Assessment of infestation levels in date samples
Insect pests infesting date cultivars across different regions of Saudi Arabia
Infestation by the date moth,
Ephestia cautella, differed significantly among regions, with the highest levels recorded in Al-Kharj and Al-Qassim and the lowest levels in Al-Madinah. In contrast, infestation by the sawtoothed grain beetle,
Oryzaephilus surinamensis, was generally low and occurred mainly in Riyadh and Al-Kharj, while remaining minimal in the other regions. Consequently, overall insect infestation showed substantial regional variation and broadly followed the same pattern observed for
E. cautella. Among natural enemies, the ectoparasitoid wasp
Bracon hebetor (Hymenoptera: Braconidae) was the only parasitoid detected during inspections and it was recorded attacking
E. cautella larvae in infested fruits; its occurrence was restricted to a subset of the surveyed regions, as shown in Table 1.
Susceptibility of date cultivars to insect pest infestation
Significant cultivar-dependent differences were observed in infestation intensity by
E. cautella and
O. surinamensis. Overall, cultivars such as Sefri and Shibeibi exhibited the highest susceptibility, largely driven by elevated infestation by
E. cautella. In contrast, Barni and Ruziz consistently showed the lowest infestation levels, indicating comparatively greater resistance under the surveyed storage conditions. Several cultivars (including Khodri, Khush-ram, Serri and Selag) displayed intermediate susceptibility, reflecting moderate levels of infestation. Infestation by
O. surinamensis remained low across all cultivars and was detected only sporadically, supporting its role as a secondary pest in stored dates. Moreover, minimal non-insect contamination (
e.g., mold) was detected across samples. These cultivar-level patterns are summarized in Table 2.
Preference and susceptibility of date cultivars to O. surinamensis
Progeny production of
O. surinamensis differed significantly among date cultivars, indicating clear variation in host suitability. Cultivars Khodri, Hatmi and Ruziz supported the highest adult emergence per female after one generation, whereas Shibeibi and Khush-ram consistently produced the lowest progeny, reflecting reduced susceptibility. These cultivar-dependent differences in reproductive performance are illustrated in Fig 1.
Weight loss caused by feeding activity of the first-generation offspring of
O. surinamensis differed among the tested date cultivars (Fig 2). Khodri and Hatmi showed the highest progeny production (11.6 adults/female), followed by Ruziz (11.1 adults/female), whereas Shibeibi and Khush-ram showed lower progeny production (7.6 and 7.5 adults/female, respectively). The corresponding mean weight loss values were 0.35 for Khodri, 0.90 for Hatmi, 0.80 for Ruziz, 0.20 for Shibeibi and 0.17 for Khushram.
Effect of water activity on O. surinamensis reproduction and weight gain in Ruziz
Fig 3 illustrates the nonlinear effects of relative humidity (RH) on both
O. surinamensis reproduction and date weight gain. Progeny production remained stable at 30-50% RH (≈7.5-8 insects/female), increased to a maximum at 70% RH (≈11 insects/female) and declined sharply at higher RH, indicating that moderate humidity enhances reproduction while excessive moisture creates unfavorable conditions. In contrast, date weight increased steadily with RH, reaching its highest at 90% RH (≈20%), reflecting the hygroscopic nature of dates and the facilitative effect of insect activity on moisture uptake. The relationship shows partial coupling: moderate moisture gain enhances insect suitability, but further weight increases do not boost progeny production. Overall, controlling RH is critical during date storage to balance insect infestation risk and fruit quality preservation.
Proximate composition, pH and reproductive performance of O. surinamensis of date samples
Marked cultivar-dependent variation was observed in proximate composition, pH and reproductive performance of
O. surinamensis (Table 3). Overall, Khodri, Ruziz and Hatmi supported the highest progeny output per female, indicating that these cultivars are comparatively more suitable hosts under the tested conditions. In contrast, Shibeibi and Khushram exhibited significantly reduced progeny production, suggesting lower host suitability and a degree of natural resistance.
