Habitat and morphology
The Naju crab was first found in clean and moderately flowing fresh water in a mountain stream. The Naju crabs live mainly in water (aquatic), whereas
G. dehaani lives both in water and on land (amphibious)
Aotsuka et al., (1995). The total population of
Geothelphusa sp. is estimated to be more than ten thousand. Its carapace is hexagonal. It has a moderately wide front-orbital border, and its margin is usually smooth (Fig 1A and 1B). Its color is reddish and dark-brown. The color of the legs resembles almond skin. Female specimens collected in September 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018 showed a typical characteristic in which the mother crab carries her fertilized eggs and immature crabs in the abdomen (data not shown). The males of Naju crabs only have a well-developed, enlarged, major cheliped, whereas the female chelipeds are small and symmetrical.
Phylogenetic analysis using 16S rDNA
It was endeavored to distinguish the Naju crab from
G. dehaani by studying the differences between the two species. The nucleotide sequences of both 16S rDNA and
COI gene were selected to establish the genotype of crabs and to identify the species
(Former et al., 1994; Crandall and Fitzpatrick, 1996;
Sobita and Basudha, 2017).
Among the 27 true freshwater crabs tested, there was a wide variance of the 28 nucleotide sequence of 16S rDNA analyzed. There was a total of 564 positions in the final dataset and 105 positions were found to be variable. A search using the BLAST of 548bp of the 16S rDNA gene of the Naju crab (accession no. KM507490) showed a 94 to 98 percentage of maximum identity among four
G. dehaani (AB551391, AB187570, AB290630 and AB535460). However, a BLAST search of 548bp of the 16S rDNA gene of
G. dehaani isolate Gd23 (AB551391) showed 96 to 99 percentage of maximum identity among four
G. dehaani (AB187570, AB290630 and AB535460). This sequence of the Naju crab was AT lower (71.9%) than
G. dehaani (AB551391; 72.6%),
G. dehaani (AB187570; 72.2%) and
G. dehaani (AB290630; 72.2%).
The phylogenetic analysis of the 16S rDNA segment showed that the newly isolated Naju crab seems to belong to the
Geothelphusa family (Fig 2). Two main clades (I and II) were found. The larger clade II contains 21 species, which are originated from Taiwan and Ryukyus islands. The smaller clade I contains 6 species, including the Naju crab, four
G. dehaani isolates (AB551391, AB187570, AB290630 and AB535460) and one
G. sakamotoan (AB266174). The branch length of two
G. dehaani (AB551391 and AB187570) is shorter than that of the Naju crab, indicating that the amount of nucleotide change of the Naju crab is more than those of the two
G. dehaani, respectively (Fig 2)
.
The genetic distance is a measure of the genetic divergence between species; the smaller the genetic distance, the closer the relation and the more recent ancestor. We calculated various genetic distances among 27 species based on the 16S rDNA frequency data (Table 1). Among the 351 combinations of estimated genetic distances, the lowest genetic distance is 0.002, between
G. eucrinodonta (AB535454) and
G. yangmingshan (AB625669), indicating the highest genetic identity. The sixth lowest genetic distance is 0.011 at three sets; the Naju crab and
G. dehaani (AB551391),
G. tali (AB625672) and
G. fulva (AB428456),
G. albogiva (AB127373) and
G. tawu (AB127379). Interestingly, it is shown that the genetic distance between
G. dehaani (AB551391) and
G. dehaani (AB187570) is 0.004, the second lowest. The estimated value of the genetic distance between the Naju crab and
G. dehaani (AB187570) is 0.015, the eighth lowest value. The Naju crab showed the highest genetic distance (0.085) with
G. monticola (AB535450), which resides in high altitude mountains in Taiwan. In contrast,
G. dehaani (AB551391) showed the highest genetic distance (0.081) with
G. minei (AB625679) and
G. eucrinodonta (AB535454). These observations suggest that the Naju crab and four
G. dehaani isolates seem to be somewhat genetically distant from each other.
Phylogenetic analysis using the COI gene
All four individual of the Naju crabs studied revealed the same haplotype, which was different in 2 nucleotides. A 658bp segment (accession no. KM507491) of the
COI gene from the Naju crab was AT richer (65.4%) than
G. dehaani (AB535491; 64.5%),
G. dehaani (AB187570; 64.9%),
G. dehaani (AB290648; 65.1%) and
G. dehaani (AB551393; 65.2%). A BLAST search of 658bp of the
CO1 gene of the Naju crab showed a 92 to 98 percentage of maximum identity among four
G. dehaani, suggesting that
G. dehaani may not be a single species. Two nucleotides of the partial
COI gene in the Naju crab are distinct (C at 190 position and G at 607 position) among the 28
Geothelphusa spp. tested (data not shown). The variance of the nucleotide sequence of
COI between the Naju crab and
G. dehaani (AB551393; 15 bases per 616 bases = 2.44%) was revealed. These observations suggest that the Naju crab seem to be separated from 4
G. dehaani crabs, as the 16S rDNA haplotype of
S. fleuosa can be differentiated from the
S. maena haplotype in 15 nucleotide differences (2.65%)
Imsiridou et al., (2011).
The analysis involved 28 nucleotide sequences and 194 positions were variable. Two main clades (I and II) were recognized (Fig 3); The larger clade I contains 22 species and the smaller clade II contains only 4 species. The Naju crab, four
G. dehaani isolates, and one
G. sakamotoan consist of the small subgroup of clade I. Each branch length of four
G. dehaani isolates is also longer than that of the Naju crab, indicating that the amount of nucleotide change of four
G. dehaani isolates is greater than that of the Naju crab.
The ITS region and the histone H3 region
The aligned ITS region of 1515bp (accession no. MG561922) from the Naju crab contains partial 18S rDNA, ITS1, 5.8S rDNA, ITS2 and partial 28S rDNA sequences. The nucleotide sequences of both the ITS1 region and the ITS2 region are not conserved at all, respectively (data not shown), although the sequence of putative 5.8S rDNA (from 467 to 629 bp) was highly conserved in
Epilobocera sinuatifrons (FN395607),
Eriocheir sinensis,
Cancer productus,
Chaceon quinquedens. and
Sesarma spp. (data not shown). The partial Histone H3 region of 328bp from the Naju crab was highly conserved in
G. dehaani isolate Gd9 (AB290667) with only one base variation (data not shown).
The phylogenetic trees indicate that the Naju crab is grouped into
Geothelphusa family. This Naju crab is mostly closed to
G. dehaani isolate Gd23 from Tottori, Japan (Fig 1, 2 and Table 1). Therefore, it is not excluded yet the possibility whether the Naju crab may have been imported previously from Japan. That is, it is possible that the Naju crab is a sister species of
G. dehaani, as this species is known to include many sister species or be a species complex.