Agronomic and yield traits performance of F2 and BC1F1 maternal half-sib families
Substantial variation was observed among the F2 cowpea progenies analysed as maternal half-sib families for all 15 quantitative traits measured (Table 2). Mean performance differed across maternal families (UCC15-03, UCC15-25, UCC15-36 and UCC15-41), indicating effective segregation for both vegetative and yield-related traits at the F2 generation.
Plant height ranged from 39.72 cm in UCC15-03 to 54.95 cm in UCC15-36, while canopy diameter varied widely, with the highest mean recorded in UCC15-25 (95.71 cm). Phenological traits showed relatively narrow ranges, with days to flowering varying from 35.91 to 37.96 days and days to pod maturity from 55.28 to 57.40 days across maternal families. Yield components, such as number of pods per plant, seeds per pod and 100-seed weight also exhibited clear differences among families, with UCC15-25 and UCC15-36, generally, having higher mean values for yield-associated traits.
The BC1F1 cowpea population also exhibited appreciable variation among maternal half-sib families for all 15 quantitative traits evaluated (Table 3). Mean values differed across the four maternal backgrounds (UCC15-03, UCC15-25, UCC15-36 and UCC15-41), indicating the persistence of genetic variability following backcrossing to the recurrent parent.
Plant height ranged from 39.18 cm in UCC15-03 to 47.70 cm in UCC15-36, while canopy diameter varied between 53.84 cm (UCC15-25) and 66.22 cm (UCC15-36). Phenological traits showed relatively narrow variation, with days to flowering ranging from 35.39 to 39.18 days and days to pod maturity from 53.32 to 54.68 days across maternal families. Yield-related traits, such as number of pods per plant, seeds per pod and 100-seed weight, displayed notable differences among maternal families, with UCC15-25 and UCC15-36 generally having higher mean values for number of pods, number of seeds and seed size attributes.
Analysis of variance (ANOVA)
The analysis of variance revealed highly significant (P≤0.001) differences among maternal half-sib families for all 15 traits evaluated (Table 4). This pattern was consistent across all four maternal backgrounds, confirming the presence of substantial genetic variability within the F‚ population.
Replication effects were generally non-significant for most traits, suggesting minimal environmental influence and reinforcing the reliability of the observed genetic differences. The significant maternal family effects for key traits, such as plant height, canopy diameter, number of pods, seeds per pod and 100-seed weight, indicate that maternal lineage played an important role in trait expression at this stage of segregation.Analysis of variance revealed highly significant (P≤0.001) differences among maternal half-sib families for all traits studied in both F2 and BC1F1 populations (Table 4 and 5). This indicates that substantial genetic variation was retained after backcrossing.
Replication effects were generally non-significant or of low magnitude, suggesting limited environmental influence on trait expression. Significant maternal family effects were consistently observed for key agronomic and yield traits, including plant height, canopy diameter, number of branches, number of pods, number of seeds per pod, pod length and 100-seed weight, highlighting the importance of maternal lineage in shaping phenotypic performance in the BC1F1 generation.
Phenotypic and genotypic coefficients of variation
The phenotypic coefficient of variation (PCV) was marginally higher than the genotypic coefficient of variation (GCV) for all traits across maternal families, indicating limited environmental influence on trait expression. High PCV and GCV values were recorded for canopy diameter, terminal leaf diameter, number of branches, number of pods and number of seeds per pod, suggesting considerable genetic variability for these traits within the F2 population (Table 3).
Conversely, relatively low PCV and GCV values were observed for days to flowering, days to pod maturity, pod length and pods per peduncle, reflecting greater phenotypic stability for these traits.
Across all traits in the BC1F1 population, phenotypic coefficients of variation (PCV) were only slightly higher than genotypic coefficients of variation (GCV), indicating minimal environmental contribution to total phenotypic variance. Moderate to high PCV and GCV values were recorded for canopy diameter, terminal leaf traits, number of branches, number of pods and number of peduncles, reflecting considerable genetic variability among maternal families.
Lower PCV and GCV values were observed for phenological traits, such as days to flowering and days to pod maturity, as well as for pod length and pods per peduncle, suggesting greater phenotypic stability for these traits in the BC1F1 population compared to yield components (Table 6).
Heritability and genetic advance
Broad-sense heritability estimates were exceptionally high for all traits, ranging from 93.33% to 100% across maternal families (Table 7). Traits, such as plant height, canopy diameter, terminal leaf dimensions, number of pods, seeds per pod and 100-seed weight, consistently exhibited heritability values exceeding 99%, indicating that the observed variation was largely under genetic control.
Genetic advance and genetic advance expressed as a percentage of the mean were also high for most yield-related traits. Notably, genetic advance as a percentage of the mean for canopy diameter, number of branches, number of pods and plant height were high, suggesting the predominance of additive gene action and the potential for effective selection in early generations.
