Weed parameters
Species wise weed count (plants/m²)
Digera arvensis
The highest weed count of
Digera arvensis (Table 1) was recorded in the untreated control (6.56 plants/m
2), indicating severe infestation where no weed management was practiced. Complete suppression was observed in the weed-free treatment (0.00 plants/m
2). Among herbicide treatments, the lowest counts were seen with atrazine (3.33), topramezone (3.50), topramezone + atrazine (3.33) and mesotrione + atrazine (3.32) post-emergence applications, all statistically at par and significantly lower than the control. These findings are supported by
Anand et al., (2025), which show that both pre-and post-emergence herbicide combinations substantially reduce broadleaf weed populations in maize, aiding efficient crop establishment and reducing competition.
Cynodon dactylon
For
Cynodon dactylon, (Table 1) the maximum count appeared in the control plot (7.15 plants/m²), underscoring the resilience of this perennial grass without intervention. Weed-free plots had no infestation (0.00 plants/m
2). Effective reductions were achieved with atrazine (4.22), topramezone (5.33) and topramezone + atrazine (4.18), which were at par and notably lower than the control. Post-emergence herbicide strategies, as confirmed by
Jeevan et al., (2022), provide moderate suppression of
Cynodon dactylon but rarely achieve complete control due to its robust rhizomatous growth, emphasizing the need for integrated management.
Amaranthus viridis
The untreated control resulted (Table 1) in the highest
Amaranthus viridis density (1.83 plants/m
2), while weed-free plots achieved total suppression (0.00 plants/m
2). Among herbicidal interventions, topramezone + atrazine (6.55) presented an anomaly with an unexpectedly high count, but other treatments like Atrazine (2.18), topramezone (2.39), mesotrione + atrazine (1.18) and mesotrione (1.65) significantly reduced populations, with atrazine and topramezone being at par with each other.
CABI (2022) and
Braz et al., (2022) supports the efficacy of atrazine and HPPD-inhibitor mixes in controlling pigweed species in maize systems.
Parthenium hysterophorus
Parthenium weed was most prevalent in the control plot (6.36 plants/m
2) and eliminated entirely in weed-free conditions (0.00 plants/m
2) in (Table 1). Among chemical treatments, atrazine (1.18), topramezone (1.65), mesotrione (1.18), topramezone + atrazine (1.18) and mesotrione + atrazine (0.70) all significantly reduced
Parthenium hysterophorus incidence compared to control, with mesotrione + atrazine showing the lowest count among the herbicide plots. These observations align with recent field studies of
Bianchini et al., (2020) and
Hasan et al., (2024) highlighting the strong suppression of
parthenium using integrated pre-and post-emergence herbicide programs.
Species wise weed dry weight (g)
Digera arvensis
The highest dry weight of
Digera arvensis (Table 2) was observed in the untreated control (8.52 g), indicating prolific growth in the absence of management, while the lowest was under weed-free conditions (0.00 g). All herbicide treatments, including atrazine, topramezone and combinations with mesotrione, significantly reduced
Digera arvensis biomass, with these treatments performing statistically on par with each other. The effect of tillage method was not significant, suggesting that chemical weed management plays a more crucial role in controlling this species than the choice of tillage. Consistent with prior findings, weed-free and herbicide-treated plots drastically reduce weed biomass compared to untreated controls. Atrazine and post-emergence herbicides, such as topramezone and mesotrione (alone or in combination), significantly suppress
Digera arvensis, matching earlier reports that herbicidal treatments suppress this broadleaf weed by over 50% from weedy checks.
(Rai et al., 2018; Prasad et al., 2020).
Cynodon dactylon
For
Cynodon dactylon, (Table 2) a troublesome perennial grassy weed, dry weight ranged from 7.21 g/m
2 in the untreated control down to 0.00 g/m
2 in weed-free plots. The combination of mesotrione + atrazine was particularly effective (3.60 g/m
2) to controlling the dry matter production of
Cynodon dactylon at 60 DAS, mesotrione alone and topramezone + atrazine combined applications also providing substantial reduction in bio mass production of it. The efficacy of these treatments highlights the importance of integrated herbicide interventions for managing this resilient grass, whereas differences due to tillage systems remained marginal. Grassy weeds like
Cynodon dactylon show substantial reduction under combined chemical strategies, notably mesotrione + atrazine. The efficacy of herbicides on controlling the weeds, especially with integration of post-emergence molecules for grassy weed management has been documented by
(Rai et al., 2018).
