Effectiveness test of Trichoderma harzianum and Pleurotus ostreatus biodecomposers
Based on the research results, the effectiveness of decomposers can be seen from the compost temperature measured every week and physical characteristics such as color, texture and odor. The following is the compost temperature data for 3 weeks (Table 1). This study revealed that the use of
Trichoderma harzianum and
Pleurotus ostreatus decomposers significantly affected the composting temperature from the first to the third week. The high temperature at the beginning of the process indicates that composting is taking place optimally. In the first week, a sharp increase in temperature indicates intensive microorganism activity in degrading organic matter. The heat generated comes from the metabolic energy of decomposer bacteria during the decomposition process. In the early phase (first week), the highest peak in
Pleurotus ostreatus (46.2°C), was statistically significantly different from the combination of
T. harzianum + P. ostreatus (45.9°C). Meanwhile, treatments
T. harzianum,
P. ostreatus, Mikrobat and
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus showed a decrease in temperature. This indicates that decomposer activity is starting to decline and the composting process is entering the maturation stage. In contrast, treatments
T. harzianum+Mikrobat and
T. harzianum +
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat experienced an increase in temperature in the second and third weeks, indicating that decomposition had only just begun at this stage. Especially in
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat treatment, the temperature continued to increase until the third week, indicating the ineffectiveness of decomposer activity in this treatment.
The findings of this study suggest that microbial treatment influences the temperature profile during the composting process. This study’s findings are consistent with those of
Faesal et al., (2020), who discovered that using a combination of bacteria and fungi as decomposers can increase biological activity during composting, as evidenced by an increase in initial temperature and accelerated degradation of organic matter.
Wang et al., (2026) found that using lignocellulolytic microbial consortia at specified phases can increase the peak composting temperature and speed the temperature rise. These findings are also pertinent to the study conducted by
Tahsini et al., (2025), who discovered that adding microbial to compost increased temperatures and lengthened the thermophilic phase while also enhancing microbial activity and compost quality. Microbial inoculation not only accelerates organic matter decomposition, but it also promotes an increase in compost temperature and speeds up the composting maturation process by increasing microbial activity
(Salih et al., 2025).
Physical properties of compost
The following are the results of observations made in the field based on the physical properties of compost in the decomposition process (Table 2). Based on the research conducted, the effectiveness of the cocoa shell waste composting process can be assessed through the compost maturity structure, which includes visual characteristics (color) and biological development (the presence of mycelium) in decomposing organic materials. As shown in the observation results table, there is a significant variation in development between the observations of the first week and the 4
th week after the application of the decomposer. Changes in texture and color can serve as markers of compost maturity. According to
Xu et al., (2025), particle size and color/texture changes in compost have a substantial impact on the humification process and the role of organic matter in humus production. During the composting process, the color darkens and other physical property measures are significantly connected with increasing compost maturity and humification, indicating increased microbial activity and improved nutrient retention in the final product
(Xie et al., 2025).
During the initial phase (first week), the control,
T. harzianum and
P. ostreatus treatments exhibited early signs of mycelial growth, whereas Mikrobat treatments to
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat treatments had already achieved approximately 50% colonization of the substrate. After 30 days, distinct differences in mycelial development were observed among the treatments. Mycelial growth in
T. harzianum and
P. ostreatus treatments progressed to around 50% substrate coverage, while Mikrobat and
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus treatments showed minimal further development. Notably,
T. harzianum+Mikrobat treatment exhibited nearly complete mycelial colonization of the cocoa pod waste, indicating strong fungal activity. In contrast,
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat treatments showed no further mycelial growth beyond the first week. In addition to biological parameters (mycelium growth), physicochemical aspects such as color, aroma and texture are also important indicators of the success of the composting process. According to
Bernal et al., (2017), color changes in compost occur due to oxidation reactions during the transformation of organic matter into inorganic compounds and the formation of humus. This was observed in
P. ostreatus,
T. harzianum+Mikrobat and
T. harzianum +
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat treatments containing the microorganism
Pleurotus ostreatus, where the yellowish-white mycelium oxidized to blackish and brownish characteristics that were considered as indicators of mature compost. According to
Setyaningsih et al., (2017), compost that appears blackish-brown is typically associated with a relatively high moisture content, whereas a lighter color indicates lower water content.
In terms of texture,
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus treatment showed optimal development with a softness level of 71-100%, indicating almost perfect material decomposition. The
T. harzianum,
P. ostreatus, Mikrobat and
T. harzianum +Mikrobat treatments were in the range of 36-70% softness, indicating an intermediate decomposition stage. This finding is consistent with the statement of
Syukur et al., (2006), who noted that compost maturity is directly proportional to the reduction in particle size. Similarly, recent studies also emphasize that color and texture are reliable indicators of compost maturity, where darker color and finer particle size reflect higher humification and microbial activity
(Bernal et al., 2017; Witasari et al., 2022).
