The statistical analysis indicated significant effects of breed on most of the measured carcass, compositional and morphometric parameters (Tables 1-6).
Carcass composition and yield
Significant breed difference (p< 0.05) was evident in the composition of bone (Table 1). The Neaimi breed showed a statistically higher proportion of Meat (43.35%) compared to both Harri (40.38%) and Najdi (38.72%) lambs, indicating a favorable lean profile. Conversely, Harri lambs exhibited the highest percentage of fat (26.20%), exceeding the Neaimi breed (20.76%). The Najdi breed demonstrated the highest proportion of bone (28.94%), significantly greater than both the Neaimi (25.52%) and Harri (23.42%) breeds.
The results regarding Pearson’s correlations between carcass characteristics (Table 2), showed strong positive relationships between slaughter weight and empty body weight (r=0.977, p<0.001), between slaughter weight and hot carcass weight (r=0.773, p<0.001) and between empty body weight and hot carcass weight (r=0.753, p<0.001). Dressing percentage showed moderate and statistically significant negative correlations with slaughter weight (r= -0.439, p=0.032) and with empty body weight (r=-0.495, p=0.014), whereas the correlation between hot carcass weight and dressing percentage was positive but not significant (r=0.198, p=0.355). Finally, rib-eye area (REA, cm
2) exhibited no meaningful correlations with the other traits, with all associations non-significant (largest magnitude r≈0.074 to -0.089; p≥0.680.
Carcass linear measurements and primal cuts
The Najdi breed consistently exhibited superior skeletal dimensions, recording significantly (p<0.05) greater internal carcass length (67.87 cm) and external carcass length (67.25 cm) compared to Neaimi and Harri lambs (Table 3). Najdi lambs also had the largest (p<0.05) leg width (39.94 cm), which is indicative of heavier primal leg cuts. Conversely, Neaimi lambs showed the highest (p<0.05) rump width (42.81 cm), while Harri lambs were lowest in this measurement (40.31 cm).
The distribution of primal cuts (Table 4) was largely comparable across the three breeds, with no significant differences observed in the percentage of shoulder, loin, leg, or foreshank and Breast. This uniformity suggests that while total carcass composition differs, the proportional anatomical distribution of cuts remains stable. However, the rack portion was significantly (p<0.05) higher in Harri lambs (9.62%) compared to Neaimi lambs (8.70%), with Najdi (9.28%) being intermediate. This suggests a slight difference in anterior body conformation and muscle distribution in the thoracic region.
Growth morphometric traits
The comparison of body measurements at week 1 (Table 5) and week 13 (Table 6) clearly established the inherent size differences among the breeds. At both time points, Najdi lambs consistently demonstrated superior linear growth, recording significantly (p< 0.05) greater body height at withers, body height at rump and body length compared to the other two breeds. This confirms the Najdi breed’s classification as a large-framed breed with a higher mature body size potential. For example, at week 12, Najdi’s body height at rump was 72.33 cm, significantly higher than Neaimi (66.70 cm) and Harri (68.30 cm). Neaimi lambs, while smaller in linear measurements, demonstrated a compensatory muscular development, as evidenced by their high body depth at week 12 (39.33 cm), which was significantly greater than Harri (38.23 cm) and Najdi (38.33 cm) at this final stage. This suggests a more compact, blocky conformation associated with superior muscle-to-bone ratio. Heart girth showed no significant difference among the breeds at either week, implying similar thoracic capacity or muscle development around the chest, despite differences in overall frame size.
The marked breed differences in this controlled study strongly suggest that inherent genetic background shaped by centuries of selection in distinct Saudi ecosystems drives body conformation and carcass composition. Clear phenotypic variation among the three registered breeds was observed; however, extrapolation should be cautious because the number of slaughtered animals per breed was limited by resources. Thus, results reflect breed-specific biological characteristics under these conditions, not conclusive guidance for national breeding programs. Larger, multi-system studies with genomic evaluation are needed to validate differences and estimate their genetic and economic impact
(Abousoliman et al., 2020; Langford et al., 2024).
Carcass composition and fat partitioning
Neaimi lambs produced the leanest carcasses, with the highest meat percentage (43.35%) and lowest fat percentage (20.76%), a highly significant finding. This suggests an energy allocation pattern favoring muscle accretion over adipose deposition
(Ferreira et al., 2015; Ayele et al., 2019; Jawasreh et al., 2019). Therefore, Neaimi is a strong candidate for selection in modern meat systems targeting leaner cuts, consistent with findings related to muscle fiber characteristics
(Jawasreh et al., 2019; Fan et al., 2022).
