Digital Extension in Haryana: An Analysis of Agricultural e-Content Utilization by Extension Personnel and Associated Factors

1Extension Education Institute, Nilokheri, Karnal-132 001, Haryana, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmer’s Welfare, Govt. of India.
  • Submitted17-06-2026|

  • Accepted16-11-2026|

  • First Online 21-11-2026|

  • doi 10.18805/BKAP944

Background: Electronic content (e-content) delivered through ICT platforms plays an increasingly critical role in modern agricultural extension services. However, empirical evidence regarding the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel and its determinants remains limited. This study was undertaken to assess the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel and examine its association with selected independent variables in Haryana.

Methods: The study was conducted across Karnal, Kaithal, Hisar and Mahendragarh districts of Haryana using a descriptive research design. Primary data were collected from 80 extension personnel using a pre-tested, structured interview schedule. Statistical analysis included frequency, percentage, mean percent score (MPS), Pearson chi-square test of independence and Cramér’s V effect size coefficient.

Results: An overwhelming majority of the respondents (87.50%) exhibited low to medium levels of e-content utilization. Among various digital delivery platforms, e-content accessed via social media recorded the highest utilization (MPS = 50.44), driven mainly by WhatsApp groups (MPS = 73.75) and YouTube channels (MPS = 58.75), whereas expert systems were the least utilized (MPS = 31.10). Chi-square analysis revealed that availability of IT gadgets (χ2 = 12.986), ICT training (χ2 = 11.003), accessibility of digital media (χ2 = 10.418) and education (χ2= 9.795) had statistically significant positive associations with the level of e-content use. In contrast, age, gender and job experience showed non-significant association. The study emphasizes that digital extension effectiveness depends fundamentally on workplace hardware availability, multi-channel accessibility and skill-oriented training.

Information and communication technologies (ICTs) play an increasingly important role in delivering professional agricultural extension services to the farming community. Digital technologies have enhanced the reach, timeliness, efficiency and inclusiveness of agricultural advisory services, particularly where conventional extension systems face limitations in manpower and outreach (Khatri et al., 2024; Byamukama et al., 2025). In India, the growing diversity of farmers’ information needs and the limited availability of extension personnel have further strengthened the importance of ICT-enabled dissemination and delivery of location-specific agricultural information (Baruah and Mohan, 2021). Agricultural extension personnel use a wide range of e-content through ICT platforms, including computers, the internet, mobile phones, websites, web portals, blogs, e-books, e-magazines, mobile applications, mass messaging services, call centres, information kiosks and social media, to provide accessible, timely and customized advisory services to farmers.

The effective functioning of these digital tools and platforms depends largely on the availability and utilization of appropriate electronic content (e-content). E-content refers to information and knowledge resources created, stored and disseminated through electronic media, incorporating text, images, audio and video. Its importance in agricultural extension has increased with the expansion of digital platforms that facilitate the rapid dissemination of updated advisories, instructional videos and other agricultural knowledge products to farmers and extension stakeholders (Baruah and Mohan, 2021; Ogedengbe et al., 2024). Evidence also indicates that ICT-enabled extension services can contribute to improved awareness, adoption of recommended agricultural practices, productivity and farm income when supported by appropriate communication strategies, capacity building and complementary extension interventions (Mulungu et al., 2025). A systematic scoping review of 315 studies by Porciello et al., (2022) found that digital agricultural services in low and middle-income countries were predominantly focused on digital advisory and extension services, with reported outcomes including increased knowledge and changes in agricultural practices. These findings highlight the potential contribution of digital information and advisory services to agricultural extension and technology transfer.

Despite the rapid development and increasing availability of agricultural e-content, its effective utilization by extension personnel remains an important concern. Previous studies have reported variations in ICT utilization among extension personnel, influenced by factors such as awareness, accessibility, educational background, technical competence, trainings and organizational support (Sa’adu et al.,  2022; Owolabi and Yekinni, 2022; George et al., 2026). Furthermore, extension personnel may be more inclined to use simple, familiar and accessible digital tools than technically complex applications, highlighting the importance of digital competencies and appropriate capacity-building interventions (Drewry et al., 2022). Similarly, recent evidence from Indian public extension systems underscores that inadequate hands-on training, limited technical troubleshooting support and restricted field-level device availability remain major barriers to routine digital tool adoption among extension functionaries (Sahoo et al., 2025).

Although the potential of ICTs in agricultural extension has received considerable research attention, an important research gap remains regarding the actual utilization of agricultural e-content by extension personnel in their routine extension activities within specific regional contexts. Much of the existing literature focuses on farmers’ access to digital services, broader ICT integration in agricultural extension, or the opportunities and challenges associated with digital technologies. Comparatively, less attention has been given to examining extension personnel’ utilization of agricultural e-content and its association with selected personal, professional and technological factors in a specific state-level context (Khan et al., 2025; Khatri et al., 2024; Drewry et al., 2022).

Against this background, the present study focuses on agricultural extension personnel in Haryana to assess and utilization of agricultural e-content and examine its association with selected independent variables. By providing empirical insights into existing utilization patterns and associated factors, the study aims to contribute to a better understanding of digital content use in agricultural extension and to inform strategies for strengthening ICT-enabled extension services in the state.
 
Objectives of the study
 
1. To assess the extent of utilization of agricultural e-content by agricultural extension personnel in Haryana.
2. To analyse the association between e-content utilization and selected 
The present study was conducted in Karnal, Kaithal, Hisar and Mahendragarh districts of Haryana state using a descriptive research design. From each selected district, 20 extension personnel were selected randomly, thus in total, 80 respondents were selected from four districts using a multi-stage sampling procedure. All field functionaries like BAOs, ADOs, HDOs, SMS, BTM and ATM from the selected districts were chosen as respondents using random sampling technique. Four commonly used ICT tools which use e-content, like website/web-portal, expert systems, mobile apps and social media platforms, were chosen purposively for the study. The sample size of 80 respondents only was determined due to limited availability of the identified extension personnel. Many extension personnel were unwilling or unavailable to participate in the interviews, as they did not use digital content and selected ICT tools. Furthermore, extension personnel in the selected districts were engaged in various time-bound agricultural extension activities, which limited their availability for participation in the study.

A structured interview schedule was developed to assess the utilization of agricultural e-content. To establish content and construct validity, the interview schedule was reviewed by a panel of subject-matter specialists who use digital content and ICT tools. The experts assessed the relevance and coverage of the items and questions meeting the specified expert-agreement criterion of 80-85 per cent were retained in the final instrument. The interview schedule was pre-tested with 30 extension personnel and necessary modifications were made before its administration. The reliability of the instrument was assessed using the test-retest method. The instrument was administered to the group of 30 agricultural extension personnel on two occasions, separated by a 15-day interval. The correlation between the two sets of scores was (rtt = 0.83), significant at the 1 per cent level, indicating satisfactory test–retest reliability. Additionally, the internal consistency of the items measuring e-content utilization was evaluated using Cronbach’s α, which yielded a high coefficient of 0.97, confirming excellent internal reliability of the scale.

Data were collected through the pre-tested interview schedule using appropriate modes, including google forms, email questionnaire and personal interaction with respondents, as applicable. Prior to data collection, written informed consent was obtained from each respondent electronically via email and necessary administrative facilitation was coordinated through the concerned officials in each district. The purpose of the study, voluntary participation, anonymity and confidentiality of responses were communicated to respondents and the collected information was kept strictly confidential and used solely for research purposes.

