Fungal isolation
A total of 37 isolates were recovered from diseased samples showing typical anthracnose symptoms on the inflorescences, leaves and fruits both pre- and postharvest. All parts of the inflorescences are susceptible to
Colletotrichum species with dark-brown spots and elongated dark lesions that enlarge and coalesce and then, the infected flower parts fall off the inflorescences. The infection of the leaves starts as small brown to black spots, often with a distinct yellow halo, that enlarge to irregular lesions with brown-gray to black necrotic spots on the leaf surfaces. While infection of mature fruits appears as small dark circular spots becoming sunken lesions, prior to ripening, the lesions are black and expand rapidly in size, producing acervuli with different colors of conidial masses under high relative humidity (Fig 1a-1c). All
Colletotrichum isolates were isolated from mangos cv. Nam Dork Mai See Tong, which were collected from 3 provinces in Thailand: Chachoengsao, Ratchaburi and Phichit, containing 10, 15 and 12 fungal pathogens, respectively (Table 2).
Generally, anthracnose disease can invade preharvest in leaves, shoots, inflorescences and fruits, including postharvest (latent infection) fruits. The postharvest phase is the most damaging and economically significant phase of the disease worldwide. This disease stage directly affects the marketability of the fruit, rendering it worthless.
Akem (2006) found that anthracnose is recognized as the most important disease in mangos, especially where high humidity prevails during the cropping season and directly affects marketability of the fruit. Apart from this, the study by
Ploetz et al., (1994) explained that mango anthracnose disease is found in all mango product areas of the world and is most important where high rainfall and humidity occur. Although some mango cultivars possess moderate resistance to anthracnose, but cv. Nam Dork Mai See Tong is different according to the report by
Sangchote (1987) and the
Department of Agriculture and Fisheries, Queensland (2014), which described the mango cv. Nam Dork Mai group to be more susceptible to fungal diseases, such as
Botryosphaeria spp.,
Lasiodiplodia theobromae and
Colletotrichum. The major mango cultivars in Thailand are Nam Dork Mai No.4 and Nam Dork Mai See Tong, which is spread throughout the country. Hence, anthracnose disease is a very common disease in mango production. The distribution of mango anthracnose in Thailand is in several important mango product areas, such as Phitsanulok, Chiang Mai, Prachuap Khiri Khan, Suphan Buri, Phetchabun, Chachoengsao, Phichit and Ratchaburi (
Thailand’s Department of Agricultural Extension, 2018). In the field, anthracnose can cause a direct loss of fruit quality, leading to a loss of the mango fruits. Therefore, field management is crucial to control mango anthracnose to reduce severe decline in fruit quality and to assure customer satisfaction.
Fungal identification
Based on morphological and colony characteristics, a total of 37 isolates were divided into 2 groups, of which 5 isolates were identified as
C. acutatum with white to gray mycelia covered with orange to bright orange conidial masses (Fig 1d-1e); the conidia were hyaline, single celled and cylindrical to clavate constricted at the middle being rounded at one end and tapered at the other (3.29-6.57×9.91-22.79 µm) (Fig 1f), setae absent; the appressoria were mostly single, medium brown, smoot-walled, ellipsoidal to obovate sometimes undulate (2.30-7.92´4.42-12.69 µm) (Fig 1g-1j). Thirty-two isolates were identified as
C. gloeosporioides with white, gray to green olive cottony aerial mycelia and pale to orange salmon conidial masses (Fig 1k-1l); conidia hyaline, 1 cell, straight to cylindrical with round shapes at both ends (3.59-6.91×11.02-19.52 µm) (Fig 1m) and the appressoria varied in shape, deeply lobed to irregular shapes (4.37-7.31×6.49-11.59 µm) (Fig 1n-1q).
Additionally, PCR assays confirmed the morphological identification of
Colletotrichum in both species. Species-specific primer sets using CaInt2/ITS4 and CgInt/ITS4 were designed to prosperously distinguish between
C. acutatum and
C. gloeosporioides. Of the 37 isolates evaluated, 32 were positive for
C. gloeosporioides when the CgInt/ITS4 primers were applied, while only 5 (isolates RB014 from Ratchaburi and PC006, PC007, PC011 and PC012 from Phichit) were positive for
C. acutatum when CaInt2/ITS4 was used. PCR products of approximately 500 bp in both species were obtained and visualized in an agarose electrophoresis gel (Table 2). Furthermore, molecular identification was similar to that based on morphological characteristics.
Many researchers have reported that anthracnose caused by
Colletotrichum is one of the most severe diseases in mangos. In particular,
C. gloeosporioides has been reported to be one of the dominant pathogens infecting mangos in Thailand. Later, it was revealed that other species of
Colletotrichum, such as
C. acutatum,
C. asianum and
C. siamense, also attacked mangos (
Đinh et al., 2003;
Than et al., 2008; Prihastuti et al., 2009; Rungjindamai, 2016;
Pongpisutta et al., 2019).
Inter simple sequence repeat-PCR (ISSR-PCR)
Six ISSR primers were used to reveal the genetic diversity of
Colletotrichum species causing mango anthracnose and all primers produced interpretable and variable banding patterns (Table 3). These primers amplified 46 total DNA bands and 35 polymorphic bands from 37 isolates with sizes ranging from 200 to 2,500 bp (Fig 2). The number of total bands scored per primer ranged from 5 (GACA
4) to 11 (GTG
5), with an average of 8 bands (Table 3). The most informative primers were CAG
5, GCA
5 and GTG
5 generating 100% polymorphic loci (PL), whereas the least informative primer was GACA
4 producing 72.97% polymorphic loci (Table 3).
