Zero analysis
The physical and chemical properties of the soil collected from feldspar mine showed that the soil is highly alkaline in nature and poor in major nutrients (Table 1). Feldspar mine spoil is having average 72% gravel and seasonally provide cohesive environment for water holding and microbes assisted mineral solubilization hence, the poor fertility of the feldspar mine spoil is depicted by the low concentration of major minerals (N, P, K, Ca and Mg) and micronutrients (Cu, Zn, Mn and Fe)
According to
Tripathi et al., (2012), soil clay content directly effects nutrients and nutrient transformation in the soil and is showed significant correlation with organic C, nitrogen and available phosphorous, found in coal mine spoil. Therefore, in present study the soil texture of having low clay content may be responsible for the low macronutrients and OC, whereas,
Yaseen et al., (2014) statistically proved the positive correlation of organic carbon with EC, available P and N. Therefore in feldspar mine spoil low EC, N and P was may be due to low organic carbon. Similarly
Pasayat and Patel (2015) while assessing the iron mine spoil quality stated that, soil texture also effects other soil properties, which in turn determines microbial growth, hence low dehydrogenase activity was attributed towards the poor soil texture of feldspar mine spoil.
Growth parameters
Influence of microbial inoculants, organic inorganic amendments can be clearly seen on plant growth parameters in feldspar mine spoil (Table 2). We have recorded maximum plant height (121 cm) in treatment
Azotobacter + OM + NPK 50% followed by treatment AMF
+ OM + NPK 50% (116 cm) over the uninoculated control and other treatments. Same trend was found in shoot diameter, plant canopy and dry weight. Overall,
Azotobacter has successfully influenced plant growth in comparison of
Azospirillum, whereas AMF was also found to be significant at P≤0.05%.
Azotobacter (Hindersah
et al., 2018),
Azospirillum (
Widawati and Suliasih, 2019) and Mycorrhizae (
Aggangan and Cortes, 2018) are known to excel in unfavourable environment and proved to establish soil fertility of groundnut (
Arachis hypogaea) in mercury spoil, great millet (
Sorghum bicolor) in tin spoil and Narra (
Pterocarpus indicus) in copper mine spoil, respectively. As
Azotobacter releases growth promoting hormones auxin, cytokinin and gibberellin (Vikhe, 2014), that stimulate cell extension and division which promote plant growth (
Takatsuka and Umeda, 2014). AM fungi inoculated seedlings of
Eucalyptus tereticornis showed 95% survival over the control seedlings and their growth was also significantly higher in bauxite mine spoil (
Karthikeyan and Krishnakumar, 2012). Study by
Gul et al., (2019), also supported our results where growth of guar responded well towards the consortium of bioinoculants and inorganic fertilizers. Hence, these bioinoculants were found to be effective in reviving the soil health and plant development and growing plants together with rhizobacteria and AMF in feldspar mine spoils stimulated the plant germination, shoot as well as root growth.
Enzymatic activities
The presence of small dehydrogenase activity and 5.5% clay in feldspar mine spoil indicated the signs of possibility for the rejuvenation of mined land as clay content directly effects soil organic carbon, available P and microbial growth. Table 3 is showing the results of the improvement in rhizosphere enzymatic activity, available P and organic carbon in guar. Among the enzymatic activities, the alkaline phosphatase activity of the soil has been increased throughout the incubation period in all the treatments than uninoculated control, irrespective of feldspar concentration in the spoil. Percentage increment in AMF+ OM+ NPK 50% treatment has been recorded 46.86% which was found to be highest followed by
Azospirillum+ OM+ NPK 50% with 44.4% increment. Results are in similarity with
Gucwa-Przepiora et al., (2016), who recorded enhanced alkaline phosphatase activity in
Plantago lanceolata by introducing AMF in Zn/Pb mine spoil.
On the other side, AMF also dominated over acid phosphatase activity which has been recorded highest in AMF+ OM+ NPK 50% treatment with 76% increment, followed by
Azotobacter+ OM+ NPK 50% with 72%. This may be due to the reason given by
Sinegani and Sharifi, (2007) that, phosphatase produced by plants is exclusively acid phosphatase, in addition it may be produced by bacteria, fungi and Yeast. In present study, AMF have been found to mineralise maximum soil phosphorous in AMF + OM + NPK 50% treatment. This is similar to the findings of
Kumar et al., (2011), who also observed that phosphatase activity is related to soil OM and NPK in soil. The increase in the bacterial count in
Azotobacter+ OM+ NPK 50% (T
7) and
Azospirillum+ OM + NPK 50% (T
12) was found (50 x 10
5CFU ml
-1) and (48 x 10
5CFU ml
-1) respectively and significant at P£0.05%, over the uninoculated control. The higher bacterial count over the control was anticipated due to the microbial stimulation with presence of plant root exudates in the rhizosphere (Rani and Juwarkar, 2012). On the same side, dehydrogenase activity in the soil followed the same trend as of microbial count. DHA activities were also found maximum with T
7 (4.76 pkat g
-1) and T
12 (4.69 pkat g
-1). The result is supported by
Rath et al., (2010), who found that the soil enzyme activities have indicated significant positive correlation with the number of bacterial and fungal colonies in iron and chromite mine spoil in Orissa, India. Similarly
Rao and Tak, (2002), while finding the effects of
Glomus mosseae on the plant species grown on limestone mine spoil found that, inoculation with AM-fungus had significantly enhanced the dehydrogenase activities compared to that of the uninoculated plants.
