Effect of Weed Management Practices on Yield Attributes, Yields and Economics of Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) Cultivars under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh

B
Brihmanand1,*
M
M.P. Singh1
U
Umesh Dubey2
A
Abhishek Dwivedi1
A
Abdhesh Kumar3
S
Satyam Gupta1
1Department of Agronomy, Janta College, Bakewar, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur-206 124, Uttar Pradesh, India.
2Department of Agronomy, Janta Mahavidyalaya, Ajitmal, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur-206 121, Uttar Pradesh, India.
3Department of Agronomy, Chandra Shekhar Azad University of Agriculture and Technology Kanpur-208 002, Uttar Pradesh, India.

Background: Weed competition significantly hampers wheat productivity and profitability by reducing the efficient utilization of growth resources. Adoption of effective weed management practices along with suitable wheat cultivars is, therefore, crucial for realizing higher yields and economic returns in the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh in India. 

Methods: A two-year field study was carried out during the Rabi seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 in the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh to examine the influence of different weed management strategies on productivity and profitability of wheat cultivars. The experiment was laid out in factorial randomized block design under four replications with three wheat cultivars viz., PBW 343, HD 2967 and DBW 222 along with six weed management practices comprising W0, weedy check; W1, tillage with one deep ploughing by disc harrow, followed by cross harrowing and cross rotavating + weeding after first irrigation-30 DAS; W2, W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha; W3, W1 + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha; W4, W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha followed by post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha and W5, weed-free condition. All the recommended packages of practices of the region were adopted during raising the good crop.

Result: The results indicated that cultivar DBW 222 produced significantly higher yield attributes, grain and straw yield as well as economic returns over the other cultivars during both years of experimentation. Among weed management practices, integrated application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha as pre-emergence followed by sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha as post-emergence (W4) remained statistically comparable with weed-free treatment (W5) and recorded superior yield attributes, yields and net returns. Maximum benefit: cost ratio was also observed under W4 owing to effective weed suppression and better crop productivity. The interaction effect between cultivars and weed management practices remained non-significant for most of the parameters studied.

Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is a major cereal crop cultivated extensively across India and contributes significantly to national food security. However, its productivity is often constrained by heavy weed infestation during the early stages of crop growth. Weeds create intense competition for essential growth resources such as nutrients, soil moisture, sunlight and growing space, ultimately reducing crop growth and yield potential (Malik and Singh, 1995). Continuous reliance on a single weed control method, particularly repeated use of similar herbicides, has resulted in problems such as herbicide resistance, weed flora shift and decline in herbicide efficiency (Chhokar and Malik, 2017). Under these circumstances, integrated weed management practices involving tillage, herbicides and manual weeding have emerged as effective and sustainable options for maintaining crop productivity (Walia, 2010).

Apart from weed management, varietal selection also plays an important role in determining wheat productivity under varying field conditions. Different wheat cultivars vary considerably in their growth behaviour, biomass production and competitive ability against weeds (Rinwa et al., 2025). Therefore, identifying a suitable cultivar along with an efficient weed management strategy is essential for achieving higher yield and profitability. In view of the above facts, the present study was undertaken to evaluate the response of wheat cultivars to different weed management practices with respect to yield attributes, productivity and economics under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh.
Location and climate
 
The field experiment was conducted during the Rabi seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 at the Agronomy Research Farm, Janta College, Bakewar, Etawah located under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh. The experimental site is located approximately 23 km East of the district headquarters in Etawah. The site is located at 26.67° North latitude and 79.18° East longitude at an average elevation of about 142 metres above from the sea level and falls under the sub-tropical climate zone with an average of 752 mm of rain every year. The soil texture of the research farm is silty loam which makes the soil suite best for growing crops.
 
Experimental design and treatments
 
The experiment was laid out in factorial randomized block design with four replications. The treatments consisted of three wheat cultivars and six weed management practices.
 
Soil sampling
 
Composite soil samples were collected in a zig-zag manner during the fallow period before the start of the experiment and after the harvesting of the crop. Soil auger and khurpi were used to collect the samples at a depth of 15 cm from the soil surface.
 