Amaranthus viridis
Amaranthus viridis, a fast-growing annual weed, was best controlled under weed-free conditions, showing (0.00 g) dry weight in (Table 2). The maximum dry weight (3.68 g) was observed with the topramezone + atrazine treatment, which, despite being a combination, was less effective on this species than singular herbicide interventions like mesotrione + atrazine (1.12 g) and mesotrione (1.52 g). These findings imply that specific combinations may not always provide broader control and the sensitivity of
Amaranthus viridis to certain herbicides plays a key role in determining efficacy. Marked reduction in dry weight through herbicide combinations is attributed to the sensitivity of this weed to both broad-spectrum and specific post-emergence herbicides, validating current best practices for
Amaranthus control in maize.
(Poojitha et al., 2021).
Parthenium hysterophorus
Parthenium hysterophorus (Table 2) presented the highest dry matter accumulation in the control (7.37 g), underscoring its strong competitive ability. Weed-free and all chemical treatments significantly curtailed its biomass, with the lowest dry weight in the mesotrione + atrazine treatment (0.70 g). This demonstrates that robust weed management interventions are essential to suppress this highly invasive and allelopathic weed, as conventional tillage practices alone were not sufficient to produce statistically significant differences.
Parthenium is a highly competitive weed; failing to control it leads to a severalfold biomass increase and sharp maize yield decline. Chemical management substantially decreases its dry biomass, agreeing with recent research underscoring the critical importance of weed-free periods especially in early crop growth stages (
Schultz and Kumar, 2015;
Rehman et al., 2020).
Total weed count (plants/m²)
The range of total weed count (Table 3) among the main plots (tillage practices) was narrow from 10.18 under conventional tillage to 10.40 under zero tillage. The lowest weed count was noted in conventional tillage (10.18), but differences among main plots were not statistically significant. For the subplots (weed management practices), weed count ranged widely from 0 in the weed free treatment (lowest) to 17.63 in the weedy check control (highest). Atrazine (8.09), mesotrione (9.19) and mesotrione + atrazine (8.26) were statistically at par, all significantly reducing weed count compared to the control. This pattern showed that active weed management, especially with pre-emergence atrazine or combinations involving mesotrione, is highly effective in reducing weed populations. These findings are in line with recent research identifying the superior efficacy of integrated herbicidal regimes over cultural (tillage-only) approaches for weed suppression in maize systems (
Thukkaiyannan and Satheeshkumar, 2024;
Sepat and Singh, 2024).
Total weed dry weight (g m-2)
In terms of total weed dry weight (Table 3), values among the main plots ranged narrowly between 10.88 g (Conventional Tillage, lowest) and 11.11 g (Minimum tillage, highest), In subplots, the range was wider, with the weed free plots having the lowest dry weight (0 g) and the control plots the highest (18.26 g). Atrazine (8.97 g), mesotrione (10.49 g), topramezone (10.99 g) and mesotrione + atrazine (9.18 g) all showed significantly reduced weed biomass and were at par, showing strong suppression compared to the untreated control. These results highlight that the implementation of an effective chemical weed management program especially using atrazine and post-emergence combinations offers substantial reductions in weed biomass. This observation is supported by contemporary field studies emphasizing that herbicidal interventions can reduce weed dry matter by 70-80% and play a much larger role in controlling total weed pressure than tillage variations.
(Hemlata et al., 2023; Sepat and Singh, 2024).
Growth parameters
Plant population
The highest plant population (Table 4) among tillage treatments was recorded under conventional tillage (9.14), which was at par with minimum tillage (8.57), while the lowest was observed under zero tillage (7.86). In weed management, atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence showed the highest plant population (10.33), closely followed by mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence (10.00). Control recorded the lowest population (7.67) and weed free was also low (6.00). Conventional tillage generally enhances plant population by improving soil structure and seed-soil contact, ensuring better germination and establishment. Its ability to reduce soil compaction compared to zero tillage is a key factor, especially in fine-textured soils, as reported by
(Cakpo et al., 2025). Weed management treatments like herbicides and post-emergence mixes significantly increase plant population by reducing early competition, supporting high crop emergence
(Naeem et al., 2022).
Plant height (cm)
The highest plant height (212.42 cm) was recorded in weed-free plots, followed by the treatment with mesotrione + atrazine (post-emergence) at 70 g/ha + 0.5 kg/ha, while the lowest plant height (191.85 cm) was observed in the control treatment showed in (Table 4). Among tillage practices, conventional tillage resulted in the tallest plants (206.00 cm), followed by minimum tillage (204.33 cm), with zero tillage showing the shortest plant height (202.77 cm), which was statistically similar to the others. Conventional tillage improves soil structure, promoting better root development and nutrient availability, which supports greater plant height
(Feng et al., 2024). Effective weed management, such as manual weeding or the use of pre-emergence herbicides, reduces competition for light and nutrients, thereby minimizing the negative impact of weeds on plant growth, as confirmed over the years as reported by (
Babu and Senthivel, 2019).
