Effect of Different Vitrification Protocols of Post-warming Hatching of in vitro Produced Buffalo Embryos

R
Ruchir D. Pranami1,*
V
Vishal S. Suthar2
K
Karshan B. Vala3
S
Suryakant S. Parikh3
D
Devshi N. Borkhatariya3
K
Kirankumar H. Parmar4
1Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, M. B. Veterinary College, Dungarpur-314 011, Rajasthan, India.
2Gujarat Biotechnology University, Gandhinagar-382 355, Gujarat, India.
3Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Junagadh-362 001, Gujarat, India.
4Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Anand-388 001, Gujarat, India.

Background: The present study compared the commercial vitrification method with laboratory-prepared vitrification solutions on the post-warming hatching of in vitro produced (IVP) blastocysts.

Methods: A total of 77 IVP blastocysts were randomly allocated into four groups: Group I (fresh, non-vitrified control; n = 22), Group II (commercial vitrification kit, Vitrogen, Brazil; n = 20), Group III (25% dimethyl sulfoxide [DMSO] + 25% ethylene glycol [EG]; n = 22) and Group IV (25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M sucrose; n = 13). Embryos of Group II were vitrified using a commercially available vitrification kit, while Groups III and IV were vitrified using a two-step equilibration protocol. Following devitrification, embryos were cultured at 38.5oC under a benchtop incubator (Cooper Surgical, USA; 90% N2, 5% O2 and 5% CO2).

Result: Post-warming developmental competence was evaluated by observing blastocyst hatching at 2, 12, 24 and 48 h of culture. The highest hatching rate was observed in the fresh control group (40.91%), followed by the commercial vitrification group (25.00%), the DMSO + EG + sucrose group (15.38%) and the DMSO + EG group (4.55%). Overall, 17 of 77 blastocysts hatched during post-warming culture, with the highest proportion of hatching occurring after 48 h (11.69%), followed by 24 h (9.09%),12 h (1.30%) and 2 h (0.00%). The commercial vitrification kit showed a better post-warming hatching rate, while addition of sucrose improved the cryosurvival of BLs in DMSO and EG-based vitrification medium.

The cryopreservation of mammalian embryos has become an integral part of methods to control animal reproduction. Cryopreservation is of practical importance for the development of reproductive technologies such as nuclear transfer, cryo-banking of animal species and the routine or commercial application of breed improvement, such as embryo transfer (Wani, 2002; Suthar and Shah, 2009). Several cryopreservation methods, such as conventional (slow), equilibrium rapid freezing (vitrification) and ultra-rapid freezing have been used to preserve embryos and oocytes of many animal species, resulting in the birth of live offspring.
       
Vitrification is a popular method of cryopreservation of embryos and oocytes. This process has mainly three phases: i) dehydration, replacing the liquid with cryoprotectant liquid through diffusion into the cell; ii) cooling, the phase where embryos and liquid form solid glass in liquid nitrogen; warming, a phase of turning back into liquid form; and iii) rehydration, a process of water returning into the cell and replacing cryoprotectants (Syafruddin et al., 2018). According to Parnpai et al., (2016), vitrification is the solidification of a solution brought about not by crystallization but by extreme elevation in viscosity during cooling. It is a common method for cryopreservation of gametes and embryos. Although successful oocyte vitrification has been achieved in several animal species, subsequent progress is still limited, especially in buffalo (Mahmoud and El-Sokary, 2013).
       
Many compounds act as cryoprotectants and are used for the protection of cells against freezing. There are two types of cryoprotectants: (a) membrane-permeating, which can freely diffuse through the membrane, such as glycerol (G), ethylene glycol (EG) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO); (b) non-membrane-permeating, which cannot permeate the cell membrane, such as sugars (Pedro et al., 2005). With promising results already obtained with embryo vitrification, various protocols have been proposed for optimization of cell survival. Various devices have been developed to reduce the volume of vitrification solutions and speed up the process. Among these, the open pulled straw (OPS) method (Vajta et al., 1998) is the most widely used technique for bovine embryos (Do et al., 2014). Recently, VitriFit device has been used for vitrification of COCs and Embryos (Patel et al., 2024; 2026; Prajapati et al., 2024; 2026). In addition, the cryoprotectant solution usually contains two intracellular cryoprotectants, e.g. ethylene glycol (EG) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), to make an effective composition to penetrate cells and tissues having lower toxicity than other cryoprotectants such as glycerol or propylene glycol.
       
When cells are exposed to high concentrations of cryoprotectants, the risk of cryodamage caused by large ice crystals is almost null, but osmotic shock can frequently occur (Lai et al., 2015). To avoid this effect, extracellular cryoprotectants, usually sugars, are added to the vitrification solution. These sugars support embryo dehydration by stabilizing the cell plasma membrane (Turner et al., 2001). Another function of the use of sugars in vitrification solutions is to increase glassy state formation, thereby reducing the formation of ice crystals during the vitrification-warming processes (Shaw and Jones, 2003). Sucrose is the most used sugar for embryo vitrification (Lai et al., 2015), but there is very little information available for the use of other sugars, like glucose, in the vitrification of bovine embryos. Glucose has been tested for vitrification of zebrafish embryos (Lahnsteiner, 2008). Therefore, the present study was undertaken to compare a commercial vitrification kit with laboratory-prepared vitrification solutions containing DMSO and EG, with or without sucrose and to evaluate their effects on post-warming hatching of in vitro produced buffalo blastocysts. However, vitrification may affect the structural and functional integrity of reproductive cells and tissues (Dua et al., 2021).
In vitro embryo production (IVEP)
 
The work was carried out at Gujarat Biotechnology Research Centre, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India, during February 2024 to December 2024. Buffalo ovaries were collected from a slaughterhouse of the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC), Ahmedabad and were transported to the laboratory under warm sterile conditions. Cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were recovered by follicular aspiration. The detailed methodology is described somewhere else (Pranami et al., 2026). In brief, the recovered COCs were morphologically graded using the protocol followed by Das et al., (1996) and only Grade I-III oocytes were selected for in vitro maturation (IVM). Matured oocytes were subsequently fertilized in vitro using frozen-thawed buffalo bull semen processed by the semen preparation protocol. Following in vitro fertilization, presumptive zygotes were denuded and cultured in pre-equilibrated embryo culture medium in a benchtop incubator under controlled environment (38.5oC, 5% CO2, 5% O2 and 90% N2). Cleavage was assessed at 72 h of fertilization and embryos were cultured until Day 6, then blastocysts (BLs) were selected for the subsequent vitrification procedure. All in vitro embryo production procedures, including IVM, IVF and IVC, were performed according to the manufacturer’s protocol of the IVF Bioscience BO-IVM™, BO-IVF™ and BO-IVC™ media system (IVF Bioscience, UK).
 
