Germination percentage
Salinity stress significantly reduced germination percentage in both genotypes. The susceptible MH-1314 showed higher reduction (30.14%) than the tolerant TMB-37 (24.99%). Both genotypes exhibited increased germination percent in control as well as saline condition when primed with ZnO-NPS. However, 50 ppm treatment was found highly effective in increasing the germination percentage in TMB-37 (7.14% and 23.81%) and MH-1314 (7.40% and 26.84%) under control and saline condition respectively (Table 2).
Sensitive genotype MH-1314 had higher reduction percent than tolerant TMB-37, indicating better germination and salt resistance. Similar is documented in
Brassica napus (Ali et al., 2021), salinity’s impact observed may be attributed to water deficit due to osmotic stress and hindered water intake
(Ahemed et al., 2017; Sinha et al., 2020). Prior studies on crops like wheat showed improved germination with zinc nanoparticles
(Rai-Kalal and Jajoo, 2021). Zn’s multifaceted roles in plants, including enzyme co-factor, protein, carbohydrate metabolism
(Gardea-Torresdey, 2014) and antioxidant enzymes and ROS scavenging
(Jiang et al., 2014), possibly enhance germination vital processes.
Seedling length and dry weight
Salinity stress significantly reduces shoot length (SL) and shoot dry weight (SW) in both genotypes compared to controls. In sensitive genotype MH-1314 percent decrease was higher in SL (57.69%) and SW (17.54%) than tolerant genotype TMB-37 in SL (56.84%) and SW (15.96%). Similarly, susceptible genotype (MH-1314) shows higher decrease percent in root length (RL) (54.05%) and root dry weight (RW) (17.25%), while TMB-37 displays non-significant increase in RL and significant decrease in RW (15.57%) against its respective control.
Zinc nanoparticle doses (50, 100, 500, 1000 ppm) significantly enhance SL and SW in both genotypes in both control and saline condition. However, 50 ppm treatment stand out i.e. by increasing following percent increase such as in TMB-37 SL: 11.69%, MH-1314 SL: 24.38%; TMB-37 SW: 21.81%, MH-1314 SW: 27.48% under control condition and TMB-37 SL: 36.23%; MH-1314 SL: 49.63%; TMB-37 SW: 18.98%; MH-1314 SW: 16.31% under saline condition. Similar trends occur in RL and RW, increased in percent change such as in TMB-37 RL: 37.82%, MH-1314 RL: 27.02%; TMB-37 RW: 21.94%, MH-1314 RW: 27.64% under control condition and TMB-37 RL: 34.32%, MH-1314 RL: 19.81%; TMB-37 RW: 18.52%, MH-1314 RW: 16.70% under saline condition (Table 3, Fig 1).
Research shows lower doses enhance seedling traits such as 50 ppm for broad beans, even lower concentration for crops like rapeseed
(Kahlel et al., 2020; Hezaveh et al., 2019). Zinc’s roles include water uptake, auxin biosynthesis, cell division and enlargement correlating with improved shoot and root traits
(Kahlel et al., 2020). Results of reduced root length and dry mass in wheat with higher doses such as 1100 ppm ZnO nanoparticles aligns with our result (Du W
et al. 2019) in which susceptible genotype’s MH-1314 root traits decreases with 1000 ppm
i.e. RL (13.22%) and RW (8.96%) in control condition and RL (17.33%) and RW (11.43%) under saline condition. Roots are foremost to get affected by ion toxicity derived from salt stress showing susceptibility to morphological and dry mass changes
(Dimkpa et al., 2012). And also the fact that Zn is micronutrient, when applied in higher concentration might have led to its adverse effect,
e.g., 1000 ppm ZnO-NPs.
Proline accumulation
Compared to controls, salinity stress significantly elevates proline with a higher percent increase in TMB-37 (26.23%) vs. MH-1314 (25.51%) (Table 4). Enhanced proline content under salt stress is widely documented
(Soleimani et al., 2017). Proline, crucial for cell osmoregulation under salt stress aids in countering osmotic stress through improved protein synthesis
(Ahmad et al., 2019; Pradhan et al., 2023). Seed priming with 50 ppm enhances proline content in TMB-37 (4.88%) and MH-1314 (7.25%) under control condition and TMB-37 (12.35%) and MH-1314 (10.198%) under saline condition. Similar findings was reported in rapeseed
(Hezaveh et al., 2019). Proline, a non-enzymatic antioxidant, combats free radicals and singlet oxygen under stress, possibly induced by Zn’s interaction with the non-enzymatic antioxidant system and protein synthesis
(Szabados et al., 2010). Conversely, Zn treatments might generate modest ROS levels for tolerance against toxicity
(Du et al., 2019).
Membrane stability and lipid peroxidation
Salinity stress reduces MSI significantly higher in MH-1314 (12.48%) vs. TMB-37 (6.32%), while increase lipid peroxidation in MH-1314 (48.80%) vs. TMB-37 (13.11%) against its respective control (Table 4). Similar findings in prior research report higher lipid peroxidation and MDA concentration under salt stress in maize leaves
(Nahar et al., 2016). Osmotic stress from salinity affects water, nutrient intake, potentially reducing phospholipid accumulation, harming membrane integrity (
Mansour, 2013;
Mandhania, 2006). ROS further damage membranes and elevate MDA (a marker for oxidative damage)
(Zheng Jia-Lang, 2016). Seed priming with 50 ppm improves MSI in TMB-37 (5.73%) and MH-1314 (3.38%) under control condition and in TMB-37 (6.63%) and MH-1314 (5.25%) under saline condition. It also reduces lipid peroxidation in TMB-37 (12.89%) and MH-1314 (7.22%) under control condition and in TMB-37 (13.20%) and MH-1314 (11.18%) under saline condition (Table 4). Zn nanoparticles enhance rice resistance to moisture stress by maintaining MSI
(Rameshraddy et al., 2017). Zn’s role in nutrient transport may boost phospholipid buildup, maintain biomembrane structural integrity. Similarly reported, ZnO nanoparticle treatment reduces lipid peroxidation in Cilantro and Lupine plants (
Reddy Pullagurala et al., 2018;
Latef et al., 2016), likely due to changes in membrane permeability along with Zn aided protection from oxidative stress
(Burman et al., 2013).
Antioxidant enzyme activity
Salinity stress raises SOD and POX activity significantly higher in TMB-37 i.e. SOD (20.10%) and POX (11.02 %) vs. MH-1314 SOD (11.68%) and POX (12.34 %) against its respective control (Table 4). Similar findings in other crops
(Unal et al., 2014) suggest salt stress boosts ROS production, antioxidant enzyme activity (Das and Das 2019). Seed priming with 50 ppm raises SOD in TMB-37 (3.25%) and MH-1314 (6.38%) under control condition and TMB-37 (7.09%) and MH-1314 (5.77%) under saline soil. Similarly, it increases POX non-significantly (NS) in both genotype (C.D. = 0.199 among treatments) under control condition and significantly in TMB-37 (17.26%) and MH-1314 (12.52%) under saline condition. It is also documented that 50 ppm ZnO nanoparticles increases antioxidant enzymes in wheat (
Du et al., 2019), combined with salinity stress improves enzyme activity also
(Latef et al., 2016). Elevated SOD, POX activity linked to Zn’s role in enzyme, non-enzymatic antioxidant production and Initial ROS generation from Zn treatment could signal chain reaction, increasing enzyme activity may be attributed for the effect (
Rezaei and Abbasi, 2014;
Soliman et al., 2015).