Bulk density
Bulk density of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under wheat/barley-fallow, cumin/kidney bean-fallow and vegetable based cropping systems (Table 1) ranged from 1.22 to 1.51, 1.22 to 1.44 and 1.21 to 1.32 Mg m
-3 with mean values of 1.30, 1.29 and 1.26 Mg m
-3, respectively, whereas in subsurface (0.15-0.30 m) bulk density varied from 1.27 to 1.55, 1.31 to 1.48 and 1.21 to 1.31 Mg m
-3 with mean values of 1.33, 1.35 and 1.24 Mg m
-3. The higher content of bulk density was found higher when compared to vegetable-based cropping systems, which might be attributed to the role of intensive management tillage operations and frequent applications of higher amounts of organic manure and fertilizers.
Mahajan et al., 2007; Tat and Vo (2023).
Mean weight diameter
The mean weight diameter of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under the cereal and vegetable based cropping systems ranged from 2.35 to 4.36, 2.45 to 4.49 and 3.24 to 4.88 mm with mean values of 3.41, 3.68 and 4.13 whereas, of subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) it varied from 2.25 to 4.31, 2.25 to 4.39 and 3.24 to 4.84 mm with mean values of 3.35, 3.46 and 4.06, respectively. Slightly higher values of MWD in vegetable-based cropping systems soils may be attributed to a high amount of organic matter responsible for more aggregation in soils (
Kanwar, 2016).
Water holding capacity
Water holding capacity of surface layer (0-15 cm) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 26.70 to 37.10, 31.10 to 38.10 and 22.80 to 44.10 per cent with mean values of 31.57, 32.53 and 36.87 per cent, whereas in subsurface (15-30 cm) water holding capacity varied from 27.70 to 38.10, 34.10 to 40.10 and 23.80 to 45.10 per cent with mean values of 32.66, 37.53 and 38.21 per cent, respectively. Higher WHC of subsurface and surface soil in vegetable-based cropping systems as compared to that of cereal-based may be due to less bulk density and more organic matter content. (
Khongjee, 2012) and
Kyandiah, 2012).
Soil pH
Soil pH of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems Table 2 ranged from 7.20 to 7.80, 7.20 to 7.80 and 7.20 to 7.80 with mean values of 7.51, 7.53 and 7.59 respectively, whereas in subsurface (0.15-0.30 m) soil pH varied from 7.20 to 7.70, 7.10 to 7.70 and 7.20 to 7.70 with mean value of 7.43, 7.42 and 7.45, respectively. pH values were found to increase in sub soil depth possibly due to leaching of bases.
Sharma and Kanwar (2010) and
Magota 2015.
Electrical conductivity (EC)
Electrical conductivity of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 0.49 to 0.68, 0.49 to 0.68 and 0.45 to 0.65 dS/m
-1 with mean values of 0.62, 0.62 and 0.58, respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 0.48 to 0.66, 0.47 to 0.67 and 0.44 to 0.63 dS/m-1 with mean values of 0.61, 0.61 and 0.56 dS/m
-1, respectively. The EC values, in general, decreased in the sub-surface soils which may be attributed to relatively higher concentrations of mineral nutrients in the surface layers (
Kumar, 1996).
Organic carbon (OC)
Organic carbon of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 10.1 to 14.6, 9.2 to 14.5 and 10.3 to 16.1 g kg-1 with mean values of 11.8, 11.7 and 12.8 respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), organic carbon ranged from 10.1 to 14.4, 9.1 to 14.4 and 10.1 to 16.1 g kg-1 with mean values of 11.7, 11.6 and 12.7 g kg
-1, respectively. Comparatively, higher average organic carbon under the vegetable-based system might be due to frequent additions of the FYM in the vegetable cultivation system and more biomass addition from intensive cropping. (Coskan
et al., 2012) and Ngu H
Nguyen et al., (2024).
Available nitrogen
Available nitrogen content of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems (Table 3) ranged from 287 to 419, 297 to 426 and 297 to 476 kgha
-1 with mean values of 313.93, 371.73 and 430.80 kg ha
-1, respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 286 to 418, 295 to 424 and 296 to 475 kg ha-1 with mean values of 312.53, 369.53 and 428.47 kgha-1, respectively. As such, available nitrogen was low to medium under all the cropping systems. The low to medium levels of N may be due to the cultivation of high-nutrient-requirement
(Chakrabarti et al., 2019).
