Table 1 shows substantial seasonal instability in onion prices and arrivals across the selected markets. Price variability was generally higher during August-December and lower during March-April. Lasalgaon recorded the highest monthly price CV in December (86.78%), while Solapur recorded 81.46% in August. Arrival variability exceeded price variability in all markets, indicating strong seasonal concentration of supply. Jalgaon showed the greatest arrival instability, whereas Pune had comparatively lower variability. These patterns are consistent with earlier evidence on onion price and arrival behaviour
(Saha et al., 2020; Ghosh et al., 2020; Baishya and Kumar, 2021).
Table 2 and 3 show that greater seasonal concentration of arrivals was associated with higher price instability. Lasalgaon recorded the highest average arrivals (415,221 tonnes) and mean price (₹1,334.36/q), with moderate arrival instability (CDVI 48.82%) but relatively high price instability (CDVI 69.47%). This indicates that prices remained sensitive to supply-demand conditions and policy-related shocks despite relatively stable inflows
(Birthal et al., 2019; Rakshit, 2021). Low R2 values suggest that short-term fluctuations explain a substantial part of the observed variation. Similar evidence on instability in vegetable production and prices has been reported in recent ARCC research
(Gupta et al., 2025; Sethi et al., 2025).
Table 4 shows a consistent seasonal pattern in onion prices. Prices remained below the annual average during March-April and increased thereafter, reaching their highest levels mainly during October-November. April recorded the lowest seasonal indices across the markets, reflecting abundant
rabi arrivals. Prices recovered from June to September as stored stocks declined. Similar seasonal movements have been reported for onion and other agricultural commodities (
Roy, 2021;
Saha et al., 2020; Vasanthi et al., 2024; Jadeja et al., 2025).
Fig 1 confirms a U-shaped seasonal price pattern, with lower prices during harvest months and higher prices during lean supply periods.
Table 5 shows that onion arrivals were above the annual average mainly during January-March, with a secondary increase in December due to late
kharif arrivals and release of stored stocks. Similar seasonal concentration of arrivals has been reported in previous studies (
Roy, 2021;
Saha et al., 2020; Vasanthi et al., 2024).
January and March recorded the highest arrival indices in several markets. January ranged from 119.90 in Ahilyanagar to 224.63 in Solapur, while March reached 161.44 in Satara and 146.22 in Solapur. The concentration reflects bulk marketing of
rabi onion, which contributes a major share of Maharashtra’s annual production (
Roy, 2021).
During the monsoon, arrival indices declined below the annual average in several markets, including Solapur (45.56 in June), Jalgaon (49.46 in September) and Vaijapur (54.04 in October). This decline is consistent with depletion of stored
rabi stocks, storage losses and limited
kharif supply
(Saha et al., 2020; Chand and Jumrani, 2013). A secondary rise occurred in December, particularly in Solapur (179.72) and Jalgaon (182.01), reflecting late
kharif arrivals and release of stored produce.
Fig 2 confirms strong seasonal concentration of arrivals, with heavy inflows during January-March, a decline during the monsoon and partial recovery in December.
Table 6 reports the ADF results. All statistics are negative and statistically significant at the 5% level, with p-values below 0.05. Thus, the null hypothesis of a unit root is rejected for all selected markets (
Dickey and Fuller, 1979).
Table 7 reports the Box-Ljung test results. All test statistics are statistically significant, with very low p-values, indicating serial dependence in the price series. The results support the presence of volatility clustering and motivate the use of ARCH-GARCH modelling (
Box and Ljung, 1978;
Engle, 1982).
Table 8 presents the GARCH (1,1) estimates. The mean price parameter (ì) is positive and statistically significant at the 1% level in all markets.
The ARCH coefficients (α1) are positive and highly significant in all markets. Moderate values occur in Lasalgaon (0.429), Pune (0.510), Satara (0.488) and Vaijapur (0.3641), indicating a strong short-run response to recent shocks. Very high values occur in Solapur (0.999), Jalgaon (0.998) and Ahilyanagar (0.999), indicating a particularly strong immediate response of volatility to recent shocks.
The GARCH coefficients (β1) vary across markets. They are significant in Lasalgaon (0.569), Pune (0.489), Satara (0.511) and Vaijapur (0.6341), indicating persistence of past volatility. In Solapur (0.00002), Jalgaon (0.0002) and Ahilyanagar (0.0006), the coefficients are very small, indicating a limited direct contribution of lagged conditional variance relative to recent shocks.
The variance constant (ω) also differs across markets. It is moderate and insignificant in Lasalgaon (1118.68), Pune (763.79), Satara (874.38) and Vaijapur (759.46), but significantly higher in Solapur (38,244.0), Jalgaon (39,042.0) and Ahilyanagar (58,555.0), indicating higher baseline variance in these markets.
The sum α1 + β1 ranges from 0.998 to 0.999 across markets, indicating highly persistent volatility. This persistence supports the use of GARCH-type models and is consistent with earlier evidence on agricultural commodity price behaviour (
Engle, 1982;
Ghosh et al., 2020; Rakshit, 2021;
Baishya and Kumar, 2021).
Fig 3-9 show clear volatility clustering across the selected markets, supporting the GARCH estimates. Major volatility spikes occurred during 2011-12, 2013-14, 2014-15, 2016-17, 2019-20 and 2022-24. Lasalgaon, Satara, Pune and Jalgaon showed more frequent clusters, while Vaijapur displayed comparatively smoother movements. These patterns confirm the recurrent nature of onion price volatility across Maharashtra markets.