Chief EditorJ. S. Sandhu
Print ISSN 0250-5371
Online ISSN 0976-0571
NAAS Rating 6.67
Impact Factor 0.8 (2023)
Full Research Article
Development of Genotypes for Foliar Disease Resistance in Mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek] through Recombination and Mutation Breeding
- Email firstname.lastname@example.org
Methods: A series of field experiments spanned over seven years (2014-2021) were conducted at Main Agricultural Research Station, University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad, Karnataka. In the first set of experiments, the material comprised of eight varieties of greengram which were treated with 20kR gamma radiation. M1was planted in Kharif 2014 and each variety was bulk harvested. M2 was planted in summer 2014 and individual plant selection was carried out. Mutant families were advanced to the further generation in Kharif 2015 and Rabi 2015. The M2 mutants were scored for their reaction to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases with respective susceptible and resistant checks. In another set of experiments aimed at developing MYMV tolerant genotypes, an investigation was carried out with 168 F2 individuals derived from crossing Vigna trilobata and DGGV2. One row infector line of DGGV-2 was raised after every three test entries to study the reaction to MYMV. Three rows of susceptible check was planted all around the border to ensure enough inoculum load. Of the 168 F2 individuals, two lines showed resistance to MYMV. They were stabilized through a series of selfing generations.
Result: Evaluation of advanced breeding lines for their reaction to various foliar diseases revealed that the advanced breeding lines DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-208, DGG-21, DGG-80, DGG-273, DGG-274, DGG-275, DGG-262, DGG-263, DGG-264, DGG-82, DGG-200, TARM-1 (C), DGG-215-5, DGG-302, DGG-152, IPM-3-2, DGG-20, DGG-73, IPM-14-10, DGG-121, DGG-250, DGG-109, DGG-96 had seed yields ranging from 9.8 g to 12.4 g and moderately resistant to both anthracnose and CLS. The breeding lines DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-21, DGG-273, IPM-3-2 (Check), DGG-96 have recorded combined resistance to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases.
Diseases are the major problem for greengram cultivation which has a devastating effect on both quantity and quality of the product. Greengram suffers from many diseases caused by fungi, bacteria, viruses, nematodes and also abiotic stresses. Among these, foliar diseases such as powdery mildew, anthracnose, Cercospora leafspot and mung bean Yellow Mosaic Virus (MYMV) are more prevalent.
Powdery mildew is caused by a fungal pathogen Erysiphae polygoni. It is one of the widespread diseases of green gram. More severe symptoms of this diseases are usually observed on 35 to 40 days old crop (during flowering and pod stage) causing upto 40 per cent (Khajudparn et al., 2007) yield losses. White powdery patches appear on leaves and other green parts which later become dull coloured. In severe infections, foliage becomes yellow causing premature defoliation. The fungus is ectophytic, spreading on the surface of the leaf, sending haustoria into the epidermal cells.
Anthracnose is a severe concern for greengram grown in hot, humid climates. It results in both qualitative and quantitative losses (Sharma et al., 1971). Colletotrichum lindemuthianum is the cause. The disease can affect any section of the plant’s aerial components and at any stage of development. On leaves and pods, the circular, black, sunken dots with a dark center and bright red-orange edges will appear (Mogali and Hegde, 2020). The damaged parts wither away in severe infections. Soon after seed germination, seedlings get blighted due to infection. Anthracnose-related yield losses have been estimated to be between 24-67 per cent (Deeksha and Tripathi, 2002).
Cercospora leaf spot of greengram is wide spread in India. Cercospora cenescens attack wide range of pulses including greengram which causes 23 to 27 per cent yield loses. Symptoms appear mainly in the above ground parts of the plant. Irregular small light brown spots measuring 2.50 to 5.00 mm, usually with grey centers and red margin are produced. These spots coalesce and cover large areas and sometime entire leaf area is engulfed resulting in death.
Mungbean plants infected with YMD generally show yellowing or chlorosis of leaves followed by necrosis, shortening of internodes and severe stunting of plants with no yield or few flowers and deformed pods produced with small, immature and shriveled seeds. It can cause yield loss of about 75-100 per cent, depending on disease incidence, virus strains, mungbean genotypes and interaction between these factors.
The management of these diseases using chemicals is a costly affair and not environmentally safe. Hence deploying genetically resistant cultivars would be cost-effective, practically feasible, eco- and farmer-friendly and a viable alternative. To address these issues breeding efforts were done to develop genotypes with resistance to various foliar diseases.
