Indian Journal of Agricultural Research
Chief EditorV. Geethalakshmi
Print ISSN 0367-8245
Online ISSN 0976-058X
NAAS Rating 5.60
SJR 0.293
Chief EditorV. Geethalakshmi
Print ISSN 0367-8245
Online ISSN 0976-058X
NAAS Rating 5.60
SJR 0.293
Genetic Analysis of Various Traits in Oilseed Brassicas
Submitted05-03-2021|
Accepted30-07-2021|
First Online 27-10-2021|
The experimental material comprised of (three different species) seven parents including three of B. campestris (Toria, UAF11, 1072), two of B. napus, (Napus1, Napus2) and two of B. juncea (Juncea1 and Shora). Three genotypes were used as female parent (Toria, Napus1 and Juncea1) each from each species and four as male parent i.e. two from B. campestris (UAF11 and 1072) one B. napus (Napus2) and one B. juncea (Shora). These were crossed in the field to obtain intra and interspecific hybrids/crosses in a line × tester fashion during 2015-2016. All crosses (12F1) along with their parents (7 parents) were sown in randomized complete block design (RCBD) with three replications at the farm of Department of Plant Breeding and Genetics University of Agriculture Faisalabad during 2016-2017. Ten plants were tagged in each replication and data were recorded for thirteen traits. Data includes four phenological (days to flowering initiation, days to 50% flowering, days to 50% siliqua formation and days to maturity), five morphological (plant height, primary branches, secondary branches, green biomass yield, harvest index) and four yield and yield related (siliquae per plant, seed per siliqua, tested seed weight and yield per plant).
Statistical analysis
Data were statistically analysed for genetic variability (Steel et al., 1997). The estimates of combining ability were obtained using the formula given by Kempthorne (1957). Heterosis over the mid parent and better parent was estimated according to Falconer, (1960).
Analysis of variance for different characters in oilseed brassicas
The analysis of variance showed highly significant mean squares values among the genotypes obtained through introgressions and extensive variability for all traits studied (Table 1). The sum of square values for indicated traits were partitioned into parents, crosses and parent vs. crosses, displayed considerable differences among themselves. The mean square values for crosses was further divided in line and tester fashion. Highly significant differences were present among lines and testers, for all the traits except for primary branches and secondary branches for testers. Evaluation of genetic variability for economic important traits in rapeseed and mustard is a fundamental purpose in breeding. Early studies on genetics of brassica species showed that morphological differences were created through breeding (Offerson, 1924). Oilseed brassicas have considerable differences at inter and intraspecific levels for morphological, phenological and yield related traits reported by earlier worker (Abideen et al., 2013 and Parveen et al., 2015).
Manifestation of heterosis due to intra and interspecific hybridization
Substantial amount of relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis was noted for yield and other related characters (Table 4). All 12 hybrids were compared with mid parent and better parent for evaluation of heterosis. The results for morphological, phenological and yield related traits were presented as under.
Days to flowering initiation
Out of total 12 crosses, 6 hybrids were identified for significant and negative relative heterosis i.e. Toria × shora (-26.49**) Toria × Napus2 (-20.68**), Napus1 × UAF11 (-18.57**). Juncea1 × Shora (-13.06**) Juncea1 × 1072 (-12.66**) and Juncea1 × Napus2 (-8.44**) respectively.
Days to 50% flowering
Out of 12 combinations only 3 showed considerable negative heterosis over mid parent and 9 over better parent heterosis. Junce1 × 1072 (-8.72), Juncea1 × Napus2 (-5.02) and Juncea1 × Shora (-2.03) showed negative relative heterosis and combinations Toria ×´ Shora (-22.68), Toria × Napus2 (-17.91) and Napus1 × UAF11 (-17.81) for heterobeltiosis.
Days to 50% siliquae formation
Out of 12 hybrids, two crosses (Toria × shora and Juncea1 × 1072) showed significant and negative relative heterosis while three (Toria × Shora, Napus1 × UAF11 and Toria × Napus2) for heterobeltiosis for days to 50% siliqua formation.
Days to maturity
Three hybrids were at the top for significant negative relative heterosis (Juncea1 × 1072, Juncea1 × Shora and Juncea1 × Napus2) and six hybrids showed significant and negative heterobeltiosis for days to maturity.
Plant height
Out of 12 crosses, only one hybrid for mid parent heterosis and three showed significant and negative heterobeltiosis for plant height (Table 4).
