Growth and yield characteristics
The primary measure of earliness, days to 50% flowering, varies among cultivars. AP-3 (V2) achieves 50% flowering in 54.08 days, the earliest, while Arka Karthik (V4) takes 80.66 days, similar to Bonneville and Arka Apoorva (Table 1). rhizobium inoculation reduces the flowering time to 72.83 daysand PSB inoculation reduces it to 72.53 days, compared to uninoculated controls at 74.36 and 74.66 days, respectively. Plant height varies by variety and inoculation; Arka Apoorva (V5) is the tallest at 109.93 cm, while P-89 (V1) is the shortest at 98.27 cm. Rhizobium-inoculated plants reach 107.84 cm versus 102.58 cm in controlsand PSB-inoculated plants show similar improvements. Arka Apoorva and Arka Karthik reach heights of 113.20 cm and 112.01 cm with rhizobium, while P-89 measures only 100.29 cm. Similarly, PSB inoculation had a significant effect compared to the uninoculated control. The statistical study indicates considerable changes in plant height, influenced by cultivars and their inoculation with rhizobium and phosphorus solubilizing bacteria. Arka Apoorva shows out as the tallest, while P-89 is the lowest, with genetic makeup and nutrient application playing key roles in plant height. This accords with studies by
Mandloi et al., (2020), Das et al., (2015), Patel et al., (2013) and
Prasad et al., (2014). Kumawat et al., (2010) also observed the importance of phosphorus in nodule development and microbial activity, contributing to higher plant height in gram.
Varieties do not considerably impact the leaf area index. Rhizobium inoculation, however, considerably increases the leaf area index, reaching 0.61 compared to the uninoculated control (0.50). Similarly, PSB-inoculated seeds result in a considerably greater leaf area index (0.58) than the uninoculated control (0.53). Most cultivars, having viney stature and comparable expansion tendencies, do not differ in leaf area index. Yet, rhizobium and PSB inoculations raise LAI due to higher nutrient digestion and increased microbial activity, supporting effective nodule formation in the soil
(Das et al., 2015).
Varieties significantly affect pod quantity and weight. P-89 has the highest pod count (41.99), while Arka Apoorva has the lowest (16.67). Rhizobium inoculation increases pod number to 30.09 compared to 27.93 in uninoculated seedsand PSB inoculation raises it to 30.56 compared to 27.46 in controls
(Jaiswal et al., 2021; Nadeem et al., 2022). Similarly, P-89 shows the highest pod count with PSB inoculation, while Arka Apoorva records the lowest. Dual inoculation enhances pod quantity due to increased nitrogen and phosphorus availability, aligning with recent studies
(Gupta et al., 2020; Perveen et al., 2021).
In terms of pod weight, P-89 leads at 7.34 g, while Arka Apoorva records the lowest at 4.45 g, similar to Arka Karthik (4.65 g). Rhizobium inoculation raises pod weight to 6.02 g compared to 5.41 g in controlsand PSB inoculation results in 5.94 g versus 5.48 g in uninoculated seeds
(Singh et al., 2020; Rodriguez et al., 2019). P-89 shows the highest weight with both rhizobium (7.62 g) and PSB (7.35 g) inoculation. Varietal differences, soil interactionand climatic factors contribute to this variability. These findings are consistent with recent research on the benefits of inoculation for improving pod weight
(Sivasakthi et al., 2020; Kumar et al., 2022). Considerable variation in shelling percentage is observed among varieties. P-89 leads with 51.01%, similar to AP-3 at 50.77%, while Bonneville has the lowest at 42.76%
(Singh et al., 2022). Rhizobium-inoculated seeds exhibit a higher shelling percentage (48.53%) compared to uninoculated seeds (47.46%) and PSB-inoculated seeds show an even greater percentage (48.67%) than controls (47.32%)
(Rao et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2022). Varietal differences are significant, with Bonneville recording the lowest shelling percentage. Single and dual inoculation with Rhizobium and PSB substantially enhance shelling percentage compared to controls, aligning with recent findings on the positive effects of biofertilizers
(Khan et al., 2023; Sharma et al., 2024).
Green pod yield (q/ha)
Data from Table 1 indicate significant varietal effects on green pod production. P-89 leads with the highest yield (126.75 q/ha), while Arka Apoorva shows the lowest (77.27 q/ha)
(Singh et al., 2022). Rhizobium inoculation substantially increases yield to 99.08 q/ha compared to uninoculated controls. Similarly, PSB inoculation improves yield, with P-89 reaching 130.79 q/ha, significantly higher than other varieties. Dual inoculation of rhizobium and PSB results in the highest yield for P-89 (134.42 q/ha), while Arka Apoorva yields the least (70.95 q/ha) when uninoculated
(Rao et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2022). Inoculation with rhizobium and PSB enhances green pod production compared to controls, reflecting findings by
Yadav and Yadav (2011),
Vimala and Natrajan (2000) and
Bhattari et al., (2003). The increase in pod yield is attributed to improved nutrient availability during pod development, as noted by
Habib and Zamin (2003),
Dalal and Nandkar (2010) and
Shamad et al., (2019).