Data were analysed using frequencies, percentages, mean scores and mean per cent scores (MPS). To test the association between the selected independent variables and the level of agricultural e-content use, the pearson chi-square test of independence was employed along with the respective degrees of freedom (df). Furthermore, to evaluate the practical strength and magnitude of the observed associations, cramér’s V coefficient was calculated as the measure of effect size, where values up to 0.10, 0.30 and 0.50 were interpreted as small, moderate and strong associations, respectively. Statistical significance was tested at the 5 per cent level of significance (p<0.05).
Socio-personal and technological profile of agricultural extension personnel
 
The socio-personal and technological profile of the 80 extension personnel depicted in Table 1 revealed that 45.00 per cent of respondents belonged to the age group of up to 35 years, while 38.75 per cent were aged 36-50 years. Regarding educational qualifications, more than half (53.75%) were postgraduates, followed by graduates (27.50%) and Ph.D. holders (18.75%). The respondents were predominantly male (88.75%). In terms of job experience, the largest proportion of respondents (41.25%) had 5-10 years of experience, followed by those with less than five years (26.25%). With respect to ICT training, half of the respondents (50.00%) had not received any training, whereas 41.25 per cent had received short-duration awareness training and only 8.75 per cent had received long-duration skill-based training.

Regarding the availability of IT gadgets with internet connectivity, 53.75 per cent reported availability at all times, while 26.25 per cent had access only at the office, 11.25 per cent only at home and 8.75 per cent reported no availability.

Regarding the accessibility of agricultural e-content, ICT tools and digital media summarized in Table 1, YouTube videos had the highest accessibility among the extension personnel (92.50%), followed by agricultural websites/web portals (88.75%) and agricultural mobile applications (83.75%). Accessibility to e-newspapers was reported by 65.00 per cent of the respondents, while reading e-magazines and e-books were accessible to 42.50 and 40.00 per cent, respectively. Similarly, 40.00 per cent of the respondents reported having access to agricultural expert systems. On average, 64.64 per cent of the respondents reported accessibility across the seven categories of agricultural e-content and digital media.

Table 1: Socio-personal and professional profile of the extension personnel. (n = 80)



These findings indicate that extension personnel had greater accessibility to video-based and web-based e-content and mobile applications than to e-publications and specialised agricultural expert systems. Overall, this baseline profile underscores that while basic digital exposure and mobile-based media access are relatively high, there remain notable gaps in advanced ICT training and specialized digital resource access, providing a crucial background for interpreting the respondents’ actual utilization of agricultural e-content and its association with selected socio-personal and technological factors.
 
Extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel
 
To obtain a comprehensive overview of the extent of agricultural e-content utilization for technology transfer, respondents were categorized into three distinct levels low, medium and high based on the mean and standard deviation of their cumulative utilization scores. The distribution of respondents across these categories is summarized in Table 2.

The empirical data presented in Table 2 indicate that the largest proportion of respondents (45.00%) belonged to the medium-level utilization category, closely followed by 42.50 per cent in the low-level category. In contrast, only 12.50 per cent of the extension personnel demonstrated a high level of agricultural e-content utilization for delivering extension services. Cumulatively, an overwhelming majority of the respondents (87.50%) fell within the low-to-medium utilization spectrum, reflecting sub-optimal integration of digital agricultural content into routine technology transfer and farm advisory services. The findings can be compared with those of Premkishor et al., (2023), who studied e-tool utilization among extension personnel in Vijayapur district, Karnataka. They reported that 31.11 per cent of respondents belonged to the high-utilization category, 35.56 per cent to the medium-utilization category and 33.33 per cent to the low-utilization category. The distribution indicates that utilization levels varied among extension personnel in their study as well.

Table 2: Distribution of respondents based on use of agricultural e-content for professional extension services. (n=80)



These findings clearly demonstrate that despite the growing availability of digital platforms, a substantial proportion of field extension personnel are yet to harness the full potential of agricultural e-content for extension services. This restrained utilization pattern can be attributed to several interrelated factors, notably inadequate hands-on training. Also may be due to the reason that the majority of respondents had either a low or medium level of knowledge about sources of agricultural e-content and associated digital tools. Similar findings were also reported by Shashidhara (2020), who observed that more than half (55.97%) of extension personnel belonged to a medium level of utilization, followed by low (25.37%) and high (18.66%) levels of utilization. This gap between digital awareness and active field deployment aligns with Patel et al., (2024), who observed that while Indian extension professionals exhibit substantial awareness of advanced digital and AI-enabled tools, actual utilization remains constrained by technical skill deficits and inadequate on-the-job capacity building.
 
Use of agricultural e-content through different digital platforms by extension personnel
 
The results presented in Table 3 reveal variations in the extent to which extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content through different digital platforms. Among the four categories, agricultural e-content accessed through social media recorded the highest overall mean per cent score (MPS) of 50.44, followed by content accessed through websites and web portals (42.70), mobile applications (37.36) and expert systems (31.10). The tool wise extent of use ranged from 32.90 to 73.75 for social media, 32.50 to 60.16 for websites and web portals, 24.58 to 44.83 for mobile applications and 24.16 to 35.83 for expert systems. These findings indicate that extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content more extensively through social media, followed by websites and web portals, while the use of e-content available through specialised expert systems was comparatively limited.

Table 3: Use of ICT tools for accessing agricultural e-content by extension personnel. (n = 80)



Within the social media category, sharing agricultural e-content with farmers through WhatsApp groups recorded the highest MPS (73.75), followed by accessing agricultural technologies and video content through YouTube channels (58.75) and disseminating digital content through WhatsApp broadcast lists (54.41). Krishi Darshan and DD Kisan, YouTube channels also recorded a comparatively high MPS of 52.91. In contrast, the use of e-magazines and e-books and access to agricultural blogs recorded comparatively lower MPS values, including 33.33 and 32.90, respectively, as reported in the table. The findings suggest that extension personnel more frequently accessed and shared agricultural e-content in the form of messages, videos and other readily disseminated digital resources than through text-oriented electronic publications. The relatively high use of WhatsApp groups may facilitate the timely circulation of agricultural advisories, technological information and other relevant content among farmers and extension personnel. These findings are consistent with Thirumal et al., (2026), which identified WhatsApp groups as a useful channel for rapid agricultural information exchange and farmer engagement. However, the usefulness of disseminated e-content depends on its reliability, relevancy, accuracy and suitability for farmers’ needs, as well as the digital literacy of users and the quality of information-sharing practices. In the Indian context, Singh and Verma (2023) similarly highlighted the dominance of WhatsApp and YouTube in agricultural knowledge exchange due to mobile internet penetration and multimedia accessibility, while emphasizing that extension agencies must ensure message quality, accuracy and local appropriateness.

Among websites and web portals, use of Haryana Agriculture Department website recorded the highest MPS (60.16), followed by the CCS Haryana Agricultural University website (49.16) and AGMARKNET (40.25). APEDA (38.91), the ICAR website (35.25) and the SeedNet India Portal (32.50) recorded comparatively lower scores. The findings indicate that extension personnel accessed agricultural information through departmental and university websites, as well as portals providing market-related and other specialised scheme and technological information. The relatively higher MPS of the Haryana Agriculture Department and CCS HAU websites highlights the importance of state-level, institutionally provided e-content for extension-related information needs. The use of these resources may help professionals obtain information on government schemes, agricultural technologies, advisories and other relevant topics, while AGMARKNET can provide market arrivals and commodity-price information.

Regarding agricultural e-content accessed through mobile applications, Digital Mandi recorded the highest MPS (44.83), followed by mKisan (42.75) and IFFCO Kisan (41.25). Plantix (37.91), Pusa Krishi (37.50), the marketing app (36.33) and the Crop Insurance app (33.75) occupied intermediate positions, whereas RiceXpert recorded the lowest MPS (24.58). These results indicate differences in the extent to which extension personnel accessed agricultural e-content through various applications. The comparatively higher MPS of Digital Mandi, mKisan and IFFCO Kisan suggests the relevance of market-related information, agricultural advisories and other practically useful content to extension service. In contrast, the lower MPS of rice xpert indicates comparatively limited use of the e-content available through this application among the respondents.

