The positive or negative growth impact of nano-particles has been known in plants. The study has been done for the morphological parameter and plant fresh weight for up to 60 days. There were many ups and downs growth results of the metallic nano oxide treatment have been seen on plants. The study reveals that the effect of the zinc-oxide was favorable for the positive morphological growth. The silver oxides showed an opposite direction. The interaction of silver oxide reduces the growth with increased dose concentration. The titanium and copper showed a little diversity in cotton growing pattern.
Effect of zinc-oxide nanoparticles on the morphological growth of Gossypium hirsutum
This has been observed in many previous studies that zinc-oxide has been shown valuable effects on many crop plants as well as many other plant species. The zinc is also very essential for the carbohydrate metabolism of the plants
(Mousavi et al., 2013). It has been observed that zinc concentrations have been helpful for the induction of seed germination and initiate seedling
(Laware et al., 2014). The interaction of zinc oxide during study also demonstrated that the effect of zinc oxide is more productive than the other three remaining nano-oxides. The treated plants with zinc were very healthy and fresh. The flowering time of zinc oxide treated plants were earliest as compare to the rest of them. The zinc oxide concentration was directly preoperational to the height, leaves count, and fresh weight of the plant. The increment of the concentration of nano-oxide from 40 ppm to 100 ppm lead to increased the height (Fig 1) as well as the fresh weight of plants (Fig 5). The concentration of 80 ppm and 100 ppm of zinc treatments were very significant for the shoot growth of the plant. The shoot was very healthy and highest in fresh weight measurement (Fig 5). The sustainable positive morphological results have been seen till the last phase of plant growth as compared to the control. The Concentration of 80 and 100 ppm of zinc-oxide also showed the healthiest plant status as well as the earliest flowering stage. The maximum number of foliage also reported at zinc-oxide treatment in comparison to the other plants having different concentration of metallic nano-oxide (Fig 5).
Effect of copper oxides nanoparticles on the morphological growth of Gossypium hirsutum
The induced copper oxides concentrations showed a concentration-specific role in many crop plants. They are also a key nutrient for better plant growth and functions as an activator for many enzymes in photosynthetic reaction
(Adhikari et al., 2012). Rajput et al., 2018 reported in his review of copper effect on crop plants, that copper causes a very specific and significant reduction or limits the seed germination
(Rajput et al., 2018). In the present study, the copper oxides did not show a uniform growth pattern as zinc and silver oxide did. The copper oxides concentration of 40, 60 and 80 ppm initially enhanced the morphological parameter of the plant in comparison to control (Fig 2). At the middle phase of plant growth around between 25
th to 40
th day 40, 60, and 100 ppm were equivalent to control. There were neither positive nor negative results have been reported but concentration 80 ppm has given the best result. The lastly, copper oxide concentrations were not that effective for plant growth as they were in the initial growth phase. The plant growth was limited if we provide them continuous doses of copper nano-oxides. The 80 ppm concentration of copper showed a little more fresh weight as compared to control. The flowering stage did not induced early as seen in case of zinc oxide.
Effect of titanium-oxide nanoparticles on the morphological growth of Gossypium hirsutum
The titanium oxides are well known for their unpredictable effects on crop plants. Each concentration of titanium oxides has variant effects on plant species
(Mattiello et al., 2018) Some studies were also proven that a small dose or concentration of titanium nano-oxide can improve the crop performance in different aspects (
Lyu et al., 2017). In the case of titanium oxide treatment, all the concentrations were given the best results initially as compared to control. The germination results of titanium oxide treatment were seen productive. The highest morphological impact of 100 ppm concentration was seen till the 45
th day (Fig 3). The titanium oxides effect fall at the time of flowering and control gave better results. The leaves count of titanium was very productive at 80 ppm concentration (Fig 5). The fresh weights were as alike as their height measures (Fig 5). Whereas 40 ppm concentration of titanium-oxide had shown much-developed root growth as compared to control. The early flowering did not even seen in titanium oxide treated plants.
Effect of silver-oxide nanoparticles on the morphological growth of Gossypium hirsutum
The silver oxides showed a negative growth impact on
Gossypium hirsutum. As the concentration of silver nano-oxide increases the development and morphological growth of plant get decreased. Plant morphological character like root and shoot growth and fresh weight of plant also get reduced with the treatment of silver
(Yan et al., 2019). Many studies revealed that phytotoxicity of silver affect the plants at their physiological level by reduction in chlorophyll content and nutrient uptake; reduce transpiration rate and also alteration of hormonal activity. The silver oxide had been little toxic for prokaryotes and cell lines of mammals and it also showed very conflict results in various kinds of plant species
(Vannini et al., 2014). The present study showed that silver treatment with species hasn’t shown a negative growth impact at the time of germination as well as in the initial growth of plants up to 80 ppm concentration. The 100 ppm concentration has been remained negative for all the majoring aspects of species growth from germination to maturity. The plants growths were positive even better till the 30th day of growth at 40, 60 and 80 ppm concentration of silver nano-oxide. After the 30
th day, growth of the plants didn’t work out well as compared to control and growth was retarded (Fig 4). The flowering period of the plant also has been slower as compared to control. The 80 ppm concentration affect root growth very negatively, it was hardly 1.5 cm in length. The fresh weight of 80 ppm plant root was very little as compared to other silver and different metallic concentrations (Fig 5). The leaves count or foliage was also getting vice versa effect due to having short stem length (Fig 5). The plants of silver oxides haven’t been that fresh and healthy as the other metallic oxides treated plants.
Co-relational study of all four metallic-nano-oxides
The detailed morphological study of four metallic nano-particles reveals that correlation between them had a very little relational degree. The zinc oxides exponential results were far better than any other metallic nano-oxide. The relational analysis between titanium oxides, silver oxides and copper oxides showed almost indistinguishable effects up to 60 ppm concentration in the case of plants fresh weight. The overall result analysis stated that silver oxides were given the substandard developmental growth. The collation in between copper and titanium oxides, copper oxides proved themselves a better expectancy for growth.
Statistical analysis
The statistical analysis was done by the software graph pad prism. The two-way ANNOVA test had been applied on morphological data. The results of two -way ANNOVA test at the 5% level (P=0.05) significant for all measurements evaluated. The results are presented as an average ± standard deviation. Test results were been significant with every morphological data of each nano-oxide treatment. The five different concentrations (00, 40, 60, 80, 100 ppm) of every nano-oxide in respect to days were used to acknowledge the variation in respect to plant height, leave count, and fresh weight of plants. The significant F-test was obtained. The triplet data of each nano-oxide concentration were provided for getting the best and mean result.