Available phosphorus
Available phosphorus of surface layer (0-0.15 m) in cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 18.90 to 55.10, 29.40 to 57.10 and 30.80 to 64.90 kg ha
-1, with mean values of 43.52,42.21 and 50.43 kg ha
-1, respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) it ranged from 18.90 to 54.10, 21.40 to 56.40 and 30.10 to 63.90 kg ha-1 with mean values of 42.65, 38.89 and 49.38 kg ha
-1, respectively. Higher available P status in vegetable-based cropping systems might be due to frequent application of organic manures and fertilizers
(Reddy et al., 2006) and
(Bajpai et al., 2006).
Available potassium
Available potassium content of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 137 to 351, 187 to 350 and 220 to 360 kg ha
-1 with mean values of 286.33, 291.60 and 301.93 kg ha
-1, respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 136 to 342, 167 to 343 and 210 to 360 kg ha
-1 with mean values of 279.73, 271.00 and 295.13 kg ha
-1, respectively. The available potassium was found decreased in subsurface soil depth (
Shekar, 2009).
Available Fe
Available Fe of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems (Table 4) ranged from 5.64 to 16.32, 8.18 to 16.32, 10.18 to 18.42 mg kg
-1 with the mean values of 10.61, 11.68 and 13.21 mg kg
-1, respectively. Whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) it varied from 5.54 to16.22, 8.14 to 16.22 and 10.12 to 16.43 mg kg
-1 with the mean values of 10.21, 11.59 and 12.21 mg kg
-1, respectively. Available Fe was found decreasing in subsoil depth in all the cropping systems.
Available Mn
Available Mn of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 1.12 to 3.11, 1.21 to 3.41 and 2.11 to 4.21 mg kg
-1 with mean values of 2.12, 2.40 and 2.93 mg kg
-1, respectively. Whereas, in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) it varied from 1.11 to 3.01, 1.11 to 3.21 and 2.01 to 4.09 mg kg
-1 with mean values of 2.03, 2.25 and 2.84 mg kg
-1, respectively.
Available Zn
Available Zn in surface soil (0-0.15 m) under cereal vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 1.23 to 4.64, 1.23 to 3.55 and 1.05 to 5.78 mg kg
-1 with mean values of 2.75, 2.51 and 2.96 mg kg
-1, respectively. Likewise, in the subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 1.13 to 4.01, 1.23 to 3.15 and 1.05 to 5.72 mgkg
-1 with mean values of 2.52, 2.36 and 2.93 mg kg
-1, respectively.
Available Cu
Available content of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 0.18 to 2.77, 0.54 to 2.33 and 0.22 to 2.55 mg kg-1 with mean values of 1.06, 1.10 and 1.27 mg kg
-1, respectively, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) it ranged from 0.17 to 2.67, 0.24 to 2.23 and 0.21 to 2.45 mg kg
-1 with the mean values of 1.00, 1.00 and 1.23 mg kg
-1, respectively. Higher content of micronutrients was observed in a vegetable-based cropping system, which may be explained on the basis of higher organic carbon
(Chandel et al., 2017).
Microbial biomass carbon
Microbial biomass carbon in surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable-based cropping systems (Table 5) ranged from 223.30 to 558.40, 234.30 to 567.30 and 302.10 to 798.80 µg g
-1 with mean values of 315.81, 353.68 and 400.39 µg g
-1, whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 221.30 to 557.40, 231.30 to 560.30 and 301.10 to 794.80 µg g
-1 with mean values of 314.28, 348.75 and 398.05 µg g
-1, respectively. Higher MBC was observed by vegetable-based cropping systems.
Microbial biomass carbon
The MBN of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereal and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged from 11.20 to 34.30, 10.20 to 30.20 and 17.20 to 25.90 µg g
-1 with mean values of 17.47,19.03 and 21.56 µg g
-1, respectively. Whereas in the subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged from 10.20 to 24.30, 10.20 to 28.20 and 16.20 to 31.20 µg g
-1 with mean values of 15.87, 16.56 and 24.43 µg g
-1, respectively. Comparatively, higher microbial biomass nitrogen was recorded in the subtropical zone. This might be due to variation in temperature
(Padalia et al., 2018).