Agricultural e-content accessed through expert systems recorded the lowest overall MPS (31.10) among the four categories. Within this category, the weed identification system recorded the highest MPS (35.83), followed by EXOWHEM for wheat-crop management (33.33), rice crop doctor (32.41) and R-M doctor for mustard plant-protection problems (32.08). Mushroom agri daksh recorded an MPS of 28.83, while puls expert recorded the lowest score (24.16). The comparatively lower MPS values indicate that the e-content available in these specialised systems was accessed less frequently than content available on social media, websites and web portals. One possible reason may be that expert systems generally provide specialised information related to particular crops, weeds, pests, diseases or diagnostic problems, whereas social media and general agricultural websites offer content covering a wider range of extension-related information needs.

Overall, the findings indicate that extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content most extensively through social media, particularly WhatsApp groups and YouTube channels, followed by websites and web portals, mobile applications and expert systems. The pattern reflects the complementary role of different digital tools in making agricultural information available to extension personnel: social media supports the rapid sharing of messages and videos; official websites and web portals provide institutionally sourced agricultural information; mobile applications offer content for specific advisory and market-related needs; and expert systems provide specialised information for particular technical problems. Therefore, strengthening digital extension requires not only access to ICT platforms but also the availability of accurate, relevant, timely and user-oriented agricultural e-content. Extension personnel should be equipped to identify reliable digital information, assess its suitability for local conditions and communicate it effectively to farmers.
 
Association between selected independent variables and level of use of agricultural e-content
 
While assessing the extent of use of agricultural e-content reveals current utilization patterns, it does not explain the underlying factors governing such behaviour. Therefore, examining the relationship between selected independent variables such as education, ICT training, gadget availability, digital media accessibility and the level of e-content use is essential to move beyond descriptive findings toward explanatory insights. This association analysis helps identify key determinants, clarifying not only who utilizes agricultural e-content, but why certain extension personnel use it more effectively than others.

Therefore, an effort was made to study the association between selected independent variables and the level of use of agricultural e-content by extension personnel. The chi-square test of independence was applied to examine the relationship between the variables, while cramér’s V was computed to determine the strength of association. In the present study, variables having a p-value less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

The data presented in Table 4 reveal that the availability of IT gadgets with internet connectivity showed the highest chi-square value (χ2=12.986, df=6, p=0.043) with a moderate degree of association (V=0.285) and was found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This establishes that extension personnel who had uninterrupted access to digital hardware such as smartphones, computers and laptops across home and office environments were utilizing agricultural e-content far more actively for transfer of technology compared to those whose access was confined only to the office or who lacked dedicated devices. Having ready and continuous access to digital gadgets facilitates prompt retrieval, storage and timely sharing of digital advisories and recommendations with farmers without administrative delays. This finding is in close agreement with Drewry et al., (2022), who observed that continuous access to connected digital devices and reliable infrastructure serves as a primary operational prerequisite for digital extension delivery.

Table 4: Association between selected independent variables and level of use of agricultural e-content. (n = 80)



Further, training received on ICT and web browsing (χ2 =11.003, df=4, p=0.027, V=0.262) was found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This reveals that extension personnel who received formal training whether short-duration capsules or specialized skill-oriented courses demonstrated higher competency and confidence in locating, filtering and deploying agricultural e-content in their regular advisory services. These findings corroborate the results of Obianefo et al., (2024), who emphasized that targeted capacity building and technical training significantly elevate the operational competence and usability of e-extension tools among field advisory staff.

Similarly, accessibility of agricultural e-content, ICT tools and digital media (χ2 =10.418, df=4, p=0.034, V=0.255) showed a significant association with the level of use of e-content, reflecting a moderate effect size. This indicates that extension personnel who possessed multi-channel access across varied electronic resources such as mobile applications, departmental web portals, online video channels, e-publications and diagnostic tools utilized agricultural e-content more extensively than those with restricted media access. Broader exposure to diverse digital content channels enables extension functionaries to cross-check recommendations, enrich their advisory packages and share relevant multimedia content tailored to farmers’ needs. This is in conformity with the observations of Khan et al., (2025), who reported that wide exposure and seamless access to diverse electronic communication channels foster regular information-seeking and dissemination behaviour among agricultural intermediaries.

In addition, educational qualification of the respondents (χ2 =9.795, df=4, p=0.044, V=0.247) was also found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This implies that higher academic attainment, particularly at the postgraduate and doctoral levels, equips extension personnel with superior analytical comprehension, scientific temperament and evaluative capabilities necessary for interpreting complex technical e-content before communicating it to the farming community. Highly educated personnel are generally more adept at evaluating the scientific credibility of online agricultural materials and translating them into easily comprehensible field advisories. Similar observations were reported by Obianefo et al., (2024), who confirmed that advanced educational background plays an essential role in fostering progressive ICT utilization behaviour and digital knowledge transfer among agricultural field workers. These observations are further corroborated by Sahoo et al., (2025) and Salokhe (2025), who emphasized that institutional investments in regular hands-on ICT training, refresher courses and accessible field-level digital infrastructure are critical prerequisites for strengthening technology-driven extension delivery.

On the other hand, personal and demographic characteristics, namely age (χ2=4.782, df=4, p=0.310, V=0.173), gender (χ2=3.526, df=2, p=0.172, V=0.210) and job experience (χ2=9.306, df=6, p=0.157, V=0.241), were found to be non-significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content, as their respective p-values were greater than 0.05. This demonstrates that chronological age, biological sex and years of service in the department do not act as decisive constraints or facilitators in the operational use of agricultural e-content. With the pervasive penetration of smartphones and digital messaging platforms in routine communication, mid-career and senior extension personnel exhibit a comparable inclination towards utilizing agricultural e-content alongside younger entrants, provided technical support and connectivity are available.

The empirical evidence clearly indicates that the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel is fundamentally governed by technological accessibility, physical gadget availability and institutional capacity-building mechanisms rather than innate personal or demographic factors. These observed relationships strongly align with the fundamental constructs of the technology acceptance model (TAM), wherein external facilitating conditions namely device availability, functional accessibility and prior training positively reinforce both the perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness of digital content, ultimately leading to higher actual adoption and utilization behaviour. Hence, it can be concluded that the transition towards a digitally driven extension paradigm in Haryana hinges directly upon institutional investments in providing dependable digital hardware, ensuring seamless media accessibility and conducting regular skill-oriented ICT training programmes across all cadres of extension functionaries.
Although this study provides useful empirical insights into agricultural e-content utilization and its determinants among extension personnel in Haryana, certain limitations must be acknowledged. The investigation was restricted to a cross-sectional sample of 80 extension personnel across four districts of Haryana, which, while representative of the state’s key agro-climatic zones, limits the generalization of the findings to broader, diverse agro-ecological regions across India. Furthermore, the study relied on structured self-reported survey responses, which may carry inherent recall and perception biases. The scope was also focused primarily on four conventional digital media categories websites, social media, mobile apps and expert systems without evaluating advanced AI-driven advisory tools or emerging digital platforms.