Agricultural operation
 
The experimental field was well levelled and provided with proper irrigation and drainage facilities. The land was prepared with one disc ploughing followed by two cross harrowings to obtain a fine tilth wherever required as per treatment. The field was divided into four replications, each containing 18 plots of 15.0 m2 size (5.0 m × 3.0 m). Necessary paths, bunds and irrigation channels were prepared according to the layout. A recommended fertilizer dose of 150 kg N, 80 kg P and 60 kg K/ha was applied, wherein full phosphorus, potassium and 50% nitrogen were applied at sowing, while the remaining nitrogen was top-dressed after first irrigation during both years of experimentation. Herbicides were applied using a knapsack sprayer fitted with flat-fan nozzle as per treatment.
 
Treatment details
 
The experiment was laid out in a randomized block design with eighteen treatments replicated four times (Table 1).

Table 1: Details of the treatments applied.


 
Data collection and analysis
 
Grain yield and straw yield (q/ha)
 
From each experimental plot, the net plot area measuring 4.5 m × 2.6 m (11.7 m2) was harvested and the produce was sun-dried at-least for 3-4 days. The dried material was then threshed using a mechanical method, followed by careful cleaning and weighing. The cleaned grain yield obtained (kg/net plot) was converted into quintals per hectare (q/ha) using the appropriate conversion factor based on the net plot area. Straw yield was determined by the differential method. The grain yield was subtracted from the corresponding biological yield of each plot to obtain straw yield per hectare. The resulting values were expressed in quintals per hectare (q/ha) using the standard conversion factor.
 
Harvest index (per cent)
 
Harvest index was calculated following the method described by Singh and Stockopf (1971) using the below formula. It was expressed as a percentage. This parameter indicates the proportion of economic yield in relation to total biomass production.
 
 Gross return (₹/ha)
 
Gross return for each treatment was estimated by multiplying the yield of grain and by-products with the minimum support price (MSP) declared by the Government of India, or with the prevailing market prices in the case of by-products. The computed amount represented the total income generated per hectare (₹/ha) before deducting any cultivation costs.
 
Net return (₹/ha)
 
Net return for both years of experimentation was obtained by subtracting the total cost of cultivation of each treatment from its corresponding gross return. The resulting figure indicated the net profit or loss realized from each treatment and was expressed in ₹/ha.
 
Benefit: cost ratio
 
The benefit: cost ratio (B:C ratio) was calculated to assess the economic viability of each treatment using the formula:
 

This ratio reflects the return per unit of investment, where a value greater than one (B:C > 1) denotes a profitable treatment, while values below one indicate uneconomic outcomes.
  
Statistical analysis
 
The observations recorded on various parameters during the crop seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 were systematically compiled and subjected to statistical analysis using the analysis of variance (ANOVA) technique appropriate for factorial randomized block design, as described by Fisher and Yates (1948). The significance of treatment differences was evaluated at the 5 per cent level of significance.
Yield attributes
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
The yield attributes of wheat were significantly influenced by different cultivars during both years of study (Table 2). Among the tested cultivars, ‘DBW 222’ recorded the highest number of grains per ear and test weight during both crop seasons. The cultivar produced 39.41 and 38.49 grains per ear during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively. Similarly, test weight under this cultivar was also maximum, recording 41.06 g and 39.63 g during the respective years (Table 2). The superior performance of ‘DBW 222’ may be attributed to better translocation of assimilates and higher sink capacity, which ultimately improved grain development and grain filling (Singh et al., 2013). Cultivar ‘HD 2967’ occupied second position, whereas ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest values for these parameters.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
Among the weed management treatments, the weed-free treatment (W5) recorded the highest number of grains per ear (39.11 and 38.30) and test weight (40.78 and 39.84 g) in 2023-24 and 2024-24, respectively. However, it remained statistically at par with the integrated weed management treatment involving W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha followed by post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha (W4), with corresponding values of 38.65 and 37.74 grains/ear and test weight of 40.25 and 39.27 g (Table 2). Effective weed control under these treatments might have ensured better availability of nutrients, moisture and light to the crop plants, resulting in improved grain formation and filling (Singh et al., 2013). The weedy check (W0) consistently recorded the minimum values owing to severe crop-weed competition.
 
