Incidence of hoof lesions in dairy cows
After hoof trimming, few claw diseases like sole hemorrhage, white line disease, sole ulcer, digital dermatitis, double hoof and overgrown hoofs were detected in animals. Out of the total claw lesions in the herd, (5%) were affected with double hoof, (5%) were affected with digital dermatitis, (5%) with sole hemorrhages, (20%) with white line disease, (30%) with sole ulcers and (35%) were effected with overgrown hoof. Incidence of hoof lesions is depicted in Fig 1.
Milk yield
The data on milk yield in kg/day for before week and after hoof trimming intervention under this study have been presented in Table 1. The mean milk yield (kg/day) of animals one week before the hoof trimming was 13.25±0.83, after hoof trimming mean milk yield on 0
th day was11.90±0.77, on 3rd day it was 11.91±0.78, on 6
th day it was 12.16±0.79, on 8
th day it was 12.71±0.81, on 11th day it was 12.98±0.84 and on 14 h day it was 13.38±0.85. There was an increase and a decrease of milk yield recorded in animals. The milk yield decreases were evident on hoof trimming day. The results showed that there was significant difference (P≤0.05) in milk yield on 0
th day, 3
rd day, 6
th day, 8
th day and 11
th day (P=0.000) when compared with before week of hoof trimming. Whereas on 14
th day there was no significant difference when compared with before week of hoof trimming. The milk yield was drastically reduced after hoof trimming in the initial days and again the increased trend was started from 11
th day onwards, finally reaching its normal on 14
th day which is similar to prior week before hoof trimming. Overall HT effected the milk yield in initial days and after this raise in milk yield is noticed which shows that HT has almost positive effect on milk yield in long term.
The results of the present study with respect to milk yield are in agreement with the findings of
Erol et al., (2019), where they performed functional hoof trimming on twenty Simmental dairy cattle. Comfortable walking and standing, equal weight distribution on hooves and correct claw shapes after hoof trimming increase the milk yield and it has positive effect on prevention of claw diseases
(Izci et al., 2018).The results of our study are in accordance with the results of
Nishimori et al. (2006) where they examined the effect of one-time hoof trimming on milk yield and found no increases in milk yield after hoof trimming. It decreased on the trimming day and after the trimming periods. This condition was correlated to the hoof trimming stress. However, the different number of milkings and stage of lactation could affect milk production.
The results of our study are in agreement with the findings of
Pesenhofer et al., (2006) where they compared the effect of functional hoof trimming with 2 different types of trimming set-ups, a mobile walk-in crush and a tilt table. In both groups milk yield was 0.6 L lower on the day of claw trimming and the day after. Milk yield reduction was significant on the day of hoof trimming and one day after hoof trimming which are in agreement with our study.
In contrast to our study,
Sogstad et al., (2007) reported that cows started to give more milk after HT than before HT. In another study by
Kibar and Caglayan (2016) they observed that one-time HT increased milk production in dairy cattle with hoof disorders in commercial dairy farms.
Yakan (2021) objectified to reveal the importance of hoof trimming (HT) in cows by determining the changes in feed consumption and milk yield, in the days before and after HT in cows with hoof deformities. Daily feed consumption and milk yield findings were recorded on days the 1, 7 (before HT), 13 (on the day of HT), 19, 25 and 31 (after HT) of the study. According to the findings of this study, after HT increased feed consumption and milk yield in cows were noticed (P<0.05).
Novotna et al., (2019) found that higher milk production was observed in dairy cows with locomotion score 2, 3 and 4 and a significant decrease was found in locomotion score 5. According to
Gundelach et al. (2013), early hoof trimmer intervention in lame cows resulted in a tendency toward higher milk yield at 100 DIM.
Taguchi et al., (2001) reported a similar experiment, but no differences in milk production and composition were showed in their research. In another study by
Tanaka et al., (1994), observed that HT slows down the rate at which milk production reductions in cows in the late lactation period.
Van Hertem et al. (2014) reported that the effect of hoof trimming on milk yield for dairy cows tended to depend on the parity of the cows (P=0.068) and lactation stage (P< 0.001), activity level (P=0.002) and ruminating time (P<0.001). Each 1-min increase in daily ruminating time increased the milk yield by 3.1 kg/d. Each 1-bit increase in daily activity level increased the milk yield by 0.9 kg/d.
Many researchers have reported milk yield in the lactation stage is affected by herd factors such as management and nutrition and individual factors as genetics, parity and disease. Differences in the literature about the influence of lameness and hoof disorders on milk production are compared to the conclusion of these complex effects.
Milk composition
Milk fat percentage
The data on mean per cent of milk fat for before week and after hoof trimming intervention under this study have been presented in Table 2.
The mean Fat % of animals one week before HT was 3.72±0.03, after hoof trimming mean Fat % on 0
th day was 3.54±0.05, on 3rd day it was 3.60±0.04, on 6
th day it was 3.67±0.04, on 8
th day it was 3.80±0.04, on 11
th day it was 3.92±0.04 and on 14h day it was 4.10±0.04. The results showed that there was significant difference (P≤0.05) in milk fat % on 0
th day and 3
rd day, (P=0.000, P=0.006) when compared with before week of hoof trimming. Whereas on 6
th day and 8
th day there was no significant difference when compared with before week of hoof trimming. Significant increase (P≤0.05) was observed on 11
th day and 14
th day, (P=0.002, P=0.000). We observed that on the day of hoof trimming fat % was reduced. Then from 3
rd day onwards we noticed increased fat %, this was continued upto14
th day. On 8
th, 11
th and 14
th day fat % was more when compared to the before week of hoof trimming. Overall HT effected the milk fat % in initial days and after this raise in milk fat% is noticed which shows that HT has almost positive effect on milk fat % which is higher than before HT.