Future research should expand to larger, multi-state and stratified samples covering public, private and non-governmental extension functionaries to enable comparative regional assessments. Longitudinal and experimental research designs are recommended to track the post-training impact of hands-on digital media interventions on actual advisory performance over time. In addition, future investigations should evaluate the farmer-end outcomes of digital advisories to examine comprehension and field adoption rates, paired with qualitative inquiries to identify the specific institutional and usability bottlenecks that currently constrain the adoption of agricultural expert diagnostic systems.
• State extension departments should ensure that all frontline extension personnel are provided with dedicated, internet-enabled digital devices (smartphones or tablets) to facilitate uninterrupted retrieval and sharing of agricultural e-content in the field.
•   Extension training organizations (such as EEIs, SAMETIs and KVKs) must organize regular, practical training programmes focusing on digital content curation, online information retrieval and video-based advisory delivery, moving beyond basic digital awareness.
•   Agricultural universities and research institutions should prioritize creating short, multimedia-rich digital content (such as infographics, diagnostic video clips and audio advisories) in regional languages, tailored to local agro-climatic conditions and seasonal farming problems.
•   The Department of Agriculture and ICAR institutes should re-engineer complex expert systems into user-friendly, mobile-compatible applications and conduct targeted awareness campaigns to increase their adoption for field-level pest, disease and nutrient diagnostics.
•   A dedicated institutional mechanism should be set up at the district and state levels to verify the technical accuracy of agricultural e-content circulated on social media groups and monitor its effective integration into regular extension activities.
The study demonstrates that agricultural e-content utilization among extension personnel in Haryana is still at a developing stage, with 87.50 per cent reporting low to medium use. Social media, particularly WhatsApp and YouTube, were the most utilized platforms, followed by departmental and university web portals and mobile applications, whereas agricultural expert systems and text-based publications were least utilized. Educational qualification, ICT training, availability of IT gadgets and accessibility to digital media showed significant positive associations with e-content utilization, whereas age, gender and job experience had non-significant associations. Thus, institutional support, digital infrastructure and capacity building are key drivers of e-content utilization. Providing IT gadgets, ensuring digital accessibility and organizing regular ICT training can strengthen digital extension services. Social media should complement face-to-face demonstrations and diagnostic farm visits for effective technology dissemination.
I acknowledge CCS Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar and EEI, Nilokheri, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmer’s Welfare, Govt. of India for providing me opportunity and resources to conduct this research. Their support and encouragement have been invaluable in completing this study. I also extend my heartfelt appreciation to the extension personnel who participated in this research for their time, insights and willingness to share their experiences. I deeply acknowledge their role in making this research meaningful.

Disclaimer
 
The views and conclusions expressed in this article are solely of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the affiliated institution. The author is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided.
The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this article. No funding or sponsorship influenced the design of the study, data collection, analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.

  1. Baruah, A. and Mohan, G.M. (2021). Exploring the ICT preferences of personnel from agricultural extension organizations in the Northeastern Region of India. Asian Journal of Agriculture and Development. 18(1): 106-120.

  2. Byamukama, W., Ssemakula, E., Ssekandi, J., Shaman, A., Businge, P., Kalibwani, R., Atukunda, C. and Turyasingura, B. (2025). A review of ICT integration in agricultural extension services: A global perspective. East African Journal of Agriculture and Biotechnology. 8(1): 292-312. https://doi.org/10.37284/eajab.8.1.849.

  3. Drewry, J.L., Shutske, J.M., Trechter, D. and Luck, B.D. (2022). Assessment of digital technology adoption and access barriers among agricultural service providers and agricultural extension professionals. Journal of the ASABE. 65(5): 1049-1059.

  4. George, J., Gabriel, K., Mubangizi, N. and Angella, N. (2026). Determinants of the use of Uganda’s e-diary application in agricultural extension monitoring and supervision. International Journal of Agricultural Research, Innovation and Technology. 16(1): 114-120. https://doi.org/10.3329/ijarit.v16i1.92287.

  5. Khan, R.P., Gupta, S., Daum, T., Birner, R. and Ringler, C. (2025). Levelling the field: A review of the ICT revolution and agricultural extension in the Global South. Journal of International Development. 37(1): 1-21. https://doi.org/10.1002/jid.3949.

  6. Khatri, A., Lallawmkimi, M.C., Rana, P., Panigrahi, C.K., Minj, A., Koushal, S. and Ali, M.U. (2024). Integration of ICT in agricultural extension services: A review. Journal of Experimental Agriculture International. 46(12): 394-410.

  7. Mulungu, K., Kassie, M. and Tschopp, M. (2025). The role of information and communication technologies-based extension in agriculture: Application, opportunities and challenges. Information Technology for Development. 31(4): 1117-1146.

  8. Obianefo, C.A., Obiekwe, N.J., Okoroji, N.O., Shah, Z.A., Uchemba, U.V. and Osegbue, E.G. (2024). Usability of e-extension technology and growth of agricultural productivity in Southeast Nigeria: ADP extension worker’s survey. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture. 40(2): 659-671. https://doi.org/10.17582/journal.sja/2024/40.2.659.671.

  9. Ogedengbe, C.T., Akanji, N.E., Malomo, O.J. and Akanji, K.A. (2024). The potentials of e-extension for sustainable agricultural development in Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural Extension. 29(1): 270-278.

  10. Owolabi, A. and Yekinni, O. (2022). Utilisation of information and communication technologies for agricultural extension service delivery in public and non-public organizations in southwestern Nigeria. Heliyon. 8(9): e10676. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e10676.

  11. Patel, M., Khodifad, P.B. and Chaudhary, M. (2024). Utilisation of artificial intelligence-related technology for agricultural extension services among extension professionals in India. Bhartiya Krishi Anusandhan Patrika. 39(3-4): 288-293. doi: 10.18805/BKAP695.

  12. Porciello, J., Coggins, S., Mabaya, E. and Otunba-Payne, G. (2022). Digital agriculture services in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic scoping review. Global Food Security. 34: 100640. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gfs.2022.100640.

  13. Premkishor, S.N., Jahagirdar, K.A., Jadhav, A. and Raghuprasad, K.P. (2023). A study on utilisation pattern of e-tools (ICT-tools) by extension personnel working in developmental departments in Vijayapur district, Karnataka, India. Asian Journal of Agricultural Extension, Economics and Sociology. 41(11): 138-145.

  14. Sa’adu, M., Norsida, M., Jasmin, A.S., Nitty, H.K. and Ahmadu, A.T. (2022). Factors affecting use of information communication technologies among extension agents in North-East, Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural Extension. 26(1): 36-43. https://doi.org/10.4314/jae.v26i1.5.

  15. Sahoo, S., Parasar, B., Dash, M. and Akomolafe, G. (2025). ICT in public extension: Constraints and suggestions through the lens of extension functionaries. Agricultural Science Digest. 45(6): 1058-1064. doi: 10.18805/ag.D-6359. 

  16. Salokhe, S. (2025). Uncovering the impact of technology-driven services on boosting farmer producer organizations (FPO) growth: A glimpse into the promising future of Indian agriculture, with a focus on the potential of information and communication technology (ICT): A review. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 59(8): 1161-1167. doi: 10.18805/IJARe.A-6341. 

  17. Shashidhara, K.K. (2020). ICT utilization behaviour among extension personnel. Journal of Extension Systems. 36(1): 15-22.

  18. Singh, D. and Verma, B.K. (2023). The utilisation of social media for accessing farming information by progressive farmers. Bhartiya Krishi Anusandhan Patrika. 38(3): 290-295. doi: 10.18805/BKAP642.

  19. Thirumal, A., Babu, G.S., Deepika, R.B. and Harish, B.P. (2026). Digital extension in agriculture: A review of WhatsApp groups for information dissemination in India. Asian Journal of Agricultural Extension, Economics and Sociology. 44(4): 125-135. https://doi.org/10.9734/ ajaees/2026/v44i42916.

