Green synthesis
The production of ZnO NPs was suggested by the reaction mixture’s color changing from pale yellow to pale white precipitate, which verified the presence of zinc
(Thi et al., 2021). The reaction mixtures changed from brown to dark brown, confirming the presence of iron
(Ustun et al., 2022). The reaction mixture changed from pale white to brown, indicating the presence of manganese
(Hoseinpour et al., 2018).
UV-visible spectroscopy
In the present study, the UV-visible absorption spectra of the biosynthesized ZnO, Fe
2O
3 and MnO
2 NPs are recorded for wavelength 200-700 nm (Fig 1a). All the biosynthesized NPs revealed a broad absorption band between 250-380 nm in the UV-region that indicated their strong ability to absorb UV light. Although, Fe
2O
3 and MnO
2 NPs both have excellent visible light absorption features between 400-700 nm than ZnO NPs (Fig 1a). The optical band gap energies (
Eg, eV) of the biosynthesized NPs have been estimated by extrapolating the straight line to the horizontal axis in the high absorption region (Fig 1b) using the Tauc plot method for direct
(Kumar et al., 2020). The calculated
Eg values for the ZnO, Fe
2O
3 and MnO2 NPs are found to be 3.17 eV, 2.11 eV and 2.01 eV respectively. These values are also consistent with the published literature
(Kumar et al., 2020).
Field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM)
FE-SEM micrographs of biosynthesized ZnO, Fe
2O
3 and MnO
2 NPs (Fig 2a-c) displayed irregular-sized, agglomerated and globular ranged assemblies. FE-SEM images are further analyzed for the particle size frequency count using ImageJ software as shown in Fig 2d-f. FE-SEM images (Fig 2a-c) displayed that the largest grain size is observed in MnO
2 NPs (20-300 nm having an average size of ~115 nm) while it has uniform smallest nano assemblies of the particles. However, for Fe
2O
3 NPs larger grains in irregular size (20-160 nm with an average of ~75 nm) are formed. In the case of ZnO NPs, irregular assemblies along with a few hexagonal shapes (20-160 nm with an average of 47 nm) are observed.
X-ray diffraction (XRD)
In the XRD pattern (Fig 3 a-c), the diffraction peaks that appeared at different 2
θ positions indexed for corresponding (
hkl) values for ZnO, Fe
2O
4 and MnO
2 nanoparticles are matched well with JCPDS card 031-1451, 89-596 and 44-0141 respectively
(Kumar et al., 2020). Also, a hexagonal type wurtzite structure for polycrystalline ZnO nanoparticles oriented along (101) reflection plane, a hematite structure for
α-Fe
2O
3 having a prominent (104) reflection plane and a tetragonal structure for
α-MnO
2 with crystallites orientation in (100) plane has been observed. Furthermore, the average size of crystallites was calculated from Debye-Scherer’s equation
(Kumar et al., 2020) and was found to be 40.14 nm for ZnO, 23.21 nm for Fe
2O
3 and 18.84 nm for MnO2 nanoparticles.
Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy
FT-IR spectra for biosynthesized ZnO, Fe
2O
3 and MnO
2 NPs were displayed in Fig 3d-f. All the samples have a strong and broad absorption band between wavenumber ~3400-3430 cm
-1 that results from the hydrogen bonding of O-H groups between H2O molecules. It is also an indication for the presence of water or moisture content on the surface of nanoparticles and is further supported by the detection of O-H bending vibration at ~1600-1630 cm
-1 and ~1030-1060 cm
-1. In case of ZnO and Fe
2O
3 (Fig 3d, e), the-CH3 vibration at ~1380 cm
-1 ascribed to the alkane group of phytochemicals also observed. For MnO
2 NPs, (Fig 3f), strong absorption bands at 860, 1415 and 1589 cm
-1 are observed which are ascribed to C-H out of plane, C-O stretch of carboxylic acid and asymmetric/symmetric C=O stretching
(Shatnawi et al., 2016). A strong absorption band observed at 480 cm
-1 is ascribed for Zn–O stretching vibrations (Fig 3d), double bands at 461 cm
-1 and 618 cm
-1 are attributed to Fe-O-Fe stretching (Fig 3e) and a band at 613 cm
-1 primarily assigned to Mn-O-Mn vibration modes in MnO
2 (Fig 3f). Moreover, the characteristics absorption bands correspond to ZnO, Fe2O3 and MnO2 NPs are well matched with the reported literature
(Keshri and Biswas, 2022).
