Effect of BAP on shoots number per explants
In order to stimulate the proliferation of
Abelmoschus esculentus shoots and to optimize the proliferation medium, several concentrations of BAP were tested to select an optimal concentration allowing the highest number of shoots to be obtained.
The influence of BAP on proliferation was analyzed on MS medium. The results after 4 weeks of cultivation showed that the number of shoots depends significantly on the BAP concentration used in the proliferation medium (p<0.001) (Table 1).
The control MS medium produced only one shoot per explant and showed no proliferation in the absence of BAP, accompanied by the formation of large green leaves and a high density of roots, this was also observed by
Belkhodja et al., (2023) in the same species. The medium supplemented with 1.0 mg L
-1 of BAP produced an average of 2.05 shoots per explant, along with the emergence of a few roots on the proliferated shoots and the development of a midsized, whitish basal callus (Fig 4).
According to LSD comparison test (Table 2), this difference in the number of shoots under 1.0 mg L
-1 of BAP and 0.0 BAP is highly significant. It should be noted that the number of shoots per explant increases significantly with increasing BAP concentrations, up to 2.0 mg L
-1 (Table 2). Under this medium (2.0 mgL
-1), 3.07 shoots per explant were produced, characterized by their green coloration, a high number of leaves and the development of large calluses, compared to other media (Fig 3).
Above 2.0 mg L
-1 of BAP, the number of shoots per explant decreases slightly, without a significant difference compared to media containing 2.0, 3.0, or 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP (Fig 3). The medium supplemented with 3.0 mg L
-1 of BAP produced 2.82 shoots per explant, while the one with 4.0 mg L
-1 produced 2.77 shoots per explant. It is also worth noting that the callus formed at 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP was less developed than that observed at 2.0 mg L
-1.
Depending on the number of shoots per explant, the medium enriched with 2.0 mg L
-1 BAP is considered the most suitable for proliferation among those tested, followed by the medium containing 4.0 mgL
-1 BAP. This medium (4.0 mg L
-1) appears to be effective for shoot proliferation and does not show a statistically significant difference compared to the medium supplemented with 2.0 mgL
-1 of BAP.
In this experiment, However, the size of the calluses is not the key factor for assessing proliferation, but rather the number, length and productivity of the shoots. We observed that 2.0 mgL
-1 BAP treatment induced enhanced shoot elongation and significantly increased callus biomass as compared to 4.0 mg L
-1 BAP treatment as shown in Fig 3 and 4, respectively.
The observed finding aligns with previous studies showing that the increase in BAP concentration enhanced bud proliferation (
Tanuwidjaja, 1998). Present results demonstrate that the efficiency of shoot proliferation varied according to the concentration of plant growth regulator, and the use of different concentrations of BAP significantly influenced the morphogenic responses in explant.
Bensalem et al., (2023) further reported that combining TDZ with BAP effectively enhanced callus induction.
An increase in BAP concentration enhanced bud proliferation, as evidenced by an increase from 2.05 shoots per explant at 1.0 mgL
-1 BAP to a maximum of 3.07 shoots per explant at 2.0 mgL
-1. The same result has already been reported with
Prosopis cineraria,
Dendrocalamus strictus and
Tinospora cordifolia (
Sangeetha and lenkatachalam, 2014;
Venkatachalam et al., 2017; Goyal et al., 2015; Panwar et al., 2018). The number of shoots initially increased with BAP concentration, reaching a maximum at 2.0 mg L
-1 and then gradually decreased at higher concentrations, with 2.82 shoots per explant at 3.0 mg L
-1 and 2.77 shoots at 4.0 mg L
-1. The differences in shoot number were statistically significant, indicating that 2.0 mg L
-1 BAP is the optimal concentration for shoot proliferation.
Similar results were reported by
Benmahioul et al., (2009); Barghchi and Aldersen (1983) and
Abousalim et al., (1991) who found that the use of 2.0 to 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP increased significantly the number lof shoots produced by explant. In pistachio trees the low and high doses of BAP had a negative effect on bud productivity and their subsequent development.
Tallón et al. (2009) demonstrated that shoot proliferation in
Citrus limon is influenced by BAP and GA concentrations, with maximum shoot numbers observed at 2 mg L
-1 BAP in combination with 1.0 or 2.0 mgL
-1 GA. For
Curcuma zedoaria, the best shoot multiplication rate was recorded in MS medium with 2.0 mgL
-1 of BAP and 1.0 mgL
-1 of TDZ yielding 5.3±0.24 shoots/explant
(Hussain et al., 2023).
The effect of hormonal concentration on shoot length per explant
The analysis of variance reveals that the BAP concentration in the media has a highly significant effect on the shoots length (p<0.001) (Table 1).
