The results of basic descriptive statistics
viz., mean maximum, minimum, standard deviation (SD) and coefficient of variation (CV) for the ten quantitative traits studied in greengram genotypes are presented in Table 1.
The genotype CO-5 had taken the maximum number of days (44 days) to attain 50% flowering, while the genotype MH-318 reached 50% flowering within a short span of 27 days. In case of maturity the genotype MH-521 matured early (59 days), while the genotype CO-5 took 74 days to complete the maturity. Plant height ranged from 32.25 to 95.00 cm. The number of branches per plant ranged from 1.52 to 6.00, TM-11-34 recording the maximum number of branches and Pusa 0871 recording less number of branches. The genotype EC-591338 produced less number of pod clusters, while CO-7 produced more number of pod clusters per plant. On an average the pod length among the genotypes was 8.04 cm. The number of pods per plant ranged from 15.30 (EC-591338) to 54.23 (EC-496839). The mean 100 SW among the genotypes is 3.85 g. With respect to seed yield per plant the genotype CO-7 produced higher seed yield of 13.21g, while the genotype EC-591338 produced 4.71g with an average of 9.30 g among the genotypes studied.
Among the ten traits studied, the largest variation was observed for number of pods per plant with CV amounting to 24.04 per cent, followed by seed yield per plant (23.23), plant height (18.37) and number of pod clusters per plant (13.72). Least coefficient of variation of 3.11 was observed for pod length.
Correlation coefficient analysis
Seed yield is a complex trait and it is very difficult to improve by selecting the genotypes for yield. Therefore, identifying the characters, which are closely related and contributed to yield, becomes highly essential. Correlation coefficient is a statistical measure, which is used to find out the degree of relationship between two or more variables. In plant breeding, correlation coefficient measures the mutual relationship between various plant characters and determines the component characters on which selection can be relied upon for genetic improvement of yield. The results revealed that the genotypic correlation coefficients were higher than the phenotypic correlation indicating the preponderance of genetic variance in expression of traits. In the present study, number of pods per plant, number of pod clusters per plant, number of seeds per pod and number of branches per plant showed as significant and positive association with seed yield per plant (Table 2). The positive association of pods per plant, pod clusters per plant, seeds per pod and branches per plant with seed yield per plant has been reported by
Raje and Rao (2000) and
Singh et al., (2018). Reddy et al., (2011) and
Hemavathy et al., (2015) reported positive association of pods per plant and seeds per pod with seed yield per plant. On contrary negative association of number of pod clusters per with seed yield was reported by
Tabasum et al., (2010). Selection of parents based on these traits can help in yield improvement in greengram.
Correlation among the component traits revealed that days to 50% flowering and days to maturity had positive significant correlation between each other. Similar finding were reported by
Hemavathy et al., (2015). Number of branches per plant had positive significant association with number of pods clusters plant and number of pods per plant. With the Increase in number of branches per plant the number of pod clusters per plant also increases, this resulted in the production of more number of flowers and pods per plant. Number of pod clusters per plant had significant positive association with number of pods per plant and number of seeds per pod and it also had non-significant association with 100 seed weight. This indicated that number of pod clusters increases the number of pods per plant and seeds per pod resulting in less seed weight. Similar observations have been reported by
Raje and Rao (2000).
Path analysis
Information obtained from correlation study does not give a complete idea about the contributions of each component character. Path coefficient analysis is useful for partially direct and indirect causes of correlation and also enables us to compare the causal factors on the basis of their relative contributions. As the correlation coefficient is not sufficient to explain true relationship for an effective manipulation of the character, path coefficient was worked out. In the present study, Path analysis showed that the maximum positive direct effect contributing to single plant yield was exhibited by days to 50% flowering followed by number of pods per plant (0.480), number of seeds per pod (0.409), number of pod clusters per plant (0.212) which implies that selection for these traits would improve seed yield per plant (Table 3). These results were in correspondence with the findings of
Srivastava and Singh (2012) and
Prasad and Prasad (2013). Genotypes with short duration, more number of pod clusters and pods per with more number of seeds and determinate growth habit are the ideal plant types which resulted in high seed yield per plant.
