Interactive effects of potassium placement and palm age on growth and yield
Potassium placement and palm age exerted significant main and interaction effects on multiple vegetative and reproductive parameters (p<0.05). Interaction effects were most pronounced for leaf area, chlorophyll concentration, leaf biomass, FFB productivity, fruitlet and mesocarp fresh weight, fruitlet-to-bunch ratio and oil-to-bunch ratio, indicating that fertilizer effectiveness varied across palm age classes. In contrast, trunk biomass and mesocarp dry matter were governed primarily by age, while soluble sugars, total starch and the oil-to-dry mesocarp ratio showed limited responsiveness to placement strategy.
Vegetative responses were highest at 12 YAP (Table 1). Compared with broadcast application, deep placement increased leaf area by 73.5% and leaf dry weight by 116%. These increases in vegetative growth were followed by higher reproductive performance, with FFB productivity increasing from 146.53 to 251.76 kg palm
-1 yr
-1 (+71.8%) and mesocarp fresh weight from 56.54 to 158.94 kg palm
-1 yr
-1 (+181%). The results indicate that deep placement improved fertilizer effectiveness by better matching nutrient supply with the active root zone. The observed increases in leaf area and leaf biomass are physiologically consistent with reports that adequate K supply improves plant water relations and chlorophyll-associated growth
(Goud et al., 2022) and can enhance leaf area duration, gas exchange and yield formation
(Sivakumar et al., 2022). Consistent with the observed canopy response,
Dassou et al., (2022) reported that KCl fertilization increased projected canopy area across four oil palm progenies.
Hasanuzzaman et al. (2018) emphasized that K regulates stomatal conductance, while
Zhou et al., (2023) further demonstrated its role in optimizing photosynthetic efficiency. These mechanisms likely underpin the observed canopy expansion. As root systems progressively extend into deeper soil layers, subsurface K placement more effectively synchronizes nutrient supply with active uptake zones, a pattern consistent with findings by
Zhang et al., (2025), thereby explaining the superior vegetative performance of deep placement in mature palms.
The interaction between K fertilization method and oil palm age significantly influenced reproductive parameters, which exhibited age-dependent variation (Table 2). At 6 YAP, broadcast achieved the highest oil-to-bunch ratio (20.39%), reflecting shallow root dominance and efficient surface nutrient exploitation, as reported by
Woittiez et al., (2019). According to
Kundu et al., (2023), young palms often exhibit elevated foliar nitrogen (N) and higher N:K ratios, conditions that may increase responsiveness to surface-applied K, particularly given nitrogen’s role in supporting canopy metabolism
(Moriwaki et al., 2019).
At 12 YAP, deep placement increased FFB productivity to 251.76 kg palm
-1 yr
-1 and mesocarp fresh weight to 158.94 kg palm
-1 yr
-1 and the advantage persisted at 23 YAP with 240.96 and 132.14 kg palm
-1 yr
-1, respectively. In a long-term field trial in Brazil, K fertilization increased mean bunch weight and FFB yield from the sixth year of cultivation onwards (
Viégas et al., 2023). Higher mesocarp-to-fruit ratio and oil-to-bunch ratio further indicate more efficient biomass allocation toward oil synthesis.
Lamade and Tcherkez (2023) documented progressive downward root exploration in mature palms, a shift that enhances the effectiveness of subsurface fertilization. Potassium fertilizer placement near active rooting zones improves nutrient uptake and reduces fixation and leaching losses, as highlighted before by
Bell et al., (2021), thereby sustaining assimilate transfer and lipid formation in the mesocarp (
Mirande-Ney et al., 2019;
Sardans and Peñuelas, 2021). Overall, broadcast K application is more effective in early-stage palms with shallow root systems, whereas deep placement becomes more advantageous with advancing palm age and the development of deeper root systems, as nutrient uptake shifts to deeper soil layers.
Associations between vegetative parameters, carbohydrate dynamics and yield performance
Pearson correlation analysis revealed a structured linkage between canopy vigor, carbohydrate dynamics and reproductive output (Table 3). Leaf area showed a strong positive association with FFB productivity (r = 0.557) and with fruitlet-to-bunch ratio, mesocarp-to-fruit ratio and oil-to-bunch ratio (r = 0.430, 0.503 and 0.399, respectively), indicating that greater canopy development supports enhanced assimilate allocation to fruit and oil formation.