Certainly, the number of polymorphic loci and percentage of polymorphic loci (PPL) are important factors that affect the level of genetic variation in a population. When using ISSR markers, values for the observed number of alleles (Na), effective number of alleles (Ne) and genetic diversity (h) within the 37 isolates are important indicators that influence the level of genetic variation in the population found. Dominant primers were able to detect the highest level of variability, which was demonstrated by the highest values, such as CAG
5 (Na=2.0000, Ne=1.8418, h=0.4530) and GTG
5 (Na=2.0000, Ne=1.7391, h=0.4137), compared to other markers. The values were calculated by using GenAlEx software version 6.5 (Table 3).
Based on the ISSR-PCR products, the dendrogram clustered all the isolates (from 3 geographic populations) into 3 main groups and 8 subgroups at similarity coefficients ranging from 61 to 73% with a 100% bootstrap value and a cophenetic value of (
r) = 0.6781. The
C. gloeosporioides species complex represented 7 subgroups showing higher variation than the
C. acutatum species complex, which found only 1 subgroup (Fig 3). Analysis of diversity is an important platform to understand the development and evolution of pathogen populations, in particular the genus
Colletotrichum, which can invade various plants. ISSR-PCR is one of the techniques for detection
(McDonald et al., 1997) because of the multilocus fingerprinting profiles obtained. ISSR analysis can be applied in several investigations concerning genetic identity, parentage, clone and strain identification and pathogen taxonomy of closely related species. In addition, ISSRs are considered useful in gene mapping studies
(Zietkiewicz et al., 1994; Godwin et al., 1997; Katkar et al., 2015; Abirami et al., 2018; Prasannan and Jose, 2021) including application markers for selection of plant disease resistance variety
(Babayeva et al., 2018). However, the isolates of each subgroup blended from different geographicorigins were observed. There was no correlation between genetic diversity and geographical origins, in contrast to the report by
Palacýoðlu et al., (2020), which found that the isolates of
C. lindemuthianum causing Turkish bean anthracnose belonging to the same geographic origin were observed to be more closely related to one another.
The statistical results showed the percentage of variation within the population of these genera with a high level of genetic differentiation. Additionally, in Thailand, the genus
Colletotrichum has been reported to have a high level of population differentiation and genetic diversity, such as
C. capsici or
C. gloeosporioides causing chilli anthracnose
(Ratanacherdchai et al., 2010; Rodkate, 2012). There may be multiple clarifications for this event; for example, dispersal, wind currents and other abiotic factors (
e.g., geographical isolation) play roles in the dissemination of spores and infected fruits/plant parts and agricultural systems play an important role, there by resulting in gene exchange within populations
(Freeman et al., 2013). The difference within the populations indicated that genetic recombination in pathogen reproduction may play an important role in the population evolution of
C. gloeosporioides in Thailand. In particular, conidial anastomosis between different strains may contribute to a high level of genetic diversity within the population. Additionally, the levels of genetic diversity observed between the isolates within the same population may be attributed to sexual recombination and the parasexual cycle, which play a role in the life cycle of the pathogen
(Padder et al., 2017).
Therefore, genetic diversity studies using ISSR markers are reliable and effective tools. The results showed that the
C. gloeosporioides species complex occupied a high level of genetic polymorphism and clustered into 2 main groups and 7 subgroups.
Pathogenicity test
Pathogenicity was tested using Koch’s postulates for all
C. gloeosporioides and
C. acutatum isolates
. These isolates all caused sunken spots and dark brown to brown lesions at Day 5 after the inoculation period. Ten
C. gloeosporioides isolates (CS001, CS005, CS006, CS007, CS010, RB001, RB002, RB009, RB010 and PC001) and 2
C. acutatum isolates (PC006 and PC007) caused the most severe symptoms, with level 3 disease incidence in particular. PC006 (
Ca) and CS005 (
Cg) showed the highest aggressiveness with disease incidences of 84.74 and 80.90%, respectively. However, there were few visible symptoms, with level 1 disease incidence from 13
C. gloeosporioides isolates (CS009, RB003, RB004, RB006, RB007, RB008, RB012, RB013, PC002, PC004, PC005, PC009 and PC010) and 3
C. acutatum isolates (RB014, PC011 and PC012). The isolates representing the lowest disease incidence, PC011 (
Ca) and RB004 (
Cg), had disease incidences of 8.42 and 6.13%, respectively (Table 2; Fig 4).
The predominance of
C. gloeosporioides (31.25%) and
C. acutatum (40%) in the mango anthracnose pathogen population from 3 provinces in Thailand can be attributed to their high levels of pathogenicity and aggressiveness. Although
, C. acutatum was found in only 5 isolates in mango plantations in Ratchaburi and Phichit provinces, 40% of the population exhibited aggressiveness higher than the population of
C. gloeosporioides. Temperature is among the key environmental factors affecting pathogen survival. Culture of
Colletotrichum on PDA in both species was performed at 25-30°C under a 12 hr light/12 photoperiod hr dark for 5 days. Mycelial growth was measured and the growth diameter of
C. gloeosporioides was found to be greater than that of
C. acutatum. However, there was no correlation between the diversity and geographical origin or aggressiveness and this research found that PC006 (
Ca) showed more aggressiveness than CS005 (
Cg). Similar to some reports, several
Colletotrichum spp. were found to have the capacity to cause strawberry anthracnose in temperate regions
(Damm et al., 2012; Weir et al., 2012). Chung et al., (2020) found that the predominance of
C. siamense (75%) and
C. fructicola (11%) in the strawberry anthracnose pathogen population in Taiwan can be attributed to their higher levels of pathogenicity and aggressiveness. Due to rising global temperatures, it will be particularly imperative to monitor the dissemination of
C. acutatum toward mango plantations in Thailand. The results provide precise information about pathogen identification, which is valuable for the development of effective disease management strategies.