The PDI of the diseases was further subjected to arc sine transformation and was then analysed using R software version 4.2.1 to know whether the breeding lines differed significantly for their reaction to these diseases.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
A series of field experiments spanned over seven years (2014-2021) were conducted at F block, AICRP on MULLaRP, Main Agricultural Research Station, University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad, Karnataka, India, geopositioned at 15°26' North latitude, 75°07' East longitude and at an altitude of 750 m above the Mean Sea Level and located in the North Western transitional agro-climatic zone of Karnataka.
In the first set of experiments, the material comprised of six varieties of greenram viz., LGG-460, VGG rul, Sonamung, IPM-2-3, IPM 2-17 and Vamban-2 which were crossed in different combinations and the resulting F1s were treated with 20kR gamma radiation. F1M1was planted in Kharif 2014 and each variety was bulk harvested. F1M2 was planted in summer 2014 and individual plant selection was carried out. Mutant families were advanced to the further generation in Kharif 2015 and Rabi 2015. The F2M2 mutants were scored for their reaction to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases with respective susceptible and resistant checks. The seeds selected from F2M2 population were sown as SPS (single plant selection) Kharif 2016 to observe for their characters and reaction to various foliar diseases. Based on the field observations, a few F3M3 progenies were selected and forwarded to F4M4 generation. Further the families conferring resistance to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases were selected and stabilized through a series of selfing generations.
In another set of experiments aimed at developing MYMV tolerant genotypes, an investigation was carried out with 195 F2 individuals derived from crossing vigna trilobata and DGGV 2. Each entry was sown in single row of three meter length with the spacing of 30 × 10 cm in two replications. One row infector line of DGGV-2 was raised after every three test entries to study the reaction to MYMV. Three rows of susceptible check was planted all around the border to ensure enough inoculum load. All the recommended agronomic practices were followed. No insecticidal spray was given in order to allow the whitefly population to spread the disease. Disease incidence was recorded periodically. Of the 195 F2 individuals, four lines DGG125, DGG 96, DGG 218 and DGG 263 Showed resistance to MYMV, DGG 302, DGG 201, DGG 126 and DGG 128 recorded moderate resistance to MYMV (Table 2). They were stabilized through a series of selfing generations till summer 2021.
Screening for foliar diseases
Through the seasons, kharif 2019 to 2021, the test genotypes and the checks were screened for fungal diseases i.e., anthracnose, cercospora powdery mildew and MYMV. One set of experiment was conducted with all the recommended cultivation and disease management practices. Another set of experiment was laid out during the same season in the vicinity of the first experimental plot under unprotected conditions. Resistant and susceptible checks for all the foliar diseases were used in the experiments. For disease reaction, percentage of leaf area covered by the disease was scored manually. The incidence of disease on the leaves of mungbean was scored by using standard scoring procedure given by Mayee and Datar (1986). The percentage was then converted to the disease score and the per cent disease index was calculated using the formula given by Wheeler (1969). Further the per cent yield reduction of each breeding line due to these diseases was calculated using the yield data from both protected and unprotected conditions.
During summer 2021, the recombinants derived from crossing DGGV2 and Vigna trilobata were screened for their reaction to MYMV In this season also two experiments (protected and unprotected conditions) were laid using augmented design. DGGV-2 was used as a susceptible check whereas IPM-2-14 was used as resistant check. The per cent disease incidence was calculated by using the formulae given by Bashir et al., (2006) at 45 DAS, 60 DAS and physiological maturity. Based on the percent disease incidence, the genotypes were categorized into different groups.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
Incidence of Powdery mildew (PDI 80.0), cercospora leaf spots (PDI 77.4) was more during 2016-2018 due to less receipt of rainfall of 435, 539, 496 mm during 2016, 2017 and 2018 respectively when compared to normal rainfall of 500-700 mm.
During 2019-2020 anthracnose disease was very severe and recorded maximum PDI of 85.22 as the rainfall received was almost double (1259 and 931 mm during 2019 and 2020 respectively) when compared to normal rainfall. MYMV incidence was more during Kharif 2020 in mungbean (70 to 80%) due exposure of crop to long dry spell during seedling stage. Moderate temperature with higher humidity and frequent rains increases the disease attack. Greengram is more sensitive to erratic rainfall with uneven distribution.Further rains during flowering and pod filling stage affect the greengram yield.
