Effect of sucrose on growth and acidification profile
The effect of sucrose on the acidification profile of cultures was depicted in (Fig 2). Initially the pH and %TA of the milk (0% and 15% sucrose) was similar at the time of culture addition
i.e. 6.6 and 0.12 respectively. After 12 h of incubation NCDC 193 and 125 were found to be the most sucrose tolerant cultures followed by NCDC 128 as the %TA was not affected by the presence of sucrose. The %TA of milk (15% sucrose) fermented by NCDC 125, 193 and 128 was 0.80, 0.81 and 0.72, respectively. Similarly, %TA of milk (0% sucrose) fermented by NCDC 125, 193 and 128 was 0.81, 0.85 and 0.81, respectively. The pH observed for NCDC 125, 193, and 128 cultured milk spiked with 15% sucrose was 4.44, 4.44 and 4.40 similar to fermented milk with 0% sucrose was 4.32, 4.40 and 4.32, respectively. However, growth of rest of the three cultures
i.e. NCDC 314, 97 and 94 were less in milk with 15% sucrose as compared to milk with 0% sucrose. The %TA (with 15% sucrose) was 0.63, 0.63, and 0.65 as compared to %TA (milk without sucrose) of 0.85, 0.77 and 1.03, respectively. After 12h of fermentation the pH ranged from 4.27 to 4.60 which is more than 2 unit reduction in most of the cultures in both cases. It can be clearly observed form figures that the selected cultures (NCDC 125, 193, 128, 314, 97 and 94) were able to tolerate the 15% sucrose concentration as well as able to produce the desirable acidity and pH with consistent rate as in case of 0% sucrose. As per the results obtained, the reduction in pH and elevation in %TA, it can be interpreted that cultures are fast acidifying and sucrose tolerant. Our results were in concurrence with the observation made by
Psoni et al., (2007), Ozkalp et al., (2007) and
Dahou et al., (2021). Moreover, no morphological changes were also observed during the experiment. Sucrose tolerance (14% and 16% sucrose concentration) of yoghurt culture and
Lactococcus lactis has also been clearly demonstrated (
Gosh and Rajorhia, 1990). Generation time of the selected cultures varied from 1.35 h (NCDC 193) to 2.27 h (NCDC 125). Similarly, slightly lower generation time was observed in case of milk containing 15% sucrose as compared to milk with 0% sucrose to lowest for NCDC 193 (1.45 h) and highest for NCDC 125 (3.14 h). The generation time (hours) was used as a tool to investigate the microbial growth dynamics of the pure cultures and demonstrate the variation in the growth of bacteria. The increase in generation time or prolonged lag phase was expected due to difficulty of the cultures to utilize the disaccharide sucrose (Desai
et al., 2004).
Flavor production (Diacetyl production)
Flavor production is mainly responsible for the consumer acceptance of the fermented products. The flavor forming capacity also varies between strains of same species (
Cogan, 1982). Flavor production by
L. lactis is found to be strain dependent, which may be due to specific transport and fermentation systems of citrate. The production of flavor compounds (Diacetyl) also varied according to the cultures used with highest color intensity produced by NCDC 193 and 128 followed by NCDC 125 after 12 h of incubation. NCDC 94 and 97 was produced minor quantity flavor whereas NCDC 314 was not able to produce any flavor compounds. The results obtained showed a clear relation was found between the rate of acid production and flavor compounds. As cultures NCDC 193 and 128 have shown higher acidification rate and flavor compounds production as compared to other selected
Lactococcus cultures.
Lindsay et al., (1965) reported that different strains of
L. lactis ssp.
lactis,
L. lactis ssp. cremoris and
L. lactis ssp.
diacetylactis produce diacetyl in the range of 0.1 to 3.24 ppm.
Protein hydrolysis of cultures in RSM medium
The proteolytic activity of skim milk fermentation by the cultures was illustrated in (Table 1). The activity varied among the different strains of
Lactococcus cultures and have shown adequate proteolytic activity which ranged from 0.17 to 0.41 mg/mL of Leucine. Highest proteolytic activity was shown by NCDC 94 (0.41) recognized by producing the highest amount of free amino groups followed by NCDC 97 (0.36), NCDC 128, NCDC 314, NCDC 193 and NCDC 125. In addition, the results obtained from this study that the cultures were found fast acidifier with high proteolytic activity. The results obtained were in agreement with the observations by
Nomura et al., (2006) in skim milk at 1% inoculation level. The final acidity (%LA), as well as the rate of acidification of yogurt cultures depend on the individual strains and their interaction (
Béal et al., 1999). Proteolysis results in production of essential growth factors as peptides and amino acids which provide protective effect and helps in improvement of survival of the starters (
Ramchandran and Shah, 2010). These fast acidifiers and good proteolytic
Lactococcus cultures could be used as starter cultures to start initial acidification. In OPA-method released a-amino groups produced after the proteolysis of milk protein is detected spectrophotometrically, thus giving a direct measurement of proteolytic activity. The degree of protein hydrolysis is expressed as content of mg/mL of Lucine after 24 h of fermentation at 30
oC in reconstituted skim milk.
L. lactis possesses a number of genes whose products are involved in the utilization of proteins present in milk, such as an extracellular protease, peptide transport systems and intracellular peptidases (
Kok and Buist, 2003). LAB proteinases (
Lactococcus sp. and
Lactobacillus sp.) are able to hydrolyse more than 40% of the peptide bonds of aS1-CN and β-CN, which results in the formation of more than100 different oligopeptides that are further degraded by the peptidase system
(Choi et al., 2012).