The positive coupling between canopy development and reproductive performance agrees with evidence from commercial tenera oil palms, in which leaf area and leaf dry weight were positively associated with bunch-related traits, while fresh fruit bunch yield was strongly related to oil yield
(Popet et al., 2022a). In contrast, starch accumulation exhibited the strongest negative association with yield, showing a robust inverse correlation with FFB productivity (r = -0.684, p<0.01) and significant negative relationships with fruit-to-bunch ratio, mesocarp-to-fruit ratio and oil-to-bunch ratio (r = -0.373 to -0.538). Soluble sugars followed a similar trend, correlating negatively with mesocarp-to-fruit ratio (r = -0.542) and fruit-to-bunch ratio (r = -0.530). As
Apriyanto et al. (2022) demonstrated, large pools of non-structural carbohydrates often reflect restricted mobilization rather than enhanced carbon supply.
Chlorophyll concentration showed weak associations with yield parameters, including a modest negative correlation with mesocarp-to-fruit ratio (r = -0.365, p<0.05), suggesting that pigment concentration alone does not reliably predict reproductive performance. Comparable evidence from olive metabolism indicates that carbon mobilization capacity, rather than storage, governs lipid biosynthesis efficiency (
Perez-Arcoiza et al., 2022). Collectively, these correlations highlight a central physiological gradient in which canopy expansion promotes productivity, whereas carbohydrate retention signals constrained assimilate flow to reproductive sinks.
Key physiological determinants of oil palm productivity
Total starch emerged as the only significant predictor of FFB productivity. The model was highly significant and explained 47% of yield variation (adjusted R
2 = 0.47). Diagnostic evaluation confirmed model adequacy, with independent residuals (Durbin–Watson = 2.18) and no evidence of multicollinearity (VIF = 1.00). The resulting equation, FFB productivity = 373.83 - 9.05 × (Total starch content), indicates that each 1 mg g
-1 DM increase in starch was associated with a 9.05 kg palm
-1 yr
-1 decline in yield.
The standardized coefficient (β = -0.684) confirms a strong inverse effect, reinforcing the negative correlations observed previously. Elevated starch therefore reflects restricted assimilate transfer rather than enhanced carbon supply. Sustained oil synthesis depends on rapid starch turnover and efficient carbon flux toward the mesocarp as demonstrated by
Apriyanto et al. (2022, 2023).
Mirande-Ney et al. (2019) similarly reported that excessive starch accumulation signals weak sink strength and impaired lipid formation. Together, these findings identify carbon mobilization efficiency, rather than carbohydrate abundance, as the principal physiological determinant of productivity.
Multivariate trait structuring through principal component analysis
To integrate the univariate, correlation and regression findings, the multivariate structure of the measured traits was examined using principal component analysis. The first two principal components provided an informative two-dimensional representation of the dataset, jointly explaining 71.32% of the total variance. PC1 accounted for 51.18% of the variance and represented a vegetative growth-productivity gradient. It was characterized by strong positive loadings for leaf area, leaf fresh and dry weight, trunk density, FFB productivity, fruitlet fresh weight and mesocarp fresh weight, whereas soluble sugar and total starch showed strong negative loadings. PC2 explained an additional 20.13% of the variance and was positively associated with trunk fresh and dry weight but negatively associated with total chlorophyll, soluble sugar and oil-related traits (Fig 1D). Similar multivariate consolidation of nutrient-responsive traits in oil palm has been reported by
Popet et al. (2022b) and
Tonra et al., (2025).
The score plots revealed a consistent age-related shift across K placement methods (Fig 1A-C). Palms at 6 YAP were positioned at negative PC1 scores under all placement methods, indicating weaker associations with vegetative growth and productivity traits. At 12 YAP, the treatment groups shifted toward positive PC1 scores, with the strongest displacement occurring under deep placement, reflecting greater associations with leaf biomass, trunk density and reproductive productivity. At 23 YAP, broadcast and strip-placement treatments were positioned predominantly toward positive PC2 scores and were therefore more closely associated with trunk biomass, whereas deep placement maintained positive PC1 scores with PC2 scores close to zero. Overall, palm age represented the principal source of separation in the PC1-PC2 space, while K placement modified the magnitude and direction of the associated vegetative, physiological and reproductive responses.