Effect of nanoparticles on seed germination
The maximum germination frequency (25.00) of brinjal seeds was observed in MnO NPs with seed vigour (88.33), followed by ZnFeMn (23.75) and Zn (22.50) NPs for 20 ppm and also in case of 10 ppm ZnO (21.25). The 50 ppm concentration was found less effective on seed germination. Therefore, the maximum seed germination frequency was observed with 20
ppm concentration of all single, double and triple combinations followed by 10
ppm.
The maximum germination frequency (20.00) of tomato seeds was observed in ZnFe, Zn and MnZn (19.00) NPs for 20
ppm and followed by ZnFeMn and Zn (18.00) for 10
ppm. The 50
ppm concentration was found less effective on seed germination. Therefore, the maximum seed germination frequency was observed with 20
ppm concentration of all single, double and triple combinations followed by 10
ppm in some cases. The maximum seed vigour was observed with 20 and 10
ppm concentrations in ZnFe (76.66), Zn (71.66) and ZnFeMn (71.66) respectively, as compared to other treatments. The maximum germination frequency (22.50) of chilli seeds was observed in Zn and MnZn NPs for 20
ppm and 10
ppm respectively, followed by Zn (18.00) and ZnFe (17.00) for 10
ppm. The 20
ppm concentration was also found more effective in case of chilli. Similar effects were also observed in case of 50
ppm concentration on seed germination. The seed vigour was observed with 20
ppm concentration in Zn (67.50) followed by ZnFe (64.16) followed by MnZn (61.66).
Statistical assessment of seed germination behavior
Assessing seed germination behavior in tomato, chili and brinjal through SG (%age), MGF and SVI is vital for ensuring seed quality and plant establishment. High SG (%age) indicates viable seeds, while MGF reflects germination speed, crucial for uniform growth. SVI offers a comprehensive measure of seed vigor. Statistical analysis of these parameters provides insights into seed performance, helping breeders and farmers make informed decisions by identifying significant differences among seed lots and varieties.
Evaluation of seed germination (%age) through regression
Regression analysis of seed germination data using Minitab revealed key insights. Time (Hrs) positively influenced germination, increasing it by 0.60% per hour, while higher substance concentrations (
ppm) decreased it by 0.36% per
ppm. Plant seed type also played a crucial role;
Solanum lycopersicum and
Solanum melongena boosted germination by 12.40% and 11.39%, respectively (Table 1). Nanoparticles significantly enhanced germination, with ZnOFe2O3 showing the highest impact at 20.09%. The model fit was strong, with an
r-squared value of 79.89%, indicating the model explained most variability in seed germination. Statistical analysis confirmed the significance of these factors, providing valuable insights for optimizing seed germination and improving crop yields.
Error bar plots were used to analyze the impact of plant seed (type), time (Hrs), nanoparticle (type) and concentration (
ppm) on seed germination (percentage). The plots revealed that
Solanum lycopersicum (66.08%) and
Solanum melongena (66.37%) had significantly higher germination rates compared to
Capsicum annuum (54.73%), highlighting the importance of plant seed type (Fig 4). Time also positively influenced germination, with rates increasing from 15.42% at 24 hours to 89.21% at 144 hours. Nanoparticle treatments enhanced germination, with ZnOFe
2O
3 showing the highest rate at 71.68%, compared to the control at 50.10%. However, higher concen- trations (50
ppm) reduced germination to 52.38%, indicating that while moderate concentrations (10-20
ppm) were beneficial, excessive amounts could inhibit germination. With
p-values below 0.05, it was confirmed that plant seed type, time, nanoparticle type and concentration significantly affected seed germination. These findings underscore the importance of optimizing these factors to improve crop yields.