The results of the present study were in agreement with the findings of Nishimori
et al. (2006) where they examined the effect of one-time hoof trimming on milk fat composition and reported that, subsequently milk fat composition (4.4±0.4 to 4.6±0.5) were increased significantly after hoof trimming.
Olechnowicz and Jaskowski (2010) reported that the month of lactation differentiated cows in terms of milk fat and protein yields. In the first months of the lactation, cows produced more milk fat than in the following months of early lactation (P<0.01). In contrast to our study
Van Straten e al. (2011) reported reduced milk fat per cent. But in our study however, milk fat percentage decreased on day of HT and began to increasing on 11
th day. On the 14
th day, the overall milk fat percentage level increased, surpassing the previous week of HT. In contrast to our studies
Taguchi et al., (2001) reported that after hoof trimming there was no change in milk fat composition. But in our study, after HT, the overall milk fat percentage level increased, surpassing the previous week of HT. In contrast to our studies
Baek et al. (2016) mentioned that after hoof trimming there was decrease in milk fat composition. But in our study, after HT, the overall milk fat percentage level increased, when compared to the previous week of HT.
Milk solids not fat percentage (SNF %)
The data on mean per cent of milk SNF for before week and after hoof trimming intervention under this study have been presented in Table 3. The mean SNF % of animals one week before HT was 8.53±0.03, after hoof trimming mean SNF % on 0
th day was 8.25±0.04, on 3
rd day it was 8.26±0.02, on 6th day it was 8.34±0.02, on 8
th day it was 8.45±0.03, on 11
th day it was 8.49±0.03 and on 14
th day it was 8.48±0.03.The results showed that there was significant decrease (Pd≤0.05) in milk SNF % on 0
th day, 3
rd day, 6
th day and 8
th day (P=0.000) when compared with before week of hoof trimming. Whereas on 11
th day and 14
th day there was no significant difference when compared with before week of hoof trimming (P=0.423, P=0.376). We observed that on the day of hoof trimming milk SNF % was reduced. Then from 3rd day onwards we noticed increased SNF %, which was continued upto14
th day. This increased trend continued up to 14
th day but which was less when compared to SNF % of the before week of hoof trimming. Overall HT effected the milk SNF % in initial days and after this raise in milk yield is noticed which shows that HT has almost positive effect on milk SNF % in long term from our study.
The results of
Taguchi et al. (2001) are in agreement with our results where they reported that after hoof trimming there was no change in milk SNF composition. In our study, milk SNF percentage was decreased on the day of HT and reached normal level on 14
th day, which is similar to before week of HT. The results of
Baek et al., (2016) are in agreement with our results where they reported that after hoof trimming there was a decrease in milk SNF composition. In our study milk SNF percentage was decreased on the day of HT and reached normal on 14
th day of HT.
Milk protein percentage
The data on mean per cent of milk protein for before week and after hoof trimming intervention under this study have been presented in Table 4. The mean protein % of animals one week before HT was 2.90±0.01, after hoof trimming mean on 0
th day was 2.60±0.03, on 3
rd day it was 2.58±0.04, on 6
th day it was 2.64±0.04, on 8
th day it was 2.84±0.04, on 11
th day it was 2.92±0.03 and on 14
th day it was 2.96±0.02. The results showed that there was significant difference (P≤0.05) in milk protein % on 0
th day, 3
rd day and 6
th day (P=0.000) when compared with before week of hoof trimming. Whereas on 8
th day, 11
th day and 14
th day there was no significant difference when compared with before week of hoof trimming (P=0.104, P=0.422, P=0.207).We observed that on the day of hoof trimming milk protein % was reduced. The reduction in milk protein % was also observed on 3
rd day, 6
th day. From 8
th day onwards increase in milk protein % was observed and it continued up to 14
th day. When compared with before week of hoof trimming milk protein % was more on 11
th and 14
th day after hoof trimming. Overall HT effected the milk protein% in initial days and after this raise in milk protein % is noticed which shows that HT has almost positive effect on milk protein% which is higher than before HT.
The results of the present study were in agreement with the findings of
Nishimori et al. (2006) who examined the effect of one-time hoof trimming on milk protein composition and reported that, milk protein composition (3.4±0.2 to 3.6±0.3) increased significantly after hoof trimming. The month of lactation differentiated cows in terms of milk fat and protein yields. In the first months of the lactation, cows produced more milk, fat and protein than in the following months of early lactation. The increased protein % may be due to feeding management in the experimental animals and there may be influx of plasma proteins (
Olechnowicz and Jaskowski, 2010).
In contrast to our studies
Taguchi et al. (2001) reported that after hoof trimming there was no change in milk protein composition. But in our study, after HT, the overall milk protein percentage level increased when compare to the previous week of HT. In contrast to our results, studies by
Baek et al. (2016) reported that after hoof trimming there was a decrease in milk protein composition. But in our study, after HT, the overall milk protein percentage level increased when compare to the previous week of HT.