Effect of location and land use on aggregate indices
Soil texture and particle size distribution (PSD)
Table 2 shows the impact of location, land use and their interaction on soil texture and PSD. Soils in Umudike exhibited a sandy loam texture, while Umuahia soils were loamy sand, reflecting a coarser texture in Umuahia. Umudike had higher clay content (138 g/kg) than Umuahia (108 g/kg), while sand content followed the opposite trend. Though texture is mostly inherent, localized leaching, illuviation and pedogenic processes often influence variability
(Osakwe et al., 2022; Oguike et al., 2023).
Forest and grazing lands exhibited lower sand and higher clay contents than other land uses, attributed to organic matter inputs and canopy protection against erosion. Cultivated lands showed the highest sand content (854 g/kg) and the lowest clay (93 g/kg) and silt (46 g/kg), likely due to tillage and erosion-consistent with
Onwuka (2020).
Dinh and Shima (2024) also found bare soils had more sand than forest soils. These interactions underscore cultivation’s negative effect on PSD, modulated by location.
Soil organic carbon in aggregates (ASOC) and bulk soil (SOCb)
Fig 3 and 4 reveal that Umudike had higher ASOC in both the 4-2 mm (25.27 g/kg) and 2-0.25 mm (28.95 g/kg) fractions, along with greater bulk SOC (20.67 g/kg) than Umuahia. This supports
Yang et al. (2022), who emphasized macroag- gregates’ role in SOC storage. In both locations, the <0.25 mm ASOC was similar, indicating diminishing location effects with decreasing aggregate size, as also noted by
Osakwe et al. (2024) and
Mao et al. (2020).
Land use effects showed that road construction eliminated ASOC in the 4-2 mm fraction (0 g/kg), demonstrating the adverse impact of soil disturbance, consistent with
Sezgin et al. (2019). Grazing areas had the highest ASOC across all sizes: 25.27 g/kg (4-2 mm), 38.95 g/kg (2-0.25 mm) and 23.56 g/kg (<0.053 mm). Forest soils showed the highest SOCb. These trends suggest that organic matter quality and type-not just quantity-drive ASOC levels.
Prabakaran et al. (2023) found that vegetation and litter-fall significantly influenced carbon pools across land uses.
SOCb followed the order: forest > grazing > fallow > cultivated > road, confirming findings by
Martens et al. (2004), who reported that forests and pastures stored 46% and 25% more SOC than cropped soils, respectively, with forest increasing SOC by 29% over pasture. SOC declines in cultivated land stem from crop residue removal, intensive tillage, oxidation and erosion
(Mengstie et al., 2020; Osakwe, 2018). Variability in SOC across land uses is also shaped by vegetation, microbial activity, substrate quality and root turnover.
Land use significantly influenced ASOC, aligning with
Yi et al. (2018). Interaction effects (Table 3) indicated road construction caused significant ASOC loss in macroaggregates at both sites, while grazing, fallow and forest enhanced ASOC. ASOC contributes to soil structural stability, so its decline under road construction likely degrades soil physical properties and ecosystem functions
(Ayoubi et al., 2020).
Grazing and forest lands in Umudike showed superior ASOC and SOCb levels, likely due to better management practices (Table 1; Fig 4). These results emphasize the importance of sustainable land use for enhancing SOC and promoting climate resilience.
Aggregate size distribution (ASD) and mean weight diameter (MWD)
Table 4 shows that Umudike soils had a higher proportion of water-stable aggregates (WSA) in all size fractions. Despite this, no significant location effect was observed on MWD. Greater WSA in Umudike is likely due to its higher clay and SOC content (Tables 2 and 3), which promote aggregation.
Li et al. (2023) reported that fine particles and SOC support aggregate formation. Umudike also had a higher proportion of microaggregates (33%) than Umuahia, linked to its finer texture. Similar findings were reported by
Gao et al. (2024) and
Wu et al. (2024) for Mollisols and silty loam soils.