The results were similar to the observations made by Kulkarni and Benagi (2012) who concluded that, the late sown crop suffered more because of coincidence of the favourable period like moderate temperature coupled with higher humidity and frequent rains with stage of the crop. Model based seasonal analysis showed that the greengram is more sensitive to change in rainfall than temperature (Sagar and Patil, 2020). Changes in erratic rainfall patterns projected under future climates are going to affect the performance and productivity of greengram and urdbean crops, especially under rainfed condition.
Anthracnose (Colletotrichum lindemuthianum) is a major problem of greengram cultivated in hot and humid areas. In northern Karnataka losses in yield and disease incidence of anthracnose have been estimated to be in the range of 24 to 67 per cent (Deeksha and Tripathi 2002a) and 18.20 to 86.57 per cent respectively (Laxman 2006). Therefore current study was aimed at development of anthracnose tolerant genotypes. Kharif -2019 season was highly favourable for anthracnose disease development as there was incidence of heavy rainfall (857.2 mm) in the initial stage of growth, with temperature of 21°C, relative humidity of 94-95 per cent and wind speed of 5-6 km/hr. In the month of august-2020, a total of 451 mm rainfall was received as against the normal rainfall of 70-100 mm (Graph 1). This disrupted the crop during its grand-growth period. In the initial days of development the incidence was very low. During 45-65 days after sowing the incidence of anthracnose drastically increased, varying from 60-90 per cent.
Evaluation of hundred breeding lines developed by various breeding methods for anthracnose disease on a scale of 0 to 9 (Mayee and Datar 1986) revealed that the breeding lines DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-208, DGG-21, DGG-80, Sonamung, DGG-273, DGG-274, DGG-275, DGG-262, DGG-263, DGG-264, DGG-82, DGG-200, TARM-1 (C), DGG-215-5, DGG-302, DGG-152, IPM-3-2, DGG-20, DGG-73, IPM-14-10, DGG-121, DGG-250, DGG-109, DGG-96 recorded moderately resistant reaction with PDI of 25, 16.6, 13.33and 16.66 per cent respectively. Resistant reaction was recorded by IPM-2-14 with PDI 12.8 per cent. Agronomicaly superior ocal check DGGV-2 showed susceptible reaction with PDI of 62 per cent and DGG-7 showed moderately susceptible reaction with PDI of 40 per cent .These breeding lines can be utilized in breeding programes aimed at developing anthracnose resistant greengram varieties, which can augment the yielding potential under varied climatic conditions.
Reaction of advanced breeding lines to Anthracnose disease during kharif-2021
In the present study, a set of forty breeding lines derived from F7 generation were screened for Anthracnose disease with susceptible and resistant checks during kharif-2021. The kharif season was highly favourable as there was receipt of heavy rainfall (338.94 mm) in the initial stage of growth, with a temperature of 21.62°C, relative humidity of 85.8 percent and wind speed of 5.85 m/s. In the month of August-2021, a total of 307.42 mm rainfall was received as against the normal rainfall of 109.5 mm. This disrupted the crop during its grand-growth period. In the initial days of development, the incidence was very low. During 45-65 days after sowing the incidence of anthracnose drastically increased, varying from 60-90 percent. Hence, the per plant yield was very low as there was a heavy incidence of foliar disease. Among ninety breeding lines, twenty-two breeding lines have recorded moderately resistant reactions to anthracnose with good performance and yield. The rest of the genotypes showed susceptibility to a highly susceptible reaction. However, the resistance has to be confirmed over seasons before including in the hybridization program. Close results were observed by Marak et al., (2018).
Correlation between Anthracnose disease and yield parameters
Anthracnose disease correlation study with yield contributing traits provides insight into reduced yield in anthracnose susceptible lines, vis a vis high yield in anthracnose resistant lines. All yield-attributing variables, such as number of branches per plant, number of pods per plant and number of seeds per pod, were found to be negatively correlated with per cent disease incidence in a correlation study. With the exception of percent disease infection, all yield indices exhibited a positive correlation with seed yield per plant. We may deduce that when disease incidence is high, the seed yield per plant will be reduced. Similar results were revealed in the study of Rekha et al., (2020); Nair et al., (2019).
On correlation analysis of Per cent disease Infection (PDI) of anthracnose and yield attributing traits, it is observed that PDI value increased as we move from highly susceptible genotypes to moderately resistant genotypes. seed yield per plant showed a slight increase as we move from susceptible genotypes to resistant genotypes.