Broad-sense heritability estimates for BC1F1 maternal half-sib families were generally high, ranging from moderate to very high values across traits (Table 4). Estimates of broad-sense heritability for most traits, including canopy diameter, terminal leaf dimensions, number of branches, number of pods, number of seeds per pod, pod length and 100-seed weight, exceeded 90%, indicating strong genetic control of these characters.
Genetic advance and genetic advance expressed as a percentage of the mean were moderate to high for several yield-related traits, notably, canopy diameter, number of branches, number of pods, number of peduncles and 100-seed weight.
The comparative evaluation of the F2 and BC1F1 cowpea populations, analysed as maternal half-sib families, provides valuable insight into the genetic consequences of segregation and backcrossing on agronomic performance, yield components and seed traits
(Santos et al., 2024). The significant genetic variation observed in both populations demonstrates that substantial variability was generated at the F2 stage and effectively retained in the BC1F1 generation following backcrossing to the recurrent parent. This outcome is particularly desirable in breeding programmes aimed at introgressing specific resistance traits while recovering elite agronomic backgrounds (
Acquaah, 2012;
Hospital, 2009).
Across most traits, the F‚ population exhibited relatively higher phenotypic and genotypic coefficients of variation compared to the BC1F1 population, reflecting the extensive segregation expected in early generations like the F2. The reduction in variability observed in the BC1F1 generation is consistent with partial genome recovery of the recurrent parent following backcrossing. Nevertheless, the persistence of significant differences among maternal half-sib families in BC1F1 indicates that sufficient genetic diversity remained available for effective selection, particularly for yield-related and seed traits. Similar trends have been reported in cowpea and other self-pollinated crops undergoing backcross breeding (
Falconer and Mackay, 1996;
Gerrano et al., 2015).
The consistently high heritability estimates observed for most traits in both populations highlight the strong genetic control governing trait expression. In the F2 population, high heritability coupled with high genetic advance as a percentage of the mean for traits, such as plant height, canopy diameter, number of branches, number of pods and 100-seed weight suggests the predominance of additive gene action, making these traits highly amenable to early-generation selection
(Johnson et al., 1955). In the BC1F1 population, although genetic advance values were comparatively reduced for some traits, heritability remained high, indicating that favourable alleles were successfully transmitted through backcrossing and could be fixed in subsequent generations.
Seed traits, particularly, 100-seed weight, seed length and seed width, showed high heritability and appreciable genetic advance in both populations, underscoring their importance as reliable selection targets. The maintenance of superior seed traits in the BC1F1 generation is especially significant, as seed size is a key determinant of consumer preference, market value and adoption of improved cowpea varieties. Previous studies have similarly reported seed weight as one of the most heritable traits in cowpea, with limited environmental influence
(Egbadzor et al., 2014; Mohammed et al., 2020).
From a breeding perspective, the results clearly demonstrate the effectiveness of marker-assisted backcross breeding (MABC) in combining
Striga resistance with desirable agronomic and seed characteristics. While conventional backcrossing can lead to linkage drag and loss of elite traits, the retention of high-performing maternal families in the BC1F1 population suggests that marker-assisted selection facilitated the recovery of the recurrent parent genome while preserving favourable alleles for yield and seed size. This aligns with reports that MABC accelerates the introgression of resistance genes while minimizing disruption to elite genetic backgrounds (
Collard and Mackill, 2008;
Hospital, 2009).
The maternal half-sib analytical framework adopted in this study further enhanced selection efficiency by emphasizing additive genetic effects and reducing environmental variance within families. This approach is particularly useful in early backcross generations, where family-based evaluation improves the accuracy of identifying superior genotypes carrying both resistance and agronomic superiority
(Hallauer et al., 2010). The consistent performance of certain maternal families across both F2 and BC1F1 generations suggests genetic stability and highlights their potential as candidates for advancement in subsequent selection cycles.
In the context of
S.
gesnerioides resistance breeding, the ability to maintain high yield potential and large seed size alongside resistance is critical for the successful deployment of improved cowpea varieties in
Striga-prone environments. The present findings demonstrate that the integration of molecular markers with conventional quantitative genetic analysis enables breeders to balance resistance introgression with agronomic performance. This integrated strategy enhances breeding efficiency and increases the likelihood of developing farmer-preferred
Striga-resistant cowpea cultivars.
Overall, the comparative analysis of F2 and BC1F1 populations confirms that early-generation selection, when guided by maternal half-sib evaluation and marker-assisted backcrossing, is an effective approach for simultaneous improvement of resistance and yield-related traits in cowpea. The results provide strong empirical support for the use of MABC in cowpea improvement programmes targeting
S.
gesnerioides resistance without compromising elite seed traits.