Grain yield and straw yield
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
Wheat cultivar ‘DBW 222’ recorded significantly higher grain and straw yields during both years of experimentation. This cultivar produced grain yields of 49.68 and 44.81 q/ha during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively. Straw yield under this cultivar was also maximum, recording 63.44 and 59.36 q/ha during the corresponding years (Table 2). The improved productivity of ‘DBW 222’ might be due to better growth characteristics and higher dry matter accumulation (Mishra et al., 2020). Further, ‘HD 2967’ occupied the second rank with respect to grain yield, whereas ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest grain yield during both years. In contrast, ‘PBW 343’ produced relatively higher straw yield than ‘HD 2967’, which may be associated with greater vegetative growth.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
Among the weed management practices, the weed-free treatment (W5) recorded the highest grain and straw yields during both years of experimentation and remained statistically at par with the integrated weed management treatment W4 (W1 + pendimethalin followed by sulfosulfuron). The grain yield under W5 increased by 52.78 and 62.73% over the weedy check (W0) during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively, while W4 recorded corresponding increases of 50.33 and 59.16% (Table 2). It might be due to improving the growth and yield attributes of wheat by minimizing crop-weed competition for nutrients, moisture and light (Jitender et al., 2022; Jeet et al., 2022 and Gill and Walia, 2024). Similarly, straw yield under W5 increased by 44.72 and 52.17% over W0 during the respective years, whereas W4 registered increases of 42.97 and 48.86%. Treatment W2 also performed better than W3 and W1 in terms of grain and straw yield. The lowest grain and straw yields were recorded under the weedy check due to severe weed competition throughout the crop growth period (Table 2). The integrated application of pendimethalin followed by sulfosulfuron effectively suppressed weeds throughout the critical crop growth period, resulting in enhanced crop yield (Khatri et al., 2020).
 
Harvest index
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
Harvest index was significantly affected by wheat cultivars during both years of experimentation. ‘HD 2967’ recorded the highest harvest index values with 47.05 and 45.16% during both years, respectively (Table 2), indicating more efficient partitioning of assimilates towards economic yield (Singh et al., 2013). Wheat cultivar ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest harvest index.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
The effect of weed management practices on harvest index remained non-significant during both years, although numerically higher values were recorded under weed-free and integrated weed management treatments (Table 2).

Table 2: Effect of weed management practices on yield attributes and yield of wheat varieties.


 
Economics
 
Cost of cultivation
 
The cost of cultivation remained similar among wheat cultivars because uniform agronomic practices were adopted for all cultivars (₹ 45583/ha). However, different weed management practices considerably affected cultivation cost (Table 3). Weed-free treatment involved the highest cultivation cost i.e. ₹ 52900/ha owing to repeated manual weeding operations, whereas the weedy check recorded minimum cultivation cost. The minimum cost of cultivation was incurred for the weedy plots (₹ 34000/ha).

Gross return and net return
 
Among the cultivars, DBW 222 recorded the highest gross and net returns during both years owing to higher grain and straw yields (Table 3) with the corresponding values of ₹ 151087 and ₹ 137557/ha for gross return and ₹ 105504 and ₹ 91974/ha for net return. Cultivar PBW 343 registered minimum gross and net returns in both the years (Table 3).

Regarding weed management practices, treatment W4 (W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha) generated maximum net return with corresponding values of ₹ 109932 and ₹ 96919/ha during first and second year, respectively. This treatment (W4) remained economically superior over the other treatments in respect of net return. Although weed-free treatment produced slightly higher gross return, its higher cultivation cost reduced the net return (Table 3). The higher economic returns was also reported in tank mixture of sulfosulfuron 75% WP + metsulfuron 20% WP (40 g/ha) applied at 25 DAS (Jeet et al., 2022).

Table 3: Gross return, net return and benefit: cost ratio of wheat varieties as influenced by weed management practices during 2023-24 and 2024-25.


 
Benefit : cost ratio
 
The highest benefit : cost ratio among cultivars was observed under DBW 222 (3.32 and 3.02 for 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively). It could be possible due to higher economic returns obtained from higher productivity under this cultivar. Cultivar HD 2967 occupied second position, whereas PBW 343 registered minimum benefit: cost ratio in both the years (Table 3).

