Biometrical observation
Plant height (cm)
In our study, we assessed the effect of various organic manures on the plant height of okra across different growth stages. At 30 and 45 days after sowing (
Rumeza et al., 2006), no significant differences in plant height were observed among treatments, with an overall mean plant height of 18.52. The tallest plants were found in the Vermicompost treatment (23.80 cm), which was statistically similar to FYM (18.73 cm), Neem cake (18.67 cm), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (18.33 cm), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (18.07 cm), Control (17.73 cm) and Kishanzyme (14.27 cm). In contrast, the shortest plants were observed in the Kishanzyme treatment (14.27 cm). By 45 DAS, plant height increased across all treatments, with an overall mean of 27.18. Vermicompost (30.67 cm) and FYM (29.27 cm) produced the tallest plants, followed by Control (28.33 cm), Neem cake (27.53 cm), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (26.93 cm), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (26.27 cm) and Kishanzyme (21.27 cm). Once again, the shortest plants were found in the Kishanzyme treatment (21.27 cm). At 60 DAS, significant differences in plant height were observed, with an overall mean plant height of 33.78.The tallest plants recorded in the Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (39.20 cm), followed by Neem cake (39.00 cm), Vermicompost (37.00 cm), FYM (35.133 cm), Control (30.633 cm), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (29.867 cm) and Kishanzyme (25.60 cm). Again, the shortest plants were observed in the Kishanzyme treatment (25.60 cm) (Table 1).
The results revealed that Vermicompost consistently promoted taller plant growth across growth stages, likely due to its rich nutrient content, improved soil structure and enhanced microbial activity that together support efficient nutrient uptake and root development (
Gutiérrez-Miceli et al., 2007). Our findings align with previous research where Vermicompost demonstrated high plant height, although some studies reported FYM as the dominant amendment (
Alam et al., 2019). Furthermore, our findings are consistent with the results reported by (
Toor et al., 2023;
Toor et al., 2024), which emphasized the positive impact of Vermicompost on plant growth.
Leaf number
No significant difference was observed at 30 DAS, 45 DAS and 60 DAS. At 30 DAS, the highest number of leaves was recorded in the Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (9.93), followed by Neem cake (9.80), Vermicompost (9.33), FYM (8.87), Control (8.53), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (8.47) and Kishanzyme (7.67), respectively (Fig 3). Similarly, although non-significant at 45 DAS, the treatments showed the highest number of leaves in Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (23.067), Neem cake (21.067), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (18.60), FYM (17.80), Control (17.40), Vermicompost (16.87) and Kishanzyme (16.07), respectively. At 60 DAS, the number of leaves was highest in Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (41.67), followed by Neem cake (39.067), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (33.40), FYM (31.40), Control (30.067), Vermicompost (29.53) and Kishanzyme (26.87), respectively.
This study recorded the highest number of leaves per plant using Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment. A previous study by (
Kumar et al., 2022) indicated that the highest number of leaves per plant and leaf width were observed under the combined application of organic manures and bio-fertilizers, specifically in treatment T6 (Vermicompost at 5 t/ha + Azotobacter). Similarly, (
Gutiérrez-Miceli et al., 2007) observed that the addition of vermicompost had no significant effect on the number of leaves 85 days after transplanting, suggesting that growth responses to vermicompost application may vary with crop type and growing conditions.
Branch number
The effect of different organic manures on the number of branches of okra is shown in Fig 4. There was no significant difference observed at 45 DAS; the highest number of branches was observed in Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (2.67), followed by Neem cake (2.43), Kishanzyme (2.267), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (2.183), Vermicompost (2.13) and Control, FYM (2.067). Similarly, although non-significant at 60 DAS, the treatments showed the highest number of branches in Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (4.13), followed by Neem cake (3.60), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (3.067), FYM (2.93), Control (2.40), Kishanzyme (2.35) and Vermicompost (2.33), respectively.
The highest number of branches in okra observed with the Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment is likely due to the combined benefits of improved nutrient availability, enhanced microbial activity, better soil structure and water retention, pest and disease resistance and the presence of growth-promoting substances. This combination provides a balanced and diverse nutrient profile, promotes beneficial microbial populations, improves soil conditions and reduces plant stress, leading to better overall plant health and growth. On the other hand, as expected, controlled plots showed the lowest branch numbers due to a lack of enough nutrients. Supporting this, (
Dessai et al., 2024) reported that treatment 120:60:50 kg NPK + 25 t FYM + 6 t Vermicompost showed the highest number of branches per plant. Their findings indicated that both organic manures and their mixtures with full NPK significantly increased the growth and total yield attributes of okra. Therefore, these experiments provide a clear pathway for farmers and growers to choose appropriate soil amendments that enhance plant growth and yield.