The advanced breeding lines viz., DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-208, DGG-21, DGG-80, DGG-273, DGG-274, DGG-275, DGG-262, DGG-263, DGG-264, DGG-82, DGG-200, TARM-1 (C), DGG-215-5, DGG-302, DGG-152, IPM-3-2, DGG-20, DGG-73, IPM-14-10, DGG-121, DGG-250, DGG-109, DGG-96 had seed yields ranging from 9.8 g to 12.4g, with a per cent incidence of 11-20 per cent, making these genotypes moderately resistant to both anthracnose and CLS ( Table 1). Seed yields of susceptible lines DGGV-230, DGGV-303, DGGV-306 and DGGV-193 ranged from 3.04 g to 4.66 g, with PDIs ranging from 50.10 to 64.8 per cent. As a result of the preceding findings, it can be concluded that percent disease incidence is negatively correlated to yield contributing features, particularly seed yield per plant. Similar results were drawn by Kiptoo et al., (2020), in which the results revealed tolerant and resistant genotypes with lower incidences and severity than those of resistant controls while susceptible genotypes recorded higher incidences and severity than those of the susceptible controls.
Green gram yield enhancement has been a challenge due to the existence of pests and diseases (Mogali and Hegde (2020). During the summer season from January to March-2021 rainfall was in the range of 3.4 mm to 12.44 mm, the maximum mean temperature was in the range of 30.62°C to 37.51°C, minimum mean temperature was in the range of 16.21°C to 19.73°C, mean relative humidity of 44.9 per cent to 63.4 per cent and wind speed of 1.67 m/s to 1.93 m/s at 2 meters and 2.59 m/s to 2.94 m/s at 10 meters. These conditions were congenial for the spread of MYMV through whiteflies. In the current study, it was observed that the disease incidence was much higher in the summer than in the other seasons, ranging from 0 to 100 per cent.
During the summer of 2021, thirty-seven of the 112 breeding lines produced from the F6 generation showed moderate resistance response, with per cent disease incidence of 0 to 64. Even though we looked at the mean percent disease incidence values of breeding lines from a certain cross as a whole, when we looked at each progeny row separately, some of the breeding lines showed resistance to the MYMV. As a result, the identified resistance lines can be used for further reactivity confirmation as well as the use of certain progenies in breeding programs to produce Mungbean Yellow Mosaic Virus (MYMV) resistant cultivars with good performance. Similar results were observed by Kingsly et al., (2015); Sudha et al., (2013); Kabi et al., (2017) and Dharajiya et al., (2018). The ABLs DGG 302, DGG201, DGG126, DGG 128, DGG237 have recorded moderate resistance to MYMV,while DGG 125,DGG 96, DGG218, DGG263 and Accession no 436714 have recorded resistance to MYMV (Table 2 ).
The current investigation emphasized on development of greengram genotypes tolerant to biotic stresses like anthracnose, CLS, powdery mildew and MYMV through recombination, followed by mutation breeding and also pedigree method. The advanced breeding lines viz., DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-208, DGG-21, DGG-80, DGG-273, DGG-274, DGG-275, DGG-262, DGG-263, DGG-264, DGG-82, DGG-200, TARM-1 (C), DGG-215-5, DGG-302, DGG-152, IPM-3-2, DGG-20, DGG-73, IPM-14-10, DGG-121, DGG-250, DGG-109, DGG-96 have recorded moderate resistance to both anthracnose and CLS. Further the breeding lines DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-21, DGG-273, IPM-3-2 (check), DGG-96 have recorded combined resistance to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases (Table 3). None of the genotypes are comparable to the desirable pod features and high yield potential of the released agronomically superior and popular variety DGGV-2. Hence all these traits can be introgressed and back crossed to DGGV-2 to breed high yielding genotypes conferring tolerance to the major biotic stresses prevalent in the area.
The breeding lines DGG-203, DGG-206, DGG-21, DGG-273, IPM-3-2 (check), DGG-96 have recorded combined resistance to anthracnose, cercospora leaf spot and powdery mildew diseases. (Plate 1).
CONFLICT OF INTEREST
- Bashir, M., Ahmad, Z. and Mansoor, S. (2006), Occurrence and distribution of viral diseases of mungbean and mashbean in Punjab. Pak. J. Bot. 38(4): 1341-1351.
- Deeksha, J. and Tripathi, H.S. (2002). Cultural, biological and chemical control of anthracnose of urdbean. J. Mycol Plant Pathol. 32(1): 52-55.
