Colchicine-sensitivity curve of cassava leaf lobes incubated on 2, 4-D or Picloram
After 21 days of dark incubation, callus production in colchicine-treated leaf lobes of four different varieties of cassava on 2, 4-D or picloram supplemented media was assessed. On 2, 4-D-supplemented, non-treated (control) explants recorded the highest proportion of callus formation compared to explants that had received colchicine (Fig 1). When the concentration of colchicine was increased from 0.00% to 0. 25%, the number of calli clumps significantly decreased (0.8≤ R2 ≥ 0.9). In a similar vein, the proportion of callus formation in leaf lobes treated with colchicine and inoculated on media supplemented with picloram reduced as colchicine concentration increased from 0.00% to 0. 25% (0.5 ≤ R2 ≥ 0.8) (Fig 1). As colchicine concentration increased, callus formation decreased in colchicine-treated leaf lobes but higher in untreated (control) leaf lobes. Due to its antimitotic activity, colchicine has been widely used to induce artificial polyploidization in plants (
Germana, 2012).
Due to its capacity to block the separation of divided nuclei during the cell cycle during anaphase, colchicine raises the ploidy levels of mitotic cells. This might result in the creation of polyploid plants, which improves the genetic diversity of crops. By increasing the number of dominant alleles or reducing the negative effects caused by recessive alleles, polyploidization in plants increases adaptability to environmental pressures or changes (
Van de Pee et al., 2021; Soltis et al., 2015). Asexual reproduction, heterosis and gene redundancy (caused by gene duplication) are further benefits of polyploidy in plants (in certain cases the facilitation of reproduction through self-fertilization or asexual means). Gene redundancy protects polyploids from the harmful effects of mutations, whereas heterosis makes polyploids stronger than their diploid ancestors (
Van de Peer et al., 2021;
Chevasco, 2012;
Zhang, 2008). The decrease in callus production and/or size seen in this study because of increased colchicine concentrations suggests that embryogenic tissues have a hermetic response to colchicine, which could explain for the decrease in callus clump size.
LD50 of colchicine-treated cassava leaf lobes
Fig 2 displays the colchicine-treated leaf lobes of four types of cassava that were inoculated on 2, 4-D, or picloram-supplemented media. The estimated lethal dose (LD
50) for colchicine-treated leaf lobes of the
Ankrah, Dagati, Tomfa and
Tuaka types were 0.09, 0.11, 0.13 and 0.09% mg/L on 2, 4-D media and 0.12, 0.1, 0.14 and 0.1% mg/L on picloram medium, respectively. The sensitivity based on the estimated LD
50 for colchicine-treated leaf lobes of the four varieties
Ankrah (0.09)
, Dagati (0.11)
, Tomfa (0.13) and
Tuaka (0.09) % mg/L of colchicine treatment on 2, 4-D and treatment in picloram medium as
Ankrah (0.12)
, Dagati (0.1)
, Tomfa (0.14) and
Tuaka (0.01) % mg/L of colchicine, indicated that the LD
50 for colchicine depends on variety as
Ankrah and
Tuaka were more sensitive to colchicine than the other cassava varieties.
Most plant breeders prefer applying LD
50 as an effective acute dose for mass sample mutagenesis to achieve average survival rates. However, in practice it is better to mass irradiate at a bit higher dose than the LD
50 for discovery of more useful mutants. A single acute dose range of LD
50 (±10%), or an acute dose resulting in 20% survival of treated material could cause effective mutations
(Amenorpe et al., 2010; Heinze and Schmidt 1995).
Number of days to callus formation in colchicine-treated leaf lobes
The number of days taken for colchicine-treated leaf lobes to develop callus recorded on 2, 4-D and picloram supplemented media (Table 1). The colchicine treatment had significant (P≤0.05) effect on the number of days to callus formation in leaf lobe explants of the four cassava varieties. Higher concentrations of colchicine delayed callus formation in all four cassava varieties. However, differences were observed in variety response to callus formation from colchicine-treated leaf lobes cultured on picloram-amended medium. Callus formation in the varieties
Dagati and
Tomfa delayed longer with increasing concentration of colchicine until 0.2 g/l compared to
Ankrah and
Tuaka (Table 1).