Among weed management practices, treatment W4 (W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha) recorded maximum benefit: cost ratio (3.26 and 2.99 for 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively), it might be owing to higher profitability and comparatively lower expenditure than weed-free treatment (Table 3). Jeet et al. (2022) reported that the tank mixture of Sulfosulfuron 75% WP + Metsulfuron 20% WP @ 40 g/ha at 25 DAS effectively controlled grassy and broad-leaved weeds, resulting in the significantly higher B:C ratio. 
The present investigation concluded that wheat cultivar DBW 222 performed significantly better in terms of yield attributes, yields and economic returns under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh. Among weed management practices, treatment involving W1 (Tillage with one deep ploughing by disc harrow followed by cross harrowing and cross rotavating, along with one hand weeding after first irrigation - 30 days after sowing) + application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha as pre-emergence followed by sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha as post-emergence (W4) proved most effective and economically viable. Therefore, adoption of cultivar DBW 222 along with integrated weed management treatment W4 may be recommended for achieving higher productivity and profitability in wheat cultivation under similar agro-climatic conditions.

Disclaimers
 
The content, opinions and findings expressed in this publication are the exclusive responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of their respective organizations or institutions. Although due care has been taken in preparing this work, the authors disclaim any liability for errors, omissions, or any outcomes arising from the application or interpretation of the information provided.
 
Informed consent
 
Janta College, Bakewar, Etawah, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh sanctioned all experimental methodologies and handling protocols.
The authors report no conflicts of interest related to this publication. Furthermore, the research was carried out without any financial support or sponsorship that could have influenced the study design, data analysis, interpretation of findings, manuscript development, or publication decisions.

  1. Chhokar, R.S. and Malik, R.K. (2017). Isoproturon-resistant littleseed canarygrass (Phalaris minor) and its response to alternate herbicides. Weed Technology. 16(1): 116-123. https://doi.org/10.1017/ wet.2016.85.

  2. Fisher, R.A. and Yates, F. (1948). The fisher-yates test of significance in 2 × 2 contingency tables. Biometrika. 35: 145-156.

  3. Gill, H.K. and Walia, U.S. (2024). Effect of planting patterns and weed competition on growth, yield and quality of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Agricultural Science Digest. 1-6. doi: 10.18805/ag.D-5966.

  4. Jeet, S., Tabassum, S., Kumar, R. and Namigial, T. (2022). Efficacy of herbicides on weed control in zero-tilled wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in the Eastern Indo-gangetic Plains. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 56(1): 38-42. doi: 10.18805/IJARe.A-5570.

  5. Jitender, Sandeep, Singh, B. and Kumar, P. (2022). Chemical weed management in wheat-A review. Journal of Agriculture Research Technology. (Special Issue)1: 143-151.

  6. Khatri, N., Pokhrel, D., Pandey, B.P., Bista, M., Marasini, M., Paudel, G.P. and Chaurasiya, B.P. (2020). Economics and yield of wheat as affected by pre and post-emergence her bicides in western Terai Region of Nepal. Journal of Research in Weed Science. 3(2): 181-187.

  7. Malik, R.K. and Singh, S. (1995). Littleseed canarygrass (Phalaris minor Retz.) resistance to isoproturon in India. Weed Technology. 9: 419-425.

  8. Mishra, C.N., Tiwari, V., Khan, H., Kumar, S., Sharma, A.K., Singh, R., Jasrotia, P. et al. (2020). DBW222 (Karan Narendra): A new high-yielding, lodging-tolerant wheat variety for North Western plains of India. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology. 20(3): 1-6.

  9. Rinwa, A., Singh, M. and Kaur, S. (2025). Weed suppression ability of wheat cultivars vary under different weed scenarios. Agricultural Research Journal. 62(1): 36-46. https://doi.org/10.5958/2395-146X.2025.00004.7.

  10. Singh, B., Dhaka, A.K., Pannu, R.K. and Kumar, S. (2013). Integrated weed management-A strategy for sustainable wheat production- A review. Agricultural Reviews. 34(4): 243- 255.

  11. Singh, I.D. and stoksopf, N.C. (1971). Harvest index in cereals. Agronomy Journal. 63(2): 224-226.

  12. Walia, U.S. (2010). Weed Management. Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi.

Effect of Weed Management Practices on Yield Attributes, Yields and Economics of Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) Cultivars under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh

B
Brihmanand1,*
M
M.P. Singh1
U
Umesh Dubey2
A
Abhishek Dwivedi1
A
Abdhesh Kumar3
S
Satyam Gupta1
1Department of Agronomy, Janta College, Bakewar, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur-206 124, Uttar Pradesh, India.
2Department of Agronomy, Janta Mahavidyalaya, Ajitmal, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur-206 121, Uttar Pradesh, India.
3Department of Agronomy, Chandra Shekhar Azad University of Agriculture and Technology Kanpur-208 002, Uttar Pradesh, India.

