Water quality
Water quality parameters recorded fortnightly across all nine tanks are summarised in Table 2. Water temperature ranged between 18.2 and 24.5°C over the experimental period, with fortnightly treatment means of 21.3-21.5°C, consistent with mid-hill conditions at Umiam during February to April. Dissolved oxygen remained above 5 mg/L throughout and pH ranged from 7.08 to 7.13 across treatments. Free CO2 and total alkalinity varied between 4.09-4.22 mg/L and 82.3-84.1 mg/L, respectively. No significant differences (p>0.05) were observed in any water quality parameter among the three dietary treatments at any fortnightly sampling point, confirming that FRB-based diets did not adversely affect the tank environment.
Growth performance
Growth performance indices of
L. gonius at Day 30 and Day 60 are presented in Table 3. Initial weights did not differ significantly among treatments (F2,6 = 0.03, p = 0.97). Significant treatment differences were already apparent by Day 30, with T3 (14.82±1.14 g) significantly heavier than T1 (10.96±0.94 g) and T2 (12.68±1.07 g) differing significantly from both. By Day 60, mean final weight followed the order T3 (26.14±2.11 g) > T2 (22.47±1.95 g) > T1 (18.63±1.82 g), with all pair-wise differences significant (T1 vs T3, p = 0.001; T1 vs T2, p = 0.006; T2 vs T3, p = 0.011). Relative to T1, final body weight was higher by 20.6% in T2 and 40.3% in T3, indicating a graded, dose-dependent growth response to increasing FRB inclusion. SGR ranged from 1.93±0.05%/day in T1 to 2.45±0.06%/day in T3 (F2,6 = 47.3, p<0.001; T1 vs T2, p = 0.008; T1 vs T3, p<0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.004) and FCR improved significantly with increasing FRB inclusion, declining from 2.82±0.09 in T1 to 1.98±0.06 in T3 (F2,6 = 52.1, p<0.001; T1 vs T2, p = 0.007; T1 vs T3, p < 0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.009). This represented an improvement in FCR of 18.1% in T2 and 29.8% in T3 relative to T1. ADG followed the same trend: T3 (0.35±0.01 g/day) > T2 (0.28±0.02 g/day) > T1 (0.22±0.01 g/day). Survival did not differ significantly among treatments (87.78-90.00%; F2,6 = 0.84, p = 0.47).
The Fulton condition factor (K) was statistically similar across treatments at Day 0. By Day 30, K in T3 (1.23±0.06) was significantly higher than in T1 (1.12±0.05), with T2 (1.18±0.04) intermediate (Table 3). At Day 60, all three treatments differed significantly from each other (T1: 1.15±0.04, T2: 1.24±0.05, T3: 1.31±0.06; T1 vs T2, p = 0.021; T1 vs T3, p<0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.014) and within each treatment, the Day 60 value was significantly higher than the corresponding Day 0 value (T1, p = 0.032; T2, p = 0.002; T3, p<0.001).
Organ indices, digestibility and muscle composition
HSI and VSI at Day 60 are presented in Table 4. HSI differed significantly among treatments (F2,12 = 6.21, p = 0.014), being highest in T1 (1.67±0.12%) and lowest in T3 (1.44±0.11%), with T2 (1.53±0.09%) not differing significantly from either group on DMRT. VSI similarly declined with increasing FRB inclusion (F2,12 = 5.84, p = 0.017), from 6.82±0.43% in T1 to 6.21±0.41% in T3, with T2 (6.43±0.38%) intermediate and not significantly different from either extreme.
ADC for dry matter increased significantly with FRB inclusion (F2,6 = 38.4, p<0.001), from 64.32±1.84% in T1 to 76.84±1.92% in T3, with all pairwise differences significant (T1 vs T2, p = 0.004; T1 vs T3, p<0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.008). This corresponds to a relative gain in dry matter digestibility of 11.3% in T2 and 19.4% in T3 over T1. ADC for crude protein likewise improved significantly across all treatments (T1: 74.18±2.31%, T2: 81.52±1.71%, T3: 86.08±2.24%; T1 vs T2, p = 0.009; T1 vs T3, p<0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.021), an improvement of 9.9% in T2 and 16.0% in T3 relative to T1. ADC for crude lipid did not differ significantly among treatments (78.64-80.32%; F2,6 = 0.19, p = 0.83).