In contrast, Harri had the highest fat content (26.20%) and consequently the highest dressing percentage (54.96%). As a fat-tailed breed, Harri accumulates adipose tissue as an adaptation to arid-region feed scarcity and heat stress, serving as an energy and water reservoir. Fat deposition is genetically distinct and involves molecular regulation of adipose partitioning (
Peña et al., 2005;
Van der Merwe et al., 2020). While this can increase carcass weight and dressing yield, it may reduce saleable lean meat proportion
(Brady et al., 2003). Similar high dressing in other fat-tailed breeds (e.g., Iraqi Awassi) likely reflects shared tail physiology
(Khaleel et al., 2019; Argyriadou et al., 2022). Thus, dietary energy must be managed to balance fatness and lean growth.
Najdi lambs showed superior skeletal development (highest bone proportion, 28.94%), larger body dimensions and heavier carcass weights, indicating greater capacity for overall carcass growth. This pattern is typical of larger, later-maturing breeds
(Suliman et al., 2021; Aldawish, 2025). Although higher bone proportion may slightly reduce proportional carcass yield relative to Harri’s blocky, fat-covered carcass, the larger frame supports greater total muscle mass. Moreover, Neaimi lambs achieved higher meat ratio and primal wholesale cuts (Table 1 and 4), indicating higher potential for total meat production.
Strong positive correlations among slaughter weight, empty body weight and hot carcass weight are biologically expected, as increases in overall body mass are generally accompanied by proportional increases in both carcass and non-carcass components. In contrast, the moderate negative correlation between dressing percentage and slaughter or empty body weight suggests that carcass weight does not increase proportionally with total body weight. Heavier animals may accumulate relatively more non-carcass tissues and exhibit greater variation in gut fill, resulting in lower dressing percentages. This pattern is consistent with allometric growth, whereby non-carcass components increase at a rate equal to or greater than carcass tissues. The positive but non-significant association between hot carcass weight and dressing percentage further indicates that dressing percentage is influenced more by variation in non-carcass components than by carcass mass alone. Ribeye area (REA) showed no meaningful correlations with other traits, suggesting that muscularity is largely independent of body weight and carcass yield in this dataset. Therefore, selection for heavier slaughter or carcass weights alone may reduce dressing percentage and is unlikely to improve REA without targeted selection.
Morphometric traits and growth
Morphometric analysis supported the carcass findings. Najdi lambs consistently exhibited greater body height and body length than the other breeds from Week 1 to Week 13, confirming their large frame size and high skeletal growth potential. A larger skeletal frame is a prerequisite for attaining higher slaughter weights and is an important selection criterion for increasing meat production (
Van der Merwe et al., 2020). These results agree with previous studies
(Kumar et al., 2021; Kumar et al., 2018; Rangamma et al., 2023), which reported strong associations between body measurements, growth performance, live weight and carcass traits in sheep. Linear measurements, particularly body length, body height and heart girth, are widely recognized as practical indicators of production potential and valuable selection criteria in breeding programs. They also serve as effective, non-invasive predictors of slaughter weight and carcass characteristics in indigenous sheep breeds (
Obeidat, 2021;
Al-Qargouli and Salim, 2023).
The Neaimi breed’s compact morphology, characterized by lower linear dimensions but greater body depth at Week 13, suggests enhanced muscular development relative to skeletal growth, which may contribute to a favorable lean-to-fat ratio and improved feed conversion efficiency
(Souza et al., 2019). The absence of significant differences in heart girth at the final stage (Table 4) indicates that, despite Najdi lambs being taller and longer, all breeds achieved comparable thoracic development and muscularity, likely due to the ad libitum feeding regime. Such morphological variation is consistent with patterns reported in resilient indigenous breeds, where multivariate analyses have successfully differentiated populations based on skeletal traits while reducing multicollinearity in selection programs
(Hamadani et al., 2022). The ability of indigenous breeds to maintain muscle integrity and protein turnover under physiological stress further enhances their production value
(Abudabos et al., 2021).
Overall, significant breed-specific differences were observed in carcass composition and morphometric development. Neaimi lambs produced leaner carcasses with higher meat yield, Harri lambs showed superior fat deposition, higher dressing percentage and lower chill shrinkage, while Najdi lambs exhibited greater frame size and carcass weight. These differences support the development of breed-specific breeding objectives. Although the limited sample size may reduce the precision of estimated relationships, the consistency of the results across breeds supports the biological relevance of tailored selection strategies.