Observations on whitefly population, per cent disease incidence, seed yield and 1000 seed weight were recorded in the experiment.
Effect of different insecticides on whitefly population transmitting YMD in horsegram
After first spray (30 DAS), the results revealed that treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] recorded lowest mean whitefly population of 2.86, with highest per cent reduction over control of about 69.14 per cent. This was followed by T
2 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS 5 ml/kg seeds followed by spray with imidacloprid 350 SC at 0.3 ml/l], which had mean whitefly population of 3.69 and per cent reduction over control was 60.18 per cent. The highest mean whitefly population of 9.26 was recorded in the control plot (Table 3).
After second spray (45 DAS), the results revealed that treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] recorded lowest mean whitefly population of 2.53, with highest per cent reduction over control of about 71.73 per cent. This was followed by T
2 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS 5 ml/kg seeds followed by spray with imidacloprid 350 SC at 0.3 ml/l], which had mean whitefly population of 2.98 and per cent reduction over control was 66.70 per cent. The highest mean whitefly population of 8.95 was recorded in the control plot (Table 4).
After third spray (60 DAS), the results revealed that treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] recorded lowest mean whitefly population of 2.08, with highest per cent reduction over control of about 74.91 per cent. This was followed by T
2 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS 5 ml/kg seeds followed by spray with imidacloprid 350 SC at 0.3 ml/l], which had mean whitefly population of 2.99 and per cent reduction over control was 63.85 per cent. The highest mean whitefly population of 8.27 was recorded in the control plot (Table 5).
At physiological maturity, the results revealed that treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] recorded lowest mean whitefly population of 3.25, with highest per cent reduction over control of about 60.80 per cent. This was followed by T
2 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS 5 ml/kg seeds followed by spray with imidacloprid 350 SC at 0.3 ml/l], which had mean whitefly population of 3.99 and per cent reduction over control of 51.87 per cent. The highest mean whitefly population of 8.29 was recorded in the control plot (Table 6).
Effect of different insecticides on the incidence of YMD in horsegram
The data analysis from the experiment revealed that treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] three times at 15-day intervals resulted in the lowest disease incidence of 4.55, 10.05, 16.18 and 23.86 per cent at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, 60 DAS and at physiological maturity, respectively with 59.46 per cent disease reduction over control, followed by T
2 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS 5 ml/kg seeds followed by spray with imidacloprid 350 SC at 0.3 ml/l] with disease incidence of 4.68, 11.86, 19.11 and 30.38 per cent at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, 60 DAS and at physiological maturity, respectively with 52.45 per cent disease reduction over control. The highest incidence was observed in the control plot with 11.85, 25.67, 42.38 and 58.85 per cent at 30 DAS, 45 DAS, 60 DAS and at physiological maturity, respectively (Plate 2, Table 7).
Effect of different insecticides in the management of HgYMD with respect to 1000 seed weight, seed yield and benefit: Cost ratio
Thousand seed weight was recorded in all treatment blocks after harvest, the highest 1000 seed weight was recorded in T
7 (40.56 g), followed by T
4 (39.82 g), T
2 (39.04 g), T
3 (38.53 g), T6 (38.17 g), T
8 (37.22 g), T10 (37.05 g) and T
11 (36.29 g). The least 1000 seed weight was recorded in control treatment T
12 (34.33 g), followed by T
1 (35.09 g), T
9 (35.21 g) and T
5 (35.24 g).
The yield was notably superior in chemical treatment T
7 [seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg of seeds followed by spray with (pyriproxyfen 5% + diafenthiuron 25%) 30% SE at 2 ml/1] (6.91 q/ha) with gross return of 37590.40 Rs/ha and net return of 15326.40 Rs/ha with B:C ratio of 1.69. But in T
4 treatment with an yield of 6.02 q/ha, the gross returns and net returns was 32748.80 Rs/ha and 14699.20 Rs/ha, respectively and B:C ratio was 1.81, which was highest when compared to T
7 treatment because of difference in cost of chemicals. Whereas, control treatment (T
12) recorded the lowest yield of 3.24 q/ha with 17625.60 Rs/ha gross returns and net returns of 1975.60 Rs/ha with 1.13 B:C ratio (Table 8).
Similar results were obtained by
Hugar et al., (2020) who conducted the field experiments during
Kharif, 2016 and 2017 on the evaluation of a combi-product (diafenthiuron 30% + pyriproxyfen 8% SE) efficacy against whiteflies on cotton. The pooled data of two seasons as impact of three sprays revealed 89.00 per cent reduction of whitefly in (diafenthiuron 30% + pyriproxyfen 8% SE) at 1200 ml/ha applied treatment.
The results were also in agreement with
Prasad et al., (2024) who conducted field experiment during
Rabi 2020-21 to evaluate the efficacy of nine insecticides against whitefly. The results revealed that diafenthiuron 50 WP at 1.25 g/l was most effective in reducing the whitefly population (75.23%) and YMD incidence (13.51%) followed by spiromesifen 240 SC at 1.0 ml/l (65.19% and 17.17%) and thiomethoxam 25 WG at 0.2 g/l (54.64% and 21.27%), while thiocloprid 21.7 SC at 1.0 ml/l (20.21% and 48.88%) and spinoteram 11.7 SC at 1.0 ml/l (25.16% and 43.91%).
The field experiment conducted on management of whiteflies vectoring YMD of blackgram by using different combination of insecticides revealed that seed treatment with imidacloprid 600 FS at 5 ml/kg seed + foliar spray of (pyriproxifen 5% + difenthuron 25% SE) at 2 ml/ l achieved the highest reduction of whitefly population over control, lowest disease incidence and maximum yield of 7.87 q/ha with the highest B: C ratio of 2.89 (
Swapna and Prema, 2025).