Plant dry weight (g)
Mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence (Table 4) had the highest plant dry weight (153.81g), which was at par with topramezone (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) (151.85 g) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (147.57 g), the lowest was recorded in the control (131.64 g). For the main plot, conventional tillage also achieved the highest dry weight (147.27 g), followed by minimum tillage (143.76 g) and the lowest under zero tillage (141.12 g). Higher dry biomass under conventional tillage is attributable to enhanced soil aeration and root proliferation, supporting vigorous growth and productive canopies.
(Birla et al., 2023). Superior weed control with a combination of pre- and post-emergence herbicides, or keeping plots weed free, markedly boosts crop biomass by preventing yield-reducing resource competition
(Naeem et al., 2022).
Yield parameters
Length of cobs (cm)
The highest cob length (Table 5) was observed under conventional tillage (13.06 cm), which was at par with minimum tillage (12.77 cm); the lowest was in zero tillage (12.46 cm). Among weed control plots, the mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence treatment produced the longest cobs (15.20 cm), followed by weed free (14.04 cm) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (13.41 cm), while control had the shortest cobs (10.72 cm). Conventional tillage generally leads to increased cob length due to improved soil aeration, nutrient availability and reduced compaction, which enhance root growth and crop vigour
(Tukur et al., 2024; Gao et al., 2024). Effective weed management, particularly the integration of post-emergence herbicides, maximizes cob length by minimizing resource competition during critical crop growth periods (
Nimanwad, 2020;
Hemlata et al., 2023).
Grith of cobs (cm)
The widest cob girth (Table 5) was recorded for conventional tillage (11.10 cm), at par with minimum tillage (10.77 cm); the narrowest was in zero tillage (10.46 cm). For weed control, mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence resulted in the widest cobs (13.31 cm), followed by weed free (12.04 cm) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (11.41 cm); the narrowest was in control (8.72 cm). Conventional tillage increases cob girth by promoting uniform seedbed conditions and robust early growth, which result in enhanced assimilate distribution to developing cobs
(Tukur et al., 2024). Among weed treatments, application of both pre-and post-emergence herbicides produces the largest cob girth by suppressing weed competition through the crop cycle
(Hemlata et al., 2023).
Number of grain rows/cob
The maximum rows per cob (Table 5) were recorded under conventional tillage (11.20), statistically similar to minimum tillage (10.87); the lowest was in zero tillage (10.56). In weed management, the highest row number was in the mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence plot (13.41), closely followed by weed free (12.14) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (11.51); the lowest was in control (8.82). Higher number of rows per cob under conventional tillage can be attributed to improved soil structure, which enhances nutrient availability and supports reproductive development in maize. This is consistent with multi-seasonal research showing tillage positively influences yield components
(Tukur et al., 2024; Kumar et al., 2025). Integrated herbicide programs maintain the highest row counts by providing complete weed suppression during sensitive developmental windows, reducing stress on developing cobs
(Hemlata et al., 2023).
Grain yield (t/ha)
The highest grain yield was with conventional tillage (3.39 t/ha) showed in (Table 5), at par with minimum tillage (3.30 t/ha); the lowest was with zero tillage (3.13 t/ha). Mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence attained the maximum grain yield (4.39 t/ha), followed by weed free (4.07 t/ha) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (3.55 t/ha); control had the lowest grain yield (2.14 t/ha). The superior grain yield under conventional tillage arises from better seed placement, optimal root proliferation and higher soil fertility, supporting greater cob development and grain filling.
Gao et al., (2024); Hirwe et al., (2025) emphasize the effectiveness of herbicide-based weed control particularly combined pre- and post-emergence treatments in boosting maize grain yield due to greatly diminished crop-weed competition throughout the season.
Straw yield (t/ha)
Conventional tillage produced the highest straw yield (5.98 t/ha), with minimum tillage (5.70 t/ha) close behind (Table 5), the lowest was with zero tillage (5.53 t/ha). In weed management, mesotrione (70 g/ha) + atrazine (0.5 kg/ha) post-emergence gave the greatest stover yield (7.23 t/ha), surpassed only slightly by weed free (6.47 t/ha) and atrazine (1.0 kg/ha) pre-emergence (5.95 t/ha); the lowest was control (4.54 t/ha). Straw yield mirrors trends in grain yield, with conventional tillage offering better biomass accumulation due to favorable physical and chemical conditions in the soil
(Gao et al., 2024). Integrated weed management, especially treatments combining herbicides and hand weeding or sequential applications, consistently result in higher stover yields because of vigorous growth with minimal resource competition
(Vardhan et al., 2018).