Distribution of In vitro produced embryos in different groups
 
In group I, fresh in vitro produced embryos at BL stage were selected for Group I and three other different vitrification groups as described below. Randomly allotted BLs were cultured for evaluation for expansion and hatching.
       
In group II, BLs were vitrified using a vitrification kit (Vitrogen, Brazil) at room temperature, 25oC, as directed in the manufacturer’s guidelines. After the procedure, BLs were loaded immediately in a vitrification device (VitriFit, ref. 42802001A, Cooper Surgical) and extra media were removed using the micropipette on the tip of the device. The device was then plunged immediately into LN2 and closed with a precooled lid. Subsequently, the device was transferred into a pencil goblet in canisters of the LN2 tank for storage till devitrification.
       
In group III, BLs were vitrified using 25% DMSO and 25% EG. BLs of this experimental group were placed in a 50 μl droplet of DMEM (Dulbecco’s modified eagle medium) supplemented with 10% FBS (Fetal Bovine Serum; Basic medium). All embryos were manipulated at 38.5oC and were exposed in a two-step process to an 800 μl vitrification solution. Embryos were first incubated in 15% DMSO + 15% EG dissolved in a basic medium for 1 min (Step 1) and then transferred into a 20 μl droplet of 25% DMSO+25% EG dissolved in a basic medium for 4 min (Step 2), following the protocol of Souza et al., (2018).
       
In group IV, BLs were vitrified using 25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M Sucrose. All cryoprotectants used during the preparation of the solutions were purchased from Sigma. BLs of this experimental group were placed in a 50 μl droplet of DMEM supplemented with 10% FBS (Basic medium). All embryos were manipulated at 38.5oC and were exposed in a two-step process to an 800 μl vitrification solution. Embryos were first incubated in 15% DMSO + 15% EG+ 1.0 M Sucrose dissolved in a basic medium for 1 min (Step 1) and then transferred into a 20 μl droplet of 25% DMSO+25% EG+ 1.0 M Sucrose dissolved in a basic medium for 4 min (Step 2), following the protocol of Souza et al., (2018).
       
In Group I, as it is a fresh group, no devitrification process was performed. For Group II, devitrification of vitrified BLs were performed using de-vitrification media (D1, D2 and D3; Vitrogen, Brazil) as per the manufacturer’s guidelines. The vitrified device was opened within LN2 and immediately kept in the devitrification media. The BLs were recovered by observing under a stereo zoom microscope and kept for 1 min. Subsequently, the BLs were again transferred using a micropipette (10 μl) in devitrification media.
       
For group III and IV, devitrification of BLs were performed in Basic medium + 0.4 M sucrose for 1 min for removal of cryoprotectant, followed by Basic medium + 0.4 M sucrose for 5 min, 0.2 M sucrose for 5 min and Basic Medium only for 5 min.
       
Post devitrification, the BLs were incubated at 38.5oC, in a 90% N2, 5% O2 and 5% CO2 in an incubator in an IVC medium and hatching rates were determined after 2 h, 12 h, 24 h and 48 h.
 
Statistical analysis
 
All observations were recorded in an Excel sheet (MS Office 2016) and analyzed using SPSS 26.0 software (IBM SPSS software Bengaluru, India). The descriptive analysis was performed using a descriptive function in the analysis drop-down menu of SPSS software. Differences among groups were analyzed using Chi-square test. Data were expressed as percentages and frequencies. The values were considered significant when “p≤0.05”.
Vitrification of in vitro produced embryos
 
A total of 77 (5.5±0.6/Session) buffalo BLs in vitro produced were utilized in the present investigation. The representative images of the BLs produced during the experiment are documented in Fig 1. Among them, 22 (28.57%), 20 (25.97%), 22 (28.57%) and 13 (16.88%) blastocysts were allocated to Group I (fresh control), Group II (commercial vitrification kit; Vitrogen), Group III (25% DMSO + 25% EG) and Group IV (25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M sucrose), respectively (Table 1).

Fig 1: Different buffalo blastocyst stages on day 6 of in vitro culture and used for different vitrification treatments.



Table 1: Session wise In vitro produced blastocysts and random distribution in four vitrification groups.


       
The developmental competence of BLs following vitrification-warming was assessed based on their ability to hatch during post-warming culture. Hatching is considered one of the most reliable indicators of embryo viability because it reflects the capacity of the BLs to re-expand, resume metabolic activity and continue normal development after cryopreservation stress.
       
The results demonstrated a significant effect of vitrification treatment on BLs hatching rate (χ2 test, P = 0.004). Fresh, non-vitrified BLs (Group I) showed the highest hatching rate (40.91%), which was significantly greater than all vitrified groups. Representative images of fresh and vitrified-warmed BLs showing re-expansion and hatching are presented in Fig 2. Among the vitrified embryos, the highest hatching rate was observed in Group II (Vitrogen; 25.00%), followed by Group IV (DMSO + EG + sucrose; 15.38%) and Group III (DMSO + EG; 4.55%) (Table 2; Fig 2).

Table 2: Session wise vitrified, devitrified and hatching Bls of different groups (Group I-IV).



Fig 2: Representative images of post-devitrification expansion of BLs in three different vitrification treatments for Buffalo BLs.


       
The superior performance of fresh BLs were expected since these embryos were not exposed to the osmotic and chemical stresses associated with cryopreservation. Vitrification subjects BLs to rapid changes in temperature, dehydration and high concentrations of cryoprotectants, all of which can induce cellular injury, cytoskeletal disruption, membrane damage and oxidative stress, thereby reducing subsequent developmental competence. These results are in accordance with our previous results (Prajapati et al., 2026).  The hatching rates obtained in the present study were higher than those reported by Manjunatha (2006), Varago et al., (2018) and Souza et al., (2018), who observed comparatively lower post-warming embryo development following vitrification. These differences may be attributed to variations in BLs quality, species or breed differences, vitrification devices, cryoprotectant composition, equilibration duration, warming protocols and culture conditions.
       
In contrast to our study, several researchers have reported substantially higher hatching rates following embryo vitrification. Hufana-Duran et al. (2004) recorded hatching rates ranging from 75-91% in buffalo embryos, while Saha et al., (2013), Xu et al., (2006), Oliveira et al., (2020), Rodero et al., (2021) and Do et al., (2019) has reported hatching rates between approximately 52% and 90%.
       
The lower hatching rates observed in the present study may be associated with the inherent cryosensitivity of in vitro-produced buffalo BLs. Buffalo embryos generally contain relatively high intracellular lipid content, which increases susceptibility to chilling injury and cryodamage during vitrification. In addition, differences in embryo developmental stage, blastocyst quality, cryoprotectant exposure time and operator handling could have contributed to the reduced post-warming developmental competence recorded herein.
       