Day of first picking
The effect of different organic manures on days to first harvest is presented in Table 2. Significant differences were observed in the days to the first harvest. The mean values indicate that the earliest days to first harvest were observed in the Vermicompost treatment (44.53 days), while treatments Vermicompost + Kishanzyme, FYM, Kishanzyme and Control had similar durations (44.93 days). The Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment required the longest period to reach the first harvest (48.178 days). Specifically, the Neem cake treatment required more days to reach the first harvest compared to the Vermicompost, Vermicompost + Kishanzyme + FYM, Kishanzyme and Control treatments, respectively.
The early maturity observed in the Vermicompost treatment may be attributed to its balanced nutrient composition, particularly the readily available nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium, along with plant growth-promoting substances such as humic acids and beneficial microorganisms (
Tognetti et al., 2005;
Aslam et al., 2019;
Oyege and Balaji Bhaskar, 2023). These components enhance root development, accelerate vegetative growth and promote early flowering and fruit set. Additionally, vermicompost improves soil aeration, microbial activity and enzymatic processes (
Bianco et al., 2022;
Oyege and Balaji Bhaskar, 2023), creating favorable conditions for faster physiological development of okra plants. Furthermore, the application of vermicompost as a partial substitute for synthetic fertilizers has been shown to stimulate plant production and promote early flowering and fruit development (
Rehman et al., 2023). (
Steffen et al., 2019) reported that replacing 40-50% of synthetic fertilizers with vermicompost in tomatoes resulted in earlier flowering, higher fruit mass and improved yield performance, supporting the present findings on okra.
Number of pickings per plant
The effect of different organic manures on the number of pickings per plant is presented in Table 3. No significant difference was observed in the number of pickings per plant. The mean values show that the highest number of pickings per plant was observed in the Vermicompost treatment (9.53), which was statistically similar to Kishanzyme (8.67), FYM (8.20), Control (7.73), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme (7.67), Neem cake (7.40) and Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM (7.33), respectively.
Fruit weight
The effect of different organic manures on the fruit weight of okra is presented in Table 4. Significant differences were observed in fruit weight among treatments. The mean values indicate that the highest fruit weight (135.56 gm) was recorded in the Vermicompost treatment, which was statistically similar to the FYM treatment (109.05 gm), Kishanzyme treatment (89.37 gm), Control (80.67 gm), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme treatment (80.34 gm), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (77.01 gm) and Neem cake treatment (75.95 gm), respectively. The lowest fruit weight was observed in the Neem cake treatment (75.95 gm).
Fruit length
The effect of different organic manures on the fruit length of okra is presented in Table 5. Significant differences were observed in fruit length among treatments. The mean values indicate that the longest fruit length (12.08 cm) was recorded in the Vermicompost treatment, which was statistically similar to the FYM treatment (11.56 cm), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (9.33 cm), Kishanzyme treatment (9.24 cm), Control (9.22 cm), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme treatment (9.03 cm) and Neem cake treatment (9.03 cm), respectively. The shortest fruit length was observed in the Neem cake treatment (9.03 cm), with Vermicompost + Kishanzyme treatment showing similar results.
Average fruit weight
The effect of different organic manures on the average fruit weight of okra is presented in Table 6. Significant differences were observed in average fruit weight among treatments. The mean values indicate that the highest average fruit weight (14.66 g) was observed in the Vermicompost treatment, which was statistically similar to the FYM treatment (13.33 g), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (10.69 g), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme treatment (10.57 g), Kishanzyme treatment (10.54 g), Control (10.46 g) and Neem cake treatment (10.33 g), respectively. The lowest average fruit weight was observed in the Neem cake treatment (10.33 g).
Yield
The effect of different organic manures on yield (kg/ha) is presented in Table 7. Significant differences were observed in yield among treatments. The mean values indicate that the highest yield (569.37 kg/ha) was observed in the Vermicompost treatment, which was statistically similar to the FYM treatment (458.01 kg/ha), Kishanzyme treatment (375.20 kg/ha), Control (338.80 kg/ha), Vermicompost + Kishanzyme treatment (337.47 kg/ha), Vermicompost + Neem cake + FYM treatment (323.74 kg/ha) and Neem cake treatment (319.02 kg/ha), respectively. The Neem cake treatment had the lowest yield (319.02 kg/ha).
The highest yield in the current research was observed with the Vermicompost treatment, likely due to its steady nutrient release and soil health benefits (
Enebe and Erasmus, 2023). However, according to (
Niraj et al., 2023), the treatment involving 50% recommended N through chemical fertilizer + 50% N through poultry manure (T4) resulted in the highest yield per hectare, indicating that integrating organic and inorganic fertilizers provides complementary benefits for improving soil fertility and productivity. Furthermore, (
Khatun et al., 2023) reported that Vermicompost 20 ton/ha was the best treatment for okra cultivation in the coastal region of Bangladesh, with the maximum yield per hectare (17.8 ton/ ha). These results further justify that the application of vermicompost at an appropriate rate substantially enhances okra growth and yield due to improved nutrient dynamics, soil structure and biological activity.