Assessment of MGF through One-way ANOVA
One-way ANOVA on mean germination frequency (MGF) revealed significant effects of plant seed (type), nanoparticle (type) and concentration (
ppm) on germination. For plant seed type, the ANOVA showed significant differences (
p = 0.006,
f = 5.59), with
Solanum melongena having the highest mean MGF (17.603), followed by
Solanum lycopersicum (15.738) and
Capsicum annuum (14.628). Regarding nanoparticle type, significant differences were found (
p = 0.023,
f = 2.52), with ZnO yielding the highest mean MGF (18.60) and the control group the lowest (13.050). The analysis of concentration revealed the most substantial differences (
p = 0.000,
f = 15.95), with 20
ppm showing the highest MGF (17.859), while 50
ppm had the lowest (13.473). These results highlighted that
Solanum melongena seeds, ZnO nanoparticles and a concentration of 20
ppm were optimal for enhancing seed germination. The findings emphasize the importance of selecting the right seed type, nanoparticle treatment and concentration for optimal germination outcomes.
The error-bar plots revealed key insights into MGF with respect to plant seed (type), nanoparticle (type) and concentration (Fig 5).
Solanum melongena seeds had the highest MGF (~ 19.1) and showed consistent germination performance, outperforming
Solanum lycopersicum and
Capsicum annuum. Among nanoparticles, ZnO had the highest MGF (21.0), significantly enhancing seed germination compared to the control group, which had the lowest MGF (13.9). Concentration analysis showed that 20
ppm yielded the highest MGF (19.3), while 50
ppm, though more variable, resulted in the lowest MGF (14.4). These findings highlighted that
Solanum melongena seeds, ZnO nanoparticles and a 20
ppm concentration were optimal for improving germination, providing valuable guidance for optimizing seed treatment protocols.
Estimation of SVI through analysis of means
Seed Vigour Index (SVI) analysis revealed significant differences among plant seed (types) with
Solanum lycopersicum having the highest mean SVI (62.15), closely followed by
Solanum melongena (61.50), while
Capsicum annuum had the lowest (49.68). The analysis of nanoparticles suggested that ZnOFe
2O
3 had the highest mean SVI (65.13), although the differences were not statistically significant (Fig 6). Concentration levels significantly influenced SVI, with 20
ppm yielding the highest mean SVI (65.07), followed by 10
ppm (60.00). The highest concentration (50
ppm) resulted in the lowest SVI (48.27). The findings highlighted that
Solanum species, ZnOFe2O3 nanoparticles and moderate concentrations (20
ppm) were optimal for enhancing seed vigour, providing crucial insights for improving seed treatments.
Nano-fertilizers have shown positive effects on seed germination and seedling health, with notable improvements over control groups
(Prasad et al., 2012; Madzokere et al., 2021). Research indicates that soaking brinjal, tomato and chili seeds in various nano-fertilizer concentrations significantly boosts growth in a dose-dependent manner. Seeds treated with ZnO, Fe
2O
3 and MnO
2 NPs generally germinated between the fifth and sixth day, with more intense germination towards the end. ZnO-NPs had varying effects across crop species, with 20
ppm concentrations improving seed germination more effectively than 50
ppm. García-López
et al. (2018) observed that while different ZnO NP concentrations did not significantly affect chili seed germination, they notably improved seedling vigor, attributed to zinc nanoparticles’ role in auxin synthesis. Green synthesized Fe
2O
3 NPs increased the vigor index of tomatoes
(Karunakaran et al., 2017; Abusalem et al., 2019).
High NP concentrations may harm seedlings, but low concentrations of ZnO-NPs generally enhance germination and growth, 50
ppm ZnO-NPs improved germination. ZnO-NPs also increase root phytohormones, such as IAA, which promote growth
(Pandey et al., 2010). Concentrations above 800
ppm ZnO-NPs were detrimental to growth and germination
(Liu et al., 2015). Topical NP-based nutrients offer a faster, more efficient means of nutrient delivery
(Kanwal et al., 2022), with green NPs gaining popularity for their biocontrol efficacy
(Hoang et al., 2022; Kumar et al., 2024) and yield
(Sharma et al., 2024). Optimizing these parameters enhances agricultural practices and yields, leading to stronger crops and reduced plant competition.