Background: Weed competition significantly hampers wheat productivity and profitability by reducing the efficient utilization of growth resources. Adoption of effective weed management practices along with suitable wheat cultivars is, therefore, crucial for realizing higher yields and economic returns in the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh in India. 

Methods: A two-year field study was carried out during the Rabi seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 in the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh to examine the influence of different weed management strategies on productivity and profitability of wheat cultivars. The experiment was laid out in factorial randomized block design under four replications with three wheat cultivars viz., PBW 343, HD 2967 and DBW 222 along with six weed management practices comprising W0, weedy check; W1, tillage with one deep ploughing by disc harrow, followed by cross harrowing and cross rotavating + weeding after first irrigation-30 DAS; W2, W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha; W3, W1 + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha; W4, W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha followed by post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha and W5, weed-free condition. All the recommended packages of practices of the region were adopted during raising the good crop.

Result: The results indicated that cultivar DBW 222 produced significantly higher yield attributes, grain and straw yield as well as economic returns over the other cultivars during both years of experimentation. Among weed management practices, integrated application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha as pre-emergence followed by sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha as post-emergence (W4) remained statistically comparable with weed-free treatment (W5) and recorded superior yield attributes, yields and net returns. Maximum benefit: cost ratio was also observed under W4 owing to effective weed suppression and better crop productivity. The interaction effect between cultivars and weed management practices remained non-significant for most of the parameters studied.

Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) is a major cereal crop cultivated extensively across India and contributes significantly to national food security. However, its productivity is often constrained by heavy weed infestation during the early stages of crop growth. Weeds create intense competition for essential growth resources such as nutrients, soil moisture, sunlight and growing space, ultimately reducing crop growth and yield potential (Malik and Singh, 1995). Continuous reliance on a single weed control method, particularly repeated use of similar herbicides, has resulted in problems such as herbicide resistance, weed flora shift and decline in herbicide efficiency (Chhokar and Malik, 2017). Under these circumstances, integrated weed management practices involving tillage, herbicides and manual weeding have emerged as effective and sustainable options for maintaining crop productivity (Walia, 2010).

Apart from weed management, varietal selection also plays an important role in determining wheat productivity under varying field conditions. Different wheat cultivars vary considerably in their growth behaviour, biomass production and competitive ability against weeds (Rinwa et al., 2025). Therefore, identifying a suitable cultivar along with an efficient weed management strategy is essential for achieving higher yield and profitability. In view of the above facts, the present study was undertaken to evaluate the response of wheat cultivars to different weed management practices with respect to yield attributes, productivity and economics under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh.
Location and climate
 
The field experiment was conducted during the Rabi seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 at the Agronomy Research Farm, Janta College, Bakewar, Etawah located under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh. The experimental site is located approximately 23 km East of the district headquarters in Etawah. The site is located at 26.67° North latitude and 79.18° East longitude at an average elevation of about 142 metres above from the sea level and falls under the sub-tropical climate zone with an average of 752 mm of rain every year. The soil texture of the research farm is silty loam which makes the soil suite best for growing crops.
 
Experimental design and treatments
 
The experiment was laid out in factorial randomized block design with four replications. The treatments consisted of three wheat cultivars and six weed management practices.
 
Soil sampling
 
Composite soil samples were collected in a zig-zag manner during the fallow period before the start of the experiment and after the harvesting of the crop. Soil auger and khurpi were used to collect the samples at a depth of 15 cm from the soil surface.
 
Agricultural operation
 
The experimental field was well levelled and provided with proper irrigation and drainage facilities. The land was prepared with one disc ploughing followed by two cross harrowings to obtain a fine tilth wherever required as per treatment. The field was divided into four replications, each containing 18 plots of 15.0 m2 size (5.0 m × 3.0 m). Necessary paths, bunds and irrigation channels were prepared according to the layout. A recommended fertilizer dose of 150 kg N, 80 kg P and 60 kg K/ha was applied, wherein full phosphorus, potassium and 50% nitrogen were applied at sowing, while the remaining nitrogen was top-dressed after first irrigation during both years of experimentation. Herbicides were applied using a knapsack sprayer fitted with flat-fan nozzle as per treatment.
 