Differences in reproductive success were closely aligned with cultivar chemistry. Higher progeny output was associated with lower fiber and ash contents, whereas cultivars characterized by higher fiber and mineral (ash) levels tended to suppress reproduction. The correlation analysis supports this pattern, showing strong negative relationships between progeny production and fiber, ash and moisture content, while positive correlations were observed with carbohydrate, protein and pH. These relationships suggest that nutritional quality and matrix structure jointly shape beetle performance, where increased fiber/mineral content may reduce feeding efficiency and/or nutrient assimilation, ultimately limiting progeny production. Although larval mortality was not quantified separately, the observed reduction in adult progeny likely reflects constraints on larval development and survival within less suitable fruit matrices.
Taken together, these findings provide mechanistic evidence that biochemical composition contributes to cultivar-specific susceptibility to
O. surinamensis. From an applied perspective, cultivars showing lower beetle reproductive performance (
e.g., Shibeibi and Khushram) may be prioritized in cultivar-based postharvest integrated pest management programs, while more susceptible cultivars (
e.g., Khodri, Ruziz and Hatmi) may require stricter storage hygiene and humidity control to minimize secondary pest establishment.
Sugar analysis of date samples
Sugar profiling revealed clear cultivar-dependent differences in the relative proportions of glucose, fructose and sucrose, with monosaccharides dominating most cultivars and sucrose generally absent or present only at trace levels. Overall, Khodri was distinguished by comparatively higher glucose alongside substantial fructose, whereas Ruziz and Hatmi were characterized by fructose-rich profiles. Shibeibi showed a minor but detectable sucrose fraction, while Khushram exhibited the lowest glucose level among the tested cultivars.
These sugar patterns provide mechanistic support for the cultivar-specific performance of
O. surinamensis. Cultivars exhibiting higher monosaccharide availability (glucose and/or fructose) tended to support greater reproductive output, consistent with the role of readily assimilable sugars in enhancing palatability and energy supply for development and fecundity. In contrast, cultivars with comparatively lower glucose and/or detectable sucrose were associated with reduced progeny production, suggesting lower nutritional suitability and/or altered feeding efficiency. Collectively, the sugar profiles corroborate the observed differences in cultivar susceptibility and reinforce the importance of biochemical composition as a practical component of cultivar-based postharvest risk management as shown in Table 4.
The present study demonstrates that insect pest infestation in stored Saudi date cultivars is governed by interaction among regional storage conditions and cultivar-specific physicochemical characteristics. Across all surveyed regions,
Ephestia cautella clearly emerged as the predominant postharvest pest, corroborating earlier reports that consistently identify this species as the principal insect threat to stored dates in the Middle East
(Husain et al., 2017; Alwaneen et al., 2019; Sukirno et al., 2021). The widespread dominance of
E. cautella highlights its strong adaptation to date fruits and storage environments typical of arid and semi-arid regions. Marked regional variation in infestation levels was observed, with significantly higher overall infestation in Al-Kharj and Al-Qassim compared with Al-Madinah. These patterns are strongly associated with the warmer climates’ characteristic of central Saudi Arabia, which have been shown to accelerate development, increase survival and enhance reproductive capacity of
E. cautella (Sukirno et al., 2021; Berhe et al., 2022). Spatial patterns of infestation have been documented previously in Saudi Arabia and neighboring regions (
Abo El Saad and El Shafie, 2013), reinforcing the consistency of this relationship.
In parallel with pest monitoring, the survey also documented natural enemies when encountered.
Bracon hebetor (Say) is a well-known solitary ectoparasitoid of late-instar lepidopteran larvae and is widely recognized as an effective biological control agent against several stored-product moths, including
E. cautella. The parasitoid attacks host larvae by paralyzing them and ovipositing externally on the host body, with larval development completed outside the host integument. The detection of this parasitoid, even at low frequency, confirms the existence of natural biological regulation within storage ecosystems and highlights its potential contribution to suppressing pest populations under favorable conditions. Comparable studies in other crop systems have likewise shown that documenting the abundance and diversity of natural enemies is important for developing biologically based pest-management programs and for strengthening IPM under storage or postharvest conditions
(Roy et al., 2024).
While the infestation by the sawtoothed grain beetle (
Oryzaephilus surinamensis) remained very low across all regions, with the highest levels recorded only in Riyadh and Al-Kharj. This limited and uneven distribution supports the interpretation that O
. surinamensis functions as a secondary pest in stored dates, primarily exploiting fruits that are already damaged. Such behavior suggests that beetle occurrence is more closely linked to postharvest handling practices and storage conditions rather than field infestation, in agreement with
Berhe et al., (2022) and
Latifian et al., (2020), who reported reduced beetle performance under controlled storage environments.
