Ecological observations and spatial-temporal data gathered across the two habitat types-namely the camping ground (CG) and trekking path (JT) under varying tourist visitation conditions (national holidays, weekends and weekdays) provide a comprehensive overview of butterfly community structures within the Lake Tambing Nature Tourism Area (LTNTA). Based on these field inventory results, significant taxonomic richness was recorded, including several species endemic to Sulawesi (Fig 2). To establish a rigorous baseline and facilitate comparative evaluation, the complete dataset, species composition, spatio-temporal abundance, ecological indices and statistical validation metrics derived from this study are systematically presented and detailed in Table 1, Table 2, Table 3, Table 4 and Table 5, respectively.
Table 1 shows that 39 butterfly species beloning to four families
viz., Lycaenidae, Nymphalidae, Papilionidae and Pieridae, were recorded at the LTNTA. Out of these, 20 species are endemic to Sulawesi. Nymphalidae was the most dominant group, in terms of both species and individual abundance.
The highest diversity index values were found in the camping ground habitat (an open area) during both holidays (H’ = 2.17) and weekdays (H’ = 2.15), indicating that open areas with high light exposure and abundant flowering vegetation provide optimal food sources for butterflies. Conversely, the lowest diversity index value was recorded on the trekking path (a closed area) on weekdays (H’ = 0.82) and this is likely attributable to low light intensity, dense canopy cover and limited availability of flowering plants.
Evenness values ranged from 0.37 to 0.86, indicating a relatively balanced distribution of individuals across species. Examples of butterfly species found in the LTNTA are presented in Fig 2.
Ecological indices across two habitats and three tourist visitation periods in the LTNTA indicate that the camping ground area has higher diversity of butterfly species than the trekking path area. The findings indicate that open areas with high light exposure and abundant flowering vegetation provide favorable food sources for butterflies. Comparisons among national holidays, weekends and non-visitor days also indicate that tourist activities did not significantly affect butterfly diversity indices. Statistical tests confirmed that the observed differences were not statistically significant.
The differences in butterfly activity patterns were evident during all the periods of observation. The results indicate that butterfly diversity is not directly related to visitor’s presence but are more closely associated with ecophysiological conditions and microhabitat characteristics surrounding the camping ground (open habitat) and trekking path (relatively closed habitat).
Fungomeli et al. (2026) showed that habitat heterogeneity and microhabitat conditions shape butterfly community responses, including maintaining diversity under varying environmental conditions. Meanwhile,
Cheng et al. (2025) stated that habitat disturbance in tropical forests can influence butterfly activity patterns through microhabitat changes resulting from altered canopy structure, even when such changes are not intense. This is in line with
Dutra et al., (2025), who found that microhabitat variation between the canopy and the understory is associated with changes in butterfly community structure, even though species richness does not differ significantly. Furthermore,
Singh and Varatharajan (2010) and
Dutra et al. (2025) indicated that fragmentation and forest stratification can act as habitat filters affecting butterfly composition. Therefore, changes in microhabitat conditions between open and relatively closed habitats, including variations in light intensity, temperature, humidity and vegetation/canopy structure, may be more relevant factors in explaining butterfly species diversity than the presence of visitors.
The t-test results comparing butterfly diversity indices across habitats in the LTNTA are presented in Table 4. The t-test results (α = 0.05) indicate no significant difference in butterfly diversity indices between the camping ground (CG) and trekking path (JT) habitats across various tourist visiting periods suc as national holidays, weekends and non-visitor days. However, the non-visitor condition showed a higher diversity index value than periods with high visitor numbers, such as national holidays and weekends. The habitat’s relatively natural state and dense vegetation allow butterflies to avoid disturbances without permanently abandoning their habitat. According to
Ammalia et al., (2026), habitat diversity influences butterfly species richness, while human activities within habitats can also affect species occurrence. Music played during tourist visitation hours may also contribute to variation in the number of butterfly species observed.
The Categorisation of ecological indices of butterflies at LTNTA indicates that butterfly diversity in the Lake Tambing Nature Tourism Area ranges from moderate to high, with Shannon index values between 0.82 and 2.17. High evenness values (0.27-0.86) indicate that individuals are distributed relatively evenly among species and that no single species dominates. Statistical test results show that the t-count is lower than the t-table, hence there is no significant difference in butterfly diversity indices between the camping ground and the trekking path. The findings suggest that tourist activities at LTNTA currently impose a low level of disturbance on the butterfly community.
Mahata et al., (2023) found that temperature is the most significant factor influencing butterfly species richness.
Wenda et al., (2025) examined 21 species across four Asian tropical forest sites, comparing open-canopy and closed-canopy forests. The findings support the observation that tourist activities do not necessarily cause significant differences in butterfly diversity, as responses to disturbance may not be immediately reflected in diversity indices. Butterflies may instead alter their activity patterns in response to disturbance. Accordingly, the lack of a significant difference in diversity indices in this study does not imply an absence of ecological response from butterflies. Instead, it may indicate a response, likely more subtle, manifesting through changes in microhabitat conditions and butterfly activity patterns.
The results align with
Yang et al., (2025), who found that anthropogenic disturbance from birdwatching tourism did not significantly impact hornbills or their breeding success rates, nor did it affect locomotor, preening, or social behaviors in Yunnan Province, China. However, they discovered that such disturbance significantly influenced breeding behavior, particularly during the pre-nest-building phase, with weaker effects observed during the nest-building phase. Overall, birdwatching activities at observation posts had complex and multifaceted effects, with disturbance and protective effects occurring simultaneously during the breeding season.
Zhang et al., (2025) examined the effects of photographer-induced anthropogenic disturbance on the Blue-crowned Laughingthrush (
Pterorhinus courtoisi) in Wuyuan, Jiangxi Province, China. The study reported that photographer-induced disturbance made the birds more cautious when selecting nest sites, resulting in nest construction at greater heights and potentially increasing the conservation challenges faced by the endangered species.
Digenis et al. (2025) identified five butterfly families comprising 995 individuals across 79 species in natural habitats, compared to 627 individuals (29 species) in modified habitats. Based on the Shannon-Wiener index (H’) and Margalef richness index (R), diversity in the natural habitat was classified as high (H’ = 3.84, R = 11.2). Meanwhile, Simpson and Evenness indices were high in both habitats, showing no significant disparity between them. T-test results indicated a significant difference in the mean number of butterfly individuals between natural and non-natural habitats (t = 2.45; p = 0.015). Among the biotic factors tested, only wind speed significantly influenced butterfly abundance.
According to
Sala et al. (2026), ecotourism activities, including butterfly watching, often take place in natural habitats that still harbor large predator populations. The presence of tourists, particularly butterfly watchers, does not necessarily have negative impacts; instead, it can deter butterfly predators, indirectly reducing predation pressure on butterfly populations.
These findings have significant implications for ecotourism management at and other areas with similar status.
Ekin et al., (2026) and
Cribbs et al. (2025) suggested that mitigating the negative effects of tourism on butterfly species can be achieved by limiting visitor numbers and access to sensitive areas, as well as implementing impact-reduction plans. This is in line with
Neelam and Kumar (2026) and
Kc (2025), who noted that developing ecotourism activities that promote wildlife-friendly practices, such as guided butterfly watching, can foster a mutually beneficial relationship between tourism and biodiversity conservation efforts.