Effect on growth attributes
Data presented in Table 1, reveals that RDF supplemented by foliar application of nutrients at pod initiation stage showed significant effect on growth attributes except number of branches per plant, dry matter production per plant at 30 DAS, crop growth and relative growth rate. Plant height (57.63 cm) and number of internodes per plant (11.67) at the time of harvest were significantly higher in treatment RDF + Urea 2% foliar application at the time of pod initiation over control (49.75 cm and 10.67) and was observed at par with application of RDF along with 2% DAP (55.37 cm and 11.55) and 0.5% MOP (54.27 cm and 11.40). Dry matter produced per plant at 45 and 60 DAS was significantly high in treatment RDF + Urea 2% foliar application over control and RDF + water spray at pod initiation stage. Crop growth rate (CGR) and relative growth rate (RGR) were not significantly different due to various treatments of foliar application of nutrients on soybean crop. In earlier studies it was observed that foliar fertilization treatments significantly increased plant height (Banasode and Math, 2018), dry matter per plant and number of internodes per plant
(Odeleye et al., 2007). Increased plant height and internodes per plant might be due to application of nutrients at later stages which increased the availability of nutrients for plant growth and development and better utilization of applied major nutrients in addition to biological nitrogen fixation. These results are in agreement with findings of Sharifi
et al., (2018) who reported that foliar application of water soluble fertilizer along with RDF on growth of Soybean at pod filling stage resulted in increased plant height. Similarly, dry matter production per plant at 45 and 60 DAS was significantly high in treatment RDF + Urea 2% foliar application at pod initiation stage over control and RDF + water spray. This could be due to foliar application of urea resulted in ready availability of amide through leaf cuticles and stomata, meeting the need of nitrogen required for vegetative growth
(Kalpande et al., 2010). The crop growth rate (CGR) and relative growth rate (RGR) were not significantly affected due to different treatments studied.
Effect on nodulation and its dry weight
Number of root nodules per plant and their dry weight at 50% flowering stage were observed to be significantly superior in treatment RDF + Urea 2% (46.67 nos., 230 mg) foliar application over control (37.33 nos., 160 mg) and RDF + water spray (37 nos., 160 mg) and was found at par with RDF + 2% DAP (46.17 nos., 220 mg) foliar application (Table 2). Increased nodulation and its dry weight might be due to supply of the required nutrients easily and rapidly to soybean plants
(Meena et al., 2017). Similarly, Parmar
et al., (1999) also suggested that the foliar application of nutrient helps in spreading of root system and gives more site for rhizobia infection and increase their proliferation in rhizosphere, helps in forming more effective nodules and increase in their dry weight.
Effect on morpho-physiological parameters
The effect of foliar application of nutrients on morpho-physiological parameters of soybean was studied and the data presented in Table 2. The results revealed that the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) was significantly higher with treatment RDF + 2% Urea over control and RDF + water spray and was followed by RDF + 2% DAP and RDF + 0.5% MOP spray at pod initiation stage. The chlorophyll index (SPAD value) was significantly affected due to different foliar nutrition treatments. Chlorophyll index (SPAD value) was significantly high in treatment RDF + 2% Urea over control and RDF + water spray and was followed by RDF + 2% DAP and RDF + 0.5% MOP foliar spray at pod initiation stage. The higher values for NDVI and SPAD might be due to better ground cover by crop resulting from optimum N supply through foliar application of 2% Urea and biological nitrogen fixation. NDVI represents amount of green biomass containing chlorophyll
(Prince et al., 2016). Similarly, higher the NDVI value, larger the degree of vegetation coverage and better the crop condition
(Huang et al., 2014).