As organic matter decomposes, complex lignocellulosic compounds are gradually broken down into simpler forms, which increases the softness and reduces particle size, while microbial biomass contributes to the dark coloration through the formation of stable humic substances
(Gabhane et al., 2020; Tandy et al., 2022). Therefore, the observed increase in softness and darkening in
T. harzianum +
P. ostreatus treatment can be considered a sign of advanced compost stabilization and readiness for agronomic use. The analysis revealed significant differences in compost weight loss among the biodecomposer treatments (Fig 1). The control and
T. harzianum+Mikrobat treatment exhibited the highest percentage of weight loss, suggesting intense microbial activity in breaking down organic matter. This aligns with findings by
Witasari et al., (2022), who stated that high mass loss reflects the efficiency of organic matter mineralization into volatile compounds during composting. Similarly,
Rahman et al., (2023) reported that vigorous microbial metabolism accelerates carbon loss as CO
2 and water vapor, leading to greater weight reduction.
However, interestingly, treatments with lower weight loss, such as
T. harzianum alone,
P. ostreatus alone, Mikrobat,
T. harzianum+
P. ostreatus and
T. harzianum +
P. ostreatus+Mikrobat treatments demonstrated a more efficient composting mechanism. In these treatments, organic matter was not only decomposed but also more effectively converted into microbial biomass and stable humic substances, thereby retaining greater mass and nutrient content in the final compost product. This is supported by
Zhao et al., (2021) and
Sari et al., (2024), who found that the incorporation of lignocellulolytic fungi can enhance humification, stabilize organic carbon and reduce excessive mass loss, ultimately improving compost quality and nutrient retention.
Micro and macro nutrient content
Based on the data in Table 3, there are significant variations in the chemical properties of compost resulting from various bio-decomposer treatments. The C-organic content ranged from 14.38 to 17.90%, with the highest value observed in the combination of
Trichoderma harzianum and Mikrobat (17.90%). This indicates the effectiveness of this combination in maintaining and stabilizing organic matter during the decomposition process. The role of
T. harzianum in accelerating the degradation of lignocellulosic material has been reported to enhance organic matter stabilization and humus formation
(Shanmugaiah et al., 2023). Similarly, the addition of biofertilizer consortia is known to support microbial activity and improve compost organic carbon content
(Saputra et al., 2024). Microbial activity is critical for nutrient recovery during composting. This is consistent with
Wang et al., (2025) research findings, which showed that aeration and microbial treatment may maintain organic carbon levels while increasing total nitrogen, phosphate and potassium in compost compared to the control. According to
Zhou et al., (2025), the inclusion of lignocellulolytic inoculants greatly improved compost maturity by lowering the C/N ratio and boosting total N, total P and total K in the finished compost.
In terms of nitrogen, the highest total N content (1.01%) was found in the treatments with
T. harzianum alone and its combination with Mikrobat, which far exceeded the SNI 19-7030-2004 minimum standard of 0.40%. The increase in nitrogen content is associated with microbial-mediated protein mineralization, where complex proteins are transformed into amino acids, ammonium and subsequently nitrates
(Hastuti et al., 2017; Kumar et al., 2022). In contrast,
Pleurotus ostreatus exhibited the lowest nitrogen content (0.55%), which may be due to its preferential utilization of nitrogen during lignin degradation, yet it still met the compost quality standards
(Rahman et al., 2023b).
Another crucial parameter is the C/N ratio, which varied between 16 and 27 across treatments. The
T. harzianum treatment recorded the lowest ratio (16), indicating optimal compost maturity. According to
Mawar et al., (2022), compost maturity is achieved when the C/N ratio is below 20, as lower values reflect sufficient organic carbon decomposition relative to nitrogen content. A low C/N ratio is desirable as it promotes microbial efficiency and nutrient mineralization
(Gao et al., 2024). Conversely, the high ratio observed in the
P. ostreatus treatment suggests slower decomposition, possibly linked to its primary role as a lignin degrader rather than a nitrogen fixer
(Khan et al., 2024).
Phosphorus (P) content also varied considerably among treatments, ranging from 0.24 to 1.08%, all exceeding the SNI minimum standard (0.10%). The highest P content (1.08%) was recorded in the combined treatment of
T. harzianum,
P. ostreatus and Mikrobat. The increase in phosphorus availability has been attributed to microbial solubilization of inorganic phosphate through the production of organic acids and phosphatase enzymes
(Du et al., 2021; Marra et al., 2023). This suggests that the synergistic activity of multiple decomposer species enhances the release of P from organic matter and mineral sources during composting.
