Analysis of variance (ANOVA) showed significant treatment effect on vegetative growth, biochemical responses in defence mechanisms, chlorophyll content, disease severity and yield of tubers (Table 1-8). The treatments with
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 and its lipopeptides proved effective under greenhouse conditions for supressing the
Fusarium sambucinum csnmgmu7 and enhancing plant performance in potato variety Kufri Khyati.
Effect of different treatments on vegetative growth
Different treatments significantly affected the vegetative growth of Kufri Khyati (Table 1 and 2). Plants inoculated with
Fusarium sambucinum alone (T
2) exhibited the poorest growth for all parameters, whereas biological treatments significantly improved plant development. Among all treatments,
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
3) produced the best vegetative growth, while lipopeptides (T
7) and the combined
Fusarium +
Bacillus treatment (T
4) also alleviated the adverse effects of pathogen infection.
Plant height, shoot length, shoot diameter and root length differed significantly among treatments (Table 1). The highest plant height (64.01 cm), shoot length (13.09 cm), shoot diameter (6.85 cm) and root length (14.91 cm) were recorded in T
3, whereas T
2 recorded the lowest values (40.06, 9.02, 2.36 and 9.26 cm, respectively). Among the pathogen-challenged treatments, T
7 maintained higher plant height (53.93 cm), shoot length (12.88 cm) and root length (14.22 cm), while T
4 also showed substantial improvement over pathogen inoculation alone. Enhanced vegetative growth following
B. subtilis application may be attributed to improved nutrient uptake, production of plant growth-promoting substances and suppression of pathogen development. Similar improvements in potato growth following
Bacillus-based biological control have been reported by
Larkin et al., (2024) and
Serrão et al. (2024).
T
3 recorded the greatest leaf length (20.87 cm) and number of leaflets (17.33), whereas the widest leaflets were observed in T
4 (12.24 cm) (Table 2). In contrast, T
2 produced the shortest leaflets (12.17 cm), the narrowest leaflets (6.26 cm) and the fewest leaflets (9.67). Among the pathogen-challenged treatments, lipopeptides (T
7) maintained higher leaf length (20.25 cm) and leaf number (17.00 plant
-1), indicating better maintenance of canopy growth under pathogen stress. Improved leaf development in the biological treatments may be attributed to reduced disease severity and enhanced physiological activity, resulting in greater photosynthetic surface area and overall plant vigour. Similar improvements in leaf growth following the application of
Bacillus spp. have been reported in potato and other crops
(Chowdhury et al., 2015; Larkin, 2024).
Overall,
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
3) was the most effective treatment for promoting vegetative growth, while lipopeptides (T
7) were the most effective among the pathogen-challenged treatments, demonstrating their potential as sustainable biological alternatives for mitigating the adverse effects of
Fusarium sambucinum.
Effect of different treatments on defence-related biochemical and physiological responses
Defence-related biochemical and physiological parameters were significantly influenced by different treatments throughout the observation period (Table 3, 4, 5 and 6). Activities of PAL, POD and PPO increased rapidly following pathogen inoculation, reaching peak levels between 5 and 7 DAT before declining slightly at 14 DAT. Biological treatments maintained higher enzyme activities than the untreated control and chemical fungicide treatment, indicating enhanced activation of host defence mechanisms against
Fusarium sambucinum. Significant differences in total chlorophyll content were observed at 5, 7 and 14 DAT, indicating better maintenance of photosynthetic capacity under pathogen stress.
Pathogen infection significantly induced PAL activity, especially in T‚ with a maximum activity of 7 DAT (69.04 U g
-1 FW) thereby proving activation of phenylpropanoid pathway after fungal invasion (Table 3). The biological treatments with consistently higher PAL activity followed lipopeptides (T
7) indicative of effective induction of host defence response, amongst the biologicals explored
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
3). On the other hand, the PAL activity of T
6 (Mancozeb) was lower as compared to the rest of the time. Induced resistance by
Bacillus has also been shown to enhance the activity level of PAL by,
Chowdhury et al., (2015), Verma et al., (2024) and
Bakki et al., (2024).
The pathogen inoculation also significantly raised the polyphenol oxidase (PPO) activity with the maximum (91.04 U g
-1 FW) recorded in T
2 at 7 DAT (Table 4). The enzymatic defence response was efficient in the T
3 and T
7 treatments, which resulted in overall high PPO activity compared to T
6 amongst the management treatments. Presence of increased PPO leads to an increase in the generation of quinones, which are antimicrobial molecules that limit colonization by pathogens (
Choudaker et al., 2024;
Serrão et al., 2024).