Treatment details
 
The experiment was laid out in a randomized block design with eighteen treatments replicated four times (Table 1).

Table 1: Details of the treatments applied.


 
Data collection and analysis
 
Grain yield and straw yield (q/ha)
 
From each experimental plot, the net plot area measuring 4.5 m × 2.6 m (11.7 m2) was harvested and the produce was sun-dried at-least for 3-4 days. The dried material was then threshed using a mechanical method, followed by careful cleaning and weighing. The cleaned grain yield obtained (kg/net plot) was converted into quintals per hectare (q/ha) using the appropriate conversion factor based on the net plot area. Straw yield was determined by the differential method. The grain yield was subtracted from the corresponding biological yield of each plot to obtain straw yield per hectare. The resulting values were expressed in quintals per hectare (q/ha) using the standard conversion factor.
 
Harvest index (per cent)
 
Harvest index was calculated following the method described by Singh and Stockopf (1971) using the below formula. It was expressed as a percentage. This parameter indicates the proportion of economic yield in relation to total biomass production.
 
 Gross return (₹/ha)
 
Gross return for each treatment was estimated by multiplying the yield of grain and by-products with the minimum support price (MSP) declared by the Government of India, or with the prevailing market prices in the case of by-products. The computed amount represented the total income generated per hectare (₹/ha) before deducting any cultivation costs.
 
Net return (₹/ha)
 
Net return for both years of experimentation was obtained by subtracting the total cost of cultivation of each treatment from its corresponding gross return. The resulting figure indicated the net profit or loss realized from each treatment and was expressed in ₹/ha.
 
Benefit: cost ratio
 
The benefit: cost ratio (B:C ratio) was calculated to assess the economic viability of each treatment using the formula:
 

This ratio reflects the return per unit of investment, where a value greater than one (B:C > 1) denotes a profitable treatment, while values below one indicate uneconomic outcomes.
  
Statistical analysis
 
The observations recorded on various parameters during the crop seasons of 2023-24 and 2024-25 were systematically compiled and subjected to statistical analysis using the analysis of variance (ANOVA) technique appropriate for factorial randomized block design, as described by Fisher and Yates (1948). The significance of treatment differences was evaluated at the 5 per cent level of significance.
Yield attributes
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
The yield attributes of wheat were significantly influenced by different cultivars during both years of study (Table 2). Among the tested cultivars, ‘DBW 222’ recorded the highest number of grains per ear and test weight during both crop seasons. The cultivar produced 39.41 and 38.49 grains per ear during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively. Similarly, test weight under this cultivar was also maximum, recording 41.06 g and 39.63 g during the respective years (Table 2). The superior performance of ‘DBW 222’ may be attributed to better translocation of assimilates and higher sink capacity, which ultimately improved grain development and grain filling (Singh et al., 2013). Cultivar ‘HD 2967’ occupied second position, whereas ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest values for these parameters.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
Among the weed management treatments, the weed-free treatment (W5) recorded the highest number of grains per ear (39.11 and 38.30) and test weight (40.78 and 39.84 g) in 2023-24 and 2024-24, respectively. However, it remained statistically at par with the integrated weed management treatment involving W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha followed by post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha (W4), with corresponding values of 38.65 and 37.74 grains/ear and test weight of 40.25 and 39.27 g (Table 2). Effective weed control under these treatments might have ensured better availability of nutrients, moisture and light to the crop plants, resulting in improved grain formation and filling (Singh et al., 2013). The weedy check (W0) consistently recorded the minimum values owing to severe crop-weed competition.
 
