Initial physicochemical properties and their implications
The initial characteristics of the eight substrates are presented in Table 1. Moisture content ranged from 4.62 per cent (rice husk, RH) to 7.86 per cent (rice straw and cow dung mixture, RSt+CD). Ash content varied significantly (p<0.05), with the highest value (23.49±4.08 per cent) in RSt+CD and the lowest (17.11±3.15 per cent) in RH+chicken waste (CW). The pH ranged from 6.79 (RH) to 8.48, with all other substrates being alkaline. The highest Total Organic Carbon (TOC, 47.19±10.07 per cent) was recorded in RSt+CD, while the highest Total Nitrogen (TN, 1.47±0.06 per cent) was found in RSt. The lowest TN was in RH. The highest concentrations of Total Potassium (TK, 1.59±0.07 per cent), Total Phosphorus (TP, 0.43±0.03 per cent) and Magnesium (Mg, 0.79±0.06 per cent) were all measured in the RSt+CW mixture. This significant variation in initial properties can be attributed to the distinct biochemical compositions of the substrates. This finding is consistent with those of other studies on agro-waste
(Asmadi et al., 2023). Despite this variability, all materials had suitable nutrient profiles for vermicomposting.
Properties of the substrates after vermicomposting
Following the 90-day vermicomposting period, there were significant differences among the substrates in all measured physicochemical parameters (p<0.001; Table 2). The moisture content of all vermicomposted substrates increased compared to their raw state, reaching a maximum of 6.84±1.82% in RSt+CW. This increase, particularly in treatments amended with animal waste, can be attributed to the burrowing activity of
E. eugeniae and the water-holding capacity of their organically rich casts
(Li et al., 2020). Earthworm activity enhances porosity and introduces hydrophilic organic colloids, thereby improving moisture retention
(Ding et al., 2013; Hauser et al., 2012).
Final pH values ranged from 6.83 to 8.17. The modulation of pH towards this neutral to slightly alkaline range is a well-documented outcome of vermicomposting, reflecting the optimal conditions for earthworm and microbial metabolism
(Rayela et al., 2025).
A consistent pattern emerged across all treatments: TOC and TK contents decreased, while TN, TP and Mg contents increased relative to initial values. The significant reduction in TOC indicates intense microbial respiration and mineralisation, processes that are notably accelerated by earthworm mucus and gut-associated enzymes, particularly in nutrient-rich substrates such as animal manure mixtures
(Garg et al., 2006). The concurrent increase in TN is due to the concentration effect resulting from carbon loss, nitrogen mineralisation and the direct addition of nitrogenous compounds
via earthworm excretions
(Sofo et al., 2023). The decline in TK is likely due to leaching
(Orozco et al., 1996), while the increase in TP is attributed to the mineralisation and mobilisation of phosphorus via microbial and earthworm gut phosphatase activity (
Le Bayon and Binet, 2006).
Evolution of the C/N and C/P ratios
The carbon-to-nitrogen (C/N) and carbon-to-phosphorus (C/P) ratios decreased significantly (p<0.001) in all substrates after vermicomposting (Fig 1 and Fig 2). The most pronounced reduction in the C/N ratio occurred in the amended substrates, dropping from 51.85 to 15.05 in the RSt+CD mixture and from 40.53 to 13.51 in the four-component mixture (RSt+RH+CD+CW). The C/P ratio also decreased substantially across treatments, with percentage reductions ranging from 33.1 per cent (RSt+CW) to 94.91 per cent (RH+CD). This drastic reduction is a key indicator of successful bioconversion and compost maturity. Substrates amended with animal manure achieved C/N ratios below 20, meeting the established benchmark for stabilised organic amendments (
Senesi, 1989). This decline highlights the efficient conversion of carbon by microbes and earthworms and the subsequent enrichment of nutrients
(Atiyeh et al., 2000; Garg et al., 2006; Lakshmi et al., 2014).
Earthworm performance in relation to substrate
The growth and fecundity of
Eudrilus eugeniae were highly dependent on substrate composition (Table 3). The highest final earthworm population (354±62.08), biomass and cocoon production (127.66±18.14) were achieved in the RSt+RH+CD+CW mixture. In stark contrast, pure RH supported the lowest final population, biomass and fecundity (23±16.23).
The superior performance of the four-component mixture demonstrates the critical importance of balanced substrate chemistry. This mixture likely provided an optimal, less recalcitrant resource with readily available nutrients and a more favourable microclimate. Earthworms preferentially consume organics with lower lignin and cellulose content
(Manna et al., 2003; Sarangi and Lama 2013); conditions that are best met in co-amended substrates. The poor earthworm development in pure RH emphasises the limitations of highly lignocellulosic, nutrient-poor substrates for vermiculture and highlights the necessity for supplementation to achieve efficient waste valorisation.