Overall prevalence of C. perfringens
As shown in Table 1, from 100 feacal samples
C. perfringens was identified in 48 samples, while 52 samples were found negative. The prevalence of
C.
perfringens was found significantly higher (p<0.01) in sheep (60%) as compared to goats (36%). The confirmation of positive samples was done by amplification of 324 bp fragment of
CPA gene using PCR (Fig 1).
Prevalence of C. perfringens in goats
The results presented in Table 2 exhibited a highest prevalence in Kalat (50%) followed by the Mangochar (38.46%), Johan (30.77%) and Gazg (25%). The statistical analysis revealed the significant differences (p<0.05; 95% confidence interval (CI) 18.808-68.913) in
C. perfringens prevalence in various areas of Kalat district. The results of the gender-wise prevalence of
C. perfringens exhibited a numerically higher (p>0.05; 95% CI 9.228-49.023) prevalence in females’ goats (40%) than male goats (32%). All the specimens were collected from dissimilar age groups of goats and categorized as <1 year, >1 but <2 years and ≥2 year. The age-wise analysis indicated that, in <1 year age group (44.44%), the prevalence of
C. perfringens was higher (p<0.05; 95% CI 8.002-57.888) than >1 but <2 years (29.41%) and ≥ 2-year (33.33%) age groups.
Prevalence of C. perfringens in sheep
As shown in Table 3, the highest prevalence was found in Kalat (76.92%) followed by Mangochar (66.67%), Johan (58.33%) and Gazg (38.46%). The statistical analysis revealed the significant difference (p<0.014; 95% CI 19.009-93.092) in
C. perfringens prevalence in various areas of Kalat district. Similarly, the age wise analysis indicated that, in <1 year age group (68.18%), the prevalence of
C. perfringens was higher (p<0.05; 95% CI 29.514-82.467) than >1 but <2 years (62.50%) and ≥2-year (41.67%) age groups. However, the results regarding gender-wise prevalence of
C. perfringens exhibited a numerically higher (p>0.05; 95% CI 38.038-83.594) prevalence in female (72%) as compared to male (48%) sheep.
Antibiogram of C. perfringens isolates
As shown in Table 4, among 30 sheep isolates of
C. perfringens, a highest number (28 isolates) showed resistance against amikacin, followed by amoxicillin/penicillin (25 isolates) and colistin sulphate (22 isolates). Whereas, among 18 isolates of goat a highest number (17 isolates) found resistant against colistin sulphate, followed by amoxicillin/amikacin (16 isolates) and penicillin (13 isolates). All the isolates (100%) of sheep and goat origin found susceptible to ceftazidime.
In current investigation, the overall prevalence of
C. perfringens was detected as 48%; with comparatively higher incidence in sheep (60%) as compared to goats (36%). A total of 48 isolates (30 sheep and 18 goat) were confirmed using biochemical characterization from 48 positive colonies. Similar results of
C. perfringens prevalence have been reported by
Taj et al., (2018), who reported 34.4% prevalence in goats and 54.78% in sheep in different areas of Balochistan. In another study,
Rahimoon et al., (2020) examined 100 samples, collected from small ruminants, out of which 45 samples were found positive for
C. perfringens. In contrast,
Ajaz-ul-Haq et al., (2016) reported 66.5% incidence of
C. perfringens in goats and sheep of district Khuzdar Balochistan. This high prevalence percentage of the organism may be due to environmental conditions, vaccination status and management
(Shehzadi et al., 2021). In current investigation, we also used polymerase chain reaction assay to confirm the isolates of
C. perfringens by amplifying the 324bp fragment of
CPA (alpha toxin gene) as suggested in literature
(Alsaab et al., 2021).
Our study showed the area-wise differences (25 to 50% in goats and 38.46 to 76.92% in sheep) in the prevalence of
C. perfringens in small ruminants in Kalat district. Similar results have been reported by
Rahimoon et al., (2020) who reported the 11.11 to 44.44% prevalence of
C. perfringens in goats of different areas of district Tharparkar. The authors postulated that occurrence rates of enterotoxaemia in different geographical locations might be due to improper vaccination schedule against enterotoxaemia, geographical differences and/or difference in breeds used in study. Earlier studies have reported the breed-wise differences in farm animals for susceptibility against infectious diseases
(Mangi et al., 2015).
Gender wise prevalence of
C. perfringens in goats and sheep exhibited the high prevalence in females as compared to males. These results reveled that females are at high risk then males. Our results are in agreement with the results of
Ajaz-ul-Haq et al., (2016) who observed that 38% females are positive with
C. perfringens, as compared to males 28.5%. Previous published literature have also demonstrated that females are comparatively more susceptible to chronic as well as acute microbial infections as compared to male animals
(Malhi et al., 2020).
The current investigation demonstrated the high incidence of
C. perfringens in small ruminants of less than 1 year age group, which are in aggrement with the results of
Ajaz-ul-Haq et al., (2016), who reported 18.5% prevalence of
C. perfringens in age group of 6 months to 1 year as compared to adult small ruminants (7.5%). In another study,
Nazki et al., (2017), reported high prevalence of
C. perfringens in lambs (56.16%) and kids (46.16%) than adult goat and sheep (3.84%). The authors described that high prevalence rate of
C. perfringens in young animals is probably due to heavy feeding of lambs and kids on lush pastures in addition to milking by their mothers; they also detected higher incidence in adult small ruminants grazed on luxurious pastures
(Nazki et al., 2017).
In this study antibiogram of the isolated organisms from small ruminants was conducted by disk diffusion method. The obtained results revealed that
C. perfringens isolates of both sheep and goat origin exhibited 100% susceptibility against ceftazidime (a third generation cephalosporin) which is also in accordance with study of
Mohiuddin et al., (2020) who reported 100% inhibition of
C. perfringens isolates against a third generation cephalosporin
viz., ceftiofur. Our results revealed trimethoprim as a second most susceptible antibiotic against
C. perfringens isolates. In contrary, the study of
Haider et al., (2022) reported the little efficacy of trimethoprim against
C. perfringens isolates of poultry. This might be due to the frequent use of this antibiotic in poultry production to get utmost production
(Mohsin et al., 2019). Our results are also in agreement with the study of
Elariny et al., (2021), who reported the resistant behavior of
C. perfringens against oxytetracycline (87.5%), amoxicillin (83.4%), ampicillin and erythromycin (75%).