Antagonistic activity against spoilage and pathogenic bacteria
The zone of inhibition by different
Lactococcus strains against spoilage and pathogenic bacteria are shown in Fig 3. Among all the cultures NCDC 97 have shown good zone of inhibition against the four test organism with maximum against spoilage bacteria
i.e.
P. fluorescenes NCDC 316 (16 mm). NCDC 94 (13 -23 mm) and 314 (14-22 mm) were also found to have inhibitory activity against all the test organisms with varying zone of inhibition. As NCDC 97, 314 and 94 had wider range of inhibitory effect as they are active against all the test organisms whereas NCDC 193 was found to be least active culture as zone of inhibition was shown against
M. luteus only. Similarly, cultures NCDC 128 and 125 have shown zone of inhibition against
M. luteus and
P. fluorescenes. The main activity of
Lactococcus cultures was found against
M. luteus NCDC 131 which is a pathogenic organism in dairy products. In a study conducted by
Bachanti et al., (2017) out of 12 selected
Lactobacilli spp all the cultures have shown antagonistic activity against
S. aureus and weak to moderate antibacterial activity was observed against
E. coli by most of the cultures. The effect of inhibition is probably due to proteinaceous nature of the cultures, which is yet to be proved. This inhibitory effect is also contributed by the lowering of pH below 6.0 and production of compounds such as lactate, acetate, organic acid and bacteriocins and this fact may contribute to their colonizing and competitive ability
(Balciunas et al., 2013). The results obtained were supported by previous studies
(Atanasova et al., 2014 and
Alomar et al., 2008) that the variable antimicrobial activity had been showed by
Lactococcus lactis.
Microbiological and physio-chemical properties of Dahi and Misti dahi
The microbiological and physio-chemical properties of prepared
Dahi and
Misti dahi after 12 h of incubation at 30oC is shown in (Table 2). The pH value for dahi ranged from 4.53 to 4.62 and 4.64 to 4.73 for
Misti dahi. The lowest value was reported in
Dahi prepared using NCDC 94 (4.53) followed by NCDC 125 (4.57), in case of
Misti Dahi NCDC 314 (4.64) exhibited minimum pH value followed by NCDC 94 (4.65). The range of pH values observed here are in accordance with the values recommended by
Frye (2013) for yoghurt. Lowering the pH by Lactic acid bacteria is due to production of lactic acid during fermentation of milk- lactose
(Eke et al., 2013). These pH values are satisfactory in order to prevent any pathogenic growth on the products, thus increasing its shelf life
(Donkor et al., 2006).
The titratable acidity also ranged from 0.71 to 0.81% LA after 12h of incubation at 30
oC for
Dahi and 0.74 to 0.81% LA for
Misti dahi. Maximum acid production was observed by NCDC 94 (0.81%) for
Dahi, whereas in case of
Misti dahi NCDC 193 and 128 (0.81%) produced highest amount of lactic acid during fermentation. It is suggested that acidity in fermented products should be within definite limits for consumer acceptance. The TA of all yoghurt formulations in our results was more than the minimum recommended limit of 0.6% by Codex (2011). The TA obtained for
Misti Dahi was found less than the results obtained by
Chatterjee et al., (2015).
The total lactic count present in
Dahi and
Misti dahi samples ranged from 9.41 to 9.58 log CFU/mL and 8.94 to 9.28 log CFU/mL respectively. Maximum growth was observed by NCDC 193 in both the products, which shows that the culture was able to tolerate high amount of sucrose (15%) as well as total solids. All the cultures performed well in
Misti dahi samples also which has higher total solid content and less difference was found in viability of cells as compared to
Dahi samples. Our results were in agreement with the findings of
Mahdian and Tehrani (2007) who showed that growth and activity of starter bacteria improved in samples with higher amounts of total solids. All the
Dahi and
Misti dahi samples had a total lactic count of >9 log10 CFU/g which is the minimum limit recommended by National Yoghurt Association of the USA. A higher bacterial cell produces metabolites during fermentation which has beneficial effects on human health.
Sensory evaluation
Acceptable scores for Flavor, body and texture and color and appearance in case of
Misti dahi, were ranged between 40.2-44.8 ot of 45, 36.0-36.8 out of 40 and 8.6-9.2 out of 15, respectively. The sensory scores for
Dahi and
Misti dahi are presented in Table 3.
Dahi highest score for flavor, body and texture was obtained by NCDC 97 (46.75 and 38.0), and for color and appearance NCDC 125 obtained highest score (9.25). Overall acceptable sensory scores of
Dahi for flavor, body and texture and color and appearance were ranged between 41.75-46.75, 35.38-38.00 and 8.50-9.25, respectively. NCDC 97 scored highest for flavor and body and texture attributes but for color and appearance NCDC 125 found to obtain maximum score. Overall,
Dahi prepared with NCDC 97 (93.25) obtained significantly highest total score (P<0.05%) due to its flavor producing ability whereas, NCDC 314 (89.0), NCDC 94 (90.0) and NCDC 97 (90.0) obtained significantly higher total score scores for
Misti dahi preparation, as the texture obtained with NCDC 314 is most acceptable. The sensory scores obtained clearly prove that both the products prepared using the six starter cultures were acceptable.