Among vitrified treatments, embryos cryopreserved using the commercial Vitrogen kit exhibited better post-warming survival than those vitrified using laboratory-prepared cryoprotectant solutions. The improved outcome may be attributed to the optimized composition of the commercial vitrification media, which are specifically formulated to balance cryoprotectant permeability, osmotic regulation and toxicity. Commercial protocols often include proprietary additives that enhance membrane stabilization and reduce cryoinjury during both cooling and warming phases.
       
A notable finding of the present study was the beneficial effect of sucrose supplementation. Addition of 1.0 M sucrose to the DMSO + EG vitrification solution improved hatching rate from 4.55% (Group III) to 15.38% (Group IV). Although the hatching rate remained lower than that obtained with the commercial kit, the improvement suggests a positive role of sucrose in embryo cryosurvival. Sucrose acts as a non-permeating cryoprotectant that promotes cellular dehydration before vitrification, thereby minimizing intracellular ice crystal formation. Furthermore, sucrose contributes to osmotic buffering during warming and supports stabilization of the plasma membrane. These functions help reduce osmotic shock and structural damage associated with exposure to concentrated intracellular cryoprotectants. Similar observations have been reported by Turner et al., (2001) and Shaw and Jones (2003), who emphasized the importance of sugars in enhancing vitrification efficiency and protecting embryonic cells from cryoinjury.
       
The low hatching rate observed in Group III indicates that the combination of DMSO and EG alone was insufficient to provide adequate cryoprotection under the conditions used in the present experiment. Although both DMSO and EG are highly permeating cryoprotectants, their effectiveness depends on achieving a balance between protective action and cytotoxic effects. Exposure to high concentrations may induce osmotic stress and chemical toxicity, ultimately compromising embryo viability after warming.
 
Temporal pattern of hatching following warming
 
Out of the 77 BLs evaluated, total 17 BLs successfully hatched during the culture period. No hatching was observed during the first 2 h following warming. Only one BL hatched by 12 h (1.30%), whereas hatching increased to 9.09% after 24 h and reached a maximum of 11.69% after 48 h of culture (Table 3).

Table 3: Number of hatching blastocysts at different time interval (Group I-IV).


       
In comparison to our results, Varago et al. (2018), Manjunatha (2006) and Souza et al., (2018) found a lower hatching rate. Moreover, higher hatching rates of 68.2% (Saha et al., 2013), 52.5% (Oliveira et al., 2020), 78.4± 2.0% (Rodero et al., 2021), Morula 91%, Early BL 80%, BL 75% (Hufana-Duran et al., 2004), 84.4% (Xu et al., 2006) and 90.2% (Do et al., 2019) have been reported by different workers using different vitrification techniques.
       
This temporal pattern suggests that vitrified-warmed embryos require a recovery period before resuming active development. During this period, embryos re-establish osmotic equilibrium, repair cellular damage, re-expand the blastocoel cavity and restore metabolic activity. The greater proportion of hatched embryos observed at 48 h indicates that post-warming developmental assessment should be conducted for at least 48 h to obtain a realistic estimate of embryo viability.
       
Similar observations have been reported in previous cryopreservation studies (Prajapati et al., 2026; Patel et al., 2026) where embryo development gradually resumed during the first 24-48 h after warming. The delayed hatching phenomenon likely reflects the physiological recovery process following cryogenic stress and is commonly observed in vitrified embryos.
       
Additionally, Vitrification outcomes are influenced by the type, concentration and combination of cryoprotectants used. Srilatha et al. (2025) found a higher cleavage rate in a combination of cryoprotectants in case of mature oocyte vitrification, indicating the benefit of using cryoprotectants in combination rather than a single agent. Similarly, in our study, we used different cryoprotectant combinations (Group III and Group IV) for evaluation of post-warming hatching of in vitro buffalo embryos at the blastocyst stage. However, the findings of Srilatha et al. (2025) relate to cleavage rate after oocyte vitrification-warming and therefore provide supporting background for the use and selection of suitable combinations of cryoprotectants for embryo vitrification.
       
A limitation of the present study was the relatively small number of blastocysts available for vitrification, particularly in Group IV. Further studies involving larger sample sizes and pregnancy outcomes following embryo transfer are required.
       
Overall, the findings indicate that although vitrification remains an effective method for embryo cryopreservation, the selection of an appropriate cryoprotectant system is critical for maximizing embryo survival. The superior performance of the commercial vitrification kit and the beneficial influence of sucrose supplementation highlight the importance of optimizing both intracellular and extracellular cryoprotectants to improve post-warming developmental competence of in vitro-produced buffalo embryos.
Overall, our study observed that vitrification significantly affected the developmental competence of in vitro produced blastocysts. Fresh embryos showed the highest hatching rate, while among the vitrified groups, the commercial vitrification kit (Vitrogen) yielded better post-warming hatching than the laboratory-prepared cryoprotectant solutions. The addition of 1.0 M sucrose to the DMSO+EG vitrification medium improved embryo hatching, indicating its beneficial role in cryosurvival. These findings suggest that vitrification protocol and cryoprotectant combinations have a major role in successful embryo cryopreservation and warrant further optimization in the protocol to improve in vitro produced embryo survival.
This research article is part of the M.V.Sc. thesis of Ruchir D. Pranami. The authors are thankful to the Department of Animal Reproduction, Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Kamdhenu University, Junagadh, Gujarat, India, in collaboration with Gujarat Biotechnology Research Centre, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India.
 
Disclaimers
 
The views and conclusions expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of their affiliated institutions. The authors are responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided, but do not accept any liability for any direct or indirect losses resulting from the use of this content.
The authors declare no conflict of interest in the conduct of this experiment.
 
Compliance with ethical standards
 
Institutional Animal Ethics Committee (IAEC) approval was not required, as the study utilized slaughterhouse-derived buffalo ovaries collected post-mortem from a registered abattoir and no live animal experimentation was involved.

  1. Das, G.K., Jain, G.C., Solanki, V.S. and Tripathi, V.N. (1996). Efficacy of various collection methods for oocyte retrieval in buffalo. Theriogenology. 46: 1403-1411.

  2. Do, V.H., Catt, S., Kinder, J.E., Walton, S. and Taylor-Robinson, A.W. (2019). Vitrification of in vitro-derived bovine embryos: Targeting enhancement of quality by refining technology and standardizing procedures. Reproduction, Fertility and Development. 31: 837-846.

  3. Do, V.H., Walton, S. and Taylor-Robinson, A.W. (2014). Benefits and constraints of vitrification technologies for cryopreservation of bovine in vitro fertilized embryos. Journal of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry. 1: 1-5.

  4. Dua, D., Alam, A., Chauhan, M.S., Palta, P. and Singh, M.K. (2021). Effect of vitrification on folliculogenesis-related genes in ovarian follicles of Bubalus bubalis. Indian Journal of  Animal Research. 55(8): 873-878. doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-4245.