Digital Extension in Haryana: An Analysis of Agricultural e-Content Utilization by Extension Personnel and Associated Factors

1Extension Education Institute, Nilokheri, Karnal-132 001, Haryana, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmer’s Welfare, Govt. of India.
  • Submitted17-06-2026|

  • Accepted16-11-2026|

  • First Online 21-11-2026|

  • doi 10.18805/BKAP944

Background: Electronic content (e-content) delivered through ICT platforms plays an increasingly critical role in modern agricultural extension services. However, empirical evidence regarding the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel and its determinants remains limited. This study was undertaken to assess the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel and examine its association with selected independent variables in Haryana.

Methods: The study was conducted across Karnal, Kaithal, Hisar and Mahendragarh districts of Haryana using a descriptive research design. Primary data were collected from 80 extension personnel using a pre-tested, structured interview schedule. Statistical analysis included frequency, percentage, mean percent score (MPS), Pearson chi-square test of independence and Cramér’s V effect size coefficient.

Results: An overwhelming majority of the respondents (87.50%) exhibited low to medium levels of e-content utilization. Among various digital delivery platforms, e-content accessed via social media recorded the highest utilization (MPS = 50.44), driven mainly by WhatsApp groups (MPS = 73.75) and YouTube channels (MPS = 58.75), whereas expert systems were the least utilized (MPS = 31.10). Chi-square analysis revealed that availability of IT gadgets (χ2 = 12.986), ICT training (χ2 = 11.003), accessibility of digital media (χ2 = 10.418) and education (χ2= 9.795) had statistically significant positive associations with the level of e-content use. In contrast, age, gender and job experience showed non-significant association. The study emphasizes that digital extension effectiveness depends fundamentally on workplace hardware availability, multi-channel accessibility and skill-oriented training.

Information and communication technologies (ICTs) play an increasingly important role in delivering professional agricultural extension services to the farming community. Digital technologies have enhanced the reach, timeliness, efficiency and inclusiveness of agricultural advisory services, particularly where conventional extension systems face limitations in manpower and outreach (Khatri et al., 2024; Byamukama et al., 2025). In India, the growing diversity of farmers’ information needs and the limited availability of extension personnel have further strengthened the importance of ICT-enabled dissemination and delivery of location-specific agricultural information (Baruah and Mohan, 2021). Agricultural extension personnel use a wide range of e-content through ICT platforms, including computers, the internet, mobile phones, websites, web portals, blogs, e-books, e-magazines, mobile applications, mass messaging services, call centres, information kiosks and social media, to provide accessible, timely and customized advisory services to farmers.

The effective functioning of these digital tools and platforms depends largely on the availability and utilization of appropriate electronic content (e-content). E-content refers to information and knowledge resources created, stored and disseminated through electronic media, incorporating text, images, audio and video. Its importance in agricultural extension has increased with the expansion of digital platforms that facilitate the rapid dissemination of updated advisories, instructional videos and other agricultural knowledge products to farmers and extension stakeholders (Baruah and Mohan, 2021; Ogedengbe et al., 2024). Evidence also indicates that ICT-enabled extension services can contribute to improved awareness, adoption of recommended agricultural practices, productivity and farm income when supported by appropriate communication strategies, capacity building and complementary extension interventions (Mulungu et al., 2025). A systematic scoping review of 315 studies by Porciello et al., (2022) found that digital agricultural services in low and middle-income countries were predominantly focused on digital advisory and extension services, with reported outcomes including increased knowledge and changes in agricultural practices. These findings highlight the potential contribution of digital information and advisory services to agricultural extension and technology transfer.

Despite the rapid development and increasing availability of agricultural e-content, its effective utilization by extension personnel remains an important concern. Previous studies have reported variations in ICT utilization among extension personnel, influenced by factors such as awareness, accessibility, educational background, technical competence, trainings and organizational support (Sa’adu et al.,  2022; Owolabi and Yekinni, 2022; George et al., 2026). Furthermore, extension personnel may be more inclined to use simple, familiar and accessible digital tools than technically complex applications, highlighting the importance of digital competencies and appropriate capacity-building interventions (Drewry et al., 2022). Similarly, recent evidence from Indian public extension systems underscores that inadequate hands-on training, limited technical troubleshooting support and restricted field-level device availability remain major barriers to routine digital tool adoption among extension functionaries (Sahoo et al., 2025).

Although the potential of ICTs in agricultural extension has received considerable research attention, an important research gap remains regarding the actual utilization of agricultural e-content by extension personnel in their routine extension activities within specific regional contexts. Much of the existing literature focuses on farmers’ access to digital services, broader ICT integration in agricultural extension, or the opportunities and challenges associated with digital technologies. Comparatively, less attention has been given to examining extension personnel’ utilization of agricultural e-content and its association with selected personal, professional and technological factors in a specific state-level context (Khan et al., 2025; Khatri et al., 2024; Drewry et al., 2022).

Against this background, the present study focuses on agricultural extension personnel in Haryana to assess and utilization of agricultural e-content and examine its association with selected independent variables. By providing empirical insights into existing utilization patterns and associated factors, the study aims to contribute to a better understanding of digital content use in agricultural extension and to inform strategies for strengthening ICT-enabled extension services in the state.
 
Objectives of the study
 
1. To assess the extent of utilization of agricultural e-content by agricultural extension personnel in Haryana.
2. To analyse the association between e-content utilization and selected 
The present study was conducted in Karnal, Kaithal, Hisar and Mahendragarh districts of Haryana state using a descriptive research design. From each selected district, 20 extension personnel were selected randomly, thus in total, 80 respondents were selected from four districts using a multi-stage sampling procedure. All field functionaries like BAOs, ADOs, HDOs, SMS, BTM and ATM from the selected districts were chosen as respondents using random sampling technique. Four commonly used ICT tools which use e-content, like website/web-portal, expert systems, mobile apps and social media platforms, were chosen purposively for the study. The sample size of 80 respondents only was determined due to limited availability of the identified extension personnel. Many extension personnel were unwilling or unavailable to participate in the interviews, as they did not use digital content and selected ICT tools. Furthermore, extension personnel in the selected districts were engaged in various time-bound agricultural extension activities, which limited their availability for participation in the study.

A structured interview schedule was developed to assess the utilization of agricultural e-content. To establish content and construct validity, the interview schedule was reviewed by a panel of subject-matter specialists who use digital content and ICT tools. The experts assessed the relevance and coverage of the items and questions meeting the specified expert-agreement criterion of 80-85 per cent were retained in the final instrument. The interview schedule was pre-tested with 30 extension personnel and necessary modifications were made before its administration. The reliability of the instrument was assessed using the test-retest method. The instrument was administered to the group of 30 agricultural extension personnel on two occasions, separated by a 15-day interval. The correlation between the two sets of scores was (rtt = 0.83), significant at the 1 per cent level, indicating satisfactory test–retest reliability. Additionally, the internal consistency of the items measuring e-content utilization was evaluated using Cronbach’s α, which yielded a high coefficient of 0.97, confirming excellent internal reliability of the scale.

Data were collected through the pre-tested interview schedule using appropriate modes, including google forms, email questionnaire and personal interaction with respondents, as applicable. Prior to data collection, written informed consent was obtained from each respondent electronically via email and necessary administrative facilitation was coordinated through the concerned officials in each district. The purpose of the study, voluntary participation, anonymity and confidentiality of responses were communicated to respondents and the collected information was kept strictly confidential and used solely for research purposes.