Effect on yield and its attributes
Foliar application of nutrients to soybean crop resulted in significant increase in yield and its attributes
viz., pods per plant, seed yield per plant and yield per hectare. The data pertaining to yield and its attributes presented in Table 3 revealed that number of pods per plant were significantly higher in treatment RDF + 2% Urea (63.73) foliar application over control (54.70) and RDF + water spray (53.80) and was followed by DAP 2%, MOP 0.5%, molybdenum 0.1% and zinc chillated 0.5% along with RDF. Foliar application of 2% Urea along with RDF gave significantly higher number of pods per plant over control and RDF + water spray. Ultimately, increase in pod number resulted into higher seed yield of soybean. Application of RDF + 2% urea (3098 kg ha
-1) at pod initiation stage gave significantly higher soybean seed yield than control (2704 kg ha
-1) and RDF + water spray (2686 kg ha
-1) and was at par with RDF + 2% DAP (3050 kg ha
-1), RDF + MOP 0.5% (2992 kg ha
-1) and RDF + Molybdenum 0.1% (2955 kg ha
-1) foliar spray at pod initiation stage. Increase in seed yield with application of RDF + 2% Urea along with RDF was 14.57% over control and 15.34% on RDF + water spray.
Oko et al., (2003) reported that foliar application of urea at R2-R3 growth stage increased soybean grain yield between 6 and 68% compared to control. Similarly,
Vinothkumar et al., (2013) and
Eman et al., (2014) reported that the increase in seed yield due to foliar application of nutrients might be due to enhanced uptake of nutrients by soybean and by effective translocation of nutrients from sink to reproductive area of crop. The straw yield, seed index and harvest index were non-significantly affected due to foliar application of nutrients.
Economics of study
From the data on economics of different treatments in Table 3 shows that, net returns (Rs. 49,006/- ha
-1) and benefit: cost ratio (2.23) were significantly higher with RDF + Urea 2% followed by RDF + DAP 2% foliar spray at pod initiation owing to higher yield than the rest of the treatments. Least net returns and benefit cost ratio was observed with RDF + water spray (Rs. 37,271/- ha
-1 and 1.93) and control (Rs. 38,032/- ha
-1 and 1.96). The increase in the yield due to foliar application of 2% Urea along with RDF showed 28.85% and 31.48% increase in net returns over control and water spray, respectively.
Effect on soil nutritional status and nutrient uptake by plants
Data on available nutrients in soil before sowing and after harvest of crop given in the Table 4 revealed that, the values for organic carbon content and available nitrogen in soil were non-significantly different whereas, the values for phosphorus and potassium was significantly differed, this might be due to the initial richness of soil in available nutrients. Foliar application of nutrients along with RDF had significant effect on availability of nutrients in soil after harvest of the crop. Organic carbon content of the soil after harvest was significantly high in RDF + 2% Urea and was followed by RDF + 2% DAP foliar application at pod initiation stage during 2017, while the trend was different during 2016. Variation might be due to the inconsistency in values of organic carbon content in soil during the first year of testing. Available nutrients in the soil after harvest during
kharif 2016 were significantly high with RDF + 2% Urea and RDF + 2% DAP over the rest of treatments studied whereas, the trend was different. During
kharif 2017 availability of nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium was significantly higher under the treatment RDF + 2% Urea foliar spray at pod initiation stage over control and RDF + water spray, while it was statistically similar to RDF + 2% DAP foliar application. Available soil nitrogen might be high due to the high activity of root nodules which helped the atmospheric nitrogen fixation, ultimately resulted in increase in nitrogen status of soil. Similarly, maximum phosphorus and potassium content of soil might have resulted due to its fixation into the soil and also shading of leaves and senescence of root nodules helped in increase in phosphorus and potassium content. Uptake of nitrogen and phosphorus by soybean plants was observed to be significantly affected due to the different foliar nutrition treatments (Table 5). Uptake of nitrogen and phosphorus by soybean crop was found significantly higher in the treatment RDF + 2% Urea and RDF + 2% DAP foliar spray at the time of pod initiation over RDF + water spray and control for the years under study and the values for both the treatments were observed at par. These results were in the conformity with the findings of
Jyothi et al., (2013) who reported that 2% Urea foliar spray at pod development stage along with soil application of NPK fertilizer was found more beneficial to improve soybean productivity than application of NPK alone. RDF along with foliar application of 2% Urea recorded higher nitrogen and phosphorus uptake; it might be due to response of soybean crop to the foliar applied macro and micro nutrients and it is helpful to absorb other nutrients in balanced manner. Similar, results were also reported by
Mitra et al., (1987).