An experiment was taken up to study the influence of changing weather on incidence of ULCD on popular varieties in black gram
i.e., PU-31, TBG-104 and LBG-752 during 2021-22 and 2022-23 at Agricultural Research Station, Utukur and to find out the most favourable sowing window of Black gram during
rabi season in the southern zone of Andhra Pradesh. The symptoms of ULCD include stunting of plants, crinkling, curling, puckering and rugosity on leaves. The severity of the disease depends on the variety, cropping season and weather conditions prevailing during the season. However, the effect of weather factors on the incidence of the crinkle disease was studied.
Effect of dates of sowing on leaf crinkle incidence and yield of black gram varieties
The incidence of leaf crinkle disease varied significantly with sowing dates and varieties, whereas their interaction was found to be non-significant (Table 1). The early-sowings (D1 and D2) had lower incidence, while delayed sowings (D4 and D5) experienced higher disease incidence.
Among the five sowing dates studied, D1 (I fortnight of October) recorded the lowest mean disease incidence (13.4%), followed by D3 (18.2%) and D2 (20.3%), whereas the highest incidence was observed in D5 (23.0%) followed by D4 (22.4%). Among the varieties, PU-31 recorded comparatively higher mean disease incidence (22.42%), followed by LBG 752 (19.9%), while TBG-104 showed the lowest incidence (16.02%), indicating relative tolerance to leaf crinkle disease. Overall, the results indicated that delayed sowing during December showed higher disease incidence compared to early October sowing. The present findings are in agreement with
(Sushma et al., 2022), who reported that TBG-104 as resistant, while LBG-752 and PU-31 are the moderately resistant varieties to ULCD under natural field conditions.
Among the different dates of sowings, D2 (II fortnight of October) recorded the highest mean seed yield (1194 kg ha
-1), followed by D1 (792 kg ha
-1), whereas the lowest mean was observed in D3 (I fortnight of November) (259 kg ha
-1). Early sowings (D1 and D2) recorded higher seed yield compared to delayed sowings. Among the varieties, TBG-104 registered the highest overall mean (762 kg ha
-1), followed by PU-31 (638 kg ha
-1), while LBG-752 recorded the lowest mean (564 kg ha
-1). The non-significant interaction indicated that the performance trend of varieties remained similar across different sowing dates (Table 2). In present study, it was observed that though the disease incidence in D2 sowing was relatively higher than D1, prevailing environmental conditions during reproductive stage were more favourable for crop growth, pod filling and biomass accumulation. Therefore, the negative impact of moderate disease incidence under on yield was compensated by the beneficial effect of favourable environment. Similar influence of sowing time on the disease incidence was reported by
Kadian (1989), who observed that environmental conditions prevailing during crop growth significantly affected the development of leaf crinkle disease in blackgram.
Relationship between leaf crinkle disease incidence and weather parameters
The relationship between leaf crinkle disease incidence and prevailing weather conditions also exhibited a distinct variation across sowing windows. The early sowing periods (D1 and D2) were characterized by moderate maximum temperatures (28.8-29.2°C), relatively high minimum temperatures (20-21°C), high relative humidity (RH I: 85-87%, RH II:63-70%) and substantial rainfall (111-308 mm). Under these weather conditions, comparatively lower incidence of leaf crinkle was recorded. In contrast, the delayed sowing periods (D4 and D5) experienced higher maximum temperatures (30.8-32.4°C), lower humidity (RH I: 74%, RH II: 44-52%) and very low rainfall (4-6 mm), where disease incidence was significantly higher. These findings indicate that disease development was influenced by complex interactions among weather parameters and sowing environments.
Although higher temperatures coincided with increased disease incidence under certain sowing windows, the correlation was mostly non-significant. Conversely, relative humidity showed a strong negative correlation with leaf crinkle disease occurrence. As humidity decreased, the incidence of leaf crinkle disease increased. High humidity during early sowing periods may have indirectly reduced the disease spread. Similarly, rainfall also played a crucial role, higher rainfall during October may have been less conducive for disease development, while the near absence of rainfall in November and December provided dry conditions appeared conducive for disease incidence. Therefore, early sowing, which coincides with cooler temperatures, higher humidity and occasional rainfall, provides a more favorable environment for healthy crop growth and minimizes the risk of disease.
Among the three varieties, TBG-104 consistently maintained the lowest incidence across all weather conditions, suggesting its better adaptability and tolerance to fluctuating environmental factors. In contrast, PU-31 and LBG-752 were more adversely affected by late sowing and unfavorable weather, showing higher disease incidence under increasing temperature and decreasing humidity. From this study it is suggested that, T
max with a range of 29 to 33°C while a range of T
min of 22°C and above and a diurnal temperature variation of 9°C or below can create the most favourable microclimate for disease development and possible vector activity. These observations are in agreement with those of
Kadian (1989);
Ashfaq et al. (2008) and
Dubey et al. (2019).