Availability of Olsen P was found maximum with AMF in combination with OM+ NPK 50% which is higher than NPK 100% alone. Organic carbon (OC) was also increased in the reclaimed site over the control. Maximum accumulation of OC was observed in
Azotobacter + OM + NPK 50% treatment followed by
Azospirillum + OM + NPK 50% and AMF + OM + NPK 50%. The results are in line with the previous studies showed that, soil organic carbon of coal mine increased after inoculation with AMF
(Qian et al., 2012) and organic matter
(Shrestha et al., 2019). This enhancement was due to the accumulation of organic matter in the mine soil, which has accelerated organic carbon production. These findings agree with the study by
Ekka and Behera (2011) and
Rath et al., (2010) who found the direct relationship between amount of organic carbon and soil organic matter. Legumes are also known to increase soil organic carbon.
(Rothe et al., (2002) has reported the increment in SOC by legumes. The same findings have also been observed in the present study where guar grown in feldspar mine spoil improved the SOC.
Metabolites
The photosynthetic pigments chlorophyll a, chlorophyll b, total chlorophyll and reducing sugar content in the leaves of guar grown on feldspar mine spoil are presented in Fig 1. Total chlorophyll content was found to be highest in treatment with
Azotobacter + OM+ NPK 50% (6.21 mg g
-1 fwt.) followed by
Azospirillum + OM+ NPK 50% (6.16 mg g
-1 fwt.) and AMF+ OM + NPK 50% (6.10 mg g
-1 fwt.). The results were found significant at P£0.05% over the uninoculated control. The increase in the chlorophyll content was may be due the nitrogen fixation by guar. This is supported by Hokmalipour and Darbandi, (2011), who found that chlorophyll content in the leaves is positively influenced by fertilizer application, especially nitrogen.
Verdugo et al., (2010) observed the increased chlorophyll content after the introduction of AMF in rye grass grown in copper mine whereas,
Vafadar et al., (2014), Rajashekharan and Nagarajan (2005) have seen similar rise in the chlorophyll content after the introduction of
Azotobacter chroococcum and organic manure in mine spoil. Guar has shown increased chlorophyll content and this is directly responsible for the production of various metabolites including reducing sugar.
Jin et al., (2015) reported that the level of sugar content increased in the leaves of maize plant with increased level of nitrogen. Similarly, in our studies the percentage of reducing sugar enhanced significantly with the increase of nitrogen, which may be due to the nitrogen fixation by the microbial inoculants and by guar itself.
Macro and micro nutrients
The mineral uptake in guar upon introduction of bio inoculants in mine spoil has shown significant increase over the uninoculated control (Table 4), the percentage increase in N was found to be 7 to 29%, in P it was 11 to 86%, in K 5 to 50%, in Ca 3 to 16% and in Mg it was 16 to 71%. The present study demonstrated the highest N content in a treatment of
Azospirillum+ OM and NPK 50%, highest P content was in AMF + OM + NPK 50% treatment and K, Ca, Mg content was highest in
Azotobacter + OM and NPK 50%. This result is in the line with
Yang et al., (2016), who observed that legume- rhizobia have always provided a synergistic approach on nitrogen management and was enhanced by introducing compatible soil organisms including mycorrhizal hyphae which is known for mineral solubilisation and mobilization
(Temperton et al., 2007). We have observed highest N uptake with
Azospirillum and significant intake with AMF. Similarly,
Nayak et al., (2015) indicated that organic amendments significantly enhanced the nutrient status of iron mine spoil.
Nyoki and Ndakidemi (2014) reported that rhizobia inoculation of leguminous crops supplemented with P fertilizer improves the uptake of N, P, K, Ca and Mg. Whereas,
Haferburg and Kothe (2010) reported the use of bacteria and AMF as natural biofertilizers for the delivery of metals and nutrients to the plants in metal spoils.
Phosphorus content is low in mine spoil, but the greater P concentration in feldspar mine spoil, may be due to mobilization of P by AMF (
Tarafdar and Marschner, 1994). Phosphate solubilization by rhizobacterial isolates may be influenced by the production of organic acids such as formic, acetic, propionic, lactic, glycolic, fumaric and succinic acids
(Yasmin et al., 2009), resulting in mineralization and mobilization of unavailable soil P, thus helping in increased uptake of P by the plants
(Dotaniya et al., 2014). Feldspar has insoluble form of potassium (8-10%) and therefore, this K could be effectively utilized by native potassium solubilizing microorganisms
(Kasana et al., 2017). Similarly,
Ullaman et al., (1996), has seen absorption of K enhanced rapidly upon introduction of
Bacillus mucilaginosus that can solubilize rock K mineral such as potash feldspar by production and excretion of organic acids. In our study, along with guar bioinoculants also have nitrogen fixing properties which have shown positive impact in the mineral solubilisation that supports the uptake of essential macro nutrients by the plant.
Cu, Mg and Zn resulted in significant increase but, Fe content (237 mg g
-1) was observed much higher over the control and almost three folds in case of feldspar mine spoil, since feldspar, mica and quartz are most likely responsible for the release of these metal elements
(Nagaraju et al., 2013). There has been no fixed trend observed in the absorption of Cu, Zn and Mn, these micronutrients have been found with almost similar enhancement in all the treatments.