Data were analysed using frequencies, percentages, mean scores and mean per cent scores (MPS). To test the association between the selected independent variables and the level of agricultural e-content use, the pearson chi-square test of independence was employed along with the respective degrees of freedom (df). Furthermore, to evaluate the practical strength and magnitude of the observed associations, cramér’s V coefficient was calculated as the measure of effect size, where values up to 0.10, 0.30 and 0.50 were interpreted as small, moderate and strong associations, respectively. Statistical significance was tested at the 5 per cent level of significance (p<0.05).
Socio-personal and technological profile of agricultural extension personnel
 
The socio-personal and technological profile of the 80 extension personnel depicted in Table 1 revealed that 45.00 per cent of respondents belonged to the age group of up to 35 years, while 38.75 per cent were aged 36-50 years. Regarding educational qualifications, more than half (53.75%) were postgraduates, followed by graduates (27.50%) and Ph.D. holders (18.75%). The respondents were predominantly male (88.75%). In terms of job experience, the largest proportion of respondents (41.25%) had 5-10 years of experience, followed by those with less than five years (26.25%). With respect to ICT training, half of the respondents (50.00%) had not received any training, whereas 41.25 per cent had received short-duration awareness training and only 8.75 per cent had received long-duration skill-based training.

Regarding the availability of IT gadgets with internet connectivity, 53.75 per cent reported availability at all times, while 26.25 per cent had access only at the office, 11.25 per cent only at home and 8.75 per cent reported no availability.

Regarding the accessibility of agricultural e-content, ICT tools and digital media summarized in Table 1, YouTube videos had the highest accessibility among the extension personnel (92.50%), followed by agricultural websites/web portals (88.75%) and agricultural mobile applications (83.75%). Accessibility to e-newspapers was reported by 65.00 per cent of the respondents, while reading e-magazines and e-books were accessible to 42.50 and 40.00 per cent, respectively. Similarly, 40.00 per cent of the respondents reported having access to agricultural expert systems. On average, 64.64 per cent of the respondents reported accessibility across the seven categories of agricultural e-content and digital media.

Table 1: Socio-personal and professional profile of the extension personnel. (n = 80)



These findings indicate that extension personnel had greater accessibility to video-based and web-based e-content and mobile applications than to e-publications and specialised agricultural expert systems. Overall, this baseline profile underscores that while basic digital exposure and mobile-based media access are relatively high, there remain notable gaps in advanced ICT training and specialized digital resource access, providing a crucial background for interpreting the respondents’ actual utilization of agricultural e-content and its association with selected socio-personal and technological factors.
 
Extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel
 
To obtain a comprehensive overview of the extent of agricultural e-content utilization for technology transfer, respondents were categorized into three distinct levels low, medium and high based on the mean and standard deviation of their cumulative utilization scores. The distribution of respondents across these categories is summarized in Table 2.

The empirical data presented in Table 2 indicate that the largest proportion of respondents (45.00%) belonged to the medium-level utilization category, closely followed by 42.50 per cent in the low-level category. In contrast, only 12.50 per cent of the extension personnel demonstrated a high level of agricultural e-content utilization for delivering extension services. Cumulatively, an overwhelming majority of the respondents (87.50%) fell within the low-to-medium utilization spectrum, reflecting sub-optimal integration of digital agricultural content into routine technology transfer and farm advisory services. The findings can be compared with those of Premkishor et al., (2023), who studied e-tool utilization among extension personnel in Vijayapur district, Karnataka. They reported that 31.11 per cent of respondents belonged to the high-utilization category, 35.56 per cent to the medium-utilization category and 33.33 per cent to the low-utilization category. The distribution indicates that utilization levels varied among extension personnel in their study as well.

Table 2: Distribution of respondents based on use of agricultural e-content for professional extension services. (n=80)



These findings clearly demonstrate that despite the growing availability of digital platforms, a substantial proportion of field extension personnel are yet to harness the full potential of agricultural e-content for extension services. This restrained utilization pattern can be attributed to several interrelated factors, notably inadequate hands-on training. Also may be due to the reason that the majority of respondents had either a low or medium level of knowledge about sources of agricultural e-content and associated digital tools. Similar findings were also reported by Shashidhara (2020), who observed that more than half (55.97%) of extension personnel belonged to a medium level of utilization, followed by low (25.37%) and high (18.66%) levels of utilization. This gap between digital awareness and active field deployment aligns with Patel et al., (2024), who observed that while Indian extension professionals exhibit substantial awareness of advanced digital and AI-enabled tools, actual utilization remains constrained by technical skill deficits and inadequate on-the-job capacity building.
 
Use of agricultural e-content through different digital platforms by extension personnel
 
The results presented in Table 3 reveal variations in the extent to which extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content through different digital platforms. Among the four categories, agricultural e-content accessed through social media recorded the highest overall mean per cent score (MPS) of 50.44, followed by content accessed through websites and web portals (42.70), mobile applications (37.36) and expert systems (31.10). The tool wise extent of use ranged from 32.90 to 73.75 for social media, 32.50 to 60.16 for websites and web portals, 24.58 to 44.83 for mobile applications and 24.16 to 35.83 for expert systems. These findings indicate that extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content more extensively through social media, followed by websites and web portals, while the use of e-content available through specialised expert systems was comparatively limited.

Table 3: Use of ICT tools for accessing agricultural e-content by extension personnel. (n = 80)



Within the social media category, sharing agricultural e-content with farmers through WhatsApp groups recorded the highest MPS (73.75), followed by accessing agricultural technologies and video content through YouTube channels (58.75) and disseminating digital content through WhatsApp broadcast lists (54.41). Krishi Darshan and DD Kisan, YouTube channels also recorded a comparatively high MPS of 52.91. In contrast, the use of e-magazines and e-books and access to agricultural blogs recorded comparatively lower MPS values, including 33.33 and 32.90, respectively, as reported in the table. The findings suggest that extension personnel more frequently accessed and shared agricultural e-content in the form of messages, videos and other readily disseminated digital resources than through text-oriented electronic publications. The relatively high use of WhatsApp groups may facilitate the timely circulation of agricultural advisories, technological information and other relevant content among farmers and extension personnel. These findings are consistent with Thirumal et al., (2026), which identified WhatsApp groups as a useful channel for rapid agricultural information exchange and farmer engagement. However, the usefulness of disseminated e-content depends on its reliability, relevancy, accuracy and suitability for farmers’ needs, as well as the digital literacy of users and the quality of information-sharing practices. In the Indian context, Singh and Verma (2023) similarly highlighted the dominance of WhatsApp and YouTube in agricultural knowledge exchange due to mobile internet penetration and multimedia accessibility, while emphasizing that extension agencies must ensure message quality, accuracy and local appropriateness.

Among websites and web portals, use of Haryana Agriculture Department website recorded the highest MPS (60.16), followed by the CCS Haryana Agricultural University website (49.16) and AGMARKNET (40.25). APEDA (38.91), the ICAR website (35.25) and the SeedNet India Portal (32.50) recorded comparatively lower scores. The findings indicate that extension personnel accessed agricultural information through departmental and university websites, as well as portals providing market-related and other specialised scheme and technological information. The relatively higher MPS of the Haryana Agriculture Department and CCS HAU websites highlights the importance of state-level, institutionally provided e-content for extension-related information needs. The use of these resources may help professionals obtain information on government schemes, agricultural technologies, advisories and other relevant topics, while AGMARKNET can provide market arrivals and commodity-price information.

Regarding agricultural e-content accessed through mobile applications, Digital Mandi recorded the highest MPS (44.83), followed by mKisan (42.75) and IFFCO Kisan (41.25). Plantix (37.91), Pusa Krishi (37.50), the marketing app (36.33) and the Crop Insurance app (33.75) occupied intermediate positions, whereas RiceXpert recorded the lowest MPS (24.58). These results indicate differences in the extent to which extension personnel accessed agricultural e-content through various applications. The comparatively higher MPS of Digital Mandi, mKisan and IFFCO Kisan suggests the relevance of market-related information, agricultural advisories and other practically useful content to extension service. In contrast, the lower MPS of rice xpert indicates comparatively limited use of the e-content available through this application among the respondents.