Grain yield and straw yield
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
Wheat cultivar ‘DBW 222’ recorded significantly higher grain and straw yields during both years of experimentation. This cultivar produced grain yields of 49.68 and 44.81 q/ha during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively. Straw yield under this cultivar was also maximum, recording 63.44 and 59.36 q/ha during the corresponding years (Table 2). The improved productivity of ‘DBW 222’ might be due to better growth characteristics and higher dry matter accumulation (Mishra et al., 2020). Further, ‘HD 2967’ occupied the second rank with respect to grain yield, whereas ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest grain yield during both years. In contrast, ‘PBW 343’ produced relatively higher straw yield than ‘HD 2967’, which may be associated with greater vegetative growth.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
Among the weed management practices, the weed-free treatment (W5) recorded the highest grain and straw yields during both years of experimentation and remained statistically at par with the integrated weed management treatment W4 (W1 + pendimethalin followed by sulfosulfuron). The grain yield under W5 increased by 52.78 and 62.73% over the weedy check (W0) during 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively, while W4 recorded corresponding increases of 50.33 and 59.16% (Table 2). It might be due to improving the growth and yield attributes of wheat by minimizing crop-weed competition for nutrients, moisture and light (Jitender et al., 2022; Jeet et al., 2022 and Gill and Walia, 2024). Similarly, straw yield under W5 increased by 44.72 and 52.17% over W0 during the respective years, whereas W4 registered increases of 42.97 and 48.86%. Treatment W2 also performed better than W3 and W1 in terms of grain and straw yield. The lowest grain and straw yields were recorded under the weedy check due to severe weed competition throughout the crop growth period (Table 2). The integrated application of pendimethalin followed by sulfosulfuron effectively suppressed weeds throughout the critical crop growth period, resulting in enhanced crop yield (Khatri et al., 2020).
 
Harvest index
 
Effect of wheat cultivars
 
Harvest index was significantly affected by wheat cultivars during both years of experimentation. ‘HD 2967’ recorded the highest harvest index values with 47.05 and 45.16% during both years, respectively (Table 2), indicating more efficient partitioning of assimilates towards economic yield (Singh et al., 2013). Wheat cultivar ‘PBW 343’ recorded the lowest harvest index.
 
Effect of weed management practices
 
The effect of weed management practices on harvest index remained non-significant during both years, although numerically higher values were recorded under weed-free and integrated weed management treatments (Table 2).

Table 2: Effect of weed management practices on yield attributes and yield of wheat varieties.


 
Economics
 
Cost of cultivation
 
The cost of cultivation remained similar among wheat cultivars because uniform agronomic practices were adopted for all cultivars (₹ 45583/ha). However, different weed management practices considerably affected cultivation cost (Table 3). Weed-free treatment involved the highest cultivation cost i.e. ₹ 52900/ha owing to repeated manual weeding operations, whereas the weedy check recorded minimum cultivation cost. The minimum cost of cultivation was incurred for the weedy plots (₹ 34000/ha).

Gross return and net return
 
Among the cultivars, DBW 222 recorded the highest gross and net returns during both years owing to higher grain and straw yields (Table 3) with the corresponding values of ₹ 151087 and ₹ 137557/ha for gross return and ₹ 105504 and ₹ 91974/ha for net return. Cultivar PBW 343 registered minimum gross and net returns in both the years (Table 3).

Regarding weed management practices, treatment W4 (W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha) generated maximum net return with corresponding values of ₹ 109932 and ₹ 96919/ha during first and second year, respectively. This treatment (W4) remained economically superior over the other treatments in respect of net return. Although weed-free treatment produced slightly higher gross return, its higher cultivation cost reduced the net return (Table 3). The higher economic returns was also reported in tank mixture of sulfosulfuron 75% WP + metsulfuron 20% WP (40 g/ha) applied at 25 DAS (Jeet et al., 2022).

Table 3: Gross return, net return and benefit: cost ratio of wheat varieties as influenced by weed management practices during 2023-24 and 2024-25.


 
Benefit : cost ratio
 
The highest benefit : cost ratio among cultivars was observed under DBW 222 (3.32 and 3.02 for 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively). It could be possible due to higher economic returns obtained from higher productivity under this cultivar. Cultivar HD 2967 occupied second position, whereas PBW 343 registered minimum benefit: cost ratio in both the years (Table 3).