As per LSD resultl (Table 2), Shoot length was significantly reduced with increasing concentrations of the plant growth regulator. Shoot length obtained in the MS0 was significantly better compared to the media supplemented with 1.0, 2.0, 3.0 and 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP. Specifically, shoots in the control medium reached an average length of 4.26 cm, which was significantly higher than those grown in the BAP-supplemented media (Table 2). Although a decreasing trend in shoot length was observed with increasing BAP concentrations, but this reduction was not statistically significant.
From our study, it was observed that the presence of BAP in the culture media had reduced the length of proliferated shoots. Moreover, the length of the shoots obtained was short in the presence of BAP compared to the control without PGR. Similar results were reported by
Tallón et al. (2009) and
de Jesus et al. (2022) working respectively on
Citrus macrophylla and
Guazuma ulmifolia Lam.
Arab et al., (2014) reported that hormone concentration affects significantly shoot length, so increasing hormone level triggers a significant decrease in shoot length. Their findings indicated that the longest shoots were obtained from media without PGRs. This could be explained by the fact that media containing cytokinins promote the formation of a higher number of shoots, which consume more nutrients. As a result, the limited availability of nutrients per shoot may reduce their capacity for elongation.
It has been reported that in
Guazuma ulmifolia Lamp, the reduction in shoot ength may be related to the antagonistic interaction between the cytokinins and gibberellins of the shoot meristems. Cytokinin stimulates cytokinesis by promoting the proliferation of cells with meristematic characteristics, while inhibiting the activity of gibberellins, which are responsible for cell elongation
(Maekawa et al., 2009; Shi and Vernoux, 2022).
Effect of hormonal concentration on explant productivity
Productivity is a valuable parameter as it reflects the combined effect of the treatment on both shoot number and length and gives a general idea of the
in vitro behaviour of shoots (
Pérez-Tornero and Burgos, 2000).
The analysis of variance reveals that productivity varies very significantly according to the hormonal concentration in the media (p<0.001) (Table 1).
Statistical analysis of shoot productivity across the different culture media, performed using the LSD test (Table 2), showed that the MS0 medium was the most productive, with an average of 4.26 shoots per explant. This productivity was significantly higher than that observed in media supplemented with 1.0, 3.0 and 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP. The medium supplemented with 2.0 mg L
-1 of BAP showed intermediate productivity (3.91 shoots per explant), with no significant difference compared to either MS0 or the medium containing 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP. However, MS0 recorded the lowest number of shoots.
The shoot productivity observed in the 4.0 mg L
-1 BAP medium was close to that of the 2.0 mg L
-1 BAP medium which proved to be the most efficient for shoot proliferation (Table 2). The LSD test indicated no significant difference between the 2.0 mg L
-1 and 4.0 mg L
-1 BAP treatments. In contrast, the media supplemented with 1.0 and 3.0 mg L
-1 of BAP exhibited the lowest productivity, with mean values of 2.84 and 3.13 shoots per explant, respectively. These values were significantly lower than those obtained in the control (MS0) and the media containing 2.0 and 4.0 mg L
-1 of BAP.
From our work, the best productivity results were obtained in the control and at 2.0 mg L
-1 BAP. It has also been observed by
Tallón et al. (2009) that Productivity peaks below 2.0 mgL
-1 BAP and 2.0 mgL
-1 Ga.The results obtained in this work conclude that the concentration of BAP in the media has a highly significant effect on productivity (p<0.001). Similar results are reported by
Pérez-Tornero and Burgos (2000). In apricots, they found that productivity is significantly affected by the cultivar and by the interaction between the genotype and the media.
Present study indicates that 2.0 mgL
-1 of BAP treatment significantly increased shoot proliferation. It has been found that the MS medium with the addition of 6-Benzylaminopurine promotes the proliferation of shoots. Our results corroborate several studies, such as those by
Almeida et al., (1995) and
Adel et al., (2011), which reported that BAP at 2.0 mgL
-1 significantly affected shoot proliferation, length and weight in
Ananas comosus L.
Rooting and acclimatization of plantlets
Okra shoots were rooted in MS0 culture medium in glass test tubes containing 10 ml of medium. Within one week, the elongated shoots formed 2 to 3 nodes developed roots (Fig 5). The resulting plantlets were lthen ltransferred lto lsmall lpots containing sterile compost and covered with transparent lplastic bags to maintain humidity and facilitate acclimatization. After 10 days (Fig 5), lthe lacclimatized lplants were transferred to llarger pots lin a controlled greenhouse at a temperature of 30°C±3. After 30 days of greenhouse cultivation, the plants showed robust development with lmature leaves land lvisible lflower bud initiation (Fig 5). The survival rate lof the lplantlets llwas 100%. These results are lsimilar lto llthe work of
Belkhodja et al., (2023).