Muscle crude protein was significantly highest in T3 (61.4±1.1% dw) and lowest in T1 (56.2±1.2% dw), with all three treatments differing significantly from each other (T1 vs T2, p = 0.012; T1 vs T3, p<0.001; T2 vs T3, p = 0.006; Table 4). Muscle crude protein was thus 4.4% and 9.3% higher in T2 and T3, respectively, than in T1. Muscle crude lipid was significantly lowest in T3 (13.6±0.7% dw) compared to T1 (14.8±0.6% dw), while T2 (14.1±0.5% dw) did not differ significantly from either. Muscle moisture and ash did not differ significantly among treatments (p>0.05).
Water quality parameters remained within acceptable ranges for
Labeo species culture throughout the experiment, with mean temperatures of 21.3-21.5°C reflecting characteristic mid-hill conditions at Umiam (Meghalaya) during February to April, consistent with observations of
Debnath et al., (2025) and
Das et al., (2021a). Although
L. gonius tolerates cooler temperatures better than
L. rohita (
Bhuyan, 2003), the moderate SGR values relative to warmer plainland studies are partly attributable to reduced metabolic activity at lower temperatures. Dietary treatments did not interfere with any measured water quality parameter, confirming that FRB-based diets impose no adverse effect on the tank environment, consistent with findings for
L. rohita and tilapia in cage systems
(Islam et al., 2025; Alom et al., 2025).
The progressive improvement in growth indices and FCR with increasing FRB inclusion may be attributed to several interacting mechanisms associated with fermentation. Fermentation reduced the crude fibre content of rice bran from 12.60% to 9.20%, resulting in a lower overall dietary fibre content in T3 (7.68%) than in T1 (9.14%) and potentially improving energy availability, as cyprinids are inherently limited in their ability to digest high-fibre substrates
(Putra et al., 2021). In addition, LAB-mediated phytase activity and enzyme production by yeast may have reduced phytic acid and other anti-nutritional factors, thereby improving mineral and nutrient bioavailability (
Gatesoupe, 2008;
Dan et al., 2017). The higher crude protein content of FRB (15.80% CP) compared with unfermented rice bran (UFRB) (12.20% CP) may partly reflect microbial biomass production during the combined LAB and
S. cerevisiae fermentation, which could also have promoted more extensive degradation of anti-nutritional factors than fermentation with either microorganism alone
(Siddik et al., 2024). This interpretation is supported by findings in rohu, where
S. cerevisiae-fermented aquafeed showed increased crude protein, reduced crude fibre and anti-nutritional factors and consequently improved nutrient digestibility, growth performance and intestinal enzyme activity compared with unfermented feed
(Das et al., 2021b). Similarly, fermented rice bran has recently been reported to promote microbial floc development and enhance growth and digestive enzyme activity in Indian spiny loach
(Heniton et al., 2026), suggesting that the nutritional benefits of rice bran fermentation may extend beyond cyprinids. The use of freshly prepared curd as the inoculum further provides a plausible source of LAB, as freshly set home-prepared dahi has been reported to contain approximately 10
7-10
9 CFU/g of LAB, with
Lactobacillus bulgaricus and
Streptococcus thermophilus among the dominant bacteria, while homemade preparations may contain viable LAB populations of approximately 1.6 × 10
8 CFU/mL
(Sudheer et al., 2025). Although the microbial load and species composition of the fermented rice bran were not directly determined in the present study, the decline in pH from 6.2 to 4.0, together with the increase in crude protein and reduction in crude fibre after 48 h of incubation, is consistent with active microbial fermentation and provides indirect evidence that the fermentation process proceeded successfully. Nevertheless, direct enumeration and molecular identification of the dominant microbiota in future studies would be valuable for confirming this interpretation and establishing a clearer link between the microbial community and the observed nutritional improvements.