  5. Hufana-Duran, D., Pedro, P.B., Venturina, H.V., Hufana, R.D., Salazar, A.L., Duran, P.G. and Cruz, L.C. (2004). Post- warming hatching and birth of live calves following transfer of in vitro-derived vitrified water buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) embryos. Theriogenology. 61: 1429-1439.

  6. Lahnsteiner, F. (2008). The effect of internal and external cryoprotectants on zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos. Theriogenology. 69: 384-396.

  7. Lai, D., Ding, J., Smith, G.W., Smith, G.D. and Takayama, S. (2015). Slow and steady cell shrinkage reduces osmotic stress in bovine and murine oocyte and zygote vitrification. Human Reproduction. 30: 37-45.

  8. Mahmoud, K. and El-Sokary, M.M. (2013). Improvement of the efficacy of buffalo oocytes vitrification. Global Veterinarian. 11: 420-431.

  9. Manjunatha, B.M. (2006). Studies on in vitro production and cryopreservation of buffalo embryos. Doctoral Dissertation, Karnataka Veterinary, Animal and Fisheries Sciences University, Bidar, India.

  10. Oliveira, C.S., da Silva Feuchard, V.L., de Freitas, C., da Silva Rosa, P.M., dos Reis Camargo, A.J. and Saraiva, N.Z. (2020). In-straw warming protocol improves survival of vitrified embryos and allows direct transfer in cattle. Cryobiology. 97: 222-225.

  11. Parnpai, R., Liang, Y., Ketudat-Cairns, M., Somfai, T. and Nagai, T. (2016). Vitrification of buffalo oocytes and embryos. Theriogenology. 86: 214-220.

  12. Patel, R., Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Mansuri, MM, Suthar, B.N., Jhala, D., Samova, S., Joshi, M., Joshi, C.G. and Nakhashi, H.C. (2024) Assessing factors influencing in vitro maturation and success of vitrification in buffalo oocytes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 9: 615-621.

  13. Patel, R., Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Suthar, B.N., Jhala, D., Joshi, M., Joshi, C.G. and Nakhashi, H.C. (2026). Assessment of morphological integrity and in vitro developmental competence of vitrified buffalo oocytes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 10: 24-32.

  14. Pedro, P.B., Yokoyama, E., Zhu, S.E., Yoshida, N., Valdez Jr, D.M., Tanaka, M. and Kasai, M. (2005). Permeability of mouse oocytes and embryos at various developmental stages to five cryoprotectants. Journal of Reproduction and Development. 51: 235-246.

  15. Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Patel, R., Mansuri, M.M., Sharma, A., Jhala, D. and Joshi, C.G. (2024). Assessing the cleavage, blastocyst and hatching rate of buffalo origin cumulus oocyte complexes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 9: 872-876.

  16. Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Patel, R., Mansuri, M.M., Sharma, A., Jhala, D., Samova, M., Joshi,  M. and Joshi, C.G.C. (2026). Evaluation of slow freezing and vitrification methods of cryopreservation in in vitro produced buffalo embryos. Journal of Advances in Biology and Biotechnology. 29: 872-886.

  17. Pranami R.D., Vala, K.B. and Suthar V.S. (2026). Evaluation of different vitrification methods and cryoprotectants on viability of in vitro matured buffalo oocytes. Indian Journal of Veterinary Science and Biotechnology (Accepted). 

  18. Rodero, M.I., García-Martinez, T., Ordonez-Leon, E.A., Vendrell- Flotats, M., Olegario Hidalgo, C., Esmoris, J. and Mogas, T. (2021). A shorter equilibration period improves post- warming outcomes after vitrification and in straw dilution of in vitro-produced bovine embryos. Biology. 10: 142.

  19. Saha, A., Panda, S.K., Chauhan, M.S., Manik, R.S., Palta, P. and Singla, S.K. (2013). Birth of cloned calves from vitrified- warmed zona-free buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) embryos produced by hand-made cloning. Reproduction, Fertility and Development. 25: 860-865.

  20. Shaw, J. M. and Jones, G.M. (2003). Terminology associated with vitrification and other cryopreservation procedures for oocytes and embryos. Human Reproduction Update. 9: 583-605.

  21. Souza, J.F., Oliveira, C.M., Lienou, L.L., Cavalcante, T.V., Alexandrino, E., Santos, R.R. and Dias, F.E.F. (2018). Vitrification of bovine embryos followed by in vitro hatching and expansion. Zygote. 26: 99-103.

  22. Srilatha, B., Reddy, K.R., Velmurugan, S., Kumari, N.N. and Raghunandhan, T. (2025). Effect of vitrification on mature buffalo oocytes and their fertilization rates using different concentrations of cryoprotectants. Indian Journal of Animal Research. doi: 10.18805/IJAR.B-5175.

  23. Suthar, V.S. and Shah, R.G. (2009). Bovine in vitro embryo production: An overview. Veterinary World. 2: 478-479.

  24. Syafruddin, S., Siregar, T. N., Azrina, A., Armansyah, T., Panjaitan, B., Aliza, D., Sutriana, A., Zuhrawati, Z., Rosmaidar, R. and Roslizawaty, R. (2018). Histological description of Aceh cattle ovary cryopreserved by various cryoprotectants.  Indian Journal of Animal Research. 52(8): 1223-1226.  doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-688.

  25. Turner, S., Senaratna, T., Touchell, D., Bunn, E., Dixon, K. and Tan, B. (2001). Stereochemical arrangement of hydroxyl groups in sugar and polyalcohol molecules as an important factor in effective cryopreservation. Plant Science. 160: 489-497.

  26. Vajta, G., Holm, P., Kuwayama, M., Booth, P.J., Jacobsen, H., Greve, T. and Callesen, H. (1998). Open pulled straw (OPS) vitrification: A new way to reduce cryoinjuries of bovine ova and embryos. Molecular Reproduction and Development: Incorporating Gamete Research. 51: 53-58.

  27. Varago, F.C., Saliba, W.P., Alvim, M.T.T., Vasconcelos, A.B., Oliveira, C.H., Stahlberg, R. and Lagares, M.A. (2018). Vitrification of in vitro produced Zebu embryos. Animal Reproduction. 3: 353-358.

  28. Wani, N.A. (2002). In vitro maturation and in vitro fertilization of sheep oocytes. Small Ruminant Research. 44: 89-95.

  29. Xu, J., Guo, Z., Su, L., Nedambale, T.L., Zhang, J., Schenk, J. and Du, F. (2006). Developmental potential of vitrified Holstein cattle embryos fertilized in vitro with sex-sorted sperm. Journal of Dairy Science. 89: 2510-2518.