Among the component traits studied, high indirect effect on seed yield was attributed by days to maturity
via days to 50% flowering (0.454) and number of pod clusters via number of pods per plant (0.218). Such an observation was reported by
Biradar et al., (2007). The residual effect of path analysis was moderate (0.3995), which shows that some more traits may be included in the study to see the pattern of interaction on yield. From the path analysis traits
viz., days to 50% flowering, number of pods per plant and number of seeds per pod showed maximum direct effects on seed yield per plant. Among these, number of pods per plant and number of seeds per pod exhibited highly significant and positive association with seed yield. Therefore, to increase yield in greengram the emphasis should be given to the selection of these traits.
Principal component analysis (PCA)
Principal component analysis (PCA) was applied as a dimensionality-reduction tool for the multivariate data to analyze the structure of the genetic diversity in the experimental material. In the present study it revealed that first five principal components in the PCA contributed to a maximum of 79.12% of the total phenotypic diversity among the 44 genotypes (Table 4 and Fig 2). The first principal component (PC1) with an eigen value of 2.68 explained 26.77% of the total variation. PC1 was associated mainly with seed yield per plant, number of pod clusters per plant, number of pods per plant and number of branches per plant as well as number of seeds per pod. The second principal component (PC2) accounted for 21.47% of the total variation and was mainly related to days to 50% flowering and maturity. PC3 accounted for 11.63% of the total variation and was characterized by 100 seed weight. The PC4 and PC5 explained about 10.62 and 8.63 per cent of total variation and were contributed by pod length and number of seeds per pod. The first two PCs which contributed to 48.24% of the total variance were plotted graphically to demonstrate the relationships between accessions (Fig 3). It can be inferred that there exists wide genetic variability among the genotypes based on the distribution pattern of the genotypes on the biplot.
Mehandi et al., (2015) studied twenty one greengram genotypes and reported that PC1 was positively contributed by short plant height and number of seeds per pod. They also reported that the major contribution of PC2 through number of pods per plant, 100 seed weight, pod length, seeds per pod and number of pod clusters per plant whereas PC3 was attributed by number of pod clusters per plant.
Cluster analysis
Cluster analysis was used to determine the genetic relationship among the genotypes and find out the suitable genotypes for future breeding programme. Cluster analysis based on ten quantitative traits for 44 genotypes grouped them into six discrete and well defined clusters. Cluster III was the largest consisting of 12 genotypes (Table 5 and Fig 4) whereas, the smallest was cluster VI with four genotypes. It is noted that genotypes from of different geographical origin were grouped in the same cluster indicating the absence of relationship between genetic diversity and geographical diversity.
Presence of variability in the 44 genotypes was also reflected in the cluster means for the ten traits evaluated (Table 6). Cluster I comprised of seven genotypes characterized by genotypes with more number of pods per plant. Cluster II comprised of five genotypes with more branches and more pod clusters resulted in high yielding genotypes (11.92g). Cluster III comprised of 12 genotypes predominantly early maturing genotypes with small pods. Cluster IV comprised of five genotypes which were characterized by small seeds having low seed weight (2.75g) and less number of seeds per pod (7.49). Cluster V comprised of 11 genotypes which were characterized by late flowering (69 days) and dwarf genotypes (49.90cm). Cluster VI comprised of four genotypes which were predominantly characterized by tall genotypes (70.90cm) having long pods (8.99). The selection of diverse parents should be based on the component characters of yield that leads to better adaptation of the crop. Several researchers
viz.,
Katiyar et al., (2009) and
Singh et al., (2014) also gave emphasis on need of high genetic diversity to create the high genetic variation and genetic gain under selection. In the present study the genotypes grouped under cluster II, having more number of branches, pod clusters, seeds per pod and single plant yield can be utilized as potential donors in crossing program for improving yield.