The peroxidase activity exhibited the same pattern with maximum activity observed in T
2 at 7 DAT (108.28 U g
-1 FW) and the maximum peroxidase activity among the biological treatments was observed in T
3 (88.69 U g
-1 FW) (Table 5). Lipopeptides (T
7) also exhibited increased POD activity compared to Mancozeb, indicative of improved ability to remove ROS and strengthen barriers in the cell wall. Similar results have been seen in
Bacillus treated plants attacked by fungal pathogens
(Hammerschmidt et al., 1982; Berendsen et al., 2012).
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 and its lipopeptides activate induced systemic resistance (ISR), as seen by the increased PAL, POD and PPO activities seen in the biological therapies. By participating in the phenylpropanoid pathway, lignification, phenolic compound oxidation and plant cell wall fortification, these defence enzymes limit pathogen colonisation. On the other hand, rather than effective disease resistance, the pathogen-inoculated treatment’s greatest enzyme activity probably represented a stronger stress response brought on by a severe infection. The biological treatments’ mild but persistent enzyme activity suggests effective host defence priming along with a decrease in pathogen load
(Bakki et al., 2024; Verma et al., 2024; Gulzar et al., 2025).
The total chlorophyll content were significantly different for the different treatments during the experiment (Table 6). It was found that the amount of chlorophyll was utmost at T
5 (2.80 mg g
-1 FW) at 7 DAT followed by T
7 (2.74 mg g
-1 FW) and T
4 (2.37 mg g
-1 FW), while T
1 exhibited the lowest chlorophyll level during observation. The chlorophyll content was higher in the biological treatment and was significantly higher than the pathogen treatment, signifying a better preservation of photosynthetic capacity when in disease stress. Chlorophyll content in plants after
Bacillus spp. application was reported previously, which showed similar improvement
(Chowdhury et al., 2015; Siddika et al., 2024).
Better preservation of photosynthetic ability under pathogen stress was evidenced by higher chlorophyll concentration in the biological treatments. Improved plant physiological state and less pathogen colonisation may have reduced chlorophyll breakdown, maintain photosynthetic efficiency and promote increased plant growth and output. Similar findings have been documented in plants treated with
Bacillus under both biotic and abiotic stress
(Siddika et al., 2024; Verma et al., 2024).
Effect of different treatments on disease severity and tuber yield
Disease severity
The severity of disease continued to rise as the days passed on pathogen-inoculated plants, but both biological and chemical treatments proved effective at reducing disease (Table 7). In the case of the
Bacillus subtilis MGM123, disease symptoms were kept under check, remaining essentially negligible plants throughout the study; in the maximum points, 21 and 28 DAT, the DSI reached a maximum of 0.67, in the untreated control (T
1) received a few minimal symptoms.
Fusarium sambucinum, as under greenhouse conditions, was found to have a very aggressive affect, with T
2 being the first control symptom group to appear at 7 DAT (DSI 1.67), followed by 2.67 at 14 DAT, 3.67 at 21 DAT and 4.67 at 28 DAT.
Among the disease-management treatments, lipopeptides (T
7) and Mancozeb (T
6) were the most effective, each recording the lowest final DSI (1.67) at 28 DAT, followed by
Fusarium +
Trichoderma (T
5) (2.33) and
Fusarium +
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
4) (3.00). The marked reduction in disease severity following application of
B. subtilis MGM123 and its lipopeptides may be attributed to the combined effects of antifungal lipopeptide production and induction of host defence responses. Similar reductions in
Fusarium-associated diseases through
Bacillus-mediated biological control have been reported by
Ongena and Jacques (2008),
Chowdhury et al., (2015) and
Gulzar et al., (2025) .
Tuber yield differed significantly among treatments (Table 8). The highest yield was obtained with
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
3) (140.00 g plant
-1), followed by lipopeptides (T
7) (129.00 g plant
-1) and
Fusarium +
Bacillus subtilis MGM123 (T
4) (107.00 g plant
-1).
Fusarium +
Trichoderma (T
5) and Mancozeb (T
6) each produced 103.00 g plant
-1, whereas the pathogen treatment (T
2) recorded the lowest yield (48.00 g plant
-1), representing a substantial reduction compared with the untreated control (76.00 g plant
-1). The higher tuber yield obtained with the biological treatments reflects their ability to suppress pathogen infection while promoting healthier plant growth. Notably, lipopeptides produced a higher tuber yield than Mancozeb while maintaining comparable disease suppression, highlighting their potential as environmentally sustainable alternatives for potato dry rot management. Similar improvements in tuber yield following application of
Bacillus spp. have been reported by
Larkin et al., (2024) and
Li et al., (2022).
Environmental heterogeneity in the field may affect the effectiveness of the biocontrol treatments, even if the current study showed encouraging disease suppression under greenhouse settings. Therefore, before promoting large-scale agricultural use, multilocation field evaluations are necessary.