Effect of Different Vitrification Protocols of Post-warming Hatching of in vitro Produced Buffalo Embryos

R
Ruchir D. Pranami1,*
V
Vishal S. Suthar2
K
Karshan B. Vala3
S
Suryakant S. Parikh3
D
Devshi N. Borkhatariya3
K
Kirankumar H. Parmar4
1Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, M. B. Veterinary College, Dungarpur-314 011, Rajasthan, India.
2Gujarat Biotechnology University, Gandhinagar-382 355, Gujarat, India.
3Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Junagadh-362 001, Gujarat, India.
4Department of Veterinary Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Anand-388 001, Gujarat, India.

Background: The present study compared the commercial vitrification method with laboratory-prepared vitrification solutions on the post-warming hatching of in vitro produced (IVP) blastocysts.

Methods: A total of 77 IVP blastocysts were randomly allocated into four groups: Group I (fresh, non-vitrified control; n = 22), Group II (commercial vitrification kit, Vitrogen, Brazil; n = 20), Group III (25% dimethyl sulfoxide [DMSO] + 25% ethylene glycol [EG]; n = 22) and Group IV (25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M sucrose; n = 13). Embryos of Group II were vitrified using a commercially available vitrification kit, while Groups III and IV were vitrified using a two-step equilibration protocol. Following devitrification, embryos were cultured at 38.5oC under a benchtop incubator (Cooper Surgical, USA; 90% N2, 5% O2 and 5% CO2).

Result: Post-warming developmental competence was evaluated by observing blastocyst hatching at 2, 12, 24 and 48 h of culture. The highest hatching rate was observed in the fresh control group (40.91%), followed by the commercial vitrification group (25.00%), the DMSO + EG + sucrose group (15.38%) and the DMSO + EG group (4.55%). Overall, 17 of 77 blastocysts hatched during post-warming culture, with the highest proportion of hatching occurring after 48 h (11.69%), followed by 24 h (9.09%),12 h (1.30%) and 2 h (0.00%). The commercial vitrification kit showed a better post-warming hatching rate, while addition of sucrose improved the cryosurvival of BLs in DMSO and EG-based vitrification medium.

The cryopreservation of mammalian embryos has become an integral part of methods to control animal reproduction. Cryopreservation is of practical importance for the development of reproductive technologies such as nuclear transfer, cryo-banking of animal species and the routine or commercial application of breed improvement, such as embryo transfer (Wani, 2002; Suthar and Shah, 2009). Several cryopreservation methods, such as conventional (slow), equilibrium rapid freezing (vitrification) and ultra-rapid freezing have been used to preserve embryos and oocytes of many animal species, resulting in the birth of live offspring.
       
Vitrification is a popular method of cryopreservation of embryos and oocytes. This process has mainly three phases: i) dehydration, replacing the liquid with cryoprotectant liquid through diffusion into the cell; ii) cooling, the phase where embryos and liquid form solid glass in liquid nitrogen; warming, a phase of turning back into liquid form; and iii) rehydration, a process of water returning into the cell and replacing cryoprotectants (Syafruddin et al., 2018). According to Parnpai et al., (2016), vitrification is the solidification of a solution brought about not by crystallization but by extreme elevation in viscosity during cooling. It is a common method for cryopreservation of gametes and embryos. Although successful oocyte vitrification has been achieved in several animal species, subsequent progress is still limited, especially in buffalo (Mahmoud and El-Sokary, 2013).
       
Many compounds act as cryoprotectants and are used for the protection of cells against freezing. There are two types of cryoprotectants: (a) membrane-permeating, which can freely diffuse through the membrane, such as glycerol (G), ethylene glycol (EG) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO); (b) non-membrane-permeating, which cannot permeate the cell membrane, such as sugars (Pedro et al., 2005). With promising results already obtained with embryo vitrification, various protocols have been proposed for optimization of cell survival. Various devices have been developed to reduce the volume of vitrification solutions and speed up the process. Among these, the open pulled straw (OPS) method (Vajta et al., 1998) is the most widely used technique for bovine embryos (Do et al., 2014). Recently, VitriFit device has been used for vitrification of COCs and Embryos (Patel et al., 2024; 2026; Prajapati et al., 2024; 2026). In addition, the cryoprotectant solution usually contains two intracellular cryoprotectants, e.g. ethylene glycol (EG) and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), to make an effective composition to penetrate cells and tissues having lower toxicity than other cryoprotectants such as glycerol or propylene glycol.
       
When cells are exposed to high concentrations of cryoprotectants, the risk of cryodamage caused by large ice crystals is almost null, but osmotic shock can frequently occur (Lai et al., 2015). To avoid this effect, extracellular cryoprotectants, usually sugars, are added to the vitrification solution. These sugars support embryo dehydration by stabilizing the cell plasma membrane (Turner et al., 2001). Another function of the use of sugars in vitrification solutions is to increase glassy state formation, thereby reducing the formation of ice crystals during the vitrification-warming processes (Shaw and Jones, 2003). Sucrose is the most used sugar for embryo vitrification (Lai et al., 2015), but there is very little information available for the use of other sugars, like glucose, in the vitrification of bovine embryos. Glucose has been tested for vitrification of zebrafish embryos (Lahnsteiner, 2008). Therefore, the present study was undertaken to compare a commercial vitrification kit with laboratory-prepared vitrification solutions containing DMSO and EG, with or without sucrose and to evaluate their effects on post-warming hatching of in vitro produced buffalo blastocysts. However, vitrification may affect the structural and functional integrity of reproductive cells and tissues (Dua et al., 2021).
In vitro embryo production (IVEP)
 
The work was carried out at Gujarat Biotechnology Research Centre, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India, during February 2024 to December 2024. Buffalo ovaries were collected from a slaughterhouse of the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation (AMC), Ahmedabad and were transported to the laboratory under warm sterile conditions. Cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) were recovered by follicular aspiration. The detailed methodology is described somewhere else (Pranami et al., 2026). In brief, the recovered COCs were morphologically graded using the protocol followed by Das et al., (1996) and only Grade I-III oocytes were selected for in vitro maturation (IVM). Matured oocytes were subsequently fertilized in vitro using frozen-thawed buffalo bull semen processed by the semen preparation protocol. Following in vitro fertilization, presumptive zygotes were denuded and cultured in pre-equilibrated embryo culture medium in a benchtop incubator under controlled environment (38.5oC, 5% CO2, 5% O2 and 90% N2). Cleavage was assessed at 72 h of fertilization and embryos were cultured until Day 6, then blastocysts (BLs) were selected for the subsequent vitrification procedure. All in vitro embryo production procedures, including IVM, IVF and IVC, were performed according to the manufacturer’s protocol of the IVF Bioscience BO-IVM™, BO-IVF™ and BO-IVC™ media system (IVF Bioscience, UK).
 
Distribution of In vitro produced embryos in different groups
 
In group I, fresh in vitro produced embryos at BL stage were selected for Group I and three other different vitrification groups as described below. Randomly allotted BLs were cultured for evaluation for expansion and hatching.
       