Potassium (K) content ranged from 0.29 to 0.82%, with all treatments exceeding the SNI standard (0.20%). The highest value (0.82%) was found in the combination of
T. harzianum and Mikrobat. The release of potassium during composting is facilitated by the formation of humic and fulvic acids, which chelate and mobilize potassium ions, thereby increasing their availability
(Ratriyanto et al., 2023). Additionally, microbial enzymatic activity enhances cell wall breakdown and the liberation of intracellular potassium, further contributing to K enrichment in compost
(Prasetyo et al., 2024).
Overall, the combination of
T. harzianum and Mikrobat demonstrated the best performance, showing optimal chemical parameters: the highest C-organic (17.90%), maximum total N (1.01%), ideal C/N ratio (~18) and the highest K (0.82%). Meanwhile, the combination of three decomposers (
T. harzianum,
P. ostreatus and Mikrobat) excelled in phosphorus content (1.08%). This highlights the potential of integrating multiple bio-decomposers to enhance the chemical quality of compost, thus improving its agronomic value and nutrient content for sustainable soil fertility management
(Hasibuan et al., 2024).
Lignocellulolytic test
The results of the study indicated that the effectiveness of lignocellulose decomposition in compost was significantly affected by the formulation of the decomposer applied (Table 4).
T. harzianum demonstrated limited efficacy in lignin degradation, as evidenced by elevated levels of crude fiber (ADF and NDF) and remaining lignin residues
. Mikrobat proved to be more effective in decomposing hemicellulose, although it still left significant amounts of lignin. The combination of
T. harzianum with
P. ostreatus produced a balanced performance in reducing ADF, NDF and lignin levels, indicating good enzymatic synergy between the two microorganisms. Meanwhile, the combination of
T. harzianum with Mikrobat produced high lignin levels but with low ATL values, indicating the transformation of lignin into more stable humic compounds. These findings confirm that the success of the decomposition process is not only determined by the ability to reduce lignin levels but also by the capacity of microbes to modify lignin into compounds that are beneficial for the stability and maturity of the compost. Given that cocoa shells contain relatively high levels of lignin (18.6%) and cellulose (13.7%), each biodecomposer treatment encounters specific challenges in degrading this material. The study
(Djali et al., 2021) further noted that most
Trichoderma species produce polyphenol oxidase enzymes involved in the lignin degradation process, although their effectiveness remains limited.
The decomposition of lignocellulosic materials during composting is a complex process influenced by microbial communities and their enzymatic activities. Recent studies have shown that combinations of microorganisms, such as
Trichoderma harzianum and
Phanerochaete chrysosporium, can synergistically degrade lignin and enhance humification, resulting in more mature compost products
(Muteab et al., 2025; Zhai et al., 2025). White-rot fungi like
Pleurotus ostreatus are especially effective in breaking down lignin and cellulose due to their ligninolytic enzymes, including laccase and lignin peroxidase, which improve the overall composting process and increase the nutritive value of the final compost
(Yu et al., 2024; Olagunju et al., 2023). Microbial inoculation with targeted agents has also been demonstrated to accelerate lignocellulose degradation and improve compost quality by enhancing microbial diversity and enzymatic activity. For example, two-stage inoculation of lignocellulose-degrading microbes can enhance the decomposition of cattle manure and bagasse, optimizing both nutrient release and compost maturity
(Zhang et al., 2025). The addition of biochar along with microbial agents has been reported to further optimize microbial community dynamics and promote efficient degradation of lignocellulosic substrates
(Li et al., 2024; Yang et al., 2023).
Environmental factors, particularly temperature and moisture, significantly influence the degradation process. Optimal temperature conditions enhance microbial activity and lignocellulose breakdown, while microbial community succession determines which species dominate at various composting stages, affecting the rate and efficiency of lignocellulose decomposition
(Wang et al., 2025; Martín et al., 2023). Cocoa shells, a byproduct of cocoa processing, present specific challenges due to their high lignin and cellulose content. Studies have shown that using specialized microbial inoculants and optimized composting techniques can significantly enhance the degradation of lignocellulosic components in cocoa shells, producing high-quality compost suitable for agricultural use
(Arini et al., 2021; Djali et al., 2021; Sánchez et al., 2023).
Overall, these findings indicate that the success of lignocellulose decomposition in compost is not determined solely by the reduction of lignin content but also by the microorganisms’ ability to transform lignin into stable, beneficial compounds. The utilization of bio-decomposers based on Trichoderma harzianum, Pleurotus ostreatus and microbial consortia is critical for optimizing the composting process of CPH waste. The temperature dynamics and changes in the physical features of the compost show that the effectiveness of decomposition is determined by the kind and combination of decomposers used. As a result, this strategy has the potential to be a long-term solution for agricultural waste management while simultaneously promoting the use of high-quality organic fertilizer in ecologically friendly farming systems.