Relative zona thickness index
The principal analysis showed a difference in RZTI between the two-pre-slaughter udder-status groups.
The apparently normal group had a median RZTI of 9.97%, compared with 7.70% in the apparently abnormal group. Mean RZTI values were 9.70±1.00% and 7.95±1.32%, respectively. The corresponding ranges were 7.32-10.95% for the apparently normal group and 6.03-10.33% for the apparently abnormal group. The exact two-sided Mann-Whitney test yielded P = 0.0159 (Table 1), indicating an unadjusted difference in the distribution of RZTI between the two groups. The distribution of RZTI values according to pre-slaughter udder status is presented in Fig 1.
Distribution of the relative zona thickness index (RZTI) among bovine oocytes according to pre-slaughter udder status. Each point represents one donor-level observation. The box represents the interquartile range and the horizontal line within each box indicates the median. The apparently abnormal group showed lower RZTI values than the apparently normal group (exact two-sided Mann-Whitney U test, P = 0.0159).
Individual oocyte measurements
Absolute zona pellucida thickness showed a pattern consistent with the RZTI finding. The median ZPT was 18.16 μm in the apparently normal group and 15.01 μm in the apparently abnormal group, with an exact P value of 0.0314. In contrast, outer oocyte diameter did not differ significantly between the groups. Median outer oocyte diameter was 187.81 μm in the apparently normal group and 194.84 μm in the apparently abnormal group (P = 0.1569). Ooplasm diameter and perivitelline space also showed no statistically significant between-group differences. Similarly, COC diameter before and after maturation did not differ significantly between the two groups (Table 2).
Magnitude and direction of between-group differences
The median difference in RZTI, calculated as apparently abnormal minus apparently normal, was -2.26 percentage points, with a rank-biserial correlation of -0.646 (P = 0.0159). The negative direction indicates lower RZTI values in the apparently abnormal group. Similarly, the median difference in absolute ZPT was -3.16 μm, with a rank-biserial correlation of -0.583 (P = 0.0314), indicating lower ZPT values in the apparently abnormal group. In contrast, outer oocyte diameter showed a positive median difference of +7.03 μm, indicating a higher median value in the apparently abnormal group; however, this difference was not statistically significant (P = 0.1569). Ooplasm diameter also showed a positive median difference (+3.68 μm), whereas perivitelline space and COC measurements showed smaller differences in either direction (Table 3).
Median difference was calculated as the median value in the apparently abnormal group minus the median value in the apparently normal group. Negative values indicate lower values in the apparently abnormal group, whereas positive values indicate higher values.
Multiple-testing consideration
The unadjusted exact Mann-Whitney U tests showed nominal statistical significance for RZTI (P = 0.0159) and absolute zona pellucida thickness (ZPT; P = 0.0314). However, after adjustment for multiple comparisons using the Benjamini-Hochberg false discovery rate (FDR) procedure across the seven tested endpoints, the adjusted P values for both parameters were approximately 0.110. Neither association remained statistically significant after FDR adjustment. Therefore, the nominal P values are reported as unadjusted results, whereas the FDR-adjusted P values account for multiple testing. These findings should be interpreted as exploratory associations rather than statistically confirmed evidence and require further investigation in larger prospective studies.
The present study identified an association between pre-slaughter udder appearance and relative zona pellucida thickness in bovine oocytes. The median relative zona thickness index (RZTI) was lower in the apparently abnormal udder group than in the apparently normal group (7.70% vs. 9.97%; nominal P = 0.0159). This difference was accompanied by lower absolute zona pellucida thickness (ZPT) in the apparently abnormal group (15.01 vs. 18.16 μm; nominal P = 0.0314), whereas outer oocyte diameter (OOD) did not differ significantly between groups. These findings indicate that the observed variation was mainly associated with zona-related measurements rather than a detectable difference in overall oocyte diameter. The biological relevance of zona pellucida characteristics has been investigated in previous bovine oocyte studies.
Santos et al. (2008) examined relationships between zona pellucida ultrastructure, polyspermic penetration and oocyte developmental characteristics, while
Koester et al., (2011) investigated zona pellucida properties as potential indicators of embryonic developmental potential.
Timlin et al., (2021) also evaluated physical characteristics of bovine oocytes and zygotes in relation to subsequent developmental outcomes. These studies provide a biological basis for examining zona pellucida morphology. In this context, RZTI offers a complementary description of zona thickness by expressing it relative to OOD, rather than considering absolute thickness alone. Nevertheless, the present study did not evaluate fertilization or embryo development and therefore cannot establish whether the observed RZTI differences have functional consequences.
The association between udder appearance and zona-related measurements may be considered in the broader context of donor physiological condition. Previous studies have reported associations between mastitis and changes in bovine oocyte characteristics.
Roth et al., (2013) reported impaired developmental competence of oocytes from cows with naturally occurring mastitis, while
Asaf et al., (2014) investigated the effects of experimentally induced mastitis on bovine oocytes. Previous work from our group also demonstrated associations between ovarian characteristics, oocyte quality and
in vitro maturation outcomes
(Ammari et al., 2022), as well as seasonal variation in oocyte recovery, quality and maturation
(Ammari et al., 2023). These findings provide context for investigating donor-related characteristics in relation to oocyte morphology. However, the present study identified an association with external udder appearance and did not establish that mammary inflammation was responsible for the observed differences. The absence of significant differences in ooplasm diameter, perivitelline space and cumulus–oocyte complex measurements before and after maturation suggests that the observed variation was not accompanied by detectable differences across all measured morphometric parameters. The findings were mainly concentrated in absolute ZPT and RZTI. Although both parameters showed nominally significant between-group differences, neither remained statistically significant after Benjamini-Hochberg adjustment for multiple comparisons (FDR-adjusted P = 0.1100 for both). Therefore, these results should be interpreted as exploratory and hypothesis-generating rather than confirmatory. The consistent direction of the two zona-related measurements nevertheless supports further investigation of RZTI as a complementary morphometric descriptor.
Several limitations should be considered when interpreting these findings. First, the study included only 20 donor-level observations, comprising 12 apparently normal and 8 apparently abnormal udder records. Second, udder classification was based on recorded external appearance before slaughter rather than objective diagnostic procedures. The absence of somatic cell counts, bacteriological cultures, inflammatory biomarkers and histopathological examination means that the apparently abnormal group cannot be considered a laboratory-confirmed mastitis group. Third, the study did not include direct measurements of fertilization, cleavage, blastocyst formation, or embryo quality. Accordingly, no conclusions can be drawn regarding the effects of udder appearance or RZTI on reproductive or developmental outcomes. Future studies should include larger donor populations and standardized assessments of udder health, supported by somatic cell counts, microbiological examination and inflammatory biomarkers. Combining these assessments with detailed oocyte morphometry and subsequent in vitro maturation, fertilization and embryo-development outcomes would help determine whether variations in RZTI have functional reproductive significance. Overall, the present findings indicate an association between pre-slaughter udder appearance and relative zona pellucida thickness in bovine oocytes. The lower RZTI and absolute ZPT observed in the apparently abnormal group suggest that zona-related measurements may vary according to donor characteristics. However, the limited sample size, observational classification and absence of inflammatory and developmental measurements require cautious interpretation. Further studies are needed to establish the reproducibility and biological significance of this association.