Kadian (1989) reported that maximum disease incidence was observed when the Maximum and Minimum temperatures are 35°C+2°C and 25°C+2°C respectively.
Ashfaq et al. (2008) found that ULCD disease progress had significant positive correlation with maximum and minimum temperatures and found no correlation with relative humidity, rainfall and wind movement.
Dubey et al. (2019) also studied on threshold temperatures for crinkle disease symptoms expression through mechanical inoculation of seeds and exposed to a fixed temperature under glasshouse conditions and found that typical ULCD symptoms were observed in the temperature range 25-38°C and they also reported that leaf crinkle incidence was significantly increased between temperature range 30-35°C and reduced at 38°C or above. Over all, the disease symptom expression is highly influenced by temperature. Furthermore, a standardized sap transmission/inoculation technique developed for ULCD can facilitate future studies on disease progression and symptom expression under controlled environmental conditions
(Teja et al., 2024).
Correlation and regression analysis
The correlation analysis revealed that most of the weather parameters showed non-significant association with leaf crinkle disease incidence in all the blackgram varieties and sowing dates (Table 3). However, significant negative correlation was observed between RH-I and disease incidence in D3 sowing across all the varieties, indicating reduction in disease incidence with increase in morning relative humidity. Similarly, RH-II exhibited significant negative correlation in D4 sowing, suggesting that higher evening relative humidity reduced disease incidence. Maximum and minimum temperatures and rainfall showed inconsistent and mostly non-significant correlation with leaf crinkle disease.
Multiple regression equations were performed using maximum temperature (T
Max), minimum temperature (T
Min), morning relative humidity (RH I), evening relative humidity (RH II) and rainfall (RF) as independent variables to quantify their combined influence on disease incidence (Table 4). The coefficient of determination (R
2) values ranged from 0.52 to 0.99, indicating moderate to very high contribution of weather factors towards disease development. Higher R
2 values were observed in D2, D3 and D4 sowings, suggesting that weather parameters had greater influence on disease incidence during these sowing periods. Relative humidity generally exhibited negative regression coefficients in most sowing dates, indicating reduction in disease incidence with increased humidity, whereas maximum temperature showed both positive and negative effects depending upon sowing time and variety. Rainfall had comparatively lesser influence on disease incidence across all sowing dates.
Although correlation and regression analysis identified individual relationships between weather variables and leaf crinkle disease incidence, they are limited in explaining multivariate interactions among meteorological factors. Therefore, principal component analysis (PCA) was performed to identify major weather variables contributing to disease development across crop growth stages and sowing environments.
Principal component analysis
Principal component analysis performed using different weather variables (Maximum temperature: T
max, minimum temperature: T
min, morning relative humidity: RH I, evening relative humidity: RH II, rainfall-RF, growing degree days: GDD, diurnal temperature ranges: DTR, rainy days: RD) across four growth stages (Vegetative, flowering, pod formation and maturity) explained 86.2% of the total variation in the first two components. PC1 alone captured 59% variation, mainly representing the overall temperature, relative humidity and accumulated heat units across all stages. PC2 explained an additional 27.2% of the variation and primarily separated the flowering- and pod-stage humidity and rainfall variables (Fig 1). The PCA correlation circle revealed strong structure among the weather variables across crop growth stages. Variables associated with temperature (T
max, T
min, GDD and DTR) showed long vectors aligned strongly with PC1, indicating that temperature-related parameters contributed most to the overall variance in the dataset. In contrast, humidity variables (RH I, RH II), rainfall and rainy days loaded predominantly on the positive side of PC2, suggesting that moisture-related factors formed an independent axis of variation. The clear separation of temperature and humidity vectors, combined with their vector lengths, indicates that thermal conditions were the dominant drivers of variability, whereas moisture-related factors explained additional but secondary variation across sowing dates and stages.
The PCA biplot (Fig 2) further revealed clear separation among sowing dates. Early sowings (D1, D2) clustered towards negative PC1, representing cooler and more humid environments, whereas late sowings (D4, D5) shifted toward positive PC1, indicating hotter and drier conditions. Varieties showed partial overlap, but TBG-104 showed lower disease incidence levels across the sowing environments, indicating better tolerance to the leaf crinkle disease. Disease incidence gradients superimposed on the PCA scatter confirmed that higher severity of leaf crinkle disease was associated with late sowing environments characterized by higher Tmax, lower RH and higher DTR.
Taken together, PCA demonstrated that stage-wise thermal and humidity environments are the primary drivers of disease development and sowing date exerts a major modifying effect by altering exposure to these critical weather factors. However, further multi-location and multi season validation may further strengthen the prediction of disease-weather relationships.