In group II, BLs were vitrified using a vitrification kit (Vitrogen, Brazil) at room temperature, 25oC, as directed in the manufacturer’s guidelines. After the procedure, BLs were loaded immediately in a vitrification device (VitriFit, ref. 42802001A, Cooper Surgical) and extra media were removed using the micropipette on the tip of the device. The device was then plunged immediately into LN2 and closed with a precooled lid. Subsequently, the device was transferred into a pencil goblet in canisters of the LN2 tank for storage till devitrification.
       
In group III, BLs were vitrified using 25% DMSO and 25% EG. BLs of this experimental group were placed in a 50 μl droplet of DMEM (Dulbecco’s modified eagle medium) supplemented with 10% FBS (Fetal Bovine Serum; Basic medium). All embryos were manipulated at 38.5oC and were exposed in a two-step process to an 800 μl vitrification solution. Embryos were first incubated in 15% DMSO + 15% EG dissolved in a basic medium for 1 min (Step 1) and then transferred into a 20 μl droplet of 25% DMSO+25% EG dissolved in a basic medium for 4 min (Step 2), following the protocol of Souza et al., (2018).
       
In group IV, BLs were vitrified using 25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M Sucrose. All cryoprotectants used during the preparation of the solutions were purchased from Sigma. BLs of this experimental group were placed in a 50 μl droplet of DMEM supplemented with 10% FBS (Basic medium). All embryos were manipulated at 38.5oC and were exposed in a two-step process to an 800 μl vitrification solution. Embryos were first incubated in 15% DMSO + 15% EG+ 1.0 M Sucrose dissolved in a basic medium for 1 min (Step 1) and then transferred into a 20 μl droplet of 25% DMSO+25% EG+ 1.0 M Sucrose dissolved in a basic medium for 4 min (Step 2), following the protocol of Souza et al., (2018).
       
In Group I, as it is a fresh group, no devitrification process was performed. For Group II, devitrification of vitrified BLs were performed using de-vitrification media (D1, D2 and D3; Vitrogen, Brazil) as per the manufacturer’s guidelines. The vitrified device was opened within LN2 and immediately kept in the devitrification media. The BLs were recovered by observing under a stereo zoom microscope and kept for 1 min. Subsequently, the BLs were again transferred using a micropipette (10 μl) in devitrification media.
       
For group III and IV, devitrification of BLs were performed in Basic medium + 0.4 M sucrose for 1 min for removal of cryoprotectant, followed by Basic medium + 0.4 M sucrose for 5 min, 0.2 M sucrose for 5 min and Basic Medium only for 5 min.
       
Post devitrification, the BLs were incubated at 38.5oC, in a 90% N2, 5% O2 and 5% CO2 in an incubator in an IVC medium and hatching rates were determined after 2 h, 12 h, 24 h and 48 h.
 
Statistical analysis
 
All observations were recorded in an Excel sheet (MS Office 2016) and analyzed using SPSS 26.0 software (IBM SPSS software Bengaluru, India). The descriptive analysis was performed using a descriptive function in the analysis drop-down menu of SPSS software. Differences among groups were analyzed using Chi-square test. Data were expressed as percentages and frequencies. The values were considered significant when “p≤0.05”.
Vitrification of in vitro produced embryos
 
A total of 77 (5.5±0.6/Session) buffalo BLs in vitro produced were utilized in the present investigation. The representative images of the BLs produced during the experiment are documented in Fig 1. Among them, 22 (28.57%), 20 (25.97%), 22 (28.57%) and 13 (16.88%) blastocysts were allocated to Group I (fresh control), Group II (commercial vitrification kit; Vitrogen), Group III (25% DMSO + 25% EG) and Group IV (25% DMSO + 25% EG + 1.0 M sucrose), respectively (Table 1).

Fig 1: Different buffalo blastocyst stages on day 6 of in vitro culture and used for different vitrification treatments.



Table 1: Session wise In vitro produced blastocysts and random distribution in four vitrification groups.


       
The developmental competence of BLs following vitrification-warming was assessed based on their ability to hatch during post-warming culture. Hatching is considered one of the most reliable indicators of embryo viability because it reflects the capacity of the BLs to re-expand, resume metabolic activity and continue normal development after cryopreservation stress.
       
The results demonstrated a significant effect of vitrification treatment on BLs hatching rate (χ2 test, P = 0.004). Fresh, non-vitrified BLs (Group I) showed the highest hatching rate (40.91%), which was significantly greater than all vitrified groups. Representative images of fresh and vitrified-warmed BLs showing re-expansion and hatching are presented in Fig 2. Among the vitrified embryos, the highest hatching rate was observed in Group II (Vitrogen; 25.00%), followed by Group IV (DMSO + EG + sucrose; 15.38%) and Group III (DMSO + EG; 4.55%) (Table 2; Fig 2).

Table 2: Session wise vitrified, devitrified and hatching Bls of different groups (Group I-IV).



Fig 2: Representative images of post-devitrification expansion of BLs in three different vitrification treatments for Buffalo BLs.


       
The superior performance of fresh BLs were expected since these embryos were not exposed to the osmotic and chemical stresses associated with cryopreservation. Vitrification subjects BLs to rapid changes in temperature, dehydration and high concentrations of cryoprotectants, all of which can induce cellular injury, cytoskeletal disruption, membrane damage and oxidative stress, thereby reducing subsequent developmental competence. These results are in accordance with our previous results (Prajapati et al., 2026).  The hatching rates obtained in the present study were higher than those reported by Manjunatha (2006), Varago et al., (2018) and Souza et al., (2018), who observed comparatively lower post-warming embryo development following vitrification. These differences may be attributed to variations in BLs quality, species or breed differences, vitrification devices, cryoprotectant composition, equilibration duration, warming protocols and culture conditions.
       
In contrast to our study, several researchers have reported substantially higher hatching rates following embryo vitrification. Hufana-Duran et al. (2004) recorded hatching rates ranging from 75-91% in buffalo embryos, while Saha et al., (2013), Xu et al., (2006), Oliveira et al., (2020), Rodero et al., (2021) and Do et al., (2019) has reported hatching rates between approximately 52% and 90%.
       
The lower hatching rates observed in the present study may be associated with the inherent cryosensitivity of in vitro-produced buffalo BLs. Buffalo embryos generally contain relatively high intracellular lipid content, which increases susceptibility to chilling injury and cryodamage during vitrification. In addition, differences in embryo developmental stage, blastocyst quality, cryoprotectant exposure time and operator handling could have contributed to the reduced post-warming developmental competence recorded herein.
       
Among vitrified treatments, embryos cryopreserved using the commercial Vitrogen kit exhibited better post-warming survival than those vitrified using laboratory-prepared cryoprotectant solutions. The improved outcome may be attributed to the optimized composition of the commercial vitrification media, which are specifically formulated to balance cryoprotectant permeability, osmotic regulation and toxicity. Commercial protocols often include proprietary additives that enhance membrane stabilization and reduce cryoinjury during both cooling and warming phases.
       