Agricultural e-content accessed through expert systems recorded the lowest overall MPS (31.10) among the four categories. Within this category, the weed identification system recorded the highest MPS (35.83), followed by EXOWHEM for wheat-crop management (33.33), rice crop doctor (32.41) and R-M doctor for mustard plant-protection problems (32.08). Mushroom agri daksh recorded an MPS of 28.83, while puls expert recorded the lowest score (24.16). The comparatively lower MPS values indicate that the e-content available in these specialised systems was accessed less frequently than content available on social media, websites and web portals. One possible reason may be that expert systems generally provide specialised information related to particular crops, weeds, pests, diseases or diagnostic problems, whereas social media and general agricultural websites offer content covering a wider range of extension-related information needs.

Overall, the findings indicate that extension personnel accessed and disseminated agricultural e-content most extensively through social media, particularly WhatsApp groups and YouTube channels, followed by websites and web portals, mobile applications and expert systems. The pattern reflects the complementary role of different digital tools in making agricultural information available to extension personnel: social media supports the rapid sharing of messages and videos; official websites and web portals provide institutionally sourced agricultural information; mobile applications offer content for specific advisory and market-related needs; and expert systems provide specialised information for particular technical problems. Therefore, strengthening digital extension requires not only access to ICT platforms but also the availability of accurate, relevant, timely and user-oriented agricultural e-content. Extension personnel should be equipped to identify reliable digital information, assess its suitability for local conditions and communicate it effectively to farmers.
 
Association between selected independent variables and level of use of agricultural e-content
 
While assessing the extent of use of agricultural e-content reveals current utilization patterns, it does not explain the underlying factors governing such behaviour. Therefore, examining the relationship between selected independent variables such as education, ICT training, gadget availability, digital media accessibility and the level of e-content use is essential to move beyond descriptive findings toward explanatory insights. This association analysis helps identify key determinants, clarifying not only who utilizes agricultural e-content, but why certain extension personnel use it more effectively than others.

Therefore, an effort was made to study the association between selected independent variables and the level of use of agricultural e-content by extension personnel. The chi-square test of independence was applied to examine the relationship between the variables, while cramér’s V was computed to determine the strength of association. In the present study, variables having a p-value less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

The data presented in Table 4 reveal that the availability of IT gadgets with internet connectivity showed the highest chi-square value (χ2=12.986, df=6, p=0.043) with a moderate degree of association (V=0.285) and was found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This establishes that extension personnel who had uninterrupted access to digital hardware such as smartphones, computers and laptops across home and office environments were utilizing agricultural e-content far more actively for transfer of technology compared to those whose access was confined only to the office or who lacked dedicated devices. Having ready and continuous access to digital gadgets facilitates prompt retrieval, storage and timely sharing of digital advisories and recommendations with farmers without administrative delays. This finding is in close agreement with Drewry et al., (2022), who observed that continuous access to connected digital devices and reliable infrastructure serves as a primary operational prerequisite for digital extension delivery.

Table 4: Association between selected independent variables and level of use of agricultural e-content. (n = 80)



Further, training received on ICT and web browsing (χ2 =11.003, df=4, p=0.027, V=0.262) was found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This reveals that extension personnel who received formal training whether short-duration capsules or specialized skill-oriented courses demonstrated higher competency and confidence in locating, filtering and deploying agricultural e-content in their regular advisory services. These findings corroborate the results of Obianefo et al., (2024), who emphasized that targeted capacity building and technical training significantly elevate the operational competence and usability of e-extension tools among field advisory staff.

Similarly, accessibility of agricultural e-content, ICT tools and digital media (χ2 =10.418, df=4, p=0.034, V=0.255) showed a significant association with the level of use of e-content, reflecting a moderate effect size. This indicates that extension personnel who possessed multi-channel access across varied electronic resources such as mobile applications, departmental web portals, online video channels, e-publications and diagnostic tools utilized agricultural e-content more extensively than those with restricted media access. Broader exposure to diverse digital content channels enables extension functionaries to cross-check recommendations, enrich their advisory packages and share relevant multimedia content tailored to farmers’ needs. This is in conformity with the observations of Khan et al., (2025), who reported that wide exposure and seamless access to diverse electronic communication channels foster regular information-seeking and dissemination behaviour among agricultural intermediaries.

In addition, educational qualification of the respondents (χ2 =9.795, df=4, p=0.044, V=0.247) was also found to be significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content. This implies that higher academic attainment, particularly at the postgraduate and doctoral levels, equips extension personnel with superior analytical comprehension, scientific temperament and evaluative capabilities necessary for interpreting complex technical e-content before communicating it to the farming community. Highly educated personnel are generally more adept at evaluating the scientific credibility of online agricultural materials and translating them into easily comprehensible field advisories. Similar observations were reported by Obianefo et al., (2024), who confirmed that advanced educational background plays an essential role in fostering progressive ICT utilization behaviour and digital knowledge transfer among agricultural field workers. These observations are further corroborated by Sahoo et al., (2025) and Salokhe (2025), who emphasized that institutional investments in regular hands-on ICT training, refresher courses and accessible field-level digital infrastructure are critical prerequisites for strengthening technology-driven extension delivery.

On the other hand, personal and demographic characteristics, namely age (χ2=4.782, df=4, p=0.310, V=0.173), gender (χ2=3.526, df=2, p=0.172, V=0.210) and job experience (χ2=9.306, df=6, p=0.157, V=0.241), were found to be non-significantly associated with the level of use of agricultural e-content, as their respective p-values were greater than 0.05. This demonstrates that chronological age, biological sex and years of service in the department do not act as decisive constraints or facilitators in the operational use of agricultural e-content. With the pervasive penetration of smartphones and digital messaging platforms in routine communication, mid-career and senior extension personnel exhibit a comparable inclination towards utilizing agricultural e-content alongside younger entrants, provided technical support and connectivity are available.

The empirical evidence clearly indicates that the extent of agricultural e-content utilization by extension personnel is fundamentally governed by technological accessibility, physical gadget availability and institutional capacity-building mechanisms rather than innate personal or demographic factors. These observed relationships strongly align with the fundamental constructs of the technology acceptance model (TAM), wherein external facilitating conditions namely device availability, functional accessibility and prior training positively reinforce both the perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness of digital content, ultimately leading to higher actual adoption and utilization behaviour. Hence, it can be concluded that the transition towards a digitally driven extension paradigm in Haryana hinges directly upon institutional investments in providing dependable digital hardware, ensuring seamless media accessibility and conducting regular skill-oriented ICT training programmes across all cadres of extension functionaries.
Although this study provides useful empirical insights into agricultural e-content utilization and its determinants among extension personnel in Haryana, certain limitations must be acknowledged. The investigation was restricted to a cross-sectional sample of 80 extension personnel across four districts of Haryana, which, while representative of the state’s key agro-climatic zones, limits the generalization of the findings to broader, diverse agro-ecological regions across India. Furthermore, the study relied on structured self-reported survey responses, which may carry inherent recall and perception biases. The scope was also focused primarily on four conventional digital media categories websites, social media, mobile apps and expert systems without evaluating advanced AI-driven advisory tools or emerging digital platforms.