- Dharajiya, D.T., Ravindrababu, Y. and Pagi, N.K. (2018). Screening of Mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek] genotypes for resistance against Mungbean yellow mosaic virus (MYMV) under field condition. Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. Sci. 7(5): 3472-3483.
- Kabi, M., Das, T.R. and Baisakh, B. (2017). Screening of superior genotypes for cold tolerance and MYMV resistance in green gram (Vigna radiata). Int. J. Curr. Microbiol. App. Sci. 6(12): 2270-2276.
- Kajjidoni S.T., Roopalaksmi, K.V., Immadi, S., Nagaral, R. (2008). Developing an improved variety utilizing both gamma rays induced and recombinational variability in blackgram [Vigna mungo (L.) Hepper]. International Symposium on Induced Mutations in Plants. 12-15 August 2008 Vienna, Austria.
- Khajudparn, P., Wongkaew, S. and Thipyapong, P. (2007). Identification of genes for resistance to powdery mildew in mungbean. Breed. Sci. 8: 743-745.
- Kingsly, N.B.J., Packiaraj, D., Pandiyan, M. and Senthil, N. (2015). Screening of mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek] genotypes for resistance to yellow mosaic virus. Trends Biosci. 8(8): 2042-2046.
- Kiptoo, G.J., Kinyua, M.G., Kiplagat, O.K. and Matasyoh, L.G. (2020). Incidence and severity of anthracnose (Colletotrichum lindemuthianum) on selected common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) genotypes. Agric. Res. 5: 84. DOI:10.28933/ ajar-2019-09-2705.
- Kulkarni, S.A. and Benagi, V.I. (2012). Effect of date of sowing and correlation of weather parameters on the incidence of anthracnose of greengram. Internat. J. Plant Protec. 5(2): 349-351.
- Laxman, R. (2006). Studies on Leaf Spot of Green Gram Caused by Colletotrichum truncatum (Schw.) Andrus and Moore. M. Sc. (Agri.) thesis, University of Agricultural Sciences, Dharwad (India).
- Majhi, P.K., Mogali, S.C. and Abhisheka, L.S. (2020). Enhancement of genetic variability for yield and component traits through recombination followed by induced mutagenesis in green gram [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek]. Curr. J. Appl. Sci. and Technol. 39, pp.38-48.
- Marak, T., Sandham, T., Mahapatra, S., Das, S. (2018). Measuring and assessing the yield loss and yield loss model of green gram due to Anthracnose of green gram (Vigna radiata). Legum. Res. LR-4030 [1-5] DOI: 10.18805/LR-4030.
- Mayee, C.D. and Datar, V.V. (1986). Phytopathometry. Marathwada Agricultural University, Parbhani.
- Mogali, S.C. and Hegde, G.M. (2020). Recent Advances in Mungbean Breeding: A Perspective. Accelerated Plant Breeding, Volume 3, pp.235-282.
- Nair, R.M., Pandey, A.K., War, A.R., Hanumantharao, B., Shwe, T., Alam, A.K.M.M., Pratap, A., Malik, S.R., Karimi, R., Mbeyagala, E.K. and Douglas, C.A. (2019). Biotic and abiotic constraints in mungbean production-progress in genetic improvement. Frontiers in Plant Science. 10, p.1340.
- Rekha, N.S., Mahto, C.S., Kumar, A., Lal, H.C. and Pande, A. (2020). Genetic, character association and multivariate studies of seed yield with different traits in mungbean [Vigna radiata (L.) Wilczek]. Journal of Food Legumes. 33(1): pp.10-16.
- Sagar, D. and Patil, R.H. (2020). Response of greengram to climate change in Northern transition zone of Karnataka: DSSAT model based assessment. Legume Research. 45: 63- 67. 10.18805/LR-4325.
- Sudha, M., Karthikeyan, A., Nagarajan, P., Raveendran, M., Senthil, N., Pandiyan, M., Angappan, K., Ramalingam, J., Bharathi, M., Rabindran, R. and Veluthambi, K. (2013). Screening of mungbean (Vigna radiata) germplasm for resistance to Mungbean yellow mosaic virus using agroinoculation. Can. J. Plant Pathol. 35(3): 424-430.
- Wheeler, B.E.J. (1969). An introduction to plant diseases. Published By: Taylor and Francis, Ltd. 62(3): 617-619.
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.