science and Technology. 20: 298-301.

  5. Gurditta, H., Patel, A. and Arora, S. (2020). Selection of dietary fibres for sucrose replacement in functional Channa-Murki (Indian Cottage Cheese based dessert) and their effect on sensory, physical and instrumental texture. International Journal of Dairy Technology. 70: 1-10.

  6. Ibrahim, A., Ukeyima, M., Ikya, J.K. (2019). Effect of some selected coagulants on the proximate and microbiological quality of cheese produced from soy milk. International Journal of Science and Research. 8(4). 2319-7064.

  7. Ingale, R., Chavan, K., More, R. and Parmeshwar, W. (2019). Studies  on healthy fruits based channa whey beverage by using Kiwi (Actinidia deliciosa) fruit extract. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry. 8(5): 1650-1653.

  8. Ingale, R., Chavan, K., More, R. and Washimbe, D. (2020). Studies on effect of using Kiwi fruit extract on sensory properties of fruit based Chhana whey beverage. Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry. 9(6): 522-526.

  9. Jesmin, M.M., Sarkar, M.A.H., Islam, M.A., Harun-ur-Rashid, M., Siddiki, M.S.R. (2021). Use of papaya plant (Carica papaya) latex for making cottage cheese from cow milk. Journal of Bangladesh Agricultural University. 19(1): 85-90.

  10. Kapoor, U.M.A., Datta, I.C., Quadari, H.S.M.A. and Kushwaha, H.S. (1977). Note on the chemical analysis and acceptability of soymilk. Indian Journal of Agricultural Science. 47(9): 172.

  11. Karki, A. and Ojha, P. (2018). Quality evaluation of kiwi juice coagulated mozzarella cheese. Journal of Food science Technology Nepal. 10: 7-10.

  12. Malaka, R., Hatta, W., Baco, S.  (2017). Properties and microstructure  of dangke fresh cheese made with passion fruit juice as coagulant. International Journal of Agriculture Innovations and Research. 5(4). 2319-1473.

  13. Olorunnisomo O.A., Adewumi, A.S. (2016). Lime and mango juice as coagulant for soft cheese made from fresh or reconstituted milk. Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare. 6(6): 37-40.

  14. Pallavi, R., Ramya, S.R., Devaki, C.S. and Shekhara, N.R. (2020). Development of nutrient rich lassi using different fruit pulp. International Journal of Science, Technology and Management. 11(1). September 24, 2022 19:09 IST.

  15. Rana, M.S., Hoque, M.R., Deb, G.K., Nahar, T.N., Habib, R., Siddiki, M.S.R. (2017a). Preparation of cottage cheese from buffalo milk with different levels of papaya latex. Bangladesh Journal of Animal Science. 46: 128-133.

  16. Roque, R.M.J., Rojas-Grau, M.A., Martinez, E.P. and Martin, B.O. (2013). Soymilk phenolic compounds, isoflavones and antioxidant activity as affected by in vitro gastrointestinal digestion. Food Chemistry. 136(1): 206-12. doi: 10.1016/j.foodchem.2012.07.115. 

  17. Santo, E.A.P., Lagazzo, A., Sousa, A.L.O.P., Perego, P., Converti, A., Marice, N., Oliveira. (2013). Rheology, spontaneous whey separation, microstructure and sensorial characteristics of probiotic yoghurts enriched with passion fruit fiber. Food Research International. 50: 224-231.

  18. Sharma, S., Vaidya, D. (2018). Kiwifruit enzyme: A new plant coagulant  for the development of cottage cheese. International Journal of Food Science and Nutrition. 3(1): 6-13. 

  19. Snedecor, C.W., Cochran, W.G. (1994). Statistical Methods 6th Edition, The Iowa State University Press Ames, Iowa, USA.

  20. Toledo, N.M.V.D., Camargo, A.C.D., Ramos, P.B.M., Button, D.C., Granato, D. and Canniatti-Brazaca, S.G. (2018). Potentials  and pitfalls on the use of passion fruit by-products in drinkable yogurt: Physiochemical, Technological, Microbiological and Sensory aspects. Beverages. 4, 47. https://doi.org/10.3390/beverages4030047.

  21. Vieira, N.F., Silva, M.A.P., Martins, Y.A.A., Souza, D.G., Lima, M.S., Placido, G.R. and Caliari, M. (2015). Physicochemical and Sensory profile of yogurt added with passion fruit peel flour. African Journal of Biotechnology. 14(2): 149-155.

  22. Xu, B. and Kow-Ching, S.C. (2009). Isoflavones, Flavan-3-ols, Phenolic acids, total phenolic profiles and antioxidant capacities of soymilk as affected by ultra high temperature  and traditional processing methods. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry. 11(57): 4706-17.

Editorial Board

View all (0)