Future research should expand to larger, multi-state and stratified samples covering public, private and non-governmental extension functionaries to enable comparative regional assessments. Longitudinal and experimental research designs are recommended to track the post-training impact of hands-on digital media interventions on actual advisory performance over time. In addition, future investigations should evaluate the farmer-end outcomes of digital advisories to examine comprehension and field adoption rates, paired with qualitative inquiries to identify the specific institutional and usability bottlenecks that currently constrain the adoption of agricultural expert diagnostic systems.
• State extension departments should ensure that all frontline extension personnel are provided with dedicated, internet-enabled digital devices (smartphones or tablets) to facilitate uninterrupted retrieval and sharing of agricultural e-content in the field.
•   Extension training organizations (such as EEIs, SAMETIs and KVKs) must organize regular, practical training programmes focusing on digital content curation, online information retrieval and video-based advisory delivery, moving beyond basic digital awareness.
•   Agricultural universities and research institutions should prioritize creating short, multimedia-rich digital content (such as infographics, diagnostic video clips and audio advisories) in regional languages, tailored to local agro-climatic conditions and seasonal farming problems.
•   The Department of Agriculture and ICAR institutes should re-engineer complex expert systems into user-friendly, mobile-compatible applications and conduct targeted awareness campaigns to increase their adoption for field-level pest, disease and nutrient diagnostics.
•   A dedicated institutional mechanism should be set up at the district and state levels to verify the technical accuracy of agricultural e-content circulated on social media groups and monitor its effective integration into regular extension activities.
The study demonstrates that agricultural e-content utilization among extension personnel in Haryana is still at a developing stage, with 87.50 per cent reporting low to medium use. Social media, particularly WhatsApp and YouTube, were the most utilized platforms, followed by departmental and university web portals and mobile applications, whereas agricultural expert systems and text-based publications were least utilized. Educational qualification, ICT training, availability of IT gadgets and accessibility to digital media showed significant positive associations with e-content utilization, whereas age, gender and job experience had non-significant associations. Thus, institutional support, digital infrastructure and capacity building are key drivers of e-content utilization. Providing IT gadgets, ensuring digital accessibility and organizing regular ICT training can strengthen digital extension services. Social media should complement face-to-face demonstrations and diagnostic farm visits for effective technology dissemination.
I acknowledge CCS Haryana Agricultural University, Hisar and EEI, Nilokheri, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmer’s Welfare, Govt. of India for providing me opportunity and resources to conduct this research. Their support and encouragement have been invaluable in completing this study. I also extend my heartfelt appreciation to the extension personnel who participated in this research for their time, insights and willingness to share their experiences. I deeply acknowledge their role in making this research meaningful.

Disclaimer
 
The views and conclusions expressed in this article are solely of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of the affiliated institution. The author is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the information provided.
The author declares that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this article. No funding or sponsorship influenced the design of the study, data collection, analysis, decision to publish or preparation of the manuscript.

  1. Baruah, A. and Mohan, G.M. (2021). Exploring the ICT preferences of personnel from agricultural extension organizations in the Northeastern Region of India. Asian Journal of Agriculture and Development. 18(1): 106-120.

  2. Byamukama, W., Ssemakula, E., Ssekandi, J., Shaman, A., Businge, P., Kalibwani, R., Atukunda, C. and Turyasingura, B. (2025). A review of ICT integration in agricultural extension services: A global perspective. East African Journal of Agriculture and Biotechnology. 8(1): 292-312. https://doi.org/10.37284/eajab.8.1.849.

  3. Drewry, J.L., Shutske, J.M., Trechter, D. and Luck, B.D. (2022). Assessment of digital technology adoption and access barriers among agricultural service providers and agricultural extension professionals. Journal of the ASABE. 65(5): 1049-1059.

  4. George, J., Gabriel, K., Mubangizi, N. and Angella, N. (2026). Determinants of the use of Uganda’s e-diary application in agricultural extension monitoring and supervision. International Journal of Agricultural Research, Innovation and Technology. 16(1): 114-120. https://doi.org/10.3329/ijarit.v16i1.92287.

  5. Khan, R.P., Gupta, S., Daum, T., Birner, R. and Ringler, C. (2025). Levelling the field: A review of the ICT revolution and agricultural extension in the Global South. Journal of International Development. 37(1): 1-21. https://doi.org/10.1002/jid.3949.

  6. Khatri, A., Lallawmkimi, M.C., Rana, P., Panigrahi, C.K., Minj, A., Koushal, S. and Ali, M.U. (2024). Integration of ICT in agricultural extension services: A review. Journal of Experimental Agriculture International. 46(12): 394-410.

  7. Mulungu, K., Kassie, M. and Tschopp, M. (2025). The role of information and communication technologies-based extension in agriculture: Application, opportunities and challenges. Information Technology for Development. 31(4): 1117-1146.

  8. Obianefo, C.A., Obiekwe, N.J., Okoroji, N.O., Shah, Z.A., Uchemba, U.V. and Osegbue, E.G. (2024). Usability of e-extension technology and growth of agricultural productivity in Southeast Nigeria: ADP extension worker’s survey. Sarhad Journal of Agriculture. 40(2): 659-671. https://doi.org/10.17582/journal.sja/2024/40.2.659.671.

  9. Ogedengbe, C.T., Akanji, N.E., Malomo, O.J. and Akanji, K.A. (2024). The potentials of e-extension for sustainable agricultural development in Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural Extension. 29(1): 270-278.

  10. Owolabi, A. and Yekinni, O. (2022). Utilisation of information and communication technologies for agricultural extension service delivery in public and non-public organizations in southwestern Nigeria. Heliyon. 8(9): e10676. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2022.e10676.

  11. Patel, M., Khodifad, P.B. and Chaudhary, M. (2024). Utilisation of artificial intelligence-related technology for agricultural extension services among extension professionals in India. Bhartiya Krishi Anusandhan Patrika. 39(3-4): 288-293. doi: 10.18805/BKAP695.

  12. Porciello, J., Coggins, S., Mabaya, E. and Otunba-Payne, G. (2022). Digital agriculture services in low- and middle-income countries: A systematic scoping review. Global Food Security. 34: 100640. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gfs.2022.100640.

  13. Premkishor, S.N., Jahagirdar, K.A., Jadhav, A. and Raghuprasad, K.P. (2023). A study on utilisation pattern of e-tools (ICT-tools) by extension personnel working in developmental departments in Vijayapur district, Karnataka, India. Asian Journal of Agricultural Extension, Economics and Sociology. 41(11): 138-145.

  14. Sa’adu, M., Norsida, M., Jasmin, A.S., Nitty, H.K. and Ahmadu, A.T. (2022). Factors affecting use of information communication technologies among extension agents in North-East, Nigeria. Journal of Agricultural Extension. 26(1): 36-43. https://doi.org/10.4314/jae.v26i1.5.

  15. Sahoo, S., Parasar, B., Dash, M. and Akomolafe, G. (2025). ICT in public extension: Constraints and suggestions through the lens of extension functionaries. Agricultural Science Digest. 45(6): 1058-1064. doi: 10.18805/ag.D-6359. 

  16. Salokhe, S. (2025). Uncovering the impact of technology-driven services on boosting farmer producer organizations (FPO) growth: A glimpse into the promising future of Indian agriculture, with a focus on the potential of information and communication technology (ICT): A review. Indian Journal of Agricultural Research. 59(8): 1161-1167. doi: 10.18805/IJARe.A-6341. 

  17. Shashidhara, K.K. (2020). ICT utilization behaviour among extension personnel. Journal of Extension Systems. 36(1): 15-22.

  18. Singh, D. and Verma, B.K. (2023). The utilisation of social media for accessing farming information by progressive farmers. Bhartiya Krishi Anusandhan Patrika. 38(3): 290-295. doi: 10.18805/BKAP642.

  19. Thirumal, A., Babu, G.S., Deepika, R.B. and Harish, B.P. (2026). Digital extension in agriculture: A review of WhatsApp groups for information dissemination in India. Asian Journal of Agricultural Extension, Economics and Sociology. 44(4): 125-135. https://doi.org/10.9734/ ajaees/2026/v44i42916.
In this Article
Published In
Bhartiya Krishi Anusandhan Patrika

Editorial Board

View all (0)