Nesting abundance and spatio-temporal distribution
Leatherback nesting in Phang Nga (2019-2024) showed significant inter-annual variation in both location and frequency. Nesting peaked in 2023 (13 nests), primarily in Tai Muang. After a complete absence in 2020 and 2021, nesting shifted in 2024, with all four recorded nests in Khura Buri. Earlier seasons showed higher nest concentrations in Tai Muang and Takua Thung (Fig 2).
Microhabitat and environmental characteristics (2024 season)
During the 2024 nesting season, all nests (n=4) were on broad, open beaches with slopes of 2.2-3.2°. Nests were positioned above the HWL at a mean distance of 21.8±1.6 m and an average distance of 12.9±14.2 m from the vegetation line (Fig 3). Ambient light intensity was negligible (0-1 lux).
Sand temperature at 50 cm depth varied significantly (27.5-31.7°C, p<0.05), whereas sand humidity showed no significant difference (7.1-8.4%, Fig 4). Substrate analysis revealed a predominance of medium sand (0.25-0.50 mm), with one instance of coarse sand (>0.50 mm).
Reproductive outcomes and success trends
A comparative analysis across four nesting seasons (2019, 2022, 2023 and 2024) showed that while clutch size (averaging 112-121) and incubation time (54-63 days) remained stable across seasons, hatching success declined catastrophically. Success rates fell from 64.3% (2019) and 64.5% (2022) to 46.9% (2023) and a record low of 4.3% in 2024 (p<0.05) (Fig 5). As shown in Table 1, the primary causes of failure were unfertilized eggs (13.6%-56.8%) and yolkless eggs (11.2%-36.8%). Notably, the 2023-2024 seasons saw new failure modes emerge: fertilized but undeveloped embryos (3.7%) and early embryo mortality (4.6%) (Fig 6).
Spatio-temporal nesting dynamics and habitat relocation
The distribution of leatherback turtle nests along the western coast of Phang Nga Province from 2019 to 2024 reveals a dynamic and precarious nesting pattern. Our findings indicate that while nesting occurs across all four districts, there is a clear and concerning shift in site selection over time. Historically, primary nesting grounds were identified on three beaches in three districts, including Khuk Khak Beach in Takua Pa district, Bor Dan Beach in Tai Muang district and Bang Kwan Beach in Takua Thung district
(Piboon et al., 2025). However, our 2024 field surveys found that many of these traditional sites have undergone significant land-use changes, characterized by the rapid expansion of tourism infrastructure, including resorts, cafés and beachfront hotels. This is supported by regional tourism statistics showing a substantial increase in both visitor numbers (from 4.4 million in 2016 to 4.9 million in 2018) and accommodation availability (from 11,903 in 2016 to 14,458 in 2020) in Phang Nga over the past decade (
Ministry of Tourism and Sports, 2026).
The relocation of nesting activities to Khura Buri district in 2024 is a significant finding of this study. These new sites are described as “pristine”, situated far from human settlements and roads, requiring significant travel on foot to reach (about 1-2 km). This spatial shift suggests that leatherback turtles are actively seeking areas with minimal anthropogenic disturbance, particularly light pollution, which was recorded at near-zero levels (0-1 lux) in our 2024 survey. While sea turtles generally exhibit nest-site fidelity, returning to their natal beaches, they also exhibit adaptive behavior by randomly selecting nearby alternative sites to optimize offspring survival when traditional habitats become unsuitable due to environmental degradation or human interference
(Neeman et al., 2015; Santos et al., 2016). However, as our study demonstrates, the move to undisturbed areas does not inherently guarantee reproductive success.