A notable finding of the present study was the beneficial effect of sucrose supplementation. Addition of 1.0 M sucrose to the DMSO + EG vitrification solution improved hatching rate from 4.55% (Group III) to 15.38% (Group IV). Although the hatching rate remained lower than that obtained with the commercial kit, the improvement suggests a positive role of sucrose in embryo cryosurvival. Sucrose acts as a non-permeating cryoprotectant that promotes cellular dehydration before vitrification, thereby minimizing intracellular ice crystal formation. Furthermore, sucrose contributes to osmotic buffering during warming and supports stabilization of the plasma membrane. These functions help reduce osmotic shock and structural damage associated with exposure to concentrated intracellular cryoprotectants. Similar observations have been reported by Turner et al., (2001) and Shaw and Jones (2003), who emphasized the importance of sugars in enhancing vitrification efficiency and protecting embryonic cells from cryoinjury.
       
The low hatching rate observed in Group III indicates that the combination of DMSO and EG alone was insufficient to provide adequate cryoprotection under the conditions used in the present experiment. Although both DMSO and EG are highly permeating cryoprotectants, their effectiveness depends on achieving a balance between protective action and cytotoxic effects. Exposure to high concentrations may induce osmotic stress and chemical toxicity, ultimately compromising embryo viability after warming.
 
Temporal pattern of hatching following warming
 
Out of the 77 BLs evaluated, total 17 BLs successfully hatched during the culture period. No hatching was observed during the first 2 h following warming. Only one BL hatched by 12 h (1.30%), whereas hatching increased to 9.09% after 24 h and reached a maximum of 11.69% after 48 h of culture (Table 3).

Table 3: Number of hatching blastocysts at different time interval (Group I-IV).


       
In comparison to our results, Varago et al. (2018), Manjunatha (2006) and Souza et al., (2018) found a lower hatching rate. Moreover, higher hatching rates of 68.2% (Saha et al., 2013), 52.5% (Oliveira et al., 2020), 78.4± 2.0% (Rodero et al., 2021), Morula 91%, Early BL 80%, BL 75% (Hufana-Duran et al., 2004), 84.4% (Xu et al., 2006) and 90.2% (Do et al., 2019) have been reported by different workers using different vitrification techniques.
       
This temporal pattern suggests that vitrified-warmed embryos require a recovery period before resuming active development. During this period, embryos re-establish osmotic equilibrium, repair cellular damage, re-expand the blastocoel cavity and restore metabolic activity. The greater proportion of hatched embryos observed at 48 h indicates that post-warming developmental assessment should be conducted for at least 48 h to obtain a realistic estimate of embryo viability.
       
Similar observations have been reported in previous cryopreservation studies (Prajapati et al., 2026; Patel et al., 2026) where embryo development gradually resumed during the first 24-48 h after warming. The delayed hatching phenomenon likely reflects the physiological recovery process following cryogenic stress and is commonly observed in vitrified embryos.
       
Additionally, Vitrification outcomes are influenced by the type, concentration and combination of cryoprotectants used. Srilatha et al. (2025) found a higher cleavage rate in a combination of cryoprotectants in case of mature oocyte vitrification, indicating the benefit of using cryoprotectants in combination rather than a single agent. Similarly, in our study, we used different cryoprotectant combinations (Group III and Group IV) for evaluation of post-warming hatching of in vitro buffalo embryos at the blastocyst stage. However, the findings of Srilatha et al. (2025) relate to cleavage rate after oocyte vitrification-warming and therefore provide supporting background for the use and selection of suitable combinations of cryoprotectants for embryo vitrification.
       
A limitation of the present study was the relatively small number of blastocysts available for vitrification, particularly in Group IV. Further studies involving larger sample sizes and pregnancy outcomes following embryo transfer are required.
       
Overall, the findings indicate that although vitrification remains an effective method for embryo cryopreservation, the selection of an appropriate cryoprotectant system is critical for maximizing embryo survival. The superior performance of the commercial vitrification kit and the beneficial influence of sucrose supplementation highlight the importance of optimizing both intracellular and extracellular cryoprotectants to improve post-warming developmental competence of in vitro-produced buffalo embryos.
Overall, our study observed that vitrification significantly affected the developmental competence of in vitro produced blastocysts. Fresh embryos showed the highest hatching rate, while among the vitrified groups, the commercial vitrification kit (Vitrogen) yielded better post-warming hatching than the laboratory-prepared cryoprotectant solutions. The addition of 1.0 M sucrose to the DMSO+EG vitrification medium improved embryo hatching, indicating its beneficial role in cryosurvival. These findings suggest that vitrification protocol and cryoprotectant combinations have a major role in successful embryo cryopreservation and warrant further optimization in the protocol to improve in vitro produced embryo survival.
This research article is part of the M.V.Sc. thesis of Ruchir D. Pranami. The authors are thankful to the Department of Animal Reproduction, Gynaecology and Obstetrics, College of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry, Kamdhenu University, Junagadh, Gujarat, India, in collaboration with Gujarat Biotechnology Research Centre, Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India.
 
Disclaimers
 
The views and conclusions expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of their affiliated institutions. The authors are responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided, but do not accept any liability for any direct or indirect losses resulting from the use of this content.
The authors declare no conflict of interest in the conduct of this experiment.
 
Compliance with ethical standards
 
Institutional Animal Ethics Committee (IAEC) approval was not required, as the study utilized slaughterhouse-derived buffalo ovaries collected post-mortem from a registered abattoir and no live animal experimentation was involved.

  1. Das, G.K., Jain, G.C., Solanki, V.S. and Tripathi, V.N. (1996). Efficacy of various collection methods for oocyte retrieval in buffalo. Theriogenology. 46: 1403-1411.

  2. Do, V.H., Catt, S., Kinder, J.E., Walton, S. and Taylor-Robinson, A.W. (2019). Vitrification of in vitro-derived bovine embryos: Targeting enhancement of quality by refining technology and standardizing procedures. Reproduction, Fertility and Development. 31: 837-846.

  3. Do, V.H., Walton, S. and Taylor-Robinson, A.W. (2014). Benefits and constraints of vitrification technologies for cryopreservation of bovine in vitro fertilized embryos. Journal of Veterinary Science and Animal Husbandry. 1: 1-5.

  4. Dua, D., Alam, A., Chauhan, M.S., Palta, P. and Singh, M.K. (2021). Effect of vitrification on folliculogenesis-related genes in ovarian follicles of Bubalus bubalis. Indian Journal of  Animal Research. 55(8): 873-878. doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-4245.

