Thugone (%)
Plants propagated vegetatively by cuttings yielded the highest percentage at 21.16%, while those propagated by tissue culture recorded the lowest at 16.76%. Regarding the covering treatments and temperature ranges during the experiment, plants subjected to a half-cover/uncovered system exhibited the highest thugone percentage at 20.34%, while the open-field treatment yielded the lowest at 17.88%. Biofertilizers also contributed to an increase in the fatty acid percentage. Treating the soil of the experimental plants with Trichoderma fungus resulted in the percentage at 20.13%, surpassing all other treatments, while the control plants yielded the lowest at 18.58% (Table 3).
The interaction of the two study factors resulted in significant differences in thugone content. The interaction of the vegetative plant culture with plants grown in semi-open fields recorded 22.52%. The content was recorded in the interaction with tissue-cultured plants grown in open fields, at 16.01%. The interaction of the plant culture with biofertilizer also had a significant difference, as shown in the same table. The interaction with vegetatively cultured plants treated with fungi resulted in the content at 21.95%, surpassing most other interaction treatments. The content was recorded in the interaction with tissue-cultured plants not treated with biofertilizer at 16.23%. The type of cultivation was combined with the addition of a biofertilizer to the soil, it had a significant effect on increasing the active ingredient. The two-way interaction (Semi-open field cultivation with the fungal biofertilizer) yielded the at 21.13%, while the lowest was obtained by plants grown in the open field without any biofertilizer treatment, at 17.22%.
Cineole (%)
The results recorded significant differences in the percentage of cineole due to variations in plant origin. Vegetative propagated plants yielded the highest average percentage at 15.42%, while tissue-cultured plants recorded the lowest percentage at 13.74%. The type of cultivation also had a significant effect on this trait. The biofertilizer increased the fatty acid content, with the treatment of the experimental plants’ soil with azotobacter bacteria yielding the increase of 15.00%, without a significant difference compared to the soil treatment with Trichoderma fungus, which recorded an average of 14.76%. The lowest decrease was observed in the control treatment, at 14.22% (Table 4).
The most significant decrease was recorded in the control treatment. The two-way interaction produced significant differences in the above trait. The interaction of vegetative propagation with plants subjected to the full-coverage system achieved the result of 15.89%, surpassing most other treatments in the experiment. The lowest result, 13.21%, was recorded with the interaction of tissue-cultured plants grown in the open field. The interaction of vegetative propagation with a biofertilizer also produced significant differences. The interaction between the type of cultivation and the biofertilizer had a significant effect on increasing the active ingredient. The interaction (Protected cultivation system with bacterial fertilizer) reaching 15.42%, while lowest 13.68%, was achieved by plants grown in the open field and not treated with biofertilizer.
Camphor (%)
There are significant differences were found in the percentage of camphor due to variations in plant origin. Vegetatively propagated plants yielded the highest at 11.43%, while tissue-cultured plants recorded the lowest percentage at 10.01%. The cultivation system did not significantly affect this trait. However, biofertilizers increased camphor acid levels. The interaction of vegetative plant material with plants subjected to the semi-exposed cover system achieved 12.02%, while the lowest was recorded with the interaction of tissue-cultured plants grown in the open system, at 9.77%. The interaction of plant material with biofertilizer also showed a significant response (Table 5).
The interaction of vegetative plants treated with bacteria recorded 11.86%, while the lowest was recorded with the interaction of tissue-cultured plants not treated with biofertilizer, at 9.36%. The interaction between the type of cultivation and the biofertilizer had a significant effect on increasing the active ingredient. The three-way interaction of experimental factors resulted in a significant increase in camphor acid. The value 12.56%, was achieved in the treatment involving this interaction (vegetatively propagated plants grown in a semi-protected system and treated with a bacterial fertilizer). In contrast, the lowest value, 8.54%, was achieved in tissue-cultured plants grown in open fields without treatment with a biofertilizer.
Camphene (%)
The results shows that the plant rootstock used in propagating sage plants significantly affected the percentage of camphene. Plants yielded recorded the highest average value 7.90%, while tissue-cultured plants recorded the lowest, at 6.12%. The significant effect of the cultivation system on the above trait continued, with the semi-open system achieving, 7.20%, while open-field plants recorded the lowest value, 6.67%. The addition of a biofertilizer to the growing soil significantly increased the camphene content. The bacterial treatment yielded 7.12%, without significantly differing from the fungal treatment, which recorded an average of 7.02%. The lowest was recorded in the control treatment, at 6.65% (Table 6).
The interaction of semi-open-field cultivation with bacterial and fungal fertilizers yielded 7.33% and 7.32%, respectively. Conversely, the lowest, 6.33%, was achieved by plants grown in open-field cultivation without any biofertilizer treatment. Significant differences were found in the percentage of camphene acid in the leaves of sedge plants due to the three-factor interaction. The 8.86%, was recorded with the three-factor interaction (Vegetatively propagated plants grown in semi-protected soil treated with bacterial fertilizer). Tissue-cultured plants grown in open-field cultivation without biofertilizer treatment achieved the lowest 5.86%.
This allowed for the study of their effect on the synthesis and formation of secondary metabolites under varying climatic conditions. The significant superiority of plants propagated vegetatively by cuttings may be due to this method being the optimal propagation method for sage plants.
Bagdat et al., (2017) stated that the common propagation method for sage plants is the use of various types of hardwood cuttings, which can produce plants with good growth and high resistance to the various climatic conditions and fluctuations they encounter during their life cycle.
The significant differences caused by protected and semi-protected farming systems compared to open-field farming, this may be explained by the fact that plants grown under protected or semi-protected systems were provided with optimal growth conditions, especially the extreme temperatures experienced during the growing season from summer to winter. Since sedges thrive in cold environments, extreme temperatures can be a hindering factor in plant growth and the quality of secondary metabolite formation, including unsaturated fatty acids
(Calvo et al., 2014; El-Shanhorey and Sorour, 2019). In contrast, open-field farming exposed plants directly to environmental and climatic variations, including temperature, light and humidity, which can directly affect vital and physiological processes, thus weakening the plant’s resilience, immunity and growth response to the temperature fluctuations observed during the research period
(Hosseinzadeh et al., 2021).
It plays a role in the formation of bacterial nodules and has the ability to dissolve many poorly soluble nutrients, such as zinc, iron and copper, due to the presence of biochemical compounds produced in large quantities that are responsible for soluble elements (
Abena, 2023). This was confirmed by
Karpi and Tewari (2010), who found that
Trichoderma spp. fungal isolates are efficient at soluble phosphate and increase phosphorus availability through the production of the enzyme phosphatase.
Pandya and Saraf (2010) also confirmed that the biofertilizer
Trichoderma spp. has the ability to process phosphorus and some micronutrients.
Aruna et al., (2025) concluded that the metabolites produced by
Trichoderma spp. It is responsible for the chelation of iron, increasing its reduction and converting it into a form readily available for absorption. It also plays a role in the breakdown of chlorinated organic compounds and contributes to increased production of the hormone IAA by oxidizing the amino acid tryptophan secreted by the roots. This, in turn, contributes to an increase in root hairs. This fungus also enhances plant resistance by secreting three types of resistance-inducing compounds: enzymes, protein analogs and oligosaccharides, along with other low molecular weight compounds (
Al-Juheishy, 2025). The reason may also be attributed to the combined positive effect of the study’s factors, which were largely linked to increased biological activity of the microorganisms added to the potting soil. These microorganisms, in conjunction with the root system of the experimental plants, positively contributed to improved growth parameters
(Vasileva et al., 2022; Botey et al., 2022; Alarkwazi, 2026).