The results showed that PEG stress and genotype significantly influenced the formation of embryogenic callus. Increasing PEG concentration from 0% to 20% led to a decrease in callus formation across all genotypes. The percentage of embryogenic callus formation of soybean mutant lines on media containing 0% and 20% PEG 6000 is presented in Table 1.
Table 1 showed that the percentage of embryogenic callus decreased under PEG 20% compared to PEG 0%. Among the tested genotypes, the mutant line A3 and A5 maintained the highest callus formation under PEG 20% (74.4% and 70.2%), followed by the A4 and A2 mutant lines and the drought-tolerant check Dering (64%). In contrast, the parental variety Argomulyo exhibited the lowest percentage of callus formation (49.8%) under stress conditions. These findings are consistent with
Saepudin et al. (2017) who found that PEG 6000 at 15-20% concentration effectively differentiated tolerant and sensitive soybean lines. Similarly,
Hartati et al. (2018) observed a significant decline in callus formation in sugarcane with increasing PEG concentration, yet tolerant genotypes exhibited better callus survival.
The reduction of water potential in the culture medium caused by PEG not only affected callus growth but also limited the ability of callus cells to form embryogenic tissues capable of somatic embryo differentiation. Similar observations were reported by
Tereso et al. (2007), who found that reduced osmotic potential inhibited cellular differentiation in embryogenic callus cultures. The inhibitory effects of PEG may also be associated with decreased levels of endogenous polyamines in explant tissues under osmotic stress.
In this study, mutant lines A2-A5 produced a higher number of somatic embryos at 20% PEG compared with the parent variety Argomulyo (Table 1). However, a significant reduction in the growth rate of embryogenic callus was observed, particularly in mutant A4, when exposed to 20% PEG. The addition of PEG to the medium reduces the free water content, leading to osmotic stress that interferes with nutrient and water uptake by the cells (
Li and Zhang, 2012). At higher PEG concentrations, callus development, proliferation and embryoid survival were strongly inhibited. This may be explained by the ability of PEG’s ethylene oxide subunits to retain water molecules through hydrogen bonding, thereby reducing the availability of free water in the medium
(Sayar et al., 2010).
Fig 1 presents the general appearance of callus formation from soybean mutant lines and control varieties cultured under different PEG treatments. Callus induction occurred in all genotypes, both under normal and PEG-supplemented media. However, visible differences in callus proliferation were observed between genotypes and PEG concentrations. Under 0% PEG, callus proliferation appeared more extensive, while at 20% PEG, the growth was visibly reduced, reflecting the osmotic stress effect of PEG on tissue development. These visual observations correspond with quantitative data showing a decline in embryogenic callus formation under PEG treatment (Table 1).
The fresh weight of embryogenic callus decreased significantly with increasing PEG concentration (Table 2). All genotypes exhibited reduced callus biomass under PEG 20% compared to PEG 0%, indicating that osmotic stress limited cell expansion and water uptake. However, mutant lines A3 and A4 maintained relatively high fresh weights (0.66-0.63 g), comparable to the drought-tolerant check Dering (0.64 g), whereas the parental variety Argomulyo showed the lowest value (0.45 g).
This reduction in fresh weight under PEG stress reflects the inhibition of cell turgor and the consequent decline in tissue hydration, as PEG decreases the water potential of the culture medium (
Li and Zhang, 2012). The relatively high biomass in mutants A3 and A4 suggests improved physiological adaptation to osmotic stress, possibly through the accumulation of compatible solutes such as proline and soluble sugars that help maintain water balance. This finding supports the use of in vitro PEG selection as a reliable approach to identify drought-tolerant soybean genotypes before field evaluation.
Fresh and actively proliferating embryogenic calli of soybean mutant lines derived from gamma irradiation showed varying responses to PEG stress. Under control conditions (0% PEG), the calli exhibited compact, yellowish and friable structures with high proliferation rates, whereas under 20% PEG, the calli became brownish and exhibited reduced growth and water content. These morphological differences clearly indicate the effect of osmotic stress induced by PEG on callus viability and proliferation (Fig 2 and 3).
Table 3 showed that both fresh and dry weights of embryogenic callus were significantly affected by PEG treatment. A consistent decrease was observed as PEG concentration increased from 0% to 20%. Under stress conditions, mutant A3 recorded the highest callus fresh weight (0.66 g), followed by A5 (0.63 g) and Dering (0.64 g), while Argomulyo and A2 showed the lowest values. The same pattern was observed for dry weight, where a 25-40% reduction occurred under PEG stress compared with the control treatment.