  5. Hufana-Duran, D., Pedro, P.B., Venturina, H.V., Hufana, R.D., Salazar, A.L., Duran, P.G. and Cruz, L.C. (2004). Post- warming hatching and birth of live calves following transfer of in vitro-derived vitrified water buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) embryos. Theriogenology. 61: 1429-1439.

  6. Lahnsteiner, F. (2008). The effect of internal and external cryoprotectants on zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos. Theriogenology. 69: 384-396.

  7. Lai, D., Ding, J., Smith, G.W., Smith, G.D. and Takayama, S. (2015). Slow and steady cell shrinkage reduces osmotic stress in bovine and murine oocyte and zygote vitrification. Human Reproduction. 30: 37-45.

  8. Mahmoud, K. and El-Sokary, M.M. (2013). Improvement of the efficacy of buffalo oocytes vitrification. Global Veterinarian. 11: 420-431.

  9. Manjunatha, B.M. (2006). Studies on in vitro production and cryopreservation of buffalo embryos. Doctoral Dissertation, Karnataka Veterinary, Animal and Fisheries Sciences University, Bidar, India.

  10. Oliveira, C.S., da Silva Feuchard, V.L., de Freitas, C., da Silva Rosa, P.M., dos Reis Camargo, A.J. and Saraiva, N.Z. (2020). In-straw warming protocol improves survival of vitrified embryos and allows direct transfer in cattle. Cryobiology. 97: 222-225.

  11. Parnpai, R., Liang, Y., Ketudat-Cairns, M., Somfai, T. and Nagai, T. (2016). Vitrification of buffalo oocytes and embryos. Theriogenology. 86: 214-220.

  12. Patel, R., Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Mansuri, MM, Suthar, B.N., Jhala, D., Samova, S., Joshi, M., Joshi, C.G. and Nakhashi, H.C. (2024) Assessing factors influencing in vitro maturation and success of vitrification in buffalo oocytes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 9: 615-621.

  13. Patel, R., Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Suthar, B.N., Jhala, D., Joshi, M., Joshi, C.G. and Nakhashi, H.C. (2026). Assessment of morphological integrity and in vitro developmental competence of vitrified buffalo oocytes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 10: 24-32.

  14. Pedro, P.B., Yokoyama, E., Zhu, S.E., Yoshida, N., Valdez Jr, D.M., Tanaka, M. and Kasai, M. (2005). Permeability of mouse oocytes and embryos at various developmental stages to five cryoprotectants. Journal of Reproduction and Development. 51: 235-246.

  15. Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Patel, R., Mansuri, M.M., Sharma, A., Jhala, D. and Joshi, C.G. (2024). Assessing the cleavage, blastocyst and hatching rate of buffalo origin cumulus oocyte complexes. International Journal of Veterinary Sciences and Animal Husbandry. 9: 872-876.

  16. Prajapati, J., Suthar, V.S., Patel, R., Mansuri, M.M., Sharma, A., Jhala, D., Samova, M., Joshi,  M. and Joshi, C.G.C. (2026). Evaluation of slow freezing and vitrification methods of cryopreservation in in vitro produced buffalo embryos. Journal of Advances in Biology and Biotechnology. 29: 872-886.

  17. Pranami R.D., Vala, K.B. and Suthar V.S. (2026). Evaluation of different vitrification methods and cryoprotectants on viability of in vitro matured buffalo oocytes. Indian Journal of Veterinary Science and Biotechnology (Accepted). 

  18. Rodero, M.I., García-Martinez, T., Ordonez-Leon, E.A., Vendrell- Flotats, M., Olegario Hidalgo, C., Esmoris, J. and Mogas, T. (2021). A shorter equilibration period improves post- warming outcomes after vitrification and in straw dilution of in vitro-produced bovine embryos. Biology. 10: 142.

  19. Saha, A., Panda, S.K., Chauhan, M.S., Manik, R.S., Palta, P. and Singla, S.K. (2013). Birth of cloned calves from vitrified- warmed zona-free buffalo (Bubalus bubalis) embryos produced by hand-made cloning. Reproduction, Fertility and Development. 25: 860-865.

  20. Shaw, J. M. and Jones, G.M. (2003). Terminology associated with vitrification and other cryopreservation procedures for oocytes and embryos. Human Reproduction Update. 9: 583-605.

  21. Souza, J.F., Oliveira, C.M., Lienou, L.L., Cavalcante, T.V., Alexandrino, E., Santos, R.R. and Dias, F.E.F. (2018). Vitrification of bovine embryos followed by in vitro hatching and expansion. Zygote. 26: 99-103.

  22. Srilatha, B., Reddy, K.R., Velmurugan, S., Kumari, N.N. and Raghunandhan, T. (2025). Effect of vitrification on mature buffalo oocytes and their fertilization rates using different concentrations of cryoprotectants. Indian Journal of Animal Research. doi: 10.18805/IJAR.B-5175.

  23. Suthar, V.S. and Shah, R.G. (2009). Bovine in vitro embryo production: An overview. Veterinary World. 2: 478-479.

  24. Syafruddin, S., Siregar, T. N., Azrina, A., Armansyah, T., Panjaitan, B., Aliza, D., Sutriana, A., Zuhrawati, Z., Rosmaidar, R. and Roslizawaty, R. (2018). Histological description of Aceh cattle ovary cryopreserved by various cryoprotectants.  Indian Journal of Animal Research. 52(8): 1223-1226.  doi: 10.18805/ijar.B-688.

  25. Turner, S., Senaratna, T., Touchell, D., Bunn, E., Dixon, K. and Tan, B. (2001). Stereochemical arrangement of hydroxyl groups in sugar and polyalcohol molecules as an important factor in effective cryopreservation. Plant Science. 160: 489-497.

  26. Vajta, G., Holm, P., Kuwayama, M., Booth, P.J., Jacobsen, H., Greve, T. and Callesen, H. (1998). Open pulled straw (OPS) vitrification: A new way to reduce cryoinjuries of bovine ova and embryos. Molecular Reproduction and Development: Incorporating Gamete Research. 51: 53-58.

  27. Varago, F.C., Saliba, W.P., Alvim, M.T.T., Vasconcelos, A.B., Oliveira, C.H., Stahlberg, R. and Lagares, M.A. (2018). Vitrification of in vitro produced Zebu embryos. Animal Reproduction. 3: 353-358.

  28. Wani, N.A. (2002). In vitro maturation and in vitro fertilization of sheep oocytes. Small Ruminant Research. 44: 89-95.

  29. Xu, J., Guo, Z., Su, L., Nedambale, T.L., Zhang, J., Schenk, J. and Du, F. (2006). Developmental potential of vitrified Holstein cattle embryos fertilized in vitro with sex-sorted sperm. Journal of Dairy Science. 89: 2510-2518.
In this Article
Published In
Indian Journal of Animal Research

Editorial Board

View all (0)