In addition to regional factors, cultivar-dependent susceptibility played a decisive role in determining infestation intensity. Cultivars exhibiting higher infestation levels, such as Sefri and Shibeibi, likely possess physicochemical attributes such as higher sugar availability, softer texture, or lower fiber content that facilitate larval penetration and development. Similar associations between fruit softness, moisture and susceptibility to internal feeders have been reported by
Phillips and Throne (2010). Conversely, cultivars such as Barni and Ruziz displayed lower infestation levels, suggesting that increased firmness or less favorable chemical composition may confer partial resistance, consistent with observations by
Rather et al., (2021). This resistance likely results from combined structural and biochemical factors, including relatively higher fiber and mineral contents, which may reduce feeding efficiency, impair nutrient assimilation and limit larval development. Increased fiber content can act as a physical barrier that restricts larval penetration and feeding, while mineral components may interfere with digestive processes or reduce palatability, ultimately lowering insect reproductive success. In addition to these structural constraints, phenolic compounds (including condensed tannins and other polyphenols) may further contribute to the comparatively resistant behavior of cultivars such as Barni and Ruziz. Phenolics are widely recognized as anti-feedant and growth-inhibitory metabolites in plant–insect interactions; they can reduce palatability, bind dietary proteins and inhibit digestive enzymes, thereby decreasing nutrient utilization and larval performance. Therefore, the lower infestation observed in Barni and Ruziz may reflect the additive (or synergistic) effects of a fiber-based physical barrier together with phenolic/tannin-mediated biochemical deterrence, ultimately reducing insect establishment and population growth.
Intermediate susceptibility observed in several cultivars aligns with earlier findings by
Duble (1996) and
Abbas et al., (2014), indicating that resistance is not absolute but exists along a continuum shaped by multiple fruit traits. The consistently low infestation of
O. surinamensis across cultivars further emphasizes its secondary pest status, as previously highlighted by
Hashem et al., (2021) and reflects its preference for already damaged fruits. These findings further support the concept that cultivar resistance in stored dates is a quantitative trait influenced by multiple interacting physicochemical and structural characteristics rather than a single determinant factor.
Environmental factors within storage facilities further modulated infestation patterns. Relative humidity (RH) emerged as a critical variable, as elevated RH not only accelerates physical deterioration of dates but also prolongs insect survival and reproductive potential (
Kamal-Eldin et al., 2020;
Abo-El-Saad et al., 2024;
Zhang et al., 2025). These findings underscore the importance of RH management as a key component of postharvest protection strategies aimed at balancing fruit quality preservation with pest suppression. Additionally, excessive moisture may alter fruit matrix structure and microbial interactions, which can indirectly influence insect development and survival. This broader postharvest perspective agrees with previous reviews emphasizing that storage environment, packaging, pest control measures and general postharvest handling practices are central determinants of quantitative and qualitative losses during storage (
Yimer, 2022).
Biochemical composition also exerted a strong influence on pest performance. Cultivars with higher glucose content supported greater insect development, consistent with studies showing that nutrient-rich substrates enhance stored-product insect growth and fecundity (
Adamaki-Sotiraki et al., 2025). In contrast, higher fiber and mineral (ash) contents appeared to reduce feeding efficiency and progeny production, supporting the deterrent effects reported by previous authors
(Alotaibi et al., 2019). Moisture and pH exerted comparatively minor effects, suggesting that nutritional quality outweighs these factors in determining host suitability. These biochemical characteristics provide a mechanistic explanation for the observed resistance patterns in cultivars such as Ruziz, where the combined effects of structural complexity and nutritional balance reduce insect fitness and population establishment.
Sugar composition provided further mechanistic insight into cultivar susceptibility. Cultivars with lower glucose levels and minimal sucrose content, such as Khushram, were less favorable for insect development, aligning with findings by
Sheng et al., (2019), who demonstrated that sugar profiles significantly influence larval growth and infestation intensity. Overall, the resistance observed among certain cultivars appears to result from the integrated effects of physicochemical structure, nutrient composition and environmental interactions, which collectively determine host suitability and pest population dynamics.