Primary branches
Two crosses out of 12 showed positive relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis for primary branches. These crosses were Toria × UAF11, (72.55), (51.72) and Juncea1 × Shora (62.96), (41.94) revealed positive and significant relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis.
Secondary branches
Two crosses out of 12 showed positive and significant heterosis and heterobeltiosis for secondary branches viz. Toria × UAF11 (633.33 and 303.33) and Toria × Shora (198.67 and 148.89).
Green biomass and harvest index
Only two cross combinations showed considerable and positive heterosis and heterobeltiosis for green biomass (Table 4). Positive relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis is desirable for high yielding cultivar. The combination Juncea1 × 1072 (147.82, 72.14) and Toria × Napus 2 (60.44, 14.96) showed positive and significant heterosis and heterobeltiosis while four, Toria × 1072 (291.77, 249.72), Toria × Shora (163.95, 134.62), Juncea1 × Shora (118.98, 101.81) and Napus1 × 1072 (66.12, 51.23) crosses showed positive and significant heterosis and heterobeltiosis for harvest index.
Number of siliquae per plant and number of seed per siliqua
Seven hybrids showed positive and significant relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis for number of siliquae per plant and none of the 12 hybrids was significant for number of seed per plant.
Tested seed weight (100-seed)
Three cross combinations; Toria × 1072 (32.79, 24.62), Toria × Shora (42.40, 30.88) and Juncea1 × Shora (44.53, 43.48) hybrid showed positive and considerable heterosis and heterobeltiosis for tested seed weight.
Seed yield per plant
Only three hybrids out of 12 combinations showed positive and significant value for relative heterosis and heterobeltiosis (Table 4). The combination was Toria × 1072 (156.47), Juncea1 × Shora (127.58) and Toria × Shora (65.00) were at the top for the value of relative heterosis in yield per plant.
The heterosis obtained from hybridization between races or species gives an excessive increase in size, weight and growth rate in the interspecific or inter-racial hybrids. Such type of heterosis is called luxuriance and hybrids are luxuriant (Dobzhansky, 1940). There is no continuation due to poor seed setting in luxuriant hybrids.
Negative heterosis is preferred in Brassica campestris because it shows earliness in flowering. The crosses showing earliness can be used for further breeding program.
Synrem et al., (2015) also reported desirable negative and significant heterosis for days to 50% flowering in Brassica species. For early maturing cultivars negative heterosis for 50% days to siliquae formation is an advantageous trait.
The comparison of nap and mur cytoplasmic system showed negative heterosis for days to maturity (Riungu and McVetty, 2004). Early maturity is a useful trait in many plant species; however it is very important in Brassica species because late maturity causes the yield losses and quality of oil due to high temperature (Turi et al., 2011). Negative heterosis is valuable in brassicas for early maturity (Yadava et al., 2012).
Negative heterosis is also desirable for plant height in Brassica species. Dwarf and medium plant height resist to high wind velocity, logging and mechanical breakage. The heterosis studied in oilseed rape for plant height was none significant. Negative values were also noted for some crosses (Grant and Beversdorf, 1985). Significant and negative heterosis for plant height had also been described by Tyagi et al., (2000).
Plant with more branches will be vigorous and produces more yield. The highest value for heterosis and heterobeltiosis was identified for primary branches 24.25 vs. 12.30% in Brassica species by Nausheen and Amanullah (2015). Vigorous plant will provide opportunity for high yielding cultivar reported by Niranjana et al., (2014).
The use of plant biomass plays an important role for animal hay and biogas production. The estimation of heterosis for fresh biomass, dry matter and dry biomass, the average was greater of hybrids than parent genotypes; however dry biomass was greater in parents. It might be increased up to thirty per cent (Ofori et al., 2008).
Fornumber ofsiliquae per plant and seed per siliqua positive and significant heterosis is advantageous for the development of high yielding genotypes. Results were partially similar reported by Synrem et al., (2015). Positive heterosis is desirable for tested seed weight for the development of high yielding genotype.
The aim of the heterosis breeding is to attain the high yielding combinations with desirable quality traits. It has been reported that the genomic components introgressed from B. rapa can improve the seed yield of rapeseed (Qian et al., 2005). Significant and positive heterosis had also been reported by earlier workers (Meena et al., 2014; Synrem et al., 2015).
All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article or claim that may be made by its manufacturer is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.
This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.