Quality characteristics
The results in Table 1 show significant varietal effects on total soluble solids (TSS) and dry matter content. Bonneville leads with the highest TSS at 16.90 °Brix, while Arka Apoorva has the lowest at 12.40 °Brix
(Patel et al., 2024). Rhizobium and PSB inoculations both significantly increase TSS compared to uninoculated seeds. Rhizobium enhances TSS by improving nitrogen fixation and chlorophyll production, whereas PSB increases phosphorus availability, promoting root development and nodulation. Dual inoculation of rhizobium and PSB achieves the highest TSS due to synergistic effects on nutrient availability and nitrogen fixation
(Singh et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2022). For dry matter content, AP-3 has the highest at 23.60%, followed by Bonneville at 23.43% and Arka Karthik at 23.46%. Arka Apoorva records the lowest at 22.32%, similar to P-89 at 22.47%. Both rhizobium and PSB inoculations significantly boost dry matter content, likely due to enhanced cell division and meristematic activity
(Verma et al., 2023; Sharma et al., 2022).
Nodulation studies
The data in Table 2 highlights significant varietal differences in root nodule counts, length, widthand weight. P-89 shows the highest nodule count (75.56), significantly more than Arka Apoorva (63.37)
(Rani et al., 2020). Rhizobium inoculation boosts nodule counts to 82.24, with P-89 reaching 87.85, while PSB inoculation increases counts to 78.51, with P-89 at 84.99. Dual inoculation results in the highest nodule count (93.91), surpassing the uninoculated control (50.56)
(Rather et al., 2021; Srivastava et al., 2022).
Nodule length does not vary significantly among varieties as shown in Table 2, Fig 1-15. Rhizobium-inoculated seeds produce longer nodules (2.10 mm) compared to uninoculated controls (1.77 mm)and PSB inoculation also increases nodule length (2.03 mm vs. 1.84 mm)
(Singh et al., 2021). Nodule width varies, with Bonneville having the widest nodules (1.65 mm), while P-89 has the narrowest (1.27 mm) with rhizobium and PSB inoculation increasing width (1.53 mm and 1.44 mm, respectively)
(Singh et al., 2021).
Regarding nodule fresh weight, AP-3 has the highest at 396.37 mg, while Bonneville has the lowest at 377.38 mg. Rhizobium inoculation increases fresh weight to 399.83 mgand PSB increases it to 393.35 mg. Dry weight is highest in P-89 (123.16 mg) and AP-3 (121.62 mg), with Bonneville recording the lowest (117.06 mg). Rhizobium and PSB inoculation both enhance dry weight (125.32 mg and 123.31 mg, respectively) compared to uninoculated controls (114.11 mg and 116.12 mg)
(Tyagi et al., 2022; Rani et al., 2020).
Nitrogen and phosphorus uptake studies (Kg/ha)
The data in Table 2 reveals significant varietal differences in nutrient uptake. P-89 shows the highest nitrogen uptake at 93.23 kg/ha, while Arka Karthik has the lowest at 87.40 kg/ha. Rhizobium inoculation increases nitrogen uptake to 97.25 kg/ha compared to 83.08 kg/ha in uninoculated controlsand PSB inoculation improves it to 96.61 kg/ha. Co-inoculation of Rhizobium and PSB results in the highest nitrogen uptake of 103.04 kg/ha, whereas uninoculated seeds have the lowest at 75.99 kg/ha
(Rudresh et al., 2022; Abid et al., 2017).
For phosphorus uptake, P-89 records the highest at 13.19 kg/ha and Arka Apoorva the lowest at 12.07 kg/ha. Rhizobium inoculation increases phosphorus uptake to 13.77 kg/ha compared to 11.69 kg/ha in controlsand PSB inoculation boosts it to 14.09 kg/ha. P-89 shows the greatest phosphorus uptake with PSB (14.67 kg/ha), while Arka Apoorva has the lowest (13.29 kg/ha). Co-inoculation enhances phosphorus uptake to 15.62 kg/ha, with uninoculated seeds showing the least at 10.82 kg/ha
(Rokhzadi et al., 2019; Wani et al., 2021).
Overall, both rhizobium and PSB inoculations improve nutrient uptake across varieties, with P-89 performing the best and Arka Karthik and Arka Apoorva showing lower uptake. Co-inoculation further enhances nutrient absorption, consistent with findings by
Rani et al., (2019) and
Bhat et al., (2015).