Among weed management practices, treatment W4 (W1 + pre-emergence application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.00 kg ai/ha + post-emergence application of sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha) recorded maximum benefit: cost ratio (3.26 and 2.99 for 2023-24 and 2024-25, respectively), it might be owing to higher profitability and comparatively lower expenditure than weed-free treatment (Table 3). Jeet et al. (2022) reported that the tank mixture of Sulfosulfuron 75% WP + Metsulfuron 20% WP @ 40 g/ha at 25 DAS effectively controlled grassy and broad-leaved weeds, resulting in the significantly higher B:C ratio. 
The present investigation concluded that wheat cultivar DBW 222 performed significantly better in terms of yield attributes, yields and economic returns under the Central Plain Zone of Uttar Pradesh. Among weed management practices, treatment involving W1 (Tillage with one deep ploughing by disc harrow followed by cross harrowing and cross rotavating, along with one hand weeding after first irrigation - 30 days after sowing) + application of pendimethalin 30 EC @ 1.0 kg a.i./ha as pre-emergence followed by sulfosulfuron @ 33 g/ha as post-emergence (W4) proved most effective and economically viable. Therefore, adoption of cultivar DBW 222 along with integrated weed management treatment W4 may be recommended for achieving higher productivity and profitability in wheat cultivation under similar agro-climatic conditions.

Disclaimers
 
The content, opinions and findings expressed in this publication are the exclusive responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of their respective organizations or institutions. Although due care has been taken in preparing this work, the authors disclaim any liability for errors, omissions, or any outcomes arising from the application or interpretation of the information provided.
 
Informed consent
 
Janta College, Bakewar, Etawah, Chhatrapati Shahu Ji Maharaj University, Kanpur, Uttar Pradesh sanctioned all experimental methodologies and handling protocols.
The authors report no conflicts of interest related to this publication. Furthermore, the research was carried out without any financial support or sponsorship that could have influenced the study design, data analysis, interpretation of findings, manuscript development, or publication decisions.

  1. Chhokar, R.S. and Malik, R.K. (2017). Isoproturon-resistant littleseed canarygrass (Phalaris minor) and its response to alternate herbicides. Weed Technology. 16(1): 116-123. https://doi.org/10.1017/ wet.2016.85.

  2. Fisher, R.A. and Yates, F. (1948). The fisher-yates test of significance in 2 × 2 contingency tables. Biometrika. 35: 145-156.

  3. Gill, H.K. and Walia, U.S. (2024). Effect of planting patterns and weed competition on growth, yield and quality of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Agricultural Science Digest. 1-6. doi: 10.18805/ag.D-5966.

  4. Jeet, S., Tabassum, S., Kumar, R. and Namigial, T. (2022). Efficacy of herbicides on weed control in zero-tilled wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) in the Eastern Indo-gangetic Plains. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 56(1): 38-42. doi: 10.18805/IJARe.A-5570.

  5. Jitender, Sandeep, Singh, B. and Kumar, P. (2022). Chemical weed management in wheat-A review. Journal of Agriculture Research Technology. (Special Issue)1: 143-151.

  6. Khatri, N., Pokhrel, D., Pandey, B.P., Bista, M., Marasini, M., Paudel, G.P. and Chaurasiya, B.P. (2020). Economics and yield of wheat as affected by pre and post-emergence her bicides in western Terai Region of Nepal. Journal of Research in Weed Science. 3(2): 181-187.

  7. Malik, R.K. and Singh, S. (1995). Littleseed canarygrass (Phalaris minor Retz.) resistance to isoproturon in India. Weed Technology. 9: 419-425.

  8. Mishra, C.N., Tiwari, V., Khan, H., Kumar, S., Sharma, A.K., Singh, R., Jasrotia, P. et al. (2020). DBW222 (Karan Narendra): A new high-yielding, lodging-tolerant wheat variety for North Western plains of India. Crop Breeding and Applied Biotechnology. 20(3): 1-6.

  9. Rinwa, A., Singh, M. and Kaur, S. (2025). Weed suppression ability of wheat cultivars vary under different weed scenarios. Agricultural Research Journal. 62(1): 36-46. https://doi.org/10.5958/2395-146X.2025.00004.7.

  10. Singh, B., Dhaka, A.K., Pannu, R.K. and Kumar, S. (2013). Integrated weed management-A strategy for sustainable wheat production- A review. Agricultural Reviews. 34(4): 243- 255.

  11. Singh, I.D. and stoksopf, N.C. (1971). Harvest index in cereals. Agronomy Journal. 63(2): 224-226.

  12. Walia, U.S. (2010). Weed Management. Kalyani Publishers, New Delhi.
In this Article
Published In
Indian Journal of Agricultural Research

Editorial Board

View all (0)