Physical drivers of nest site selection
The selection of a nesting site is a non-random process governed by a fundamental niche of environmental cues. In 2024, leatherback turtles in Phang Nga demonstrated consistent preferences for specific beach characteristics. All recorded nests were positioned on open beaches, above the high water line (HWL) at an average distance of 21.8±1.6 m. This behavior is consistent with leatherback populations in other regions, such as Costa Rica (17.4±0.1 m) (
Spanier, 2010) and Grenada (27.8±7.7 m)
(Charles et al., 2023), highlighting a global evolutionary strategy to avoid seawater inundation. Flooding of the egg chamber can be lethal to developing embryos by inducing osmotic stress from salt and blocking oxygen exchange within the sand substrate
(Nasiri et al., 2022; Stokes et al., 2024).
Furthermore, the preference for gentle to moderate slope (2.2 to 3.2°) observed in our study aligns with findings for leatherbacks and other sea turtle species globally
(Nasiri et al., 2022; Spanier, 2010;
Wood and Bjorndal, 2000;
Zavaleta-Lizárraga and Morales Mávil, 2013). A moderate slope is critical as it allows the heavy-bodied leatherback to reach a safe elevation efficiently without excessive energy expenditure during the crawl. While steep slopes may be difficult to access (
Ficetola, 2007), excessively shallow slopes increase the distance the turtle must travel
(Santos et al., 2016), thereby increasing exposure to land-based predators or human disturbance. The substrate in Phang Nga consisted primarily of medium sand, which is known to support better gas exchange and hatching success compared to finer or coarser sediments.
Thermal crisis: linking temperature to embryo mortality
The most critical finding of this research is the relationship between the nest’s thermal environment and the catastrophic decline in hatching success. Sea turtles exhibit temperature-dependent sex determination (TSD), in which incubation temperature during the middle third of development determines the sex of hatchlings
(Charles et al., 2023). In the 2024 season, we recorded nest temperatures as high as 31.7°C. Temperatures consistently above 30°C for leatherback turtles are known to produce 100% female-biased clutches
(Binckley et al., 1998), leading to concerns about the long-term availability of breeding males in the Andaman Sea population.
Beyond sex ratios, our data suggest that we are approaching the upper limit of the thermal tolerance range for leatherback embryo development (25-35°C)
(Charles et al., 2023). The appearance of “fertilized but undeveloped” eggs (3.7%) and “early embryo mortality” (4.6%) in the 2023 season, which persisted into 2024, is a major “red flag” for this population. Unlike unfertilized eggs, which reflect biological issues with the parent turtles, the death of a fertilized embryo is often a direct result of environmental stress. High temperatures can cause morphological anomalies or total developmental arrest (
Calderón Peña and Azanza Ricardo, 2021).
Our findings contrast with historical data from Thailand, which reported a much higher hatching rate of 50%
(Piboon et al., 2025) to 64% (data in 2019, 2023). The sudden drop to a mere 4.3% success rate in 2024 is statistically significant and clinically alarming. This decline suggests that even on pristine beaches like those in Khura Buri, the microhabitat conditions, specifically sand temperature and moisture, may no longer be sufficient to support successful incubation. The high variability in temperature between nests (27.5 to 31.7°C) further underscores the vulnerability of these clutches to localized microhabitat fluctuations.
Biological constraints and reproductive failure
While environmental factors are paramount, the high proportion of yolkless and unfertilized eggs cannot be ignored. In the 2024 season, unfertilized eggs accounted for 56.8% of total clutch failure. Yolkless eggs, which are a unique characteristic of leatherback clutches, also remained high at 36.8%. The prevalence of unfertilized eggs suggests a “population bottleneck” where a lack of breeding males
(Charles et al., 2023; García–Grajales et al., 2019;
Tomillo et al., 2014) or physiological stress in nesting females is preventing successful fertilization. As nesting abundance decreases year by year, the probability of successful mating encounters in offshore waters also diminishes, creating a feedback loop of reproductive failure.
This combination of biological constraints (infertility) and environmental stressors (lethal temperatures) creates a synergistic threat that could lead to the localized extinction of leatherback turtles in the Andaman Sea. Similar patterns of decline have been observed in Malaysia, where leatherbacks were once abundant but are now virtually extinct due to a combination of egg exploitation and habitat loss.