PEG stress reduces cell turgor and limits the uptake of water, thereby decreasing biomass accumulation. The ability of certain lines (A3, A5 and Dering) to maintain higher fresh and dry weights under osmotic stress indicates better osmotic adjustment capacity. According to
Jasmine et al. (2022), under osmotic stress, tolerant plants accumulate proline, which helps balance osmotic potential between the cytosol, vacuole and outside medium, thereby reducing water loss and protecting cells. These results suggest that callus biomass can be used as an early indicator of drought tolerance in soybean.
PEG application significantly reduced the percentage of plantlet regeneration in all genotypes. However, mutants A3 and A5 exhibited higher regeneration percentages (29.67% and 26.45%, respectively) compared to the control varieties. These lines also produced longer roots (2.88-3.02 cm) under PEG stress, indicating better root growth and adaptation to low water potential (Table 4 and Table 5). Reduction in regeneration capacity under PEG stress is commonly associated with limited water availability and hormonal imbalance in cultured tissues. Nevertheless, the high regeneration response of mutants A3 and A5 indicates their ability to maintain active cell division and organogenesis even under osmotic stress. These findings align with the report of
Hartati et al. (2018) that drought-tolerant genotypes tend to maintain morphogenic activity due to improved turgor regulation.
The enhanced regeneration ability observed in mutant A3 may also be related to gamma-ray-induced modifications in gene expression related to stress adaptation and antioxidative defense, as suggested by
Kadhimi et al. (2016). Thus, the combination of gamma irradiation and PEG-based in vitro selection is effective in identifying mutant lines with superior regenerative capacity under stress conditions.
The values presented in Table 6 represent the drought sensitivity index (S), which was calculated according to
Fischer and Maurer (1978). This index quantifies the relative reduction in a genotype’s performance under drought compared to normal conditions. Based on the classification, genotypes with S < 0.5 are considered highly tolerant, those with 0.5 ≤ S < 1.0 are moderately tolerant and those with S > 1.0 are sensitive to drought stress.
The results showed that mutant lines A2 and A3 exhibited the lowest S values across all parameters, including callus fresh and dry weight, plantlet height and root length, indicating that these lines were the most tolerant to drought stress. In particular, mutant line A3 (300 Gy) consistently displayed low S values (0.37-0.80), indicating strong osmotic adjustment and stable growth under PEG-induced osmotic stress. In contrast, the parental Argomulyo variety showed the highest S index (S > 1.0) for all traits, confirming its sensitivity to drought. The drought-tolerant check Dering showed moderate tolerance (S = 0.71-1.01), consistent with its known field performance under water-limited conditions.
Mutant lines A4 and A5 showed intermediate responses, with some parameters (particularly root length and dry weight) approaching the sensitivity threshold (S ≈ 1.0). These results indicate that the gamma irradiation treatment, especially at 300 Gy, effectively induced beneficial genetic variability associated with improved drought tolerance. The enhanced tolerance observed in A2 and A3 mutant lines may be attributed to their ability to maintain water balance, cell turgor and growth stability under osmotic stress.
Analysis of variance for yield under drought conditions is shown in Table 7. The data indicated significant differences among the mutant lines and control varieties grown under dry land conditions. The mutant soybean lines showed higher yield potential than the Argomulyo and Dering variety. Among all genotypes tested, the mutant line A3 recorded the highest mean yield of 2.47 t ha
-1, followed by A5 with 2.40 t ha
-1 and A4 with 2.30 t ha
-1. The lowest yield was observed in the parental variety Argomulyo (1.85 t ha
-1).
These results demonstrated that the selected mutant lines, particularly A3 and A5, maintained higher yield stability under water-limited conditions. The improvement in yield could be associated with the better physiological adaptation of these mutant lines, as reflected by their lower drought sensitivity index values (Table 6). This suggests that the mutation treatment effectively produced genotypes capable of maintaining productivity under drought stress.
A similar increase in grain yield under drought conditions due to mutation induction has also been reported in other crops
(Kadhimi et al., 2016). The consistent yield performance of mutant lines A3 and A5 in both dry land locations indicates their stability and adaptability to marginal environments. These findings confirm that mutation breeding combined with in vitro selection can be an effective approach to developing drought-tolerant soybean lines suitable for cultivation in dry areas.
The results from both
in vitro and field evaluations clearly demonstrated the positive impact of gamma-ray-induced mutation on improving drought tolerance and yield performance in soybean. The
in vitro selection using PEG 6000 as an osmotic agent effectively differentiated tolerant genotypes and the same lines (A2 and A3) also performed well under field conditions. Therefore, the in vitro screening technique developed in this study could serve as a reliable preliminary method for identifying drought-tolerant soybean genotypes. The consistent performance of mutant lines A3 and A5 across various environments further supports the potential use of mutation breeding combined with in vitro selection as an effective approach to developing drought-tolerant soybean varieties suitable for dryland cultivation in Indonesia.