Descriptive statistics
High variability for each trait was demonstrated by result with the following range of values: 67-82 (days to flowering), 1.0-2.5 mm (leaflet length), 0.3-0.7 mm (leaflet breadth), 2.0-6.0 mm (peduncle length), 125-134 (days to maturity), 35.3-80.3 cm (plant height), 3.0-7.0 (number of branches/plant), 63.7-215.3 (number of pods/plant), 2.2-7.5 mm (seed width), 4.1-11.76 g (100-seed weight) and 2.58-13.5 g (seed yield/plant) (Supplementary Table 1). The high variability in all these traits can be due to difference in the genetic composition of the lentil mutants.
Analysis of variance
Highly significant mean squares owing to genotypes for all the characters in the current analysis revealed a large level of variability among the genotypes for the characters analysed (Table 1). Furthermore, almost all of the quantitative characters have marginally larger phenotypic coefficients of variance (PCV) than their genotypic coefficients of variance (GCV), indicating that the environment had a modest confounding effect on the expression of the traits under investigation (Table 2).
Hussan et al., (2018), Kumar, (2020) and
Kumar et al., (2020) also observed higher magnitude of PCV than that of GCV for all the traits. The findings demonstrated that observed traits were largely resistant to environmental changes and also trait variation was mostly due to heritable factors.
Phenotypic and genotypic coefficient of variation
Among all the characters, high PCV was estimated only for seed yield/plant (32.85%). Moderate PCV was observed for seed width (25.35%), number of pods/plant (22.74%) and peduncle length (22.45%) whereas, low PCV was recorded for leaflet breadth (19.13%), number of branches/plant (16.67%), leaflet length (16.23%), plant height (14.82%), 100-seed weight (14.50%), days to flowering (5.32%) and days to maturity (2.10%). As far as GCV is concerned, high magnitude was observed for seed yield/plant followed by seed width (24.36%) and peduncle length (21.78%) whereas, moderate GCV was observed for number of pods/plant (19.86%), leaflet breadth (15.55%), plant height (14.02%), number of branches/plant (13.94%), leaflet length (13.77%) and 100-seed weight (12.02%) and low GCV was observed for days to flowering (5.03%) and days to maturity (1.53%).
Heritability and genetic advance
All the characters exhibited high heritability (broad sense) except days to maturity which showed moderate heritability (55.66%). These results were in partial concurrence with the results reported by
Rasheed et al., (2008) and
Bicer and Sarkar (2008). Genetic advance as percentage of mean was observed to be high for almost all the characters except days to flowering and days to maturity where it was observed moderate (12.57%) and low (3.08%), respectively. Peduncle length, number of pods/plant, seed width and seed yield/plant exhibited high PCV and GCV coupled with high heritability and genetic advance suggesting that additive gene action are responsible for inheritance of these characters and hence can be improved through direct selection. Low GCV coupled with low heritability and genetic advance were observed for days to maturity indicated presence of non-additive gene action and high GXE interaction. Leaflet length and plant height revealed moderate GCV along with high heritability and genetic advance which pointed towards presence of lesser variability for these traits in the material studied; however, they can be improved through selection to a limited extent. These results are in partial agreement with the findings of
Hussan et al., (2018), Chowdhury et al., (2019), Kumar (2020),
Kumar et al., (2020) and
Sharma et al., (2022).
Correlation coefficient analysis
The higher magnitude of genotypic correlation coefficients than the phenotypic correlation coefficients for most of the cases indicated highly heritable nature of the associations (Table 3). The results indicated that seed yield/plant was positively associated with number of branches/plant (0.215) and number of pods/plant (0.420) but it was negatively associated with days to flowering (-0.182), leaflet length (-0.207), days to maturity (-0.150) and plant height (-0.179). The results obtained in the present study were in consonance with the findings of
Kumar et al., (2017), Chowdhury et al., (2019), Maurya et al., (2020) and
Girgel et al., (2021). Number of pods/plant showed positive association with seed yield/plant (0.420) but showed negative association with leaflet length (-0.181), leaflet breadth (-0.161), days to maturity (-0.338) and seed width (-0.184). Number of branches/plant was found positively associated with plant height (0.203) but negatively associated with seed width (-0.221) and 100-seed weight (-0.240). Occurrence of significant positive association of seed yield with most of its component traits and positive association between most of the yield components revealed less complex inter relationship between yield and yield components. Such situation is favourable from breeding point of view because selection for one trait may bring correlated response for improvement of other traits which are positively associated with it. These findings remain in close agreements with the observations reported by
Kumar et al., (2017), Chopdar et al., (2017), Kumar et al., (2020) and
Sharma et al., (2020) which may be obviously due to the fact that estimates may differ from location to location, year to year and even in the same year because of different study material method of estimation used.
Path coefficient analysis
On genotypic basis (Table 4) analysis revealed that among the ten characters studied, five characters exhibited positive direct effect and five negative direct effects on seed yield. Maximum positive direct effect on seed yield/plant was observed to be that of number of pods/plant followed by 100-seed weight, number of branches/plant, days to maturity and leaflet breadth. Seed yield/plant is also contributed by Number of pods/plant
via days to flowering, leaflet length, plant height, number of branches/plant and by 100-seed weight
via days to flowering and plant height. Apart from direct effects of number of branches/plant, it also unveiled positive indirect effect
via leaflet length, leaflet breadth and number of pod/plant. Similarly, days to maturity contributes seed yield/plant
via leaflet breadth, peduncle length, plant height and seed width. Therefore, for enhancement of seed yield emphasis should more be on the traits having positive and direct effect because of the reason that importance and balanced selection based on these traits would be more rewarding for improvement of lentil.
Chowdhury et al., (2019), Kumar et al., (2020), Maurya et al., (2020), Girgel et al., (2021) and
Sharma et al., (2022) also reported more or less similar results in lentil.