That the treatment separation in body weight and condition factor was already established by Day 30 suggests that the growth-promoting effect of FRB operates from early exposure rather than accumulating gradually, consistent with a proximate, digestion-linked mechanism rather than a slower adaptive response such as gut microbiota remodelling. The FCR improvement in T3 relative to T1 aligns with findings of
Mandal and Ghosh (2019);
Dan et al., (2017) and
Shamna et al., (2015) in
L. rohita and is consistent with the general finding that fermented plant ingredients improve feed conversion efficiency in carps
(Alom et al., 2025; Das et al., 2024). Mechanistically, the improved FCR and digestibility with FRB most plausibly reflect a combination of three processes acting in sequence: partial pre-digestion of rice bran starch and protein by microbial extracellular enzymes during fermentation, which reduces the residual metabolic cost of digestion to the fish; hydrolysis of phytate-mineral and phytate-protein complexes by microbial phytase, which releases bound protein and minerals that would otherwise pass undigested through the gut; and a reduction in fibre-associated bulk that would otherwise limit gastric evacuation rate and gut transit time in a species with a relatively simple stomach and short intestine such as
L. gonius. These effects are consistent with, rather than proven by, the present dataset and enzymatic or gut-microbiota analyses would be required to establish their relative contribution. Survival was satisfactory and consistent with values reported for
L. gonius under similar tank conditions
(Debnath et al., 2024).
The higher HSI in T1 (1.67%) relative to T3 (1.44%) suggests that anti-nutritional factors in unfermented rice bran imposed greater metabolic strain on the liver
(Olsvik et al., 2010), with comparable HSI reductions reported in
L. rohita (Banerjee et al., 2023), tilapia
(Putra et al., 2021) and catfish
(Shimul et al., 2024). Declining VSI with increasing FRB inclusion reflects reduced intra-coelomic fat deposition, consistent with lower muscle crude lipid in T3 and more efficient nutrient channelling toward somatic growth, a pattern similarly reported by
Banerjee et al., (2023) and
Putra et al., (2021).
The higher ADC for dry matter (76.84% in T3 vs. 64.32% in T1) and crude protein (86.08% vs. 74.18%) confirm that curd fermentation substantially improved the nutritional accessibility of rice bran for
L. gonius. The protein ADC in T3 compares favourably with 87.20% reported for fermented rice bran in shrimp
(Jannathulla et al., 2018) and with values for
S. cerevisiae-fermented mustard oil cake in
L. rohita (Islam et al., 2025) and is broadly consistent with protein digestibility values of 77.07-83.35% reported for fermented mesquite seed meal in Nile tilapia
(Aroyehun et al., 2021). The absence of significant differences in ADC for crude lipid is expected, as LAB fermentation does not substantially alter lipid composition across isolipidic diets. Higher muscle crude protein in T3 (61.4% dw) relative to T1 (56.2% dw) reflects more efficient protein deposition consistent with improved protein digestibility, while lower muscle crude lipid in T3 likely results from reduced dietary lipid in FRB relative to UFRB and a protein-sparing effect from more efficient protein utilisation, patterns reported in
L. rohita (Das et al., 2024; Dan et al., 2017), tilapia
(Alom et al., 2025; Aroyehun et al., 2021) and catfish
(Shimul et al., 2024). Muscle moisture and ash did not differ significantly among treatments, consistent with observations in
L. rohita fed fermented linseed oil cake diets
(Banerjee et al., 2023).
Certain limitations of the present study warrant mention. The trial was conducted over a single 60-day growth phase, which, while sufficient to demonstrate clear treatment separation in growth and digestibility, does not capture performance across a full grow-out cycle to marketable size, nor across the seasonal temperature variation that mid-hill pond systems in Meghalaya experience through the year. The trial was further conducted in cement tanks under controlled feeding and water exchange, which, although necessary for precise measurement of digestibility and organ indices, does not fully replicate the more variable temperature, natural food availability and management regime of earthen pond culture under which most small-scale hill farmers in the region operate. The relatively modest number of replicate tanks per treatment (three), while adequate for the growth and digestibility endpoints reported here, limits the statistical power available for detecting smaller effect sizes in secondary indices such as VSI. Direct microbial characterisation of the fermented rice bran was also not undertaken; while indirect evidence supports active fermentation, a quantitative and species-level link between the fermenting microbiota and the observed nutritional outcomes remains to be established. Extrapolation of the present findings to commercial-scale, full-cycle culture should therefore be made with appropriate caution and the results are best regarded as establishing proof of concept rather than a final production recommendation.