Potentially mineralizable nitraogen
The PMN of surface layer (0-0.15 m) under cereal and vegetable-based cropping systems ranged between 11.10 to 30.10, 14.40 to 31.20 and 14.40 to 37.20 µg g
-1 with mean values of 19.16, 21.37 and 22.47 µg g
-1, respectively. Likewise, in the subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m) under the respective cropping systems, it varied from 11.10 to 28.10, 13.80 to 28.20 and 13.40 to 35.20 µg g
-1 with mean values of 17.63, 19.23 and 22.27 µg g
-1, respectively. Higher potentially mineralizable nitrogen was recorded under the vegetable-based cropping system as compared to the cereal based cropping system.
Soil respiration
Soil respiration rate in surface soil (0-0.15 m) under cereals and vegetable based cropping systems ranged between 32.3 to 62.10, 29.60 to 67.80 and 32.10 to 67.10 µg CO
2 g
-1 soil with mean values of 42.27, 44.32 and 83.40 µg CO
2 g
-1 soil whereas in subsurface layer (0.15-0.30 m), it ranged between 31.30 to 61.10, 31.10 to 65.10 and 32.40 to 60.10 µg CO2 g
-1 soil with mean values of 39.21, 46.77 and 47.10 µg CO2 g
-1 soil, respectively. Among different cropping systems, higher biological parameters properties were observed in vegetable-based cropping systems. This may be due to the higher application of organics that increased levels of carbon in surface soil associated with increased levels of microbial biomass
(Nath et al., 2012).
On the basis of factor loading value and contribution percentage value, different soil quality indicators were selected (Table 6) the identified average indicators were PMN, available potassium and Mn. Whereas, indicators which were not observed with significant difference between them under cereal and vegetable based cropping systems, were discarded for the next step of MDS preparation. In principal component analysis (PCA), these non-significant variables were dropped and the variables having significant difference within production systems were used further for preparation of MDS. After scoring and weighting, the values were fed in to the additive model and finally aggregate score indicating state of soil quality was determined and the numerical value of soil quality (SQI) was obtained for each parameter of the site. On the basis of factor loading value and contribution percentage value, different soil quality indicators were selected in different agro-climatic zones for soil quality assessment under cereal and vegetable based cropping systems. Whereas, indicators which were not observed with significant difference between them under cereal and vegetable based cropping systems, were discarded for the next step of MDS preparation. In principal component analysis (PCA), these non-significant variables were dropped and the variables having significant difference within production systems were used further for preparation of MDS. After scoring and weighting (Table 7) the values were fed in to the additive model and finally aggregate score indicating state of soil quality was determined and the numerical value of soil quality (SQI) was obtained for each parameter of the site.
Soil quality index
Highly weighted variables Table 8 and 9 (MDS) for assessment of soil quality were available N, P, Mn and PMN. Highly weighted variables which got higher factor loading under Principal component analysis (PCA) or minimum data set (MDS) for assessment of soil quality under cereal and vegetable-based cropping systems. All the factor loadings on PCs were discarded for MDS formation because the eigen value was less than 1 and it is assumed that PCs receiving higher eigen value are only the best to represent the variation between the systems. Therefore, only the PCs with eigen values >1 were examined and considered for MDS (minimum data set) preparation (
Kaiser, 1960). The higher value of the index implies that soil quality under that cropping system is better compared to others. In the present investigation, we have observed better SQ under vegetable-based cropping systems. This indicates that in vegetable-based cropping systems, soil generally does not deteriorate the physical, chemical and biological soil quality indicator, whereas the poorest SQ observed in this study was found under cereal based cropping systems.
The higher value of index (Table 10) implied that SQ under that cropping system is better compared to other. Better soil quality was observed under vegetable based cropping systems. This indicates that in vegetable based cropping systems soil generally does not deteriorate the physical, chemical and biological SQ indicator. The poorest SQ observed in this study was found under cereal based cropping systems.