Ankrah produced a callus in 0.05 mg/L concentration of colchicine within 8 days whilst
Dagati took 13 days. Similarly, at 0.1 and 0.2 mg/L concentrations of colchicine,
Tuaka and
Ankrah produced calli earlier compared to
Dagati and
Tomfa.
The number of days taken for colchicine-treated leaf lobes to develop callus on 2, 4-D was delayed by higher concentration of colchicine (Table 2). The colchicine treatment had significant (P≤0.05) effect on the number of days for leaf lobes to develop callus. As the concentration of colchicine increased, leaf-lobes took longer days to form callus.
Ankrah produced a callus in 0.05 mg/L concentration of colchicine within 9 days whilst
Dagati took 14 days. Similarly, at 0.1 and 0.2 mg/L concentrations of colchicine,
Dagati and
Tomfa had relatively lower number of days to callus production compared to the other varieties. Leaf lobes of varieties
Ankrah, Dagati, Tomfa and
Tuaka took different days (17, 19, 20 and 18 days respectively) to develop callus on picloram medium. The delay in callus formation of genotypes under varying concentration of colchicine was likely due to the genoype. Tissue-type sensitivity to colchicine has been observed in the different response of apical and lateral explants to colchicine treatments, showing a diversity in antimitotic sensitivity
(Manzoor et al., 2019; Carvalho et al., 2016). This emphasizes the need for radiosensitivity test to be done on the type of explant or genotype used prior to large scale treatment for mutation induction.
According to
Snehal and Madhukar (2012), higher concentrations of colchicine affect callus growth negatively, therefore causing delay in callus emergence in cassava leaf lobes. Colchicine at higher concentration may adversely restrict the mitotic process essential for callus formation because of the destruction of some of the cellular organelles
(Manzoor et al., 2019). This suggests that faster callus emergence can be moderated by controlling the concentration of colchicine. However, lowering the concentration of colchicine is detrimental to discovery of new mutants because the mutation frequency rate is seriously reduced.
Somatic embryogenesis
Somatic embryogenesis has become an important technique for plant regeneration and production of totipotent tissues in cassava. Calli cultures were assessed for somatic embryo formation and the number of somatic embryos produced per clump was recorded after two weeks in light. Fig 3 shows colchicine treated leaf lobes of
Ankrah had developed calli on 2, 4-D and embryo on NAA in two weeks. Similarly, the colchicine treated leaf lobes of
Tuaka also developed calli on picloram and embryo on NAA. It was observed that the number of somatic embryos produced per clump was independent of the size of the calli clump formed. A callus clump may be small yet contained smaller colchipoid cells with higher regeneration rate into embryo depending on the genotypes. Moreover, varieties may respond differently to auxin and cytokinin in the NAA media.
Colchicine treated leaf lobes of
Ankrah developed calli clump on 2, 4-D and embryo on NAA in two weeks. Similarly, the colchicine treated leaf lobes of
Tuaka also developed calli on picloram and embryo on NAA media in the same period, but their sizes differ (Fig 4). This was possible because NAA media has both auxins combined with cytokinins. Auxin decides the pace at which callus is going to develop further. It initiates somatic embryogenesis by inducing stress response in plant cells while the cytokine induces cell division in the explants (
Teixeira da Silva and Malabadi, 2005). Cytokinin influences cell-to-cell auxin transport by modification of expression of several auxin transport components and thus modulates auxin distribution important for regulation of activity and size of the root meristem
(Swarup et al., 2019; Rùžièka et al., 2009). It was observed that tight calli with shoot organic potentiality failed to develop into somatic embryos but only loose calli without shoot organic potentiality developed somatic embryos.
The mutagenic treatments affected the days to somatic embryogenesis as was seen in colchicine treatments compared to the controls. This result undoubtedly confirmed colchicine as an anti-mitotic agent, which suppressed mitotic division and hence inhibited somatic embryogenesis. On the other hand, Somatic embryo formation is influenced by several factors such as explant, growth hormones and environmental factors (
Bogdanović et al., 2021). Of these factors, growth hormones are the most pronounced. In this study, MS basal medium supplemented with 8 mg/l 2, 4-D led to early somatic embryo development as compared to 16 mg/l picloram.