Land use effects on ASD were as follows:
•
4.00–2.00 mm: Grazing = Forest > Fallow > Road > Cultivated
•
2.00–0.25 mm: Grazing > Fallow > Forest > Road = Cultivated
•
0.25–0.053 mm: Road = Cultivated > Fallow > Forest > Grazing
•
<0.053 mm: Road = Cultivated > Fallow = Forest = Grazing
Grazing, forest and fallow lands retained larger aggregates better than road and cultivated lands. Higher WSA in the smallest fractions under road and cultivation implies greater breakdown and weaker structure. MWD values were higher in forest, grazing and fallow, supporting
Nwite (2015), who observed improved aggregation in these systems.
Interaction effects revealed that macroaggregation was lowest at Umuahia’s road construction sites (4.53%) and in Umudike’s cultivated lands (6.41%), showing severe degradation. Grazing and forest lands recorded the highest macroaggregation (42.08-44.31%). Road construction and cultivation caused up to 88% decline in macroaggregates, consistent with
Osakwe et al. (2024) in southeastern Nigerian Ultisols.
Enhanced macroaggregation implies not only reduced compaction (
Obalum and Obi 2014) but also improves root penetration, erosion control and nutrient cycling (
Zhang et al., 2012). These findings underline the need for land management practices that improve soil aggregation.
Microaggregate stability indices
Table 5 shows that Umudike had better microaggregate stability, with lower clay ratio (CR: 7.1), clay dispersion index (CDI: 0.41), dispersion ratio (DR: 0.35) and higher aggregated silt + clay (ASC: 14.24 g/kg) than Umuahia. These values suggest Umuahia soils are more erosion-prone. Umudike’s higher clay and lower sand content explain this stability. However, both sites are highly erodible (DR > 15%,
Middleton, 1930).
Land use impacted microaggregate stability. Forest soils showed the lowest CR (5.6), CDI (0.30) and DR (0.26), whereas cultivated and road-graded lands had the highest CR (10.24 and 9.1 respectively). Cultivated soils also had the highest CDI and DR (0.65 and 0.54 respectively). This agrees with
Osakwe (2021), who reported reduced microaggregate stability due to tillage. Elevated dispersion indices indicate susceptibility to soil structure loss and increased erosion.
Interaction effects revealed that road construction increased CR in Umudike, while CDI rose under grazing (Umuahia) and cultivation (Umudike). Grazing at Umuahia (community-managed) showed higher dispersion than Umudike (better-managed pasture), demonstrating management’s role. ASC was lowest under road construction in Umudike but highest in Umuahia due to clay increase with depth, showing location influence.
Despite grazing and forest soils’ superior microaggregate stability, coastal plain sands remain inherently erodible, as indicated by CR values (5.6-10.54;
Bouyoucos, 1935) and DR >15% (
Middleton, 1930).
Correlation analysis
Table 6 presents significant correlations among PSD, SOCb, aggregate indices and ASOC, consistent with
Yi et al. (2018) and
Hoang (2024). Sand content correlated positively with dispersion (r = 0.88** - 0.94**) and negatively with aggregation (-0.58 to -0.91). Sand also negatively correlated with ASOC in all size classes, indicating reduced carbon storage. Clay content, in contrast, promoted macroaggregation and reduced dispersion.
Silt content decreased DR and increased ASC and WSA, especially in Umuahia, due to its coarser texture.
Li et al. (2023) also found positive clay and negative sand correlations with aggregate stability.
SOCb was strongly correlated with ASC, MWD, WSA1 and ASOC1 in Umudike (r = 0.71 - 0.96) and with MWD, WSA1, WSA2 and ASOC1 in Umuahia (r = 0.56 - 0.85), suggesting SOC’s key role in macroaggregation. SOCb negatively correlated with dispersion indices only in Umudike (r = -0.83 to -0.89), indicating site-specific dynamics. Negative correlations between SOCb and WSA3 and ASOC3 suggest macroaggregates